当前位置: X-MOL 学术J. Inf. Technol. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Conflating relevance with practical significance and other issues: Commentary on Sen, Smith, and Van Note’s “statistical significance versus practical importance in information systems research”
Journal of Information Technology ( IF 5.8 ) Pub Date : 2022-04-27 , DOI: 10.1177/02683962221087449
Kaveh Mohajeri 1 , Mostafa Mesgari 2 , Allen S Lee 3
Affiliation  

Expanding on the current debate on the issues of statistical and practical significance in information systems research, where the article by Sen, Smith, and Van Note is a recent contribution, this commentary cautions against conflating relevance with practical significance. We emphasize that relevance is 1) about the real-world usefulness of research findings rather than their impressiveness for the researcher audience, 2) an essential quality of research spanning beyond its findings and not merely limited to statistical studies, and 3) determined by nonacademics rather than academics. We also comment on other aspects of the article by Sen et al., such as the term “practical importance,” the treatment of effect size measures, and the presentation of “marginal effects.”



中文翻译:

将相关性与实际意义和其他问题混为一谈:对 Sen、Smith 和 Van Note 的“信息系统研究中的统计意义与实际重要性”的评论

扩展当前关于信息系统研究中统计和实际意义问题的辩论,其中 Sen、Smith 和 Van Note 的文章是最近的贡献,这篇评论警告不要将相关性与实际意义混为一谈。我们强调,相关性是 1) 研究结果在现实世界中的有用性,而不是它们对研究人员受众的印象,2) 研究的基本质量超越其研究结果,而不仅限于统计研究,以及 3) 由非学术界人士决定而不是学者。我们还评论了 Sen 等人的文章的其他方面,例如术语“实际重要性”、效应量度量的处理以及“边际效应”的呈现。

更新日期:2022-05-02
down
wechat
bug