We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 July 2023
Since the EU Directive (EC) No 128/2009 (SUD) was approved by the European Parliament, the establishment of a general framework aimed at securing the sustainable use of pesticides was laid down, and European Union (EU) Member States adopted National Action Plans in accordance with this Directive. Specifically, for EU Member States, pesticides, objectives and quantitative targets were created. Therefore, the EU Commission provided a methodology for risk assessment as the derivation of two harmonised risk indicators: HRI_1 and HRI_2. The present study focuses on HRI_1, as this can be implemented at the country level. Each EU Member State delivers annual harmonised risk indicators values to the Commission based on calculations using their own data and results. However, only the EU Commission can derive this HRI_1 (concatenated) indicator at the EU level. Therefore, the present study is an attempt to shed some light on the modus operandi used by the EU Commission to compile this HRI_1, and it also aims to clarify these calculations. Data originating from twenty-seven EU Member States were analysed. These data were compared to data published on the EU Commission website over time. Possible virtual developments including the modification and evolution of active substance statuses are envisaged.
1 “Directive 2009/128/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 establishing a framework for Community action to achieve the sustainable use of pesticides” (2009) 309 Official Journal of the European Union 71.
2 European Commission, “Main Actions, Food Safety” (2019) <https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/sustainable_use_pesticides/main-actions_en> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
3 European Commission, “Environment and human health. Joint European Environment Agency (EEA)-JRC Report No 5/2013-EUR 25933 EN” (2013) 11 Publications Office of the European Union 1 <https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/environment-and-human-health> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
4 M Calliera, A Finizio, G Azimonti, E Benfenati and M Trevisan “Harmonised pesticide risk trend indicator for food: The methodological approach” (2006) 62 Pest Management Science 1168; World Health Organization (WHO), “Harmonised assessment of risk and risk management for water-related infectious disease: an overview” in L Fewtrell and J Bartram (eds), Water Quality: Guidelines, Standards and Health (London, IWA Publishing 2001); F-E Helepciuc and A Todor, “Evaluating the effectiveness of the EU’s approach to the sustainable use of pesticides” (2021) 16 PLoS ONE e0256719; F-E Helepciuc and A Todor, “Evaluating the EU’s Efforts to Improve Resilience to Health and Environmental Risks Associated with Pesticide Use by Analyzing the National Action Plans of EU Member States from 2009 to 2019” (2022) 19 International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 5446; I-C Vasilachi, L Tapciuc, G-M Finaru Chelaru, D-M Asiminicesei, M Rosca, P Cozma et al, “Pesticides in the Environment and Harmonized Risk Indicators” (2020) The 8th IEEE International Conference on E-Health and Bioengineering – EHB 2020 <http://www.ehbconference.ro/2020/Home.aspx> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
5 J Bridges, “Human health and environmental risk assessment: The need for a more harmonised and integrated approach” (2003) 52 Chemosphere 1347.
6 European Parliament and Council, Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council. Evaluation of Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 on the placing of plant protection products on the market and of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 on maximum residue levels of pesticides, COM/2020/208 final; European Parliament and Council, Commission Staff Working Document Accompanying the document Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council. Evaluation of Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 on the placing of plant protection products on the market and of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 on maximum residue levels of pesticides, SWD/2020/87 final; European Parliament and Council, Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council On the experience gained by Member States on the implementation of national targets established in their National Action Plans and on progress in the implementation of Directive 2009/128/EC on the sustainable use of pesticides, COM/2020/204 final.
7 “Commission Directive (EU) 2019/782 of 15 May 2019 amending Directive 2009/128/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards the establishment of harmonised risk indicators” (2019) 127 Official Journal of the European Union 1.
8 J Reus, P Leendertse, C Bockstaller, I Fomsgaard, V Gutsche, K Lewis and T Seppälä, “Comparison and evaluation of eight pesticide environmental risk indicators developed in Europe and recommendations for future use” (2002) 90 Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 177.
9 I-C Vasilachi et al, supra, note 4.
10 “Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market and repealing Council Directives 79/117/EEC and 91/414/EEC” (2009) 309 Official Journal of the European Union 1.
11 Eurostat, “Agri-Environmental indicators” (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/agriculture/agri-environmental-indicators/information> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
12 G Romanazzi, Y Orçonneau, M Moumni, Y Davillerd and PA Marchand, “Basic substances, a sustainable tool to complement and eventually replace synthetic pesticides in the management of pre and postharvest diseases: reviewed instructions for users” (2022) 27 Molecules 3484.
13 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “Expansion of the low-risk substances in the framework of the European Pesticide Regulation (EC) No. 1107/2009” (2022) 13 European Journal of Risk Regulation 514.
14 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “The slow decrease of the active substances candidates for substitution in the framework of the European Pesticide Regulation (EC) No. 1107/2009” (2021) 13 European Journal of Risk Regulation 1.
15 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “Evolution of Regulation (EU) No 540/2011 since its entry into force” (2019) 7 Journal of Regulatory Science 1.
16 European Commission, supra, note 10.
17 European Commission, “A European Green Deal: Striving to be the first climate-neutral continent” (2023) <https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/priorities-2019-2024/european-green-deal_en> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
18 European Commission, “Farm to Fork strategy: for a fair, healthy and environmentally-friendly food system” (2023) <https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/farm-fork-strategy_en> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
19 European Commission, supra, note 1.
20 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “Evolution of Directive (EC) No 128/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a framework for Community action to achieve the sustainable use of pesticides” (2019) 7 Journal of Regulatory Science 1.
21 European Commission, “Member States trends in use and risk of chemical pesticides and the use of more hazardous pesticides” (2023) <https://food.ec.europa.eu/plants/pesticides/sustainable-use-pesticides/farm-fork-targets-progress/member-states-trends_en#member-state-trends> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
22 European Commission, Pesticides database v3 (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/eu-pesticides-database/start/screen/active-substances> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
23 European Commission, supra, note 1.
24 European Commission, supra, note 10.
25 “Regulation (EC) No 1185/2009 of the European Parliament and of the council of 25 November 2009 concerning statistics on pesticides” (2009) 324 Official Journal of the European Union 1.
26 “Directive (EU) 2019/782 of 15 May 2019 amending Directive 2009/128/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards the establishment of harmonised risk indicators” (2009) 127 Official Journal of the European Union 4.
27 “Regulation (EC) No 396/2005 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 February 2005 on maximum residue levels of pesticides in or on food and feed of plant and animal origin and amending Council Directive 91/414/EEC” (2005) 70 Official Journal of the European Union 1.
28 “Implementing Regulation (EU) No 540/2011 of 25 May 2011 implementing Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards the list of approved active substances” (2011) 153 Official Journal of the European Union 133.
29 European Commission, supra, note 4.
30 European Commission, supra, note 22.
31 European Commission, “Trends in Harmonised Risk Indicators for the European Union for 2020” (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/sustainable_use_pesticides/harmonised-risk-indicators/trends-hri-eu_en> (last accessed 9 June 2023); E Barany, I Barbier, J-C Jeanty and D O’Shea, “Methodology for calculating harmonised risk indicators for pesticides under Directive 2009/128/EC – 2019 edition” (2019) Manuals and Guidelines <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-manuals-and-guidelines/product/-/asset_publisher/Wq1sJK3yM5fP/content/ks-gq-19-009> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
32 Eurostat, Sales of pesticides in the EU – Product (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/fr/web/products-eurostat-news/-/DDN-20181015-1> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
33 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
34 European Commission, “Trends in Harmonised Risk Indicators for Member States. Food Safety” (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/sustainable_use_pesticides/harmonised-risk-indicators/trends-hri-ms_en> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
35 European Commission, supra, note 21.
36 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
37 European Commission, supra, note 10.
38 European Commission, “Commission notice concerning a list of potentially low-risk active substances approved for use in plant protection” (2018) C265 Official Journal of the European Union 8.
39 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 14.
40 “Commission Regulation (EU) 2017/1432 of 7 August 2017 amending Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and the Council concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market as regards the criteria for the approval of low-risk active substances” (2017) 205 Official Journal of the European Union 59.
41 European Commission, supra, note 26.
42 PA Marchand, “EU chemical plant protection products in 2023: current state and perspectives” (2023) 2 Agrochemicals 106.
43 European Commission, supra, note 27.
44 “OpenEFSA portal: the single public interface for all information related to EFSA’s scientific work” (2023) <https://open.efsa.europa.eu/> (last accessed 9 June 2023); European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) Journal (2023) <https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
45 PA Marchand, “Basic Substances: An Approval Opportunity for Low Concern Natural Products under EU Pesticide Regulation” (2015) 71 Pest Management Science 1197.
46 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
47 European Commission, supra, note 11.
48 European Commission, supra, note 26.
49 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
50 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 14.
51 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 13.
52 European Commission, supra, note 11.
53 European Commission, “Methodology for calculating harmonized risk indicators for pesticides under Directive 2009/128/EC 2021 edition” (2023) <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/3859598/12727554/KS-GQ-21-008-EN.pdf/d3b02348-3277-a1cd-e7cf-e8ae4367257d?t=1619684530876> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
54 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
55 European Commission, “Trends in Harmonised Risk Indicators for the European Union” (2023) <https://food.ec.europa.eu/plants/pesticides/sustainable-use-pesticides/harmonised-risk-indicators/trends-eu_en#fig1> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
56 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
57 European Commission, supra, note 1.
58 European Commission, supra, note 26.
59 European Court of Auditors, “Sustainable use of plant protection products: limited progress in measuring and reducing risks” (2020) Special Report 05/2020 1 <https://www.eca.europa.eu/en/Pages/DocItem.aspx?did=53001> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
60 European Commission, supra, note 24.
61 European Commission, supra, note 25.
62 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
63 European Commission, “Food Safety. Sustainable Use of Pesticides” (2023) <https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/europhyt/cgi-bin/sud_europa.cgi#/> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
64 Marchand, supra, note 45.
65 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “Low-risk substances, new effective category of biocontrol agents as lever for durable crop protection products” (2021) 5 Chronicle of Bioresource Management 9.
66 PA Marchand, “Basic and Low Risk Substances under EU Pesticide Regulation: A New Choice for Biorationals Portfolio of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises” (2017) 57 Journal of Plant Protection Research 433.
67 Commission Decision of 21 June 2007 concerning the non-inclusion of certain active substances in Annex I to Council Directive 91/414/EEC and the withdrawal of authorisations for plant protection products containing these substances (notified under document number C(2007) 2576). JO L 166 of 28.6.2007, p 16.
68 European Commission, supra, note 38.
69 European Court of Auditors, supra, note 59.
70 “Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2020/1295 of 16 September 2020 amending Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/408 as regards the inclusion of the active substances carbetamide, emamectin, flurochloridone, gamma-cyhalothrin, halosulfuron-methyl, ipconazole and tembotrione in the list of candidates for substitution” (2020) 303 Official Journal of the European Union 18.
71 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 13.
72 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 14.
73 Eurostat, supra, note 32.
74 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
75 Barany et al, supra, note 31.
76 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
77 European Commission, supra, note 53.
78 Barany et al, supra, note 31.
79 European Commission, supra, note 53.
80 Barany et al, supra, note 31.
81 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20.
82 Barany et al, supra, note 31.
83 M Charon, D Robin and PA Marchand, “The major interest for crop protection of agrochemical substances without maximum residue limit (MRL)” (2019) 23 Biotechnologie, Agronomie, Société et Environnement 22.
84 DC Robin and PA Marchand, “Biocontrol active substances: evolution since the entry in vigour of Reg. 1107/2009” (2019) 75 Pest Management Science 950.
85 Eurostat, “Sales of pesticides in the EU” (2020) <https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/fr/web/products-eurostat-news/-/ddn-20200603-1> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
86 European Environment Agency, “Pesticide sales” (2019) <https://www.eea.europa.eu/airs/2018/environment-and-health/pesticides-sales> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
87 “Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/605 of 19 April 2018 amending Annex II to Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 by setting out scientific criteria for the determination of endocrine disrupting properties” (2018) 101 Official Journal of the European Union 33.
88 Helepciuc & Todor (2021), supra, note 4; Helepciuc & Todor (2022), supra, note 4.
89 European Commission, supra, note 53, p 16.
90 European Commission, supra, note 53.
91 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 15; Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20; Robin and Marchand, supra note 84.
92 M-C Vekemans and PA Marchand, “The fate of the biocontrol agents under the European Phytopharmaceutical Regulation: a hindering for approval botanicals as new active substances?” (2020) 27 Environmental Science and Pollution Research 39879.
93 I Sundh and J Eilenberg, “Why has the authorization of microbial biological control agents been slower in the EU than in comparable jurisdictions?” (2021) 77 Pest Management Science 2170.
94 European Commission, supra, note 38.
95 European Court of Auditors, supra, note 59.
96 “Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/383 of 3 March 2021 amending Annex III to Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council listing co-formulants which are not accepted for inclusion in plant protection products” (2021) 74 Official Journal of the European Union 7.
97 “Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/574 of 13 March 2023 setting out detailed rules for the identification of unacceptable co-formulants in plant protection products in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council” (2023) 75 Official Journal of the European Union 7.
98 Commission Regulation, supra, note 87.
99 European Court of Auditors, supra, note 59.
100 European Commission, supra, note 22.
101 Euractiv, “EFSA chief: Assessing fast-changing agrifood innovation is key challenge” (n.d.) <https://www.euractiv.com/section/agriculture-food/interview/efsa-chief-assessing-fast-changing-agrifood-innovation-is-key-challenge-part-i/> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
102 European Commission, “Farmer’s Toolbox for Integrated Pest Management” (2023) <https://datam.jrc.ec.europa.eu/datam/mashup/IPM/index.html> (last accessed 9 June 2023).
103 European Commission, supra, note 1.
104 N Bakthatvatsalam, K Subharan and M Mani, “Semiochemicals and Their Potential Use in Pest Management in Horticultural Crops” in M Mani (ed.), Trends in Horticultural Entomology (Singapore, Springer 2022); PA Marchand, “Synthetic agrochemicals: a necessary clarification about their use exposure and impact in crop protection” (2019) 26 Environmental Science and Pollution Research 17996.
105 PA Marchand, “Novel plant protection regulation: new perspectives for organic production?” (2018) 4 Organic Farming 3.
106 “Regulation (EU) 2018/848 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2018 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007” (2018) 150 Official Journal of the European Union 1.
107 “Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/1165 of 15 July 2021 authorising certain products and substances for use in organic production and establishing their lists” (2021) 253 Official Journal of the European Union 13.
108 Marchand, supra, note 104.
109 N Möhring, K Ingold, P Kudsk, F Martin-Laurent, U Niggli, M Siegrist et al, “Pathways for advancing pesticide policies” (2020) 1 Nature Food 535; F Dedieu, “Organized denial at work: The difficult search for consistencies in French pesticide regulation” (2022) 16 Regulation & Governance 951; VC Schreiner, M Link, S Kunz, E Szöcs, A Scharmüller, B Vogler et al, “Paradise lost? Pesticide pollution in a European region with considerable amount of traditional agriculture” (2021) 188 Water research 116528.
110 European Parliament and Council, supra, note 6.
111 European Parliament, “The future of crop protection in Europe: Appendix 1 – Overview of current and emerging crop protection practices” (2021) <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2021/656330/EPRS_STU(2021)656330_EN.pdf > (last accessed 9 June 2023).
112 European Commission, supra, note 22.
113 Marchand, supra, note 42.
114 Vekemans and Marchand, supra, note 92.
115 European Commission, supra, note 38.
116 “Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/129 of 3 February 2021 renewing the approval of the active substance garlic extract in accordance with Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market, and amending the Annex to Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 540/2011” (2021) 40 Official Journal of the European Union 11; Robin and Marchand, supra, note 20; Robin and Marchand, supra, note 65; Robin and Marchand, supra, note 84.
117 Robin and Marchand, supra, note 14.
118 PA Marchand, “Biocontrol agents in Europe: substitution plant protection active substances or a new paradigm?” (2023) Environmental Science & Policy (submitted).
119 Möhring et al, supra, note 109.
120 DC Robin, L Merlet and PA Marchand, “Regulatory aspects of biocontrol” in C Prigent-Combaret and B Dumas (eds), Biocontrol of Plant Disease: Recent Advances and prospects in Plant Protection (London, ISTE 2023) pp 1–17.
