Abstract
The paper presents a seismic safety assessment of unreinforced masonry (URM) building using two approaches. The first approach uses the ‘Pier Analysis’ method, based on the concept of equivalent lateral stiffness, where in-plane and out-of-plane actions are considered independently. The second approach is developed with the program SAP2000, where the linear response is evaluated using continuum ‘finite element modelling’ (FEM). Both methods are compared to evaluate the safety of wall piers and the differences in the outcomes under combined gravitational and lateral seismic forces. The analysis results showed that few wall elements are unsafe in in-plane and out-of-plane tension. It is also observed that the pier analysis method is conservative compared to FEM, but can be used as a simplified and quick tool in design offices for safety assessment, with reasonable accuracy. To safeguard the URM wall piers under lateral loads, a retrofitting technique is adopted by providing vertical and horizontal belts called splints and bandages, respectively, using welded wire mesh (WWM) reinforcement. The study using the ‘Pier Analysis’ shows that the lateral load capacity of unsafe URM piers can be enhanced up to 3.67 times and made safe using the applied retrofitting technique. Further, the retrofitting design methodology and recommendations for application procedures to on-site URM buildings are discussed in detail.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Magenes G, Calvi G M. In-plane seismic response of brick masonry walls. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 1997, 26(11): 1091–1112
Tomazevic M. Earthquake Resistant Design of Masonry Buildings. London: Imperial College Press, 1999
Abrams D P. Performance-based engineering concepts for unreinforced masonry building structures. Progress in Structural Engineering and Materials, 2001, 3(1): 48–56
Asteris P G, Chronopoulos M P, Chrysostomou C Z, Varum H, Plevris V, Kyriakides N, Silva V. Seismic vulnerability assessment of historical masonry structural systems. Engineering Structures, 2014, 62–63: 118–134
Sinha R, Brzev S. Housing Report: Unreinforced Brick Masonry Building with Reinforced Concrete Roof Slab. EERI and IAEE, 2002
Padalu P K V R. Out-of-plane seismic behavior and strengthening of unreinforced masonry walls. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Roorkee: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, 2019
Kadam S. Seismic evaluation and retrofit of masonry buildings. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Roorkee: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, 2015
Agarwal P. Experimental study of seismic strengthening and retrofitting measures in masonry building. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Roorkee: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, 1999
Masood A. Out-of-plane behavior of unreinforced masonry infill panels. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Roorkee: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, India, 2006
Dubey R N. Experimental studies to verify the efficacy of earthquake resistant measures in masonry buildings. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Roorkee: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, 2010
Jain S K, Murty C V R, Arlekar J N, Sinha R, Goyal A, Jain C K. Some observations on engineering aspects of the Jabalpur earthquake of 22 May 1997. EERI Special Earthquake Report, EERI Newsletter, 1997, 32(2): 1–18
Jain S K, Murty C V R, Arlekar J N, Rajendran C P, Rajendran K, Sinha R. Chamoli (Himalaya, India) earthquake of 29 March 1999. EERI Special Earthquake Report, EERI Newsletter, 1999, 33(7): 8
Sinha R, Shaw R, Goyal A, Choudhary M D, Jaiswal K, Saita J, Arai H, Pribadi K, Arya A S. The Bhuj Earthquake of January 26, 2001. Miki: Indian Institute of Technology Bombay and Earthquake Disaster Mitigation Research Center, 2001
Javed M, Naeem Khan A, Penna A, Magenes G. Behavior of masonry structures during the Kashmir 2005 earthquake. In: Proceedings of 1st European Conference on Earthquake Engineering and Seismology. Geneva: Curran Associates, 2006
Rai D C, Singhal V, Bhushan Raj S, Lalit Sagar S. Performance of residential buildings during the M 7. 8 Gorkha (Nepal) Earthquake of 25 April 2015. Current Science, 2015, 109(11): 2126–2135
Jagadish K S, Raghunath S, Rao K N. Behavior of masonry structures during the Bhuj earthquake of January 2001. Journal of Earth System Science, 2003, 112(3): 431–440
Jain S K. Earthquake safety in India: Achievements, challenges and opportunities. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2016, 14(5): 1337–1436
Farooq S H, Ilyas M. A study on failure pattern observed in masonry buildings during 8th October Hazara-Kashmir earthquake in Pakistan. In: Proceedings of 7th International Congress on Civil Engineering. Tehran: ICCE, 2006
Rossetto T, Peiris N. Observations of damage due to the Kashmir earthquake of October 8, 2005 and study of current seismic provisions for buildings in Pakistan. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2009, 7(3): 681–699
FEMA P-774. Unreinforced Masonry Buildings and Earthquakes. Washington, D.C.: Federal Emergency Management Agency, 2009
EERI. Special Earthquake Report: Earthquake in Gujarat, India. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, 2001
Sinha R, Goyal A. Damage to buildings in Latur earthquake. Current Science, 1994, 67(5): 380–386
Sinha R, Murty C V R. The 1993 Killari Earthquake: Engineering lessons and challenges. Indian Concrete Journal, 1998, 72(11): 591–601
Kumar A, Sinha R. Rural Mud House with Pitched Roof. World Housing Encyclopedia Report, Report No. 23, 2003
Bruneau M. State-of-the-art report on seismic performance of unreinforced masonry buildings. Journal of Structural Engineering, 1994, 120(1): 230–251
Andreaus U. Failure criteria for masonry panels under in-plane loading. Journal of Structural Engineering, 1996, 122(1): 37–46
Vasconcelos G. Experimental investigations on the mechanics of stone masonry: Characterization of granites and behavior of ancient masonry shear walls. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Braga: University of Minho, 2005
Rai D C, Goel S C. Seismic strengthening of rocking-critical masonry piers. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2007, 133(10): 1445–1452
Lee J, Li C, Oh S, Yang W, Yi W. Evaluation of rocking and toe crushing failure of unreinforced masonry walls. Advances in Structural Engineering, 2008, 11(5): 475–489
Tomazevic M. Shear resistance of masonry walls and Eurocode 6: Shear versus tensile strength of masonry. Materials and Structures, 2009, 42(7): 889–907
Quagliarini E, Maracchini G, Clementi F. Uses and limits of the Equivalent Frame Model on existing unreinforced masonry buildings for assessing their seismic risk: A review. Journal of Building Engineering, 2017, 10: 166–182
Monaco M, Calderoni B, Lannuzzo A, Gesualdo A. Behavior of in-plane loaded masonry panels. Procedia Structural Integrity, 2018, 11: 388–393
Calderini C, Cattari S, Lagomarsino S. In-plane strength of unreinforced masonry piers. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 2009, 38(2): 243–267
Mojsilović N. Strength of masonry subjected to in-plane loading: A contribution. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2011, 48(6): 865–873
Betti M, Galano L, Petracchi M, Vignoli A. Diagonal cracking shear strength of unreinforced masonry panels: A correction proposal of the b shape factor. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2015, 13(10): 3151–3186
Celano T, Argiento L U, Ceroni F, Casapulla C. Literature review of the in-plane behavior of masonry walls: Theoretical vs. experimental results. Materials (Basel), 2021, 14(11): 3063
Betti M, Galano L. Shear strength of rubble stone-and-brick masonry panels. A new proposal for the interpretation of Sheppard test results. Construction & Building Materials, 2021, 279: 121925
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N. Computed versus observed seismic response and damage of masonry buildings. Journal of Structural Engineering, 1992, 118(7): 1804–1821
Ingham J M, Griffith M C. Performance of unreinforced masonry buildings during the 2010 Darfield (Christchurch, NZ) earthquake. Australian Journal of Structural Engineering, 2010, 11(3): 207–224
Dizhur D, Ingham J, Griffith M C, Biggs D, Schultz A. Performance of unreinforced masonry and infilled RC buildings during the 2015 Gorkha, Nepal earthquake sequence. In: Proceedings of 16th Brick and Block Masonry Conference. Padova: CRC Press, 2016: 2399–2407
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Experimental study of comparative efficacy of out-of-plane strengthening of masonry walls using FRP and Wire/Textile reinforced mortar. In: Proceedings of 17th Brick and Block Masonry Conference. Krakow: CRC Press, Taylor & Francis, 2020: 379–387
Griffith M C, Vaculik J, Wilson J, Lumantarna E. Cyclic testing of unreinforced masonry walls in two-way bending. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 2007, 36(6): 801–821
Senaldi I, Magenes G, Penna A, Galasco A, Rota M. The effect of stiffened floor and roof diaphragms on the experimental seismic response of a full-scale unreinforced stone masonry buildings. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2014, 18(3): 407–443
Sathiparan N. Effect of roof diaphragm on masonry structures under dynamic loading. Earthquakes and Structures, 2016, 10(2): 351–366
Graziotti F, Guerrini G, Kallioras S, Marchesi B, Rossi A, Tomassetti U, Penna A, Magenes G. Shaking table test on a full-scale unreinforced clay masonry building with flexible diaphragms. In: Proceedings of 13th Canadian Masonry Symposium (CMS). Halifax: Canada Masonry Design Center, 2017
Meisl C S, Elwood K J, Ventura C. Shake table tests on the out-of-plane response of unreinforced masonry walls. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 2007, 34(11): 1381–1392
Betti M, Galano L, Vignoli A. Comparative analysis on the seismic behavior of unreinforced masonry buildings with flexible diaphragms. Engineering Structures, 2014, 61: 195–208
Lawrence S J, Marshall R J. Virtual work approach to design of masonry walls under lateral loading. DRM429: CSIRO Division of Building, Construction and Engineering, 1996
Menon A, Magenes G. Out-of-Plane Seismic Response of Unreinforced Masonry Definition of Seismic Input. Research Report ROSE, 2008
Menon A, Magenes G. Definition of seismic input for out-of-plane response of masonry walls: I. Parametric study. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2011, 15(2): 165–194
Menon A, Magenes G. Definition of seismic input for out-of-plane response of masonry walls: II. Formulation. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2011, 15(2): 195–213
Paulay T, Priestley M J N. Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Buildings. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1992
Velazquez-Dimas J I, Ehsani M R. Modeling out-of-plane behavior of URM walls retrofitted with fiber composites. Journal of Composites for Construction, 2000, 4(4): 172–181
Tomazevic M, Lutman M, Velechovsky T. The influence of rigidity of floor on the seismic behavior of old stone-masonry buildings. European Earthquake Engineering, 1991, 3: 28–41
Lourenco P B, Mendes N, Ramos L F, Oliveira D V. Analysis of masonry structures without box behavior. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2011, 4–5: 369–382
Vintzileou E, Mouzakis C, Adami C E, Karapitta L. Seismic behavior of three-leaf stone masonry buildings before and after interventions: Shaking table tests on a two-storey masonry model. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2015, 13(10): 3107–3133
Brignola A, Pampanin S, Podesta S. Evaluation and control of the in-plane stiffness of timber floors for the performance-based retrofit of URM buildings. Bulletin of New Zealand National Society of Earthquake Engineering, 2009, 42(3): 204–221
Magenes G, Penna A, Rota M, Galasco A, Senaldi I. Shaking table test of a full-scale stone masonry building with flexible diaphragms. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2014, 8(3): 349–375
Kollerathu J A, Menon A. Role of diaphragm flexibility modelling in seismic analysis of existing masonry structures. Structures, 2017, 11: 22–39
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Out-of-plane flexural behavior of masonry wallettes strengthened using FRP composites and externally bonded grids: Comparative study. Composites. Part B, Engineering, 2019, 176: 107302
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Out-of-plane flexural strengthening of URM wallettes using basalt fiber reinforced polymer composite. Construction & Building Materials, 2019, 216: 272–295
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Efficacy of basalt fiber reinforced cement mortar composite for out-of-plane strengthening of unreinforced masonry. Construction & Building Materials, 2018, 191: 1172–1190
Gattesco N, Boem I. Out of plane behavior of reinforced masonry walls: Experimental and numerical study. Composites. Part B, Engineering, 2017, 128: 39–52
De Santis S, De Canio G, De Felice G, Meriggi P, Roselli I. Out-of-plane seismic retrofitting of masonry walls with textile reinforced mortar composites. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2019, 17(11): 6265–6300
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Cyclic two-way out-of-plane testing of unreinforced masonry walls retrofitted using composite materials. Construction & Building Materials, 2020, 238: 117784
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Tensile properties of wire and fiber reinforced cementitious matrix composites for strengthening of masonry. Structures, 2020, 23: 164–179
Shabdin M, Zargaran M, Attari N K A. Experimental diagonal tension (shear) test of un-reinforced masonry (URM) walls strengthened with textile reinforced mortar (TRM). Construction & Building Materials, 2018, 164: 704–715
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Experimental investigation of out-of-plane behavior of URM wallettes strengthened using welded wire mesh. Construction & Building Materials, 2018, 190: 1133–1153
Chellappa S, Dubey R N. Performance evaluation of a reinforced masonry model and an unreinforced masonry model using a shake table testing facility. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 2018, 32(1): 04017121
Kadam S, Singh Y, Li B. Experimental investigations on masonry buildings strengthened using ferro-cement overlay under dynamic loading. ISET Journal of Earthquake Technology, 2020, 57(1): 1–16
Arya A S. Model studies of masonry buildings as related to earthquake resistant design requirements. In: Proceedings of International Research Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Skopje: IEEES, 1980
Arya A S, Srivastava L S, Gupta S P. Survey of damages during the Dhamar Earthquake of 13 December 1982 in Yemen Arab Republic. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 1985, 75(2): 597–610
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N. Effectiveness of seismic strengthening techniques for masonry buildings. Journal of Structural Engineering, 1992, 118(7): 1884–1902
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N, Vintzeleou E, Harisis A. Effectiveness of seismic strengthening interventions. In: Proceedings of International Conference on Structural Preservation of the Architectural Heritage. Rome: IABSE Reports, 1993: 549–556
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N. Assessment of intervention techniques for seismic strengthening of masonry buildings. In: Proceedings of 1st International Congress on Restoration of the Architectural Heritage and Building. Canarias, 1992: 174–180
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N. Analytical study of strengthening techniques for earthquake resistant masonry buildings. In: Proceedings of 9th European Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Moscow: Kucherenko Tsniisk of the USSR Gosstroy, 1990: 125–134
Karantoni F V, Fardis M N. Assessment of Analysis Methods and of Strengthening Techniques for Earthquake Resistant Masonry Structures. In: Proceedings of International Conference on Structural Conservation of Stone Masonry—Diagnosis, Repair and Strengthening. Athens: ICCROM, 1989: 155–163
IS 4326. Earthquake Resistant Design and Construction of Buildings—Code of Practice. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 2002
Arya A S. Seismic retrofitting of stone houses in Marathwada Area, India. In: Proceedings of 11th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Acapulco: Elsevier Science, 1996
IS 13935. Seismic Evaluation, Repair and Strengthening of Masonry Buildings—Guidelines. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 2009
Shrestha H, Pradhan S, Guragain R. Experiences on retrofitting of low strength masonry buildings by different retrofitting techniques in Nepal. In: 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Lisbon: Lisboa SPES, 2012
Ashraf M, Khan A N, Ali Q, Khan S, Naseer A. Experimental behavior of full scale URM building retrofitted with ferrocement overlay. Advanced Materials Research, 2011, 255–260: 319–323
Betti M, Galano L, Vignoli A. Time-history seismic analysis of masonry buildings: A comparison between two non-linear modelling approaches. Buildings, 2015, 5(2): 597–621
Padalu P K V R, Singh Y, Das S. Analytical modelling of out-of-plane flexural response of unreinforced and strengthened masonry walls. Engineering Structures, 2020, 218: 110797
Parisse F, Cattari S, Marques R, Lourenço P B, Magenes G, Beyer K, Calderoni B, Camata G, Cordasco E A, Erberik M A, İçel C, Karakaya M, Malomo D, Manzini C F, Marano C, Messali F, Occhipinti G, Pantò B, Saygılı Ö, Sousamli M. Benchmarking the seismic assessment of unreinforced masonry buildings from a blind prediction test. Structures, 2021, 31: 982–1005
Ravichandran N, Losanno D, Parisi F. Comparative assessment of finite element macro-modelling approaches for seismic analysis of non-engineered masonry constructions. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2021, 19(13): 5565–5607
Lagomarsino S, Penna A, Galasco A, Cattari S. Tremuri program: An equivalent frame model for the non-linear seismic analysis of masonry buildings. Engineering Structures, 2013, 56: 1787–1799
Kadam S, Singh Y, Li B. Seismic fragility reduction of an unreinforced masonry school building through retrofit using ferrocement overlay. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration, 2020, 19(2): 397–412
Demirlioglu K, Gonen S, Soyoz S, Limongelli M P. In-plane seismic response analyses of a historical brick masonry building using equivalent frame and 3D FEM modeling approaches. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2020, 14(2): 238–256
Zucchini A, Lourenco P B. A micro-mechanical homogenization model for masonry: Application to shear walls. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2009, 46(3–4): 871–886
Lemos J V. Discrete element modelling of masonry structures. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2007, 1(2): 190–213
Ferreira T M, Mendes N, Silva R. Multiscale seismic vulnerability assessment and retrofit of existing masonry buildings. Buildings, 2019, 9(4): 91
Pandey B K, Meguro K. Simulation of brick masonry wall behavior under in-plane lateral loading using applied element method. In: Proceedings of 13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Vancouver: WCEE Secretariat, 2004
Kamran A S, Khan R A. Seismic performance of heritage school building. Procedia Engineering, 2017, 173: 1763–1770
Lourenço P B, Rots J G. A multi-surface interface model for the analysis of masonry structures. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 1997, 123(7): 660–668
Calderini C, Lagomarsino S. Continuum model for in-plane anisotropic inelastic behavior of masonry. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2008, 134(2): 209–220
Augenti N, Parisi N. Non-linear static analysis of masonry structures. In: Proceedings of 13th Italian national Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Bologna, Italy, 2009
Drysdale R G, Hamid A A, Baker L R. Masonry Structures Behavior and Design. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1994
Taly N. Design Of Reinforced Masonry Structures. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Publications, 2010
Schneider R R, Dickey W L. Reinforced Masonry Design. 3rd ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1994
Petrovcic S, Kilar V. Seismic failure mode interaction for the equivalent frame modeling of unreinforced masonry structures. Engineering Structures, 2013, 54: 9–22
Siano R, Camata G, Sepe V, Spacone E, Roca P, Pela L. Numerical validation of equivalent-frame models for URM walls. In: Proceedings of 7th European Congress on Computational Methods in Applied Sciences and Engineering. Crete Island: Institute of Structural Analysis and Antiseismic Research, School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2016
Kappos A J, Penelis G G, Drakopoulos C G. Evaluation of simplified models for lateral load analysis of unreinforced masonry buildings. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2002, 128(7): 890–897
Tomazevic M. The computer program POR. Report ZRMK, 1978
Magenes G. A method for pushover analysis in seismic assessment of masonry buildings. In: Proceedings of 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Auckland: New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 2000: 1866–1875
Penna A, Galasco A, Lagomarsino S. A nonlinear macro-element model for the seismic analysis of masonry buildings. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 2014, 43(2): 159–179
Kollerathu J A. Non-linear modelling and seismic analysis of existing unreinforced masonry structures. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Chennai: Indian Institute of Technology Madras, 2017
IS 1893 (Part-I). Indian Standard Criteria for Earthquake Design of Structures. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 2016
IS 875 (Part-I). Code of Practice for Design Loads (Other than Earthquake) for Buildings and Structures—Dead Loads. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 1987
IS 875 (Part-2). Code of Practice for Design Loads (Other than Earthquake) for Buildings and Structures—Imposed Loads. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 1987
IS 1905. Code of Practice for Structural Use of Unreinforced Masonry. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 1987
IS 456. Plain and Reinforced Concrete—Code of Practice. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 2000
ISET. A Manual of Earthquake Resistant Non-Engineered Construction, 2001
IS 13828. Improving earthquake resistance of low strength masonry buildings—Guidelines. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), 1993
CSI. Analysis Reference Manual for SAP 2000 Version 17, 2010
Angelis A D, Maddaloni G, Pecce M R. Seismic vulnerability assessment of a monumental masonry building. Infrastructures, 2020, 5(11): 93
Choudhury T, Milani G, Kaushik H B. Comprehensive numerical approaches for the design and safety assessment of masonry buildings retrofitted with steel bands in developing countries: The case of India. Construction & Building Materials, 2015, 85: 227–246
Monteiro M, Bento R. Seismic characterization and evaluation of an old masonry building. In: Proceedings of 50SE-EEE (1963-2013) International Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Macedonia, 2013
Acknowledgements
The first author has received a research assistantship from the Rail Vikas Nigam Limited, Rishikesh, Government of India project of Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee (No. EQD-6031/2019-20), for conducting this research work. The support received from the grant authority is gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Padalu, P.K.V.R., Singh, Y. Seismic safety evaluation methodology for masonry building and retrofitting using splint and bandage technique with wire mesh. Front. Struct. Civ. Eng. 16, 478–505 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11709-022-0817-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11709-022-0817-1