当前位置: X-MOL 学术JAMA Surg. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Considerations When Calculating Data Completeness
JAMA Surgery ( IF 15.7 ) Pub Date : 2018-08-01 , DOI: 10.1001/jamasurg.2018.1159
Wendy C. King 1 , Steven H. Belle 1, 2 , Anita P. Courcoulas 3
Affiliation  

To the Editor We agree with Higa and Himpens1 that obtaining long-term data following metabolic/bariatric surgery is a challenge and that appropriate analytical methods need to be used to account for missing data, although they are not a substitute for complete follow-up. However, we disagree with their characterization of 7-year data completeness in the Longitudinal Assessment of Bariatric Surgery (LABS) study.2 Higa and Himpens stated, “data at 7 years were available for 1300 of the eligible 2277 patients (57%), not the 82.9% rate as reported.”1 They determined their percentage by dividing the number of nonpregnant participants with 7-year weight data (n = 1300) by the number of participants at study entry (n = 2348) minus the number who died prior to year 7 (n = 71). However, as the article indicates, the study ended before 700 participants were due for the 7-year assessment.2 Thus, it is inappropriate to include them in the denominator when calculating 7-year data completeness. Furthermore, because weights of pregnant women were excluded from the report, pregnant women (n = 9 at year 7) should not be counted in the denominator either.



中文翻译:

计算数据完整性时的注意事项

致编辑我们同意Higa和Himpens 1的观点,即在代谢/巴氏外科手术后获取长期数据是一个挑战,尽管不能代替完整的随访,但仍需要使用适当的分析方法来处理缺失的数据。 。但是,我们不同意他们在减肥手术纵向评估(LABS)研究中对7年数据完整性的描述。2 Higa和Himpens说:“有7年的数据适用于2277例合格患者中的1300例(57%),而不是报道的82.9%。” 1个他们通过将具有7年体重数据的未怀孕参与者的数量(n = 1300)除以研究开始时的参与者数量(n = 2348)减去第7年之前死亡的人数(n = 71)来确定百分比。但是,正如文章所指出的,该研究在700名参与者进行7年评估之前就已经结束了。2因此,在计算7年数据完整性时,将它们包含在分母中是不合适的。此外,由于报告中未包括孕妇的体重,因此孕妇(第7年的n = 9)也不应计入分母。

更新日期:2018-08-15
down
wechat
bug