The aim of the present article is twofold. Firstly, it aims to study the problems arising from the notion of rule proposed by Peter Winch in The Idea of a Social Science and Its Relation to Philosophy (1958) to account for all meaningful behavior. On the one hand, it will analyze the problems in the argument posed by Winch in order to state that all meaningful behavior is governed by rules. On the other hand, it will focus on the problems concerning his conception of rules and rule-following, with specific emphasis on pointing out the issues that arise from the criterion posed by Winch in order to determine when a rule is being followed. Secondly, it aims to reassess Winch’s proposal and reformulate, accommodate and define his notion of rule in an intentional account of meaningful behavior, thus solving the problems presented. In addition, it will provide a criterion that allows to determine when a rule is being followed.

中文翻译：

---

规则、意图和社会行为：对彼得·温奇的重新评估

本文的目的是双重的。首先，它旨在研究由彼得温奇在《社会科学的理念及其与哲学的关系》（1958）中提出的规则概念所引起的问题，以解释所有有意义的行为。一方面，它将分析 Winch 提出的论点中的问题，以说明所有有意义的行为都受规则支配。另一方面，将重点关注他的规则概念和规则遵循问题，特别强调指出温奇提出的标准所产生的问题，以确定何时遵循规则。其次，它旨在重新评估温奇的提议，并在对有意义行为的有意描述中重新表述、适应和定义他的规则概念，从而解决所提出的问题。此外，