Artelle et al. (2018) conclude that "hallmarks of science" are largely missing from North American wildlife management based on a desk review of selected hunting management plans and related documents found through Internet searches and email requests to state and provincial wildlife agencies. We highlight three fundamental problems that compromise the validity of the conclusions posited: missing information to support selection of "hallmarks of science," confusion about the roles and nature of science and management, and failure to engage effectively with the scientists and managers actively managing wildlife populations in North America.

中文翻译：

---

Artelle等。（2018）错过了北美野生动植物管理的基础科学。

Artelle等。（2018）得出结论，基于对选定的狩猎管理计划的案头审查以及通过互联网搜索以及发给州和省级野生生物机构的电子邮件请求而获得的相关文件的案头审查，北美野生动植物管理在很大程度上缺少“科学标记”。我们重点介绍了三个基本问题，这些问题损害了所得出结论的有效性：缺少支持“科学标记”选择的信息，对科学和管理的作用和性质的困惑以及未能与积极管理野生生物的科学家和管理人员有效接触北美的人口。