Review articleWearable activity trackers for promoting physical activity: A systematic meta-analytic review
Introduction
In modern society, many people are habitually inactive during commuting, work, and leisure [1]. Insufficient physical activity (PA) is a leading risk factor for chronic diseases, mental health problems, and quality of life [2]. For substantial health benefits, PA guidelines recommend that adults do at least 150 min of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) per week, accumulate 10,000 steps per day, and reduce sedentary behavior [3,4]. Nevertheless, according to a global survey across 168 countries [2], over one-quarter of people do not meet the PA level recommendations.
Wearable activity trackers (WATs) have the potential to nudge people toward a more active lifestyle. By integrating sensors, algorithms, and human-computer interaction designs, WATs could benefit users in two ways. First, WATs support self-monitoring of PA, such as steps taken, timing and intensity of PA, distance walked, and calories burned. Second, WATs help build self-regulatory skills, including goal-setting, action plans, behavior control, and goal achievement [5,6].
Despite the increasing popularity of WATs (e.g., Fitbit, Mi Band, Apple Watch, Garmin) in the consumer market, formal adoption of them in public health practice is scarce [7]. One exception was a national public health project carried out by Fitbit and Singapore’s Health Promotion Board in 2019. Some empirical studies have been conducted to assess the effectiveness of WATs, albeit with mixed findings (e.g. [8,9]). The extent to which WATs are able to promote PA remains unclear in the literature. Hence, a meta-analysis method has been employed by several review studies. This approach can overcome the equivocation in the existing literature by calculating the weighted average value [10]. Although several relevant meta-analytic papers have come out in recent years [[11], [12], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24]], there are still two research gaps.
First, previous review articles did not examine all types of PA. Existing meta-analytic reviews found that WATs are effective for improving PA by assessing step counts [11,12,14,16,17,19,[22], [23], [24]], MVPA [12,14,17,19,[22], [23], [24]], or overall PA [13,15,16,18,20,21]. However, there is a lack of in-depth analysis of light PA (LPA) and sedentary behavior, leading to an incomplete understanding of the WATs’ effectiveness. To fill this gap, we propose the first research objective.
RO 1: To synthesize evidence on the effects of WATs for promoting PA in terms of steps, LPA, MVPA, and sedentary behavior.
Second, although a large heterogeneity of WATs’ effect sizes was observed, potential moderators were not systematically investigated. Specifically, by comparing between reviews with a focus on at-risk populations (e.g., chronic disease patients, older adults) [13,[15], [16], [17], [18], [19]] and those without a specific population focus [[21], [22], [23], [24]], we noticed that the former often reported larger PA effect sizes (reflected by standard mean difference, SMD) (See Table 1)
In addition to health status, past research suggested that participants’ gender, age, and baseline PA level were associated with PA outcomes [11,25,26]. Such findings indicated that different target populations could respond diversely to WATs. Notably, previous articles mainly focused on a particular population, with a lack of comparisons between multiple groups.
Even if focusing on a particular target population, previous meta-analytic reviews reported a large heterogeneity of effect sizes across trials [11,12,14,16,19,20]. However, the sources of the heterogeneity were not well explained. The heterogeneity of effect sizes could stem from intervention features, such as functionalities of WATs, intervention duration, and intervention delivery [23,27]. Unfortunately, there is a lack of comprehensive evidence on how intervention features could moderate the effects of WATs.
Therefore, we propose the second research objective.
RO 2: To explore potential moderators of WATs’ effects through examining participants’ characteristics and intervention features.
This article is important in three ways. First, by considering the PA outcome at various intensity levels (i.e., steps, MVPA, LPA, and sedentary behavior), we analyze the influence of WATs use on PA thoroughly. This helps to understand the role of WATs from a fine-grained perspective. Second, by reporting eligible studies on a wide range of populations (see Table A.1 for details), we provide a holistic view of the effectiveness of WATs. This allows for comparing the role of WATs in promoting PA across different target user groups. Third, by analyzing the moderating role of participants’ characteristics and intervention features, we fill a common gap in previous review articles: lacking a systematic investigation into the cross-studies heterogeneity.
Section snippets
Methods
We conducted and reported this review according to the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions [28] and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines [29]. The details of the applied methods were described as following.
Study selection
The initial search on the six databases resulted in 13,791 records. Of them, 6298 were remained after removing duplicates. After screening of article types, titles, and abstracts, 6131 ineligible records were excluded. The remaining 167 articles were assessed based on the full-texts, resulting in 35 articles that met the eligibility criteria. Besides, 9 eligible articles were retrieved from reference searching. Also, 4 studies were identified through database updating (from March 25, 2020, to
RO1
Overall, we found that interventions with WATs had a medium effect on daily steps and a small effect on MVPA. The positive findings were consistent with some previous reviews [13,17,20,22]. By involving studies on a broad range of populations, this review provides evidence with greater generality in supporting the use of WATs for improving steps and MVPA.
However, this paper could not support the use of WATs for improving LPA or reducing sedentary behavior. Comparison of findings of LPA was not
Conclusion
This systematic meta-analytic review analyzed 48 papers (based on 43 distinct trials) involving 5,808 participants. We found promising evidence on the effects of WATs for promoting daily steps and weekly MVPA. The extent to which the WATs help was contextual—that is, the effect of WATs for promoting PA was contingent on the type of users and the design and delivery of interventions. As the emerging of more empirical studies, future work is needed to examine the validity of the findings from the
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Caining Li: Conceptualization, Methodology, Data curation, Formal analysis, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing. Xiaoyu Chen: Conceptualization, Data curation, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing. Xinhua Bi: Supervision, Writing - review & editing.
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors report no declarations of interest.
Acknowledgments
The first author (C. Li) would like to thank the assistance in data collection from the Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, where she worked as a visiting PhD student from 2019 to 2020. This work is partly supported by the China Scholarship Council (CSC No.: 201906170120).
References (82)
- et al.
Worldwide trends in insufficient physical activity from 2001 to 2016: a pooled analysis of 358 population-based surveys with 1·9 million participants
Lancet Glob. Health
(2018) - et al.
Wearable activity trackers, accuracy, adoption, acceptance and health impact: a systematic literature review
J. Biomed. Inform.
(2019) - et al.
The impact of wearable motion sensing technology on physical activity in older adults
Exp. Gerontol.
(2018) - et al.
The effectiveness of a wearable activity tracker (WAT)-based intervention to improve physical activity levels in sedentary older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Arch. Gerontol. Geriatr.
(2020) - et al.
The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration
Bmj.
(2009) - et al.
The Oxford Implementation Index: a new tool for incorporating implementation data into systematic reviews and meta-analyses
J. Clin. Epidemiol.
(2013) - et al.
Feasibility, acceptability, and behavioral outcomes from a technology-enhanced behavioral change intervention (prostate 8): a pilot randomized controlled trial in men with prostate cancer
Eur. Urol.
(2019) - et al.
Effects of a 12-week mHealth program on peak VO2 and physical activity patterns after completing cardiac rehabilitation: A randomized controlled trial
Am. Heart J.
(2018) - et al.
Effects of a 12-week mhealth program on functional capacity and physical activity in patients with peripheral artery disease
Am. J. Cardiol.
(2018) - et al.
Behavioural modification interventions alongside pulmonary rehabilitation improve COPD patients’ experiences of physical activity
Respir. Med.
(2021)
Feasibility and effect of a physical activity counselling session with or without provision of an activity tracker on maintenance of physical activity in women with breast cancer - A randomised controlled trial
J. Sci. Med. Sport
Pierce JP. technology- and phone-based weight loss intervention
Am. J. Prev. Med.
Randomized trial of a Fitbit-based physical activity intervention for women
Am. J. Prev. Med.
Effectiveness of activity trackers with and without incentives to increase physical activity (TRIPPA): a randomised controlled trial
Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol.
Effects of two web-based interventions promoting physical activity among older adults compared to a delayed intervention control group in Northwestern Germany: Results of the PROMOTE community-based intervention trial
Prev. Med. Rep.
Improving physical activity and body composition in a medical workplace using brief goal setting
Mayo Clin Proc Innov Qual Outcomes
The effects of an activity promotion system on active living in overweight subjects with metabolic abnormalities
Obes. Res. Clin. Pract.
Web-based intervention to promote weight-loss maintenance using an activity monitor: a randomized controlled trial
Prev. Med. Rep.
Using computer, mobile and wearable technology enhanced interventions to reduce sedentary behaviour: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Int. J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act.
Global Recommendations on Physical Activity for Health
Bright spots, physical activity investments that work: National Steps Challenge, Singapore: a nationwide mHealth physical activity programme
Br. J. Sports Med.
Using organismic integration theory to explore the associations between users’ exercise motivations and fitness technology feature set use
Manage. Inform. Syst. Quarterly
The state of wearable health technologies: a transdisciplinary literature review
Mob. Media Commun.
Use of wearable technology and social media to improve physical activity and dietary behaviors among college students: a 12-week randomized pilot study
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health
Promoting physical activity using a wearable activity tracker in college students: a cluster randomized controlled trial
J. Sports Sci.
Introduction to Meta-analysis
Can consumer wearable activity tracker-based interventions improve physical activity and cardiometabolic health in patients with chronic diseases? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials
Int. J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act.
Wearable technology and physical activity behavior change in adults with chronic cardiometabolic disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Am. J. Health Promot.
Accelerometer- and pedometer-based physical activity interventions among adults with cardiometabolic conditions: a systematic review and meta-analysis
JAMA Netw Open
Use of wearable activity trackers to improve physical activity behavior in patients with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Arthritis Care Res. (Hoboken)
Effectiveness of healthcare interventions using objective feedback on physical activity: a systematic review and meta-analysis
J. Rehabil. Med.
Effect of interventions using physical activity trackers on physical activity in people aged 60 years and over: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Br. J. Sports Med.
Physical activity monitors to enhance amount of physical activity in older adults - a systematic review and meta-analysis
Eur. Rev. Aging Phys. Act.
Effectiveness of wearable trackers on physical activity in healthy adults: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth
The impact of interventions that integrate accelerometers on physical activity and weight loss: a systematic review
Ann. Behav. Med.
Consumer-based wearable activity trackers increase physical activity participation: systematic review and meta-analysis
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth
Changing the physical activity behavior of adults with fitness trackers: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Am. J. Health Promot.
Fitbit-based interventions for healthy lifestyle outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis
J. Med. Internet Res.
Breast cancer survivors reduce accelerometer-measured sedentary time in an exercise intervention
J. Cancer Surviv.
Contextual Influences on the Use and Non-Use of Digital Technology While Exercising at the Gym
Increasing physical activity in cancer survivors at cardiovascular risk using Fitbits: randomized controlled trial
J. Clin. Oncol.
Cited by (27)
Physical activity in inflammatory rheumatic disorders: Health trajectories and promotion of physical activity
2023, Revue du Rhumatisme (Edition Francaise)Understanding health information literacy of mHealth app users from digital wellbeing perspective: Evidence from regression analysis and fsQCA
2021, Library and Information Science ResearchCitation Excerpt :Given such advantages, mHealth apps have become an important tool for mobile phone users to implement daily health self-management, especially for young adults—typically seen as “digital-savvy”—who depend heavily on mobile phones to keep digitally connected (Fu, Chen, & Deng, 2021). The use of mHealth apps can help them raise HIL through multiple approaches, including healthcare knowledge education, improved autonomous self-regulation and perceived competence (Ghose, Guo, Li, & Dang, 2021; Li, Chen, & Bi, 2021). Using mHealth apps on mobile phones may facilitate an active lifestyle and behavior modification.
Wearable Devices to Improve Physical Activity and Reduce Sedentary Behaviour: An Umbrella Review
2024, Sports Medicine - OpenThe Shape of Mobile Health: A Systematic Review of Health Visualization on Mobile Devices
2024, International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction