In a recently published paper, Chetan Barde et al. [Barde C, Choubey A, Sinha R. A set square design metamaterial absorber for X-band applications. J Electromagn Waves Appl. 2019:1–14.] have proposed a wideband metamaterial absorber and have attempted to elaborate reflection theory for the absorptivity. They have claimed a wideband absorption rate due to ignorance of cross-polarization component of the reflected wave. They have erroneously interpreted a linear reflective polarization converter as a wideband absorber.

中文翻译：

---

关于“用于X波段应用的方形设计超材料吸收体”的评论

在最近发表的论文中，Chetan Barde等人。[Barde C，Choubey A，SinhaR。用于X波段应用的方形三角设计超材料吸收器。J电子波应用 [2019：1–14。]提出了一种宽带超材料吸收体，并试图阐述吸收率的反射理论。他们声称由于反射波的交叉极化分量的无知而导致了宽带吸收率。他们错误地将线性反射偏振转换器解释为宽带吸收器。