Spring flooding and recurring evacuations of Kashechewan First Nation, northern Ontario, Canada
Introduction
In Canada, 309 floods have impacted 6.58 million Canadians during 1900–2019 [1]. Floods are expected to be higher in frequency and intensity with the warming temperatures [2]. Spring flooding is one of the major natural hazards that affects northern Indigenous Peoples1 in Canada [3]. Spring flooding is caused by rapid snowmelt runoff because of ice breakup and jams in the spring season. According to the Ministry of Indigenous Services Canada (ISC), there are numerous First Nations communities at-risk of spring flooding across Canada due to their proximity to rivers. First Nations identify themselves by the nation to which they belong, such as Cree2 First Nation. There are over 630 First Nations communities in Canada, which represent more than 50 Nations and 50 Indigenous languages.3 In addition, an inadvertent bias in the disaster relief services and disaster risk reduction (DRR) programs offered by different levels of governments, such as the Flood Damage Reduction Program (FDRP), has contributed to the increased vulnerability of Indigenous Peoples to the flooding risks [4,5]. For example, the substandard community infrastructure, particularly inadequate underground sewerage system, the obsolete water treatment plant, and dike made of sand and gravel with serious deficiencies have increased the flooding risk and the community's exposure to floods resulting in numerous evacuations incurring substantial costs (see Table 1).
From 2006 to 2016, sixty-seven First Nations experienced about 100 floods in Canada, while 13 First Nations of Ontario experienced 20% recorded floods [10]. In particular, the northern Ontario climate is conducive to ice jams and spring flooding in the southwestern James Bay region [11]. The Cree First Nations, such as Attawapiskat, Fort Albany, and Kashechewan, located along the southwestern James Bay coast, are linear settlements and frequently affected by ice jam-related spring flooding risk [[12], [13], [14]].
The Kashechewan First Nation in northern Ontario is regularly affected by the increased risk of spring flooding and has been evacuated (14 times since 2004) every year from 2004 to 2008 and 2012–2019. While flooding risk and the resultant evacuations in the James Bay region of northern Ontario have been much publicized, little is known about the impacts of spring flooding and recurring evacuations [15]. According to Khalafzai and colleagues [15]; spring flooding has occurred seasonally in the region and has not increased significantly over time. But the timing and extent of flooding have changed in recent years with warming temperatures in the region due to climate change. In particular, impacts are exacerbated due to changes in the climate, landscape, and resource developments, including inadequate community infrastructure and a downriver winter ice road, which have increased the frequency and scale of breakup ice jams. Khalafzai et al. [15] conclude that these ecological changes have resulted in an increased risk of spring flooding for the First Nation. Khalafzai et al. [15] have discussed the elevated spring flooding risk because of climate change elsewhere.
Floods can affect people, property, and socio-economic activities. They can disrupt community infrastructure and essential lifeline services, such as healthcare, education, drinking water, power supply, sanitation, transportation, and waste disposal, including breaching dikes and blocking ill-planned water drainage system [[16], [17], [18]]. In the Subarctic region, flooding also affects cultural and traditional activities and the local economy, thereby negatively impacting people's well-being. In particular, health risks significantly increase because of the disruption to healthcare services and because flooding leads to a non-functional health infrastructure [[18], [19], [20], [21]]. One of the implications of floods is a short-term relocation or an evacuation.
Evacuations due to floods can seriously affect individual and community well-being [[22], [23], [24]]. Evacuation is a complex phenomenon [25]. Evacuation experiences are determined by family dynamics, childcare, mechanisms for coping with the emergency and emotional stress, and by cultural and ancestral belief [[26], [27], [28], [29], [30]]. There can be several other factors that determine the evacuation experience. Evacuees often experience emotional stress because they fear that the belongings that they leave in their homes will be stolen. They also have to leave jobs, which means a loss of income, and must find new services in evacuation centres, where they often face racism [[31], [32], [33], [34]]. In other words, evacuations can have far-reaching sociocultural, psychological, economic, and other impacts on evacuees [22,24,35]. For Indigenous Peoples, evacuations cause numerous negative impacts such as a disruption in their traditional way of life and cultural activities, a loss of the place attachments, and an erosion of community and social relationships [31,[36], [37], [38], [39]].
Using regional case studies, a small group of researchers has examined the vulnerability and resilience of communities while focusing on spring flooding that affects remote northern Canadian Indigenous communities. Ford and Smith [40] looked at the implications of flooding risk for Inuit communities and developed a conceptual model of vulnerability and presented an analytical approach for assessing adaptive capacities. Newton et al. [3] explored the linkages between natural hazards and climate change, while focusing on spring flooding and the role of Indigenous communities and their traditional knowledge. They studied ways in which the Canadian territorial governments responded to spring flooding involving Indigenous communities in northern Canada. Newton [39] examined flooding vulnerabilities and the resilience of the Indigenous communities of Aklavik and Liard, Northwest Territories, and Attawapiskat, Ontario. He looked at distinctions between perceptions, attitudes, and activities at three (individual, communal, government) operational levels and how they interrelate while responding to flooding. Thompson et al. [4] focused on the Lake St. Martin First Nation in Manitoba, which was artificially flooded and permanently displaced during 2011. Ballard and Thompson [41] studied the impacts of artificial flooding on sustainable livelihoods, homes, health, and the socio-cultural integrity of the Lake St. Martin First Nation. The relevant literature reviewed suggests that spring flooding and the resultant recurring evacuation experiences of northern Canadian Indigenous communities are not well documented. Nonetheless, there have been a few studies about the permanent (relocation) evacuation experiences that resulted from flooding in remote and isolated Indigenous communities. For example, Thompson et al. [4] studied the permanent evacuation experiences of the Lake St. Martin First Nation, whose participants told him, “We're life refugees” (p. 79). After four to five years of displacement, the Lake St. Martin First Nation was resettled at a site selected by the federal government.
There is a lack of research concerning spring flooding events and the resultant evacuations (temporary or permanent relocation) involving remote and isolated northern Canadian Indigenous communities, particularly the Southwestern James Bay Cree First Nations communities. The research on the impacts of frequent evacuations on Indigenous evacuees due to spring flooding is also lacking. This study completed is the first in the region involving Kashechewan First Nation that examines the impacts of frequent short-term recurring evacuations and a three-year long-term evacuation on residents. While the nature of other hazards risks e.g., wildfire is different from spring flooding, the evacuation experiences of remote and isolated Indigenous communities during their stay in urban host communities can be similar regardless of the cause that triggered an evacuation. Nonetheless, little is known about the impacts of regular hazard risk and recurring evacuations due to spring flooding on northern remote and isolated Canadian Indigenous communities. Notably, besides spring flooding, wildfire is another frequently occurring hazard that the northern Canadian Indigenous Peoples are at high risk because of their proximity and exposure to the hazard risk. The research work of Thistlethwaite et al. [42]; Khalafzai [43]; and Khalafzai and colleagues [15] shows that there is a lack of research on the impacts of actual spring flooding or the risk of flooding on Indigenous Peoples and their evacuation experiences in northern Canada. Because of the lack of research concerning the impacts of spring flooding and evacuations by Indigenous communities, we briefly discuss the recent research work on the impacts of evacuations due to wildfires on Indigenous Peoples.
Scharbach and Waldrem [38] explored the wildfire evacuation experiences of residents of the Hatchet Lake Denesuline First Nation in northern Saskatchewan. The main evacuation impacts on the Hatchet Lake Denesuline First Nation include the fragmentation of community social organization and stability, separation of extended family members, and negative effects on health, particularly for disabled residents. Asfaw et al. [31,36] examined wildfire evacuation preparedness and evacuation challenges while researching the Sandy Lake First Nation in north-western Ontario. The negative impacts of that evacuation included inadequate accommodation, financial difficulties, racism, and evacuees’ concerns about the condition of their homes, property, and pets. The positive experiences included material and emotional support provided by host communities, an opportunity to socialize with fellow evacuees, and the leadership provided by the Chief.
Asfaw et al. [37] studied the role of family, social supports, and place attachment among wildfire evacuees. They found that evacuees were negatively impacted by being dispersed to multiple host communities. The negative impacts included difficulty with communication and information-sharing, disruption of community cohesion and support services, and lack of a sense of place. Christianson, McGee, and the Whitefish Lake First Nation [44] explored the factors that complicated the evacuation process and caused additional stress for the evacuees of the 2011 wildfire event that occurred in the Whitefish Lake First Nation. Among the factors that affected that evacuation experience were transportation issues compounded by cultural land-use activities, fear of home loss, lack of information and media attention, health issues, and large multi-generational families.
This research focuses on the unexplored area of spring flooding impacts on a remote and isolated northern Canadian Indigenous community and their experiences of recurring short-term and long-term evacuations. Kashechewan First Nation is exposed to the increased risk of spring flooding, and the wildfire hazard is non-existent in the reserve territory. In recent years ample research has been conducted on wildfires and resultant evacuations and their impacts on Indigenous communities in Canada. This research fills the knowledge gap by elucidating the effects of increased and regular spring flooding risk and the recurring evacuations on northern Canadian Indigenous communities. Indeed, this study contributes to the literature concerning the impacts of recurring short-term and long-term evacuations on Canadian Indigenous communities.
The aim of this study was to examine how the First Nation is affected by and responds to the regular spring flooding risk. Two research questions guided this study:
- o
How has the increased spring flooding risk in Kashechewan affected the First Nation?
- o
How have regular flooding risk and recurring evacuation experiences of the Kashechewan First Nation affected the community's vulnerability and resilience?
This research examines the spring flooding risk to the socioecological system vis-a-vis the community's physical exposure and proximity to the hazard risk. This study assesses the First Nation's socio-cultural, economic, and environmental vulnerability and the community's ability to respond to and recover from flooding events—the ability to survive and deal with floods by reducing impacts and mitigating losses and damages as well as availing the opportunities emerged due to the change. Community resilience-building focuses both on vulnerabilities and resilience and resources and collective strategic action.
Section snippets
Theoretical framework
Disasters are conceptualized in three different ways. First, the classical approach conceptualizes disasters simply by focusing on the negative impacts of disasters [45]. Second, the hazard-disaster perspective characterizes disasters when vulnerable people and hazards risks interact with each other [46]. Notably, this perspective focuses on hazards risks that shape the nature of impacts. The research rooted in the hazard-disaster view also has shifted from disasters to vulnerability and
Approach for adaptation
The specific theoretical framework that guided the research questions of this study is the vulnerability and resilience framework developed by Maru, Smith, Sparrow, Pinho, and Dube [47]. The Maru et al. [47] framework recognizes that Indigenous communities demonstrate significant resilience to climate change and resource variability and, therefore, may be among those best equipped to adapt; and that such communities are marginalized and chronically disadvantaged and, therefore, are the most
Results
The audio recordings of the interviews were transcribed by a professional transcriber. The transcribed data were coded and analysed in NVivo (version 11) while using a mix of descriptive and analytical coding schemes [87]. During descriptive coding, the first author made categories using the terms and words, such as precautionary evacuation, which were locally and commonly used by the interview participants. The first author also derived analytical codes from the research literature, previous
Discussion
This study is first of its kind to examine the frequent spring flooding risk impacts and recurring evacuation experiences of the Kashechewan First Nation, a northern Subarctic Canadian Indigenous community. The increased spring flooding risk affects the inadequate community infrastructure, particularly the dike, sewerage system, tap-water treatment plant, and downriver winter ice road. It disrupts the spring cultural activities of camping and hunting and harvesting meat. The evacuations every
Conclusion
The spring flooding risk has significantly increased the community's physical and socio-cognitive vulnerability in recent years. Flooding frequently impacts the inadequate community infrastructure, traditional spring hunting and harvesting, and the local economy. Dealing with the increased flooding risk and recurring emergency experiences every spring have helped to improve the community's disaster preparedness and coping capacity. However, the First Nation's experiences during the evacuations
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgements
Special thanks to Kashechewan Chief Leo Friday, the Kashechewan First Nation and community leaders, all community members and to those who participated in survey research. The Northern Scientific Training Program (NSTP) and U Alberta North, the University of Alberta, and Human Geography Program, Earth and Atmospheric Sciences Department, the University of Alberta have provided the financial support for this research project.
References (95)
- et al.
Celerities of waves and ice runs from ice jam releases
Cold Reg. Sci. Technol.
(2016) - et al.
The role of individual well-being in risk perception and evacuation for chronic vs. Acute natural hazards in Mexico
Appl. Geogr.
(2011) - et al.
Indicators for social and economic coping capacity–moving toward a working definition of adaptive capacity
Global Environ. Change
(2002) - et al.
A place-based model for understanding community resilience to natural disasters
Global Environ. Change
(2008) Sense of place in developmental context
J. Environ. Psychol.
(1998)Canadian Disaster Database
(2019)Improve Climate Change Preparedness
(2016)- et al.
Climate change and natural hazards in northern Canada: integrating indigenous perspectives with government policy
Migration and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change
(2005) - et al.
Lake St. Marin first nation community members' experiences of induced displacement: “We’re like refugees”
Refuge
(2014) Flood Management in Canada at the Crossroads. ICLR Research Paper Series–No. 5 Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR), 151 Younge Street, Suite 1800
(2000)
Where the River Flows Fast. A Thesis Presented to the University of Waterloo in Fulfilment of the Thesis Requirement for the Degree of Master of Architecture Waterloo
A critical systems approach to social learning: building adaptive capacity in social ecological system (SES)
Ecol. Soc.
Kashechewan Reserve May Be Facing Another Evacuation
River ice breakup processes: recent advances and future directions
Can. J. Civ. Eng.
Flood history analysis and socioeconomic implications of flooding for indigenous Canadian communities
Occurrence of ice jams in Canada
Albany River 2008 ice breakup: forecasting the flood event, observations of the river during the spring breakup and the potential for mitigating the flooding risk of the kashechewan and Fort Albany first nation
Trends in river-ice breakup data for the western James Bay region of Canada
Polar Geogr.
Flooding in the James Bay region of northern Ontario, Canada: learning from traditional knowledge of kashechewan first nation
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
Impact of flood damaged critical infrastructure on communities and industries
Built. Environ. Proj. Asset. Manag.
Mobilizing for international disaster relief: comparing US and EU approaches to the 2010 Haiti earthquake
J. Homel. Secur. Emerg. Manag.
Health impacts of floods
Prehospital Disaster Med.
The impact of flood disasters on child education in muzarabani district, Zimbabwe’, jàmbá
Journal of Disaster Risk Studies
Children and disasters: understanding vulnerability, developing capacities, and promoting resilience–an introduction
Child. Youth Environ.
Climate change and human health: infrastructure impacts to small remote communities in the north
Int. J. Circumpolar Health
The impact of the san diego wildfires on a general mental health population residing in evacuation areas
Adm. Pol. Ment. Health
Evacuation behavior during wildfires: results of three case studies
West. J. Appl. For.
Evacuation as population mobility
Mass Emergencies and Disasters
The theodicy of natural disasters
Scot. J. Theol.
Saving lives, destroying livelihoods: emergency evacuation and resettlement policies
Heads above Water: Gender, Class, and Family in the Grand Forks Flood
Managing societal uncertainty in volcanic hazards: a multidisciplinary approach
Disaster Prev. Manag.
Volcanoes and Society
A qualitative study exploring barriers and facilitators of effective service delivery for indigenous wildfire hazard evacuees during their stay in host communities
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
Economic ramifications of disaster: experiences of displaced persons on the slopes of mount tungurahua, Ecuador
Pap. Proc. Appl. Geogr. Conf.
Responses of pampanga households to lahar warnings: lessons from two villages in the pasig-potrero river watershed
Behavioral Foundations of Community Emergency Planning
Community processes: warning and evacuation
Evacuation preparedness and the challenges of emergency evacuation in indigenous communities in Canada: the case of Sandy Lake first nation, northern Ontario
International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
The role of social support and place attachment during hazard evacuation: the case of Sandy Lake first nation, Canada
Environ. Hazards
Asking for a disaster: being “at risk” in the emergency evacuation of a northern Canadian aboriginal community
Hum. Organ.
An assessment of coping with environmental hazards in northern aboriginal communities
The Canadian Geography/Le Geographe canadien
A framework for assessing the vulnerability of communities in the Canadian arctic to risks associated with climate change
Arctic, Human Dimensions of the Arctic System
Flooding hope and livelihoods: Lake St. Martin first nation
Canadian Journal of Nonprofit and Social Economy Research Revue canadienne de recherche sur les OBSL et l’économie sociale, Spring/Printemps
Indigenous Reserve Lands in Canada Face High Flood Risk. Policy Brief No. 159
Frequent Spring Flooding Impacts, Evacuation Experiences, and Perceived Adaptive Capacity of Kashechewan First Nation, Northern Ontario
Wildfire evacuation experiences of band members of Whitefish Lake first nation 459, Alberta, Canada
Nat. Hazards
Cited by (9)
Mapping wildfire hazard, vulnerability, and risk to Canadian communities
2024, International Journal of Disaster Risk ReductionFlood vulnerability assessment of Thailand's flood-prone Pathum Thani province and vulnerability mitigation strategies
2023, Journal of Environmental ManagementEnhancing Flood Risk Assessment and Mitigation through Numerical Modeling: A Case Study
2023, Natural Hazards ReviewIndigenous perspectives on climate mobility justice and displacement-mobility-immobility continuum
2023, Climate and Development