Load interaction effect on fatigue crack growth in through-wall cracked pipes under large scale yielding: Experimental and numerical investigation
Graphical abstract
Introduction
Structural integrity assessment under seismic loading is essential for structural stability evaluation of a piping system. The seismic loading can be characterized by its high strain rate and large-amplitude cyclic loading. It has been shown that large-amplitude cyclic loading causes more severe degradation effect on fracture toughness than the strain rate [[1], [2], [3], [4], [5]]. Furthermore, for very low cycle fatigue loading condition caused by large-amplitude cyclic loading, fracture behavior of a cracked pipe can be different from that of a small specimen due to the constraint effect and thus the full-scale pipe test would be required to understand fracture behavior. Therefore, many full-scale pipe experiments under large-amplitude cyclic loading simulating seismic loading have been conducted to investigate fracture behavior in many countries (US [[5], [6], [7], [8]], Japan [[9], [10], [11], [12]], India [[13], [14], [15], [16], [17]] and Korea [18]). These experiments have focused on the effects of the loading type (such as the load- or displacement-controlled cyclic loading) [[5], [6], [7], [8],[13], [14], [15],18], cyclic loading variables (such as the load/displacement amplitude and load ratio) [9,10,[13], [14], [15]], material (base or weld) [9,10,16,17] and so on. However, in most of cases, constant amplitude and load ratio conditions were applied, but not variable amplitude and load ratio conditions.
The load interaction effect on the fatigue crack growth has been well known and has been analyzed experimentally as well as analytically [[19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33], [34], [35], [36], [37], [38], [39], [40], [41], [42], [43], [44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52], [53], [54]]. The crack retardation effect (decrease in the crack growth rate) was observed in the high-low loading sequence (decrease in the load amplitude) [[21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33]] and in the overload case [[27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33], [34], [35], [36], [37], [38], [39], [40], [41], [42], [43], [44], [45], [46], [47], [48], [49], [50], [51], [52], [53], [54]]. On the other hand, the crack acceleration effect (increase in the crack growth rate) was observed in the low-high loading sequence [[21], [22], [23], [24], [25], [26], [27], [28], [29], [30], [31], [32], [33]]. Such crack retardation and acceleration effects due to the load interaction can be well described by the crack closure phenomenon [19,20,[55], [56], [57], [58], [59]]. Many researchers attempted to identify the crack closure phenomenon by using the strain gage [[60], [61], [62], [63]], Digital Image Correlation (DIC) [[48], [49], [50], [51]] and SEM [64]. For a cracked specimen, the crack tip deformation, crack opening load and residual stress were difficult to observe from the fracture surface. In this respect, the crack closure was determined via FE analysis by using inversion of stresses at crack tip [42,43,65,66], last contact [27,[65], [66], [67],69] and contact force [68] in the FE analysis.
The above-mentioned works were conducted under the small-scale yielding condition, but the crack growth behavior under large scale yielding conditions is expected to differ from that under small scale yielding. Works related to the load interaction effect on fatigue crack closure under large scale yielding are quite limited. The FE analysis for a plate with a hole showed the decrease of the crack opening stress, as the maximum stress approached the yield strength [70,71]. The crack opening stress was further reduced for completely reversed cyclic loading (R=-1) under elastic-plastic condition. For plane strain FE analysis of a crack problem, crack closure was hardly observed for completely reversed cyclic loading (R=-1) when the maximum cyclic stress was close to the yield strength [72]. Experiment was performed using a specimen with the corner crack under two different fatigue loading conditions; small scale and large scale yielding conditions [73]. The crack opening and closure behaviors were investigated using experimentally measured load-displacement curves. Under the completely reversed cyclic loading, the crack was open even at the minimum load under the large scale yielding but was usually close at the zero load under the small-scale yielding. In Ref. [74], two specimens with different sizes were used to investigate the crack closure effect. A small size specimen with an artificial small surface crack and large size specimen with an actual surface crack were tested under large scale yielding fatigue loading conditions. The crack closure behavior was observed by measuring the relative displacement of the crack front using the digital image correlation. It was found that the crack opening load was approximately equal to the minimum load in both specimens under cyclic loading, suggesting that crack closure did not occur. The effect of crack closure on fatigue crack growth in a cracked pipe was also observed in [75]. The fatigue crack growth for cracked pipe was predicted by using various pipe evaluation methods (GE/EPRI [76], LBB.NRC [77], LBB.ENG2 [78,79]). The predicted fatigue crack growth depending on the crack closure showed a significant difference. Review of existing works on the crack closure phenomenon under large scale yielding suggests that more systematic work is needed for clarification.
In this paper, combined experimental and FE analyzes are conducted to investigate the effect of load interaction on fatigue crack growth of pipe under large scale yielding. For experiment, fatigue crack growth test using a through-wall cracked pipe (TWC) made of SA508 Gr.1a low-alloy steel under the large scale yielding condition was performed. For cyclic loading, periodic overload and block loading containing the high-low and low-high loading sequence were applied. The applied load was 75% and 85% of the maximum load determined from the same pipe test under monotonic loading. Section 2 presents the material and pipe test data. The effect of load interaction on very low cycle fatigue crack growth is also analyzed in Section 2, based on the experimental data. Section 3 explains the FE debonding analysis for TWC pipe with experimental validation. Based on the FE debonding analysis, the crack closure behavior for the TWC pipe under large scale yielding fatigue is also explained in Section 3. Finally, the conclusion is given in Section 4.
Section snippets
Experimental investigation using through-wall cracked pipe test
To quantify the load interaction effect on fatigue crack growth under large scale yielding experimentally, fatigue crack growth tests using through-wall cracked pipes under various loading histories were performed. Pipe test and loading conditions will be explained first in Section 2.1. Then experimental observation of the load interaction effect on fatigue crack growth rate will be explained in Section 2.2.
Numerical investigation using debonding analysis for fatigue crack growth simulation
In the previous section, based on it was found that crack retardation or acceleration was not observed in experimental data of through-wall cracked pipes under various loading large scale yielding fatigue loading history conditions. To further understand the load interaction effect on fatigue crack growth under large scale yielding, numerical investigation results are presented in this section.
For the investigation, FE debonding analysis was used for fatigue crack growth simulation. However, in
Conclusion
In this paper, the load interaction effect on fatigue crack growth in TWC pipe under large scale yielding condition is investigated via combined experimental and FE analysis. Test material is a nuclear piping material SA508 Gr.1a. TWC fracture tests under large scale yielding fatigue loading were conducted for various load amplitudes ranging from 75 % and 85 % of the maximum load measured from the pipe test under monotonic loading. The loading type consisted of the constant amplitude loading,
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Jin-Ha Hwang: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis, Writing – original draft, Visualization. Yun-Jae Kim: Validation, Writing – review & editing, Supervision, Project administration. Jin-Weon Kim: Investigation, Resources.
Declaration of Competing Interest
Please check the following as appropriate:
- ✓
All authors have participated in (a) conception and design, or analysis and interpretation of the data; (b) drafting the article or revising it critically for important intellectual content; and (c) approval of the final version. - checked
- ✓
This manuscript has not been submitted to, nor is under review at, another journal or other publishing venue.- checked
- ✓
The authors have no affiliation with any organization with a direct or indirect financial interest
Reference (84)
- et al.
Simulation of dynamic ductile crack growth using strain-rate and triaxiality-dependent cohesive elements
Eng Fract Mech
(2006) - et al.
Effect of loading sequences on fatigue crack growth and crack closure in API X65 steel
Mar Struct
(2019) - et al.
Influence of spectrum loading sequences on fatigue life in a high-temperature environment
Eng Fail Anal
(2013) - et al.
Load sequence effects and variable amplitude fatigue of superelastic NiTi
Int J Mech Sci
(2018) - et al.
Numerical simulation of plasticity induced crack closure under overloads and high–low blocks
Eng Fract Mech
(2012) - et al.
Loading sequence effect on fatigue life of Type 316 stainless steel
Int J Fatigue
(2015) - et al.
A numerical analysis of the mechanisms behind plasticity induced crack closure: Application to variable amplitude loadings
Int J Fatigue
(2016) - et al.
Load interaction effects on fatigue crack propagation in 2024-T3 aluminum alloy
Eng Fract Mech
(1976) Micromechanisms of fatigue crack growth retardation following overloads
Eng Fract Mech
(1983)- et al.
Two engineering models for predicting the retardation of fatigue crack growth caused by mixed mode overload
Int J Fatigue
(2020)
Reconsiderations of fatigue crack growth at negative stress ratios: finite element analyzes
Eng Fract Mech
A study of overload effect on fatigue crack propagation using EBSD, FIB–DIC and FEM methods
Eng Fract Mech
Experimental evaluation of the effect of overloads on fatigue crack growth by analysing crack tip displacement fields
Eng Fract Mech
Effects of tensile/compressive overloads on fatigue crack growth behavior of an extra-low-interstitial titanium alloy
Int J Mech Sci
Near-tip strain evolution and crack closure of growing fatigue crack under a single tensile overload
Int J Fatigue
Numerical modeling of fatigue crack propagation based on the theory of critical distances: effects of overloads and underloads
Eng Fract Mech
In situ synchrotron stress mappings to characterize overload effects in fatigue crack growth
Int J Fatigue
The overload effect on the crack-tip cyclic plastic deformation response in SA333 Gr 6 C-Mn steel
Theor Appl Fract Mech
Mode I fatigue crack growth at notches considering crack closure
Int J Fatigue
Fatigue crack closure: From LCF to small scale yielding
Int J Fatigue
Numerical simulation of plasticity induced crack closure: identification and discussion of parameters
Eng Fract Mech
On the accurate assessment of crack opening and closing stresses in plasticity-induced fatigue crack closure problems
Eng Fract Mech
Numerical study of contact forces for crack closure analysis
Int J Solids Struct
Low-cycle fatigue crack growth considerations in pipe fracture analyzes
Nucl Eng Des
Approximate fracture methods for pipes—part I: theory
Nucl Eng Des
Dynamic ductile fracture in aluminum round bars: experiments and simulations
Int J Fract
Numerical ductile tearing simulation of circumferential cracked pipe tests under dynamic loading conditions
Nucl Eng Technol
A study on the decrease of fracture resistance curve under reversed cyclic loading
Int J Press Vessel Pip
Pipe fracture encyclopedia. Vol. 3 Pipe fracture test data
Stability of cracked pipe under inertial stresses
Nuclear Regulat Comm
International piping integrity research group (IPIRG) program. Final report
Nuclear Regulatory Comm
Development of evaluation method for dynamic fracture of cracked pipe
Denryoku Chuo Kenkyusho Hokoku Sogo Hokoku
Low cycle fatigue and ductile fracture for Japanese carbon steel piping under dynamic loadings
Nucl Eng Des
Effect of negative stress ratio on crack growth for cracked pipe subjected to cyclic loading with large-scale yielding
Am Soc Mech Eng Press Vessel Pip Div PVP
Evaluation of low-cycle fatigue crack growth and subsequent ductile fracture for cracked pipe experiments using cyclic J-integral
Am Soc Mech Eng Press Vessel Pip Div PVP
Cyclic tearing and crack growth in circumferentially cracked straight pipes
Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct
A proposal on cyclic tearing based stability assurance for LBB demonstration of nuclear piping
Int J Press Vessel Pip
Effects of simulated seismic loading on LBB assessment of high energy piping
J Press Vessel Technol Trans ASME
Quasi-cyclic fracture studies on stainless steel welded straight pipes with circumferential through-wall crack in the weld
Int J Press Vessel Pip
Fracture studies on narrow gap welded SA 312 Type 304LN stainless steel straight pipes under quasi-cyclic loading
Int J Press Vessel Pip
Failure behavior of SA508 Gr.1a LAS and SA312 TP316 SS pipes with a circumferential through-wall crack under large amplitude cyclic loads.
Thin-Walled Struct
Cited by (6)
Pipeline condition monitoring towards digital twin system: A case study
2024, Journal of Manufacturing SystemsStress intensity factor of through-wall-cracked steel pipe wrapped with prestressed CFRP composites
2023, Engineering Fracture MechanicsOn the experimental characterisation of crack tip displacement fields on nonplanar elements: Numerical and experimental analysis
2023, Theoretical and Applied Fracture MechanicsExperimental monitoring and modeling of fatigue damage for 3D-printed polymeric beams under irregular loading
2022, International Journal of Mechanical SciencesCitation Excerpt :Most of the engineering structures are subjected to vibration-induced irregular loading. The load interaction effect induced by the irregular loading can significantly affect the fatigue dynamics [29–33]. Such effect remains one of the critical problems to solve in engineering fatigue [34].
Use of Prandtl operators in simulating the cyclic softening of Inconel 718 under isothermal low-cycle fatigue loading
2022, International Journal of Mechanical SciencesCitation Excerpt :Subsequently, several modifications to the strain memory surface have been proposed [38,40,41]. A type of non-linear mechanical behaviour under LCF loading has recently been investigated with increasing efforts [42–55]. Li et al. [49] simulated the cyclic softening of 10% Cr martensitic steel via the kinematic hardening rule, by evolving the parameters with an increasing plastic strain.