当前位置: X-MOL 学术Chem. Geol. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Some comments on the effect of uranium zonation on fission track dating by LA-ICP-MS
Chemical Geology ( IF 3.9 ) Pub Date : 2021-04-09 , DOI: 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2021.120226
Nathan Cogné , Kerry Gallagher

The use of LA-ICP-MS for uranium determination in the fission track dating technique is becoming increasingly popular because of several advantages over the classical external detector method and a variety of analytical and statistical protocols have been developed. However, two important issues remain unresolved in the context of the LA-ICP-MS approach (i) how to best deal with low track density (ρs) samples, and (ii) does a correlation between age and uranium content (or eU) reflect an annealing dependence or not? To assess the impact of the analytical methodology on these issues, we compare the multi-spot and more classical single spot methods on samples of known ages, variably zoned and/or with low track densities. To make the comparison we use an approach, implemented in a Python script, that randomly samples our multi-spot ICP-MS data to choose a single U measurement per grain, simulating the single spot approach. We then calculate the central age, p(χ2) and dispersion of the simulated single spot analysis and repeat this 2000 times. Our results show that the multi-spot approach is robust for low ρs and zoned samples, yielding both accurate and precise results without over-dispersion. Additionally, our random sampling approach shows that a single spot measurement can induce an overdispersion coupled to a relationship between single grain age and U content. This is at least partly attributable to zonation that creates a mismatch between the U in the counted area and the spot-measured U. Therefore, we recommend that if over-dispersion is observed for basement samples, when one typically expects a single age population, then multiple spot analysis should be carried out to assess if the excess dispersion is linked to undetected zoning and/or laser spot misplacement rather than to U dependent annealing behaviour.



中文翻译:

通过LA-ICP-MS对铀分区对裂变径迹定年的影响的一些评论

在裂变径迹测年技术中,使用LA-ICP-MS进行铀测定变得越来越普遍,这是因为它具有优于经典外部探测器方法的多种优势,并且已经开发了多种分析和统计方案。但是,有两个重要的问题在LA-ICP-MS方法的情况下仍然没有得到解决(我)如何与低磁道密度最划算(ρ小号)样品,以及(ii)年龄与铀含量(或eU)之间的相关性是否反映出退火依赖性?为了评估分析方法对这些问题的影响,我们比较了多点法和更经典的单点法对已知年龄,可变区域和/或低径迹密度的样本的影响。为了进行比较,我们使用一种在Python脚本中实现的方法,该方法随机采样我们的多点ICP-MS数据,以模拟单个点的方法,对每个谷物选择一个U量度。然后,我们计算出中央年龄,P(χ 2)和分散的模拟单点分析和重复这个2000倍。我们的结果表明,多点方法对于低ρs是鲁棒和分区的样品,可以得到准确而精确的结果,而不会过度分散。此外,我们的随机抽样方法表明,单点测量可能会导致过度分散,这与单晶粒龄和U含量之间的关系有关。这至少部分归因于分区,该分区在计数区域的U与现场测量的U之间造成了不匹配。因此,我们建议,如果在地下室样本中观察到过度分散的情况,那么通常会期望一个年龄段的人口,然后应进行多点分析,以评估过量的色散是否与未检测到的分区和/或激光点错放有关,而不是与U依赖的退火行为有关。

更新日期:2021-04-13
down
wechat
bug