当前位置: X-MOL 学术Holocaust and Genocide Studies › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
The Birth of the New Justice: The Internationalization of Crime and Punishment, 1919−1950
Holocaust and Genocide Studies ( IF 0.4 ) Pub Date : 2017-01-01 , DOI: 10.1093/hgs/dcx045
Lawrence Douglas

countries and their likeliness to accept bribes from the very multinational corporations he believes should be prosecuted. Kelly also underestimates the African nationalist reaction against the ICC’s indictment of President Omar Al Bashir of Sudan for the crime of genocide. This book deserved better editing. It appears to be a rather hasty compilation of several articles Kelly had previously published in legal journals. Complete sentences, long quotations, indeed entire paragraphs are repeated throughout, and later chapter content does not always seem to acknowledge the content of earlier chapters. The author’s choices of what to include in the appendices strike one as rather odd: for example, Canada’s law on Corporate Criminal Responsibility but not the CAHWCA. And there is no particular reason for a 14-page table of developments in civil law countries regarding corporate criminal liability to appear in the text. Despite shortcomings, however, this book is accessible to scholars of genocide who (like the reviewer) do not possess formal legal training. It is encouraging to learn that there may be a persuasive legal basis for prosecuting corporations for genocide, even if the prospects for the near future seem dim. Kelly’s findings should be discussed in future work on comparative genocide.

中文翻译:

新司法的诞生:犯罪与惩罚的国际化,1919年至1950年

国家和他们接受来自非常跨国公司的贿赂的可能性,他认为应该起诉。凯利还低估了非洲民族主义对国际刑事法院因种族灭绝罪起诉苏丹总统奥马尔·巴希尔的反应。这本书值得更好的编辑。这似乎是Kelly以前在法律期刊上发表的几篇文章的草率汇编。完整的句子,长引号,甚至整个段落实际上都是重复出现的,而后面章节的内容似乎并不总是承认前面章节的内容。作者对附件中内容的选择颇为奇怪:例如,加拿大的《公司刑事责任法》,而不是《 CAHWCA》。并没有特别的理由在文本中出现关于公司刑事责任的民法国家的14页发展情况表。尽管有缺点,但种族灭绝的学者(如审稿人)没有经过正规的法律培训,仍可使用这本书。令人鼓舞的是,即使在不久的将来前景暗淡的情况下,起诉公司进行种族灭绝可能有说服力的法律依据。凯利的发现应在以后有关比较种族灭绝的工作中讨论。即使在不久的将来前景暗淡。凯利的发现应在以后有关比较种族灭绝的工作中讨论。即使在不久的将来前景暗淡。凯利的发现应在以后的比较种族灭绝研究中加以讨论。
更新日期:2017-01-01
down
wechat
bug