Case ReportThe developmental origins and behavioral consequences of attributions for inequality☆
Section snippets
The development of attributions for inequality
Generally, attributions can be conceptualized along two key dimensions: locus of causality and controllability. Locus of causality refers to whether someone attributes the cause of a situation to an individual (referred to as an individual or dispositional attribution) or the context (referred to as a situational or structural attribution). The other key dimension is controllability, which is whether an individual perceives a situation or behavior as controllable or uncontrollable (Weiner, 1985
Distributive justice across development
In addition to examining the content of attributions for inequality in children of different ages, the current research tests the relationship between these attributions and giving behavior in childhood. A number of studies have examined children's use of effort (a controllable, dispositional attribution) as a guiding principle for distributing resources. In general, children have an aversion to unequal distributions and choose to allocate resources equally (e.g., Li, Spitzer, & Olson, 2014;
The current research
The current research examines the developmental origins and behavioral consequences of attributions for inequality across three studies. In our first study, we examine preferred explanations for inequality by asking parents how they would explain a number of inequality scenarios to their children (methods adapted from Hussak & Cimpian, 2015). In our second study, we explore whether parents' attributions for inequality predict their children's. In our final study, we explore the behavioral
Open practices statement
Preregistrations and de-identified datasets for all three studies can be found in our Open Science Framework repository (https://osf.io/8c4dv/). Complete materials are available in the Supplementary Material. For Study 1, the Boston sample of Study 2, and Study 3, we report all measures, manipulations, and exclusions. For the Vancouver sample of Study 2, additional unrelated measures were collected for a separate study on children's happiness and prosocial giving, which we do not report here.
Study 2
In Study 1, parents chose controllable dispositional attributions (i.e., effort) significantly more often than uncontrollable dispositional (i.e., innate ability) or uncontrollable situational attributions (i.e., luck) when asked to explain inequality to their children. Though replication is required to further substantiate these findings, these results are consistent with research showing that adults prefer controllable dispositional attributions (e.g., Piff et al., 2020). These results also
Study 3
Study 2 indicates that parents and children tend to make controllable dispositional attributions (i.e., effort) for inequality more than uncontrollable dispositional attributions (i.e., innate ability) or uncontrollable situational attributions (i.e., luck). Parents' attributions were predictive of their children's such that parents—and in particular mothers—who made more controllable dispositional attributions were more likely to have children who made these attributions. Together with the
Author note
This research is supported by a John Templeton Foundation subaward from Baylor University [grant number: 32270245-05-CIF] and Harvard Business School funding awarded to A.V. Whillans, and Western Washington University funding awarded to A.M. Gonzalez. Correspondence should be addressed to Antonya Gonzalez, Department of Psychology, Western Washington University, 516 High Street, MS 9172, Bellingham, WA, 98225; email: [email protected]. Preregistration documents and datasets for this
References (73)
- et al.
Young children’s ideas about the nature, causes, justification, and alleviation of poverty
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
(2005) - et al.
Young children’s reasoning about the effects of poverty on people experiencing it: A qualitative thematic analysis
Children and Youth Services Review
(2018) - et al.
Developmental shifts toward structural explanations and interventions for social status disparities
Cognitive Development
(2021) - et al.
Children’s developing understanding of legitimate reasons for allocating resources unequally
Cognitive Development
(2016) - et al.
The relationship between parental racial attitudes and children’s implicit prejudice
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2005) - et al.
Infants reason about deserving agents: A test with distributive actions
Cognitive Development
(2017) - et al.
Just rewards: 17-month-old infants expect agents to take resources according to the principles of distributive justice
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
(2018) - et al.
Both selfishness and selflessness start with the self: How wealth shapes responses to charitable appeals
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2017) - et al.
Belief in hard work and prosocial behavior: Evidence from a randomized field experiment [unpublished manuscript]
(2017) - et al.
Fairness and the development of inequality acceptance
Science
(2010)
The elephant curve of global inequality and growth
AEA Papers and Proceedings
Preschoolers are able to take merit into account when distributing goods
Developmental Psychology
Gender stereotypes about intellectual ability emerge early and influence children’s interests
Science
Achievement in math and science: Do mothers’ beliefs matter 12 years later?
Journal of Educational Psychology
I bet you know more and are nicer too!’: what children infer from others’ accuracy
Developmental Science
Predicting support for welfare policies: The impact of attributions and beliefs about inequality
Journal of Poverty
The psychological consequences of income inequality
Social and Personality Psychology Compass
Coached for the classroom: Parents’ cultural transmission and children’s reproduction of educational inequalities
American Sociological Review
That’s not fair”: similarities and differences in distributive justice reasoning between American and Filipino children
Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
White children’s alignment to the perceived racial attitudes of the parents: Closer to the mother than the father
British Journal of Developmental Psychology
Preschoolers’ understanding of merit in two Asian societies
PLoS One
Attitudes toward the poor and attributions for poverty
Journal of Social Issues
The second shift reflected in the second generation: Do parents’ gender roles at home predict children’s aspirations?
Psychological Science
The apple does not fall far from the tree, or does it? A meta-analysis of parent-child similarity in intergroup attitudes
Psychological Bulletin
Missing the mark: Effects of time and causal attributions on goal revision in response to goal-performance discrepancies
Journal of Applied Psychology
The development of prosocial behavior
GPOWER: A general power analysis program
Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers
Sophistication and the antecedents of Whites’ racial policy attitudes: Racism, ideology, and affirmative action in America
Public Opinion Quarterly
Social desirability bias and the validity of indirect questioning
Journal of Consumer Research
Adolescents’ theories about economic inequality: Why are some people poor while others are rich?
Developmental Psychology
Transmission and transaction: Predicting adolescents’ internalization of parental religious values
Journal of Family Psychology
The origins of children’s growth and fixed mindsets: New research and a new proposal
Child Development
The symbolic racism 2000 scale
Political Psychology
An early-emerging explanatory heuristic promotes support for the status quo
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Politics across generations: Family transmission reexamined
The Journal of Politics
Social inequality and the reduction of ideological dissonance on behalf of the system: Evidence of enhanced system justification among the disadvantaged
European Journal of Social Psychology
Cited by (12)
Intergenerational transmission of luck versus effort beliefs
2023, Economics LettersExamining the effects of socioeconomic status indicators on the association between growth mindset and sense of belonging to school
2024, Social Psychology of EducationRelational Attributions for One’s Own Resilience Predict Compassion for Others
2024, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- ☆
This paper has been recommended for acceptance by Michael Kraus.