当前位置: X-MOL 学术Libri › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Editors’ Perceptions and Views on Journal Quality: The Case of Iran’s Editors-in-Chief
Libri ( IF 0.667 ) Pub Date : 2023-05-15 , DOI: 10.1515/libri-2021-0068
Mohammad Reza Ghane 1
Affiliation  

The study aimed to determine the perceptions and views of Iranian editors about the quality of journals, articles, the responsibilities of the editorial team, review and the review process, copyright and intellectual property, consequences of open access (OA), and influential factors in the scientific life cycle of a journal. The study adopted a qualitative approach using interviews. Respondents included 13 editors of journals. Purposive and snowball sampling methods were used for the interview. The results showed that the editor’s main tasks were to supervise the reviewers’ performance, initially control the article, and send it to the reviewers. Participants believed that compliance with professional standards was the main factor influencing the scientific quality of publications. Their understanding of the ethical codes includes impartiality and confidentiality in evaluation and publication. In light of the fact that reviewers often perform superficial reviews, the editors viewed them as poor-quality. They stated that intellectual property is not valued and observed in many cases. Some participants mentioned the negative consequences of open access (OA). However, they think OA bears more positive than adverse outcomes. Observance of these factors is ultimately essential for the survival of a scientific journal.

中文翻译:

编辑对期刊质量的看法和看法:伊朗总编辑的案例

该研究旨在确定伊朗编辑对期刊、文章的质量、编辑团队的职责、审稿和审稿过程、版权和知识产权、开放获取 (OA) 的后果以及影响因素的看法和观点。期刊的科学生命周期。该研究采用访谈的定性方法。受访者包括 13 名期刊编辑。访谈采用了目的抽样和滚雪球抽样方法。结果显示,编辑的主要任务是监督审稿人的表现,初步控制文章,送审稿人。与会者认为,遵守专业标准是影响出版物科学质量的主要因素。他们对道德准则的理解包括评估和出版中的公正性和保密性。鉴于审稿人经常进行肤浅的审稿,编辑认为它们质量很差。他们表示,在许多情况下,知识产权没有得到重视和遵守。一些与会者提到了开放获取 (OA) 的负面影响。然而,他们认为 OA 带来的积极结果多于不利结果。遵守这些因素对于科学期刊的生存至关重要。然而,他们认为 OA 带来的积极结果多于不利结果。遵守这些因素对于科学期刊的生存至关重要。然而,他们认为 OA 带来的积极结果多于不利结果。遵守这些因素对于科学期刊的生存至关重要。
更新日期:2023-05-15
down
wechat
bug