In our recent review of the current status of forensic lie detection (Iacono & Ben-Shakhar, 2019), we critiqued a novel method for estimating comparison question polygraph technique accuracy introduced by Ginton (2013). Ginton (2020) has argued that we misconstrued and misinterpreted his study. In this rejoinder, we dismiss Ginton’s (2020) critical points and maintain that his polygraph validity estimates cannot be trusted.

中文翻译：

---

比较题测谎有效性估计的谬误：回复 Ginton (2020)

在我们最近对法医谎言检测现状的回顾中（Iacono 和 Ben-Shakhar，2019 年），我们批评了 Ginton（2013 年）引入的一种用于估计比较问题测谎技术准确性的新方法。Ginton (2020) 认为我们误解和曲解了他的研究。在此反驳中，我们驳回了 Ginton (2020) 的关键点，并坚持认为他的测谎有效性估计不可信。