Long-term growth decline precedes sudden crown dieback of European beech

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agrformet.2022.109103Get rights and content
Under a Creative Commons license
open access

Highlights

  • Use of generalized additive mixed models to test growth differences.

  • Declining beech trees grew slower for more than 50 years compared to vital ones.

  • Competition and species diversity not relevant for predisposition to crown dieback.

  • Early-warning signals and resilience indices cannot predict crown dieback.

Abstract

European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) has strongly suffered from the exceptional 2018 drought and subsequent dry years that hit Central Europe. While many trees showed severe signs of crown dieback or died following the 2018 extreme drought, other co-occurring and neighboring trees showed no sign of dieback or only minor damage. The reasons why some trees were more severely impacted than others and which predisposing factors make some trees more vulnerable than others are still poorly understood. Here, we analyzed differences in long-term growth trends, neighborhood composition (competition and species diversity), early-warning signals, and growth responses to past severe droughts of co-occurring vital and severely declining beech trees at six sites in Switzerland. We aimed to connect tree vitality after 2018 with past long-term growth trajectories and investigated whether declining trees had already been more susceptible to drought than vital trees before dieback occurred.

Overall, trees that showed severe crown dieback had a stronger growth decline than vital trees in the last 50 years. Declining trees exhibited stagnating and then decreasing growth trajectories even before signs of crown dieback occurred. Interestingly, we did not find significant differences in growth response to past severe droughts between the vitality classes, with the exception that vital trees recovered faster from past more severe droughts. Further, we could neither detect any difference in the effect of competition and neighborhood species composition on growth response, nor predict crown dieback based on early-warning signals which try to predict regime shifts by sudden changes in the autoregressive coefficient with lag 1, standard deviation and skewness. Our results indicate that unlike vital trees, declining beech trees showed predisposing signs for crown dieback by having lower growth rates during the last 50 years.

Keywords

Competition
Dendrochronology
Drought resilience
Early-warning signals
Fagus sylvatica
Tree vitality

Data availability

  • Data will be made available on request.

Cited by (0)