Recruiting native coastal vegetation and preventing the reinvasion of exotic Spartina alterniflora is a major challenge in China, due to harsh tidal environment for vegetation establishment and rapid Spartina colonization. This paper first reviewed the revegetation course of native Scirpus mariqueter in a coastal wetland in the Yangtze Estuary, where the adjacent Spartina was effectively eliminated. From 2014 to 2019, the area of planted Scirpus increased by 26.7 times, and the plant density and biomass growth amounted to the levels of mature sedge community. The establishment of Scirpus promoted the sedimentary accretion with an annual sedimentary rate of 9.2 cm yr⁻¹, which was significantly higher than that in the mudflat. Six years of monitoring revealed that the revegetation approach with belowground propagules (corms) was effective for Scirpus establishment under strong hydrodynamic disturbances in the tidal mudflat because the morphology and germination rate of corms benefited the anchoring function of seedlings. Both recruited Scirpus and the original community expanded constantly due to positive feedback between plant progradation and sedimentary accretion. Then, we implemented a model simulation under the scenario of Spartina retention. The prediction showed that the high-speed invasion of Spartina would colonize and replace the whole Scirpus community in the study area during the period of 2014–2019. Hence, our results highlighted the importance of coupling Scirpus recruitment with Spartina eradication in guaranteeing recolonization of native coastal sedges. As a long-lasting management strategy, unremitting field monitoring and assistant decision-making tools (such as the forecasting models) on Spartina reinvasion risk are highly suggested for preserving the restoration of native marshes.