Letter to the EditorGeological data indicate that the interpretation for the age-calibrated phylogeny for the Kurixalus-genus frogs of South, South-east and East Asia (Lv et al., 2018) needs to be rethought
Introduction
Kurixalus is a monophyletic genus of rhacophorid frogs (mainly tree dwellers) whose sixteen constituent species inhabit a broad swath encompassing the eastern Himalayas, Myanmar, Indochina, southern China, Sundaland, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Japan’s Ryukyu islands. Recently, Lv et al. (2018) presented a dated molecular phylogeny for the group based on a synthesis of sub-regionally focused investigations (Frost et al., 2006; Li et al., 2008, Li et al., 2009, Li et al., 2013; Yu et al., 2010, Yu et al., 2013; Rowley et al., 2011; Hertwig et al., 2013; Nguyen et al., 2014a, Nguyen et al., 2014b). Following their analysis, Lv et al. (2018) proposed that the genus originated in southern Indochina-Taiwan c. 36.8 Ma (Late Eocene). The deepest split, estimated at 32.8 Ma (Early Oligocene), produced lineages ancestral to clades now separated by a great circle distance ≥1,400 km. Interestingly this scenario is congruent, at least superficially, with the well-established geological model for the formation of the South China Sea (Briais et al., 1993; Hall, 2012; Sibuet et al., 2016). At about 32 Ma the Palawan block (c. 100-km-wide, 650-km-long) rifted from southern China; sea-floor spreading until sometime between 20 Ma (Early Miocene) and 15 Ma (Middle Miocene) created the basin as the terrane drifted c. 900 km south to its present location to the north-east of Borneo and to the west of the main Philippine archipelago. The fragment, when it was attached to southern China, is thought by Lv et al. (2018) to have formed part of a land surface that linked Taiwan to Indochina.
On Taiwan, two sister species of Kurixalus are recognized: Kurixalus idiootocus and the Kurixalus eiffingeri species complex. Various types of information (morphologies of the eggs, tadpoles and adults; mating calls; molecular data; ecology etc) led Wu et al. (2016) to propose that the latter comprises three forms: K. eiffingeri, Kurixalus berylliniris and Kurixalus wangi, with each occupying discrete geographical areas within the lowlands and foothills (up to 1,000 m) that ring Taiwan’s mountainous east (Wu et al., 2016). Lv et al. (2018) estimated the separation between K. idiootocus and the K. eiffingeri species complex as c. 22.0 Ma (Early Miocene). Populations of K. eiffingeri are also present on Iriomote and Ishigaki at the south-west end of Japan’s Ryukyu chain. The two islands sit atop a shallow platform and are respectively 180 km and 220 km east of northern Taiwan; this colonization was dated at c. 13.5 Ma (Middle Miocene; Lv et al., 2018).
Section snippets
Taiwan Island is considered to be just 4–5 million years old
The scenario presented by Lv et al. (2018) is, however, problematic because Taiwan is a young landmass that became emergent only 4–5 million years ago (Early Pliocene). The uprising results from spectacular crustal thickening due to the Luzon Arc on the western Philippine Sea Plate colliding with and overriding the passive margin of the Eurasian continent off south-east China (e.g. Teng, 1990; Sibuet and Hsu, 2004); in a newly proposed scheme for classifying marine landmass types, Taiwan is
Problems with the Lv et al. (2018) proposal
I therefore contend that there are major issues with the scenario proposed by Lv et al. (2018). One solution invokes another landmass, perhaps in the Ryukyu chain or elsewhere, with later transfer to Taiwan (Nishizawa et al., 2011, explored this briefly in explaining the 26.3 Ma [Late Oligocene] branching between Buergeria buergeri in mainland Japan and its sister species, Buergeria robusta, in Taiwan). However, this would be highly speculative and possibly not testable, either biologically
Other relevant information
Evolutionary features exhibited by Taiwan’s other land-locked vertebrates are also pertinent to the discussion, in particular evidence for other “old” lineages. As a consequence of the island having shallow connections to mainland Asia (70 m below the present-day sea-level datum; verified using Ryan et al., 2009), the sizeable assemblage is dominated by non-endemics (e.g. Xiang & Li, 2000; IUCN Red List, 2018; Lue, 2018; Taiwan Biodiversity National Information Network, 2018) that likely
Summary
In view of Taiwan’s considerable area and ecological-niche range, which should facilitate biodiversity expansion given a reasonable amount of geological time (say, 10–20 million years), several features of its native biota offer strong support to the young-landmass model. Firstly, although the land-locked vertebrate suite comprises at least 135 native species, the proportion of exclusives is relatively low. Secondly, those endemic species that have emerged have done so largely within the last
Acknowledgements
Formal critiques provided by Sebastian Klaus and two anonymous reviewers helped improve the document. Allan Larson is thanked for his editorial guidance.
References (40)
- et al.
Molecular phylogeny and diversification of the genus Odorrana (Amphibia, Anura, Ranidae) inferred from two mitochondrial genes
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2013) - et al.
Molecular phylogenetics of shrews (Mammalia: Soricidae) reveal timing of transcontinental colonizations
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2007) Late Jurassic-Cenozoic reconstructions of the Indonesian region and the Indian Ocean
Tectonophysics
(2012)- et al.
Diversification in a biodiversity hotspot – the evolution of Southeast Asian rhacophorid tree frogs on Borneo (Amphibia: Anura: Rhacophoridae)
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2013) Strain modes within the forearc, arc and back-arc domains in the Izu (Japan) and Taiwan arc-continent collisional settings
J. Asian Earth Sci.
(2014)- et al.
Molecular phylogeny of Rhacophoridae (Anura): a framework of taxonomic reassignment of species within the genera Aquixalus, Chiromantis, Rhacophorus, and Philautus
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2008) - et al.
New insights to the molecular phylogenetics and generic assessment in the Rhacophoridae (Amphibia: Anura) based on five nuclear and three mitochondrial genes, with comments on the evolution of reproduction
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2009) - et al.
A comprehensive phylogeny of the genus Kurixalus (Rhacophoridae, Anura) sheds light on the geographical range evolution of frilled swamp treefrogs
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2018) - et al.
Sedimentology and foreland basin paleogeography during Taiwan arc continent collision
J. Asian Earth Sci.
(2013) - et al.
Mitochondrial DNA diversification, molecular phylogeny, and biogeography of the primitive rhacophorid genus Buergeria in East Asia
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
(2011)
How was Taiwan created?
Tectonophysics
Geodynamics of the South China Sea
Tectonophysics
Geotectonic evolution of late Cenozoic arc-continent collision in Taiwan
Tectonophysics
Within-island speciation with an exceptional case of distinct separation between two sibling lizard species divided by a narrow stream
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
A species boundary within the Chinese Kurixalus odontotarsus species group (Anura: Rhacophoridae): new insights from molecular evidence
Mol. Phylogenet. Evol.
Molecular evidence for taxonomy of Rhacophorus appendiculatus and Kurixalus species from northern Vietnam, with comments on systematics of Kurixalus and Gracixalus (Anura: Rhacophoridae)
Biochem. Syst. Ecol.
Islands as biological substrates: continental
J. Biogeogr.
Molecular phylogeny and evolution of the Asian lineage of vole genus Microtus (Rodentia: Arvicolinae) inferred from mitochondrial cytochrome b sequence
Biol. J. Linn. Soc.
Modelled atmospheric temperatures and global sea level over the past million years
Nature
Updated interpretation of magnetic anomalies and seafloor spreading stages in the South China Sea: implications for the Tertiary tectonics of Southeast Asia
J. Geophys. Res.
Cited by (6)
Molecular phylogeny and diversification of Malagasy bright-eyed tree frogs (Mantellidae: Boophis)
2018, Molecular Phylogenetics and EvolutionCitation Excerpt :In addition, the fossil has not been evaluated in a phylogenetic analysis, and might not conclusively place the fossil as it is a small fragment with few characters (Folie et al., 2013). Furthermore, one recent divergence dating study (Lv et al., 2018) uses this fossil, but a response to this work suggests that the ages are significantly overestimated and lead to biogeographically implausible scenarios (Ali, 2018). Previous studies have warned that different applications of calibrations could potentially lead to large differences in age estimates (Ho and Phillips, 2009; Parham et al., 2011), yet it is encouraging that in our case, the differences were comparatively moderate.
Diversity, distribution and molecular species delimitation in frogs and toads from the Eastern Palaearctic
2022, Zoological Journal of the Linnean SocietyBiogeographic dating of phylogenetic divergence times using priors and processes
2021, The Molecular Evolutionary Clock: Theory and PracticeGeographical and temporal origins of terrestrial vertebrates endemic to Taiwan
2018, Journal of Biogeography