Investigating the application of generalized additive models to discrete-time event history analysis for birth events

Joanne Ellison; Ann  Berrington; Erengul Dodd; Jonathan J. Forster

Volume 47 - Article 22 | Pages 647–694

Investigating the application of generalized additive models to discrete-time event history analysis for birth events

By Joanne Ellison, Ann Berrington, Erengul Dodd, Jonathan J. Forster

Date received:

15 Oct 2021

Date published:

28 Oct 2022

Word count:

8264

Keywords:

discrete-time event history, educational differentials, fertility, general additive models, parity progression, period fertility, postponement of childbearing, retrospective histories, time since last birth, United Kingdom

DOI:

10.4054/DemRes.2022.47.22

Additional Files:

demographic-research.47-22 (zip file, 13 kB)
readme.47-22 (text file, 1 kB)

Download PDF
Submit a Response Letter

Abstract

Background: Discrete-time event history analysis (EHA) is the standard approach taken when modelling fertility histories collected in surveys, where the date of birth is often recorded imprecisely. This method is commonly used to investigate the factors associated with the time to a first or subsequent conception or birth. Although there is an emerging trend towards the smooth incorporation of continuous covariates in the broader literature, this is yet to be formally embraced in the context of birth events.

Objective: We investigate the formal application of smooth methods implemented via generalized additive models (GAMs) to the analysis of fertility histories. We also determine whether and where GAMs offer a practical improvement over existing approaches.

Methods: We fit parity-specific logistic GAMs to data from the UK Household Longitudinal Study, learning about the effects of age, period, time since last birth, educational qualification, and country of birth. First, we select the most parsimonious GAMs that fit the data sufficiently well. Then we compare them with corresponding models that use the existing methods of categorical, polynomial, and piecewise linear spline representations in terms of fit, complexity, and substantive insights gained.

Results: We find that smooth terms can offer considerable improvements in precision and efficiency, particularly for highly non-linear effects and interactions between continuous variables. Their flexibility enables the detection of important features that are missed or estimated imprecisely by comparator methods.

Contribution: Our findings suggest that GAMs are a useful addition to the demographer’s toolkit. They are highly relevant for motivating future methodological developments in EHA, both for birth events and more generally.