The three-volume edition of Jeremy Bentham’s Economic Writings, edited by Werner Stark, was published between 1952 and 1954, and reviewed by Terence Hutchison in the Economic Journal in 1956. Based on the Stark edition, Hutchison argued that there had been a dramatic shift in Bentham’s views and policy recommendations between his earlier and later writings on political economy. With the benefit of a new, five-volume edition of Bentham’s Writings on Political Economy, edited by Michael Quinn, it can now be seen that the revolution in Bentham’s views on political economy proposed by Hutchison did not take place. On the contrary, an examination of Bentham’s treatment of fiscal and monetary policy in his principal general works on political economy, the Manual of Political Economy and the Institute of Political Economy, show a remarkable consistency, both in policy recommendations, and in the body of economic analysis in which they were based.

中文翻译：

---

没有发生的革命：特伦斯·哈奇森谈杰里米·边沁的政治经济学

由维尔纳·斯塔克编辑的杰里米·边沁的三卷本经济著作于 1952 年至 1954 年间出版，并于 1956 年由特伦斯·哈奇森 (Terence Hutchison) 在《经济杂志》(Economic Journal) 上进行了评论。基于斯塔克版，哈奇森认为发生了戏剧性的转变在他早期和后来的政治经济学著作之间，边沁的观点和政策建议。得益于迈克尔·奎因编辑的新的五卷本《边沁政治经济学著作》，现在可以看出，和记黄埔提出的边沁政治经济学观点的革命并未发生。相反，对边沁在其关于政治经济学的主要通识著作《政治经济学手册》和《政治经济学研究所》中对财政和货币政策的处理的研究显示出显着的一致性，