Abstract

Jago (2019) uses a Fitch-style argument in an attempt to demonstrate that every truth has a truthmaker (maximalism). But Trueman (forthcoming) shows that there is a parallel argument, this time to the conclusion that no truth has a truthmaker. Since we cannot accept both, we must ditch at least one Fitch. But which?Keywords: Truth, truthmaking, truthmaker maximalism, Fitch paradox, Robert Trueman

中文翻译：

---

哪个惠誉？

摘要

Jago (2019) 使用了 Fitch 式的论证，试图证明每个真理都有一个真理制造者（最大化主义）。但是特鲁曼（即将出版）表明存在一个平行的论点，这一次得出的结论是，没有真理有一个真理制造者。由于我们不能同时接受两者，我们必须至少放弃一个惠誉。但是哪个？