Goldin-Meadow & Brentari (G-M&B) challenge the traditional separation between gestural and categorical language by modality, but they retain a binary distinction. However, multiple dimensions, particularly discreteness and combinatoriality, better carve up the range of linguistic and nonlinguistic human communication. Investigating transformation over time along these dimensions will reveal how the nature of language reflects human minds, rather than the world to which language refers.

中文翻译：

---

是语言吗（还）？手势语言二进制文件的魅力

Goldin-Meadow & Brentari (GM&B) 通过模态挑战手势语言和分类语言之间的传统分离，但它们保留了二元区别。然而，多个维度，特别是离散性和组合性，更好地划分了语言和非语言人类交流的范围。沿着这些维度研究随时间的变化将揭示语言的本质如何反映人类的思想，而不是语言所指的世界。