当前位置: X-MOL 学术Quat. Geochronol. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Comparing classical and Bayesian 210Pb dating models in human-impacted aquatic environments
Quaternary Geochronology ( IF 2.7 ) Pub Date : 2020-06-26 , DOI: 10.1016/j.quageo.2020.101106
Marco A. Aquino-López , Ana Carolina Ruiz-Fernández , Maarten Blaauw , Joan-Albert Sanchez-Cabeza

Chronologies are an essential tool to place natural archives of environmental changes on a calendar scale. Because of this, studies that compare and assess the accuracy and precision of available dating models are essential. 210Pb is a radioactive isotope which is used to date recent sediments (<150 yr). Here we contrast the chronologies resulting from two different 210Pb dating models: the Constant Flux model (also known as the Constant Rate of Supply model) and the recently developed Bayesian Plum model. This comparison was implemented by using four sediment cores from contrasting environmental settings, and showed several benefits of using a Bayesian approach. This allows to infer variables, such as the supported levels of 210Pb, crucial to the chronology and commonly estimated through either samples where an asymptotic behaviour is observed or through 226Ra measurements, which themselves contain some level of uncertainty. Another step of traditional methods is the selection of the equilibrium depth in order to calculate total inventories, which carries strong consequences for the resulting age depth model. Plum, on the other hand, infers the 210Pb flux, which eliminates the need to select an equilibrium depth and allows for dating cores with incomplete inventory. When traditional methods address cores with missing inventory, 137Cs time markers are commonly used to correct the chronology, but Plum can use these time markers to improve the chronology and to reduce the uncertainty. These aspects show that the Bayesian approach results in more robust and objective chronologies, and thus in better reconstructions of environmental change over the past centuries.



中文翻译:

在人类影响的水生环境中比较经典和贝叶斯210 Pb测年模型

年表是将自然环境变化档案保存在日历范围内的重要工具。因此,比较和评估可用约会模型的准确性和精确性的研究至关重要。210 Pb是一种放射性同位素,可用于记录最近的沉积物(<150年)。在这里,我们对比了两种不同的210 Pb测年模型产生的时间顺序:恒定通量模型(也称为恒定供给速率模型)和最近开发的贝叶斯梅花模型。通过使用来自不同环境设置的四个沉积物岩心进行了此比较,并显示了使用贝叶斯方法的一些好处。这允许推断变量,例如210的支持级别Pb对时序至关重要,通常通过观察到渐近行为的样本或通过226 Ra测量值(通常包含不确定性水平)来估算。传统方法的另一步骤是选择平衡深度以计算总库存量,这对所得的年龄深度模型会产生重大影响。另一方面,Plum推断出210 Pb的通量,这消除了选择平衡深度的需要,并允许对不完整存量的岩心进行测年。当传统方法处理缺少库存的内核时,通常使用137 Cs时间标记来更正年代,但是Plum可以使用这些时间标记来改善时间顺序并减少不确定性。这些方面表明,贝叶斯方法产生了更健壮和客观的时间顺序,从而在过去几个世纪中对环境变化进行了更好的重构。

更新日期:2020-06-26
down
wechat
bug