Philosophical Studies Pub Date : 2021-07-13 , DOI: 10.1007/s11098-021-01670-9 Ariel Zylberman 1
How should we think about apparent conflicts of moral rights? I defend a non-balancing and holistic specification model: non-balancing because moral rights have absolute deontic stringency regardless of any balance of independent values; holistic because the content of moral rights is limited only by that of other moral rights. Holistic Specification, as I call the model, offers a principled, non-consequentialist explanation of exceptions to moral rights. Moreover, Holistic Specification explains why moral rights matter to practical thought while rendering remedial duties less mysterious.
中文翻译:
没有平衡的精神权利
我们应该如何看待明显的精神权利冲突?我捍卫一个非平衡和整体规范模型:非平衡是因为精神权利具有绝对的道义严格性,而不管独立价值的任何平衡;整体性,因为精神权利的内容仅受其他精神权利的限制。整体规范,正如我所说的模型,为道德权利的例外提供了一种有原则的、非结果论的解释。此外,整体规范解释了为什么道德权利对实践思想很重要,同时使补救义务不那么神秘。