Synthese ( IF 1.3 ) Pub Date : 2021-03-17 , DOI: 10.1007/s11229-021-03072-0 Isaac Wilhelm
A popular method for comparing the structures of mathematical objects, which I call the ‘subset approach’, says that X has more structure than Y just in case X’s automorphisms form a proper subset of Y’s automorphisms. This approach is attractive, in part, because it seems to yield the right results in some comparisons of spacetime structure. But as I show, it yields the wrong results in a number of other cases. The problem is that the subset approach compares structure using automorphism sets. So a different approach is needed: structure should be compared using automorphism groups.
中文翻译:
比较数学对象的结构
比较数学对象的结构,我称之为“子方法”的常用方法,说,X具有超过结构Ÿ以防万一X的同构形成的真子集Ÿ的同构。这种方法之所以具有吸引力,部分原因在于,它在时空结构的某些比较中似乎产生了正确的结果。但是,正如我所展示的,它在许多其他情况下也会产生错误的结果。问题在于,子集方法使用自同构集比较结构。因此需要一种不同的方法:应该使用自同构组来比较结构。