I submit a few remarks concerning some limits of the Allen and Pardo’s theory and about the validity of narrativism as a theory of judicial decisions. Moreover, I discuss disputable ideas of abductive inferences and of holistical decisions on the facts in issue. Finally I suggest the opportunity of dealing with the ‘maximisation of the weight of evidence’.

中文翻译：

---

关于相对合理性的一些评论

我就艾伦和帕尔多理论的某些局限性以及叙事主义作为司法判决理论的有效性发表一些评论。此外，我还讨论了有争议的溯因推理和对相关事实的整体决策的观点。最后，我建议有机会处理“证据权重的最大化”。