This paper is a brief commentary on the paper "How stable is pitch labeling accuracy in absolute pitch possessors" by W. Gruhn, R. Ristmagi, P. Schneider, A. d'Souza, and K. Kiilu. The original paper presents evidence for the influence of timbre on the pitch labeling accuracy of absolute pitch (AP) possessors. The presented data result from a solid methodology and show a clear pitch labeling accuracy drop from instrumental timbres to sinusoidal tones, with manipulated sounds being in the middle. The commentary underlines the view that the presented results are compatible with a memory perspective on AP and can be interpreted as evidence for the influence of training on the development of AP.

中文翻译：

---

关于“绝对音调拥有者的音高标记精度如何稳定？”的评论 W. Gruhn，R.Ristmägi，P.Schneider，A.d'Souza和K.Kiilu

本文是对W. Gruhn，R。Ristmagi，P。Schneider，A。d'Souza和K. Kiilu发表的论文“在绝对音高拥有者中音高标记精度有多稳定”的简短评论。原始论文提供了有关音色对绝对音高（AP）拥有者的音高标记准确性的影响的证据。呈现的数据来自可靠的方法，并且显示了从乐器音色到正弦音调的明显音高标记准确性下降，中间是受操纵的声音。评论强调了这样一种观点，即所提出的结果与对AP的记忆观点是兼容的，并且可以被解释为训练对AP发育的影响的证据。