当前位置: X-MOL 学术Discourse Studies › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Book review: Michelle Scollo and Trudy Milburn (eds), Engaging and Transforming Global Communication Through Cultural Discourse Analysis: A Tribute to Donal Carbaugh
Discourse Studies ( IF 1.4 ) Pub Date : 2019-12-29 , DOI: 10.1177/1461445619885192a
Xueyu Wang 1
Affiliation  

addition to introductory discussion, he outlines some potential areas that would be of interest to researchers experienced in corpus-pragmatic studies. These include, for example, corpus investigation into the diagnostic potential of evaluation in recognising irony (p. 129), the compilation of multimodal corpora and, subsequently, the pragmatic annotation (e.g. speech acts) of such corpora (p. 200). These point to some new directions that will push corpus pragmatics forward. Apart from all the good features noted above, I see one minor limitation. While the brief discussion of pragmatics provided in the introductory chapter can be compensated for by the discussion of pragmatic concepts in the subsequent chapters, the brief discussion of corpus linguistics and corpus pragmatics is not supported by further explanation of relevant corpus concepts in subsequent chapters. While this certainly does not undermine the value of the book, it may cause difficulties in reading and understanding some parts of the book (e.g. query script, evaluative or semantic prosody), especially for those readers who are not that familiar with but are interested in corpus pragmatics. For these readers, I would suggest that Hunston (2002) and McEnery and Hardie (2012) would be useful resources for corpus linguistics and that Romero-Trillo (2013–2019) and Aijmer and Rühlemann (2015) can be good references for corpus pragmatics. This suggestion of course does not improve the book, but it may be helpful for readers to get a better reading experience and understanding of corpus pragmatics. To conclude, the book has discussed the major topics in corpus pragmatics, thereby achieving comprehensiveness in content; it has devoted much space to presenting practical guidelines for readers to carry out research tasks, thereby allowing them to get hands-on experience in practicing corpus-pragmatic research. As such, this book would qualify as an essential guide for newcomers to corpus pragmatics. In addition, some directions worth pursuing have also been suggested, providing ‘food for thought for seasoned pragmaticists’ (p. 9). All these contribute to further promoting corpus pragmatics as a field. It is then clear that I value the book highly and as such I recommend it to all those who are interested in these areas.

中文翻译:

书评:Michelle Scollo 和 Trudy Milburn(编辑),通过文化话语分析参与和改变全球传播:向 Donal Carbaugh 致敬

除了介绍性讨论之外,他还概述了在语料库语用研究方面有经验的研究人员可能感兴趣的一些潜在领域。例如,这些包括对评估在识别反讽方面的诊断潜力的语料库调查(第 129 页)、多模态语料库的汇编以及随后此类语料库的语用注释(例如言语行为)(第 200 页)。这些指出了一些将推动语料库语用学向前发展的新方向。除了上面提到的所有好的功能外,我还看到了一个小限制。虽然介绍性章节中对语用学的简要讨论可以通过后续章节中对语用学概念的讨论来弥补,对语料库语言学和语料库语用学的简要讨论并没有得到后续章节对相关语料库概念的进一步解释的支持。虽然这当然不会损害本书的价值,但它可能会导致阅读和理解本书的某些部分(例如查询脚本、评价或语义韵律)的困难,特别是对于那些不太熟悉但对这些内容感兴趣的读者。语料库语用学。对于这些读者,我建议 Hunston (2002) 和 McEnery and Hardie (2012) 是语料库语言学的有用资源,Romero-Trillo (2013–2019) 和 Aijmer and Rühlemann (2015) 可以作为语料库语用学的良好参考. 这个建议当然不会改进这本书,但它可能有助于读者获得更好的阅读体验和对语料库语用的理解。综上所述,本书对语料库语用学的主要课题进行了讨论,从而实现了内容的全面性;它为读者提供了开展研究任务的实用指南,提供了大量空间,从而让他们获得实践语料库语用研究的实践经验。因此,本书有资格成为语料库语用学新手的基本指南。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。本书讨论了语料库语用学的主要课题,从而达到了内容的全面性;它为读者提供了开展研究任务的实用指南,提供了大量空间,从而让他们获得实践语料库语用研究的实践经验。因此,本书有资格成为语料库语用学新手的基本指南。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。本书讨论了语料库语用学的主要课题,从而达到了内容的全面性;它为读者提供了开展研究任务的实用指南,提供了大量空间,从而让他们获得实践语料库语用研究的实践经验。因此,本书有资格成为语料库语用学新手的基本指南。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。它为读者提供了开展研究任务的实用指南,提供了大量空间,从而让他们获得实践语料库语用研究的实践经验。因此,本书有资格成为语料库语用学新手的基本指南。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。它为读者提供了开展研究任务的实用指南,提供了大量空间,从而让他们获得实践语料库语用研究的实践经验。因此,本书有资格成为语料库语用学新手的基本指南。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。此外,还提出了一些值得探索的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。此外,还提出了一些值得追求的方向,为“经验丰富的实用主义者提供了思考的食粮”(第 9 页)。所有这些都有助于进一步推动语料库语用学作为一个领域。很明显,我非常重视这本书,因此我向所有对这些领域感兴趣的人推荐它。
更新日期:2019-12-29
down
wechat
bug