Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-16T23:03:01.073Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Disciplining the Accepted and Amputating the Deviants: Religious Nationalism and Segregated Citizenship in Indonesia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 April 2021

Deasy Simandjuntak
Deasy Simandjuntak*
Affiliation:
ISEAS—Yusof Ishak Institute, Singapore
*
*Corresponding author. E-mail: deasysim@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

T. H. Marshall’s 1950 seminal work shows that the granting of civil, political, and social rights leads to the institutionalization of rules binding the state and its citizens. In practice, however, citizenship goes beyond these unproblematized paternalistic relations. It is political, involving connection, competition, and conflicts. Isin and Turner (2002) propose that “citizenship” should be examined through its extent (norms of inclusion and exclusion), content (rights and responsibility), and depth (citizens’ perceived relation to their political community). In Indonesia, the discrimination against members of minority religions by Islamic conservative groups is among the main issues in politics. This article therefore examines the ambiguity between the constitutionally embraced “religious freedom” and the everyday discriminatory practices of conservative groups. Taking the case-studies of the sectarian campaign against a Chinese-Christian governor, the blasphemy sentence of a Chinese-Buddhist woman, and the persecution of the Ahmadiyah and Syiah, I argue that conservative groups have practised a “segregated citizenship” that prioritizes the values and interests of the majority religion against those of both the “accepted” and the “unaccepted” minority religions.

Keywords

segregated citizenshipreligious nationalismreligious freedomreligious harmonyblasphemyIndonesia
Type
Religious Nationalism and Religious Freedom in Asia
Information
Asian Journal of Law and Society , Volume 8 , Issue 1 , February 2021 , pp. 88 - 107
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Asian Journal of Law and Society

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aljazeera (2017) “Ahok: Indonesia’s Religious Tolerance On Trial?,” Aljazeera, 9 May 2017, https://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/talktojazeera/2017/01/ahok-indonesia-religious-tolerance-trial-170128084747099.html (accessed 6 December 2018).Google Scholar
Arah (2017) “FPI Confirms Prosecutor’s Demand Hurts the Feelings of Muslims [FPI Tegaskan Tuntutan Jaksa Lukai Hati Umat Islam],” Arah, 21 April, https://www.arah.com/article/28929/fpi-tegaskan-tuntutan-jaksa-untuk-ahok-lukai-hati-umat-islam.html (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
A’yun, Rafiqa Qurrata (2019) “Blasphemy on the Rise,” 20 January, https://www.insideindonesia.org/blasphemy-on-the-rise (accessed 7 March 2019).Google Scholar
BBC (2017) “Ahok Trial: The Blasphemy Case Testing Indonesian Identity,” BBC, 14 February, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-38902960 (accessed 6 December 2018).Google Scholar
BBC Indonesia (2012) “FPI Attacks Ahmadiyah Mosque (FPI Serang Masjid Ahmadiyah),” BBC Indonesia, 20 April, https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/berita_indonesia/2012/04/120420_fpiahmadi (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
BBC Indonesia (2018a) “Ahmadiyah Adherents Persecuted Again, Law Enforcement Dull? [Penganut Ahmadiyah Dipersekusi Lagi, Penegakan Hukum Tumpul?],” BBC Indonesia, 21 May, https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/indonesia-44189085 (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
BBC Indonesia (2018b) “Why Ahmadiyah Is Considered Not Islamic: Facts and Controversies [Kenapa Ahmadiyah Dianggap Bukan Islam: Fakta Dan Kontroversinya],” BBC Indonesia, 19 February, https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/indonesia-42642858 (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
Burhani, Ahmad Najib (2012) “Indonesia a Failed State? Fate of the Ahmadis Shows that It Could Be,” 4 August, http://pmb.lipi.go.id/indonesia-a-failed-state-fate-of-the-ahmadis-shows-it-could-be/ (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
Burhani, Ahmad Najib (2019) Menemani Minoritas: Paradigma Islam Tentang Eberpihakan dan Pembelaan Kepada Yang Lemah [Accompanying the Minority: Islamic Paradigm on the Partiality to and Defence of the Weak], Jakarta: Gramedia.Google Scholar
Burhani, Ahmad Najib, & Simandjuntak, Deasy (2018) “The Ma’ruf Amin Vice-Presidential Candidacy: Enticing or Splitting the Conservative Votes?,” 51 ISEAS Perspective, 4 September, https://www.iseas.edu.sg/images/pdf/ISEAS_Perspective_2018_51@50.pdf (accessed 5 November 2020).Google Scholar
Butt, Simon (2010) “Islam, the State and the Constitutional Court in Indonesia.” 19 Pacific Rim Law & Policy Journal 279–301.Google Scholar
Cahya, Gemma Holliani (2018) “PGI Protests Draft Bill Regulating Sunday Schools, Catechisms,” The Jakarta Post, 25 October, https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2018/10/25/pgi-protests-draft-bill-regulating-sunday-schools-catechism.html (accessed 30 August 2019).Google Scholar
Chaplin, Chris (2016) “Stuck in the Immoderate Middle,” New Mandala, 8 November, https://www.newmandala.org/stuck-immoderate-middle/ (accessed 10 March 2020).Google Scholar
Chaplin, Chris (2018) “Salafi Islamic Piety as Civic Activism: Wahdah Islamiyah and Differentiated Citizenship in Indonesia.” 22 Citizenship Studies 208–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CNN Indonesia (2014) “Muchsin Alatas: We Are Already 7 Million People [Muchsin Alatas: Jumlah Kami Sudah 7 Juta],” CNN Indonesia, 8 October, https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20141008165430–12–5780/muchsin-alatas-jumlah-kami-sudah-7-juta (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
CNN Indonesia (2015) “FPI Surrounds Ahmadiyah Headquarters, the Police Mediates [FPI Kepung Markas Ahmadiyah, Kepolisian Gelar Mediasi],” CNN Indonesia, 15 June, https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20150615145454–20–60084/fpi-kepung-markas-ahmadiyah-kepolisian-gelar-mediasi (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
CNN Indonesia (2017) “Rizieq Shihab Dubbed a Patriot, Not a Coward [Rizieq Shihab Disebut Patriot, Bukan Penakut],” CNN Indonesia, 1 June, https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20170601203034–12–218774/rizieq-shihab-disebut-patriot-bukan-penakut (accessed 30 August 2019).Google Scholar
CNN Indonesia (2019a) “Kontras States Ahok’s Release A Momentum to Erase Article 156A [Kontras Sebut Bebasnya Ahok Momentum Hapus Pasal 156A],” CNN Indonesia, 25 January, https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190125133616–12–363795/kontras-sebut-bebasnya-ahok-momentum-hapus-pasal-156a (accessed 7 March 2019).Google Scholar
CNN Indonesia (2019b) “Vulnerable to Criminalization, PKS Promises an ‘Ulama Protection’ Bill [Rentan Kriminalisasi, PKS Janjikan RUU Perlindungan Ulama],” CNN Indonesia, 14 January, https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190113235120–32–360520/rentankriminalisasi-pks-janjikan-ruu-perlindungan-ulama (accessed 30 August 2019).Google Scholar
Fealy, Greg (2018) “Ma’ruf Amin: Jokowi’s Islamic Defender or Deadweight?,” New Mandala, 28 August, https://www.newmandala.org/maruf-amin-jokowis-islamic-defender-deadweight/ (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
Feillard, Andrée (1995) Islam et Armée dans l’Indonésie Contemporaine, Paris: L’Harmattan.Google Scholar
Formichi, Chiara (2014) “Violence, Sectarianism, and the Politics of Religion: Articulations of Anti-Shi’a Discourses in Indonesia.” 98 Indonesia 1–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guardian, The (2017) “Jakarta Governor Ahok Found Guilty of Blasphemy Jailed for Two Years,” The Guardian, 9 May, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/may/09/jakarta-governor-ahok-found-guilty-of-blasphemy-jailed-for-two-years (accessed 30 August 2019).Google Scholar
Harsono, Andreas (2018) “The Human Cost of Indonesia’s Blasphemy Law,” 25 October, http://indonesiaatmelbourne.unimelb.edu.au/the-human-cost-of-indonesias-blasphemy-law/ (accessed 7 March 2019).Google Scholar
Hefner, Robert W., ed. (2001) The Politics of Multiculturalism: Pluralism and Citizenship in Malaysia, Singapore, and Indonesia, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hefner, Robert W. (2018a) “Introduction: Indonesia at the Crossroad, Imbroglios of Religion, State and Society in an Asian Muslim Nation,” in Hefner, R. W., ed., Routledge Handbook of Contemporary Indonesia, Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 3–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hefner, Robert W. (2018b) “The Religious Field: Plural Legacies and Contemporary Contestations,” in Hefner, R. W., ed., Routledge Handbook of Contemporary Indonesia, Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 211–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hefner, Robert W. (2019) “Whatever Happened to Civil Islam? Islam and Democratisation in Indonesia, 20 Years On.” 43 Asian Studies Review 375–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hicks, Jacqueline (2014) “Heresy and Authority: Understanding the Turn Against Ahmadiyah in Indonesia.” 22 South East Asia Research 321–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hollenbach, David (1997) “Politically Active Churches: Some Empirical Prolegomena to a Normative Approach,” in Weithman, P. J., ed., Religion and Contemporary Liberalism, Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 291–306.Google Scholar
Holston, James (2011) “Contesting Privilege with Right: The Transformation of Differentiated Citizenship in Brazil.” 15 Citizenship Studies 335–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hosen, Nadirsyah (2005) “Religion and the Indonesian Constitution: A Recent Debate.” 36 Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 419–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hui, Yew-Foong, & Simandjuntak, Deasy (2016) “Indonesia’s Sectarian Violence Assumes a Religious Guise,” 22 August, https://www.todayonline.com/commentary/ indonesias-sectarian-violence-assumes-religious-guise (accessed 7 March 2019).Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch (2017) “Indonesia: ‘Religious Rights’ Bill Would Harm Minorities,” Human Rights Watch, 20 July, https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/07/20/indonesia-religious-rights-bill-would-harm-minorities (accessed 7 August 2019).Google Scholar
Indra, Putu Agung Nara (2016) “FPI Dalam Lintasan Sejarah [FPI in Historical Trajectory],” 4 November, https://tirto.id/fpi-dalam-lintasan-sejarah-b1NT (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Iqtidar, Humeira, & David, Lehmann (2012) “Introduction: Secularism and Citizenship beyond the North Atlantic World.” 16 Citizenship Studies 953–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Irwansyah (2013) “Potensi Keretakan Hubungan Sosial Muslim-Buddhis: Kasus Konflik Patung Buddha di Kota Tanjung Balai Sumatera Utara [The Potential for Breakdown in Muslim-Buddhist Relations: The Case Study of Buddhist Statue Conflict in Tanjung Balai, North Sumatra].” 20 Journal Analisa 155–68.Google Scholar
Isin, Engin, & Bryan, Turner (2002) Handbook of Citizenship Studies, London: Sage.Google Scholar
Jakarta Post, The (2013) “Mob Ransacks Ahmadiyah Village,” The Jakarta Post, 6 May, https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/05/06/mob-ransacks-ahmadiyah-village.html (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Jakarta Post, The (2018a) “Government Calls for End of Flag Burning Protest,” The Jakarta Post, 2 November, http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2018/11/01/govt-calls-for-end-of-flag-burning-protests.html (accessed 7 December 2018).Google Scholar
Jakarta Post, The (2018b) “Prabowo-Sandiaga Signs Pact with GNPF Promises to Uphold Religious Values,” The Jakarta Post, 17 September, http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2018/09/16/prabowo-sandiaga-signs-pact-with-gnpf-promises-to-uphold-religious-values.html (accessed 7 December 2018).Google Scholar
Jakarta Post, The (2019) “Preacher Abdul Somad Under Fire for Blasphemous Remarks Against Christian Cross,” The Jakarta Post, 19 August, https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2019/08/19/muslim-preacher-abdul-somad-under-fire-for-blasphemous-remarks-against-christian-cross.html (accessed 28 August 2019).Google Scholar
Kompas (2019) “MUI Hopes Preacher Abdul Somad’s Clarification Cools Down the Situation [MUI Harap Klarifikasi Ustaz Abdul Somad Dinginkan Suasana],” Kompas, 21 August, https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2019/08/21/18451971/mui-harap-klarifikasi-ustaz-abdul-somad-dinginkan-suasana?page=all (accessed 6 March 2020).Google Scholar
Marshall, Thomas H. (1950) Citizenship and Social Class, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Menchik, Jeremy (2014) “Productive Intolerance: Godly Nationalism in Indonesia.” 56 Comparative Studies in Society and History 591–621.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menchik, Jeremy (2016) Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: Tolerance Without Liberalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mujiburrahman (1999) “Islam and Politics in Indonesia: The Political Thought of Abdurrahman Wahid.” 10 Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations 339–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
New York Times (2018) “Group of Muslim Scholars Gain Political Clout in Indonesia,” New York Times, 7 October, https://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/07/world/asia/07iht-indo.1.16743950.html (accessed 5 December 2018).Google Scholar
Pamungkas, Cahyo, ed. (2017) Mereka Yang Terusir: Studi tentang Ketahanan Sosial Pengungsi Ahmadiyah dan Syiah di Indonesia [The Excluded Ones: Studies on the Social Stability of Ahmadiyah and Syiah Refugees in Indonesia], Jakarta: Yayasan Pustaka Obor.Google Scholar
Rappler (2017) “Five Years as Refugees, Syiah Communities’ Condition in Sidoarjo Raises Concerns [Lima Tahun Mengungsi, Kondisi Warga Syiah Di Sidoarjo Semakin Memprihatinkan],” Rappler, 17 March, https://www.rappler.com/indonesia/berita/nasional/164470-mengungsi-warga-syiah-sidoarjo-memprihatinkan (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
Republika (2018) “Masses of 212 Reunion Greet Prabowo with Long Live Yell,” Republika, 3 December, https://www.republika.co.id/berita/en/national-politics/18/12/03/pj5aon414-masses-of-212-reunion-greet-prabowo-with-long-live-yell (accessed 7 December 2018).Google Scholar
Republika (2019) “This Is What FPI Says of Ahok’s Release [Ini Tanggapan FPI Atas Bebasnya Ahok],” Republika, 27 January, https://www.republika.co.id/berita/nasional/hukum/19/01/27/plzknv318-ini-tanggapan-fpi-atas-bebasnya-ahok (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Safran, William (1997) “Citizenship and Nationality in Democratic Systems: Approaches to Defining and Acquiring Membership in the Political Community.” 18 International Political Science Review 313–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SETARA Institute (2017) “Intolerance Supremacy,” http://setara-institute.org/en/english-intolerance-supremacy/ (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Simandjuntak, Deasy (2017a) “Commentary: Faced with a Troubling Blasphemy Verdict, Ahok at Least Left Jakarta a Legacy of Reform,” 11 May, https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/commentary-ahok-left-jakarta-legacy-of-reform-8836708 (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Simandjuntak, Deasy (2017b) “Jokowi Must Ensure Religious Tolerance Holds at All Levels,” 21 August, https://www.todayonline.com/commentary/jokowi-must-ensure-religious-tolerance-holds-all-levels?cid=todayfbcommented (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Simandjuntak, Deasy (2017c) “Jokowi’s Ban on Radical Groups and Pancasila’s Uncomfortable Past,” 22 July, https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/commentary-jokowi-s-ban-on-radical-groups-and-pancasila-s-9047670 (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Simandjuntak, Deasy (2018) “Indonesia,” in Sharom, A. & Spooner, M., eds., Human Rights Outlook in Southeast Asia: 2017, Bangkok: SHAPE-SEA.Google Scholar
Sindonews (2018) “MUI Glad Constitutional Court Rejects Ahmadiyah’s Judicial Review [MUI Bersyukur MK Tolak Judicial Review Jamaah Ahmadiyah],” Sindonews, 23 July, https://nasional.sindonews.com/read/1324385/13/mui-bersyukur-mk-tolak-judicial-review-jamaah-ahmadiyah-1532357399 (accessed 9 December 2018).Google Scholar
South China Morning Post (2018) “Another Ahok? Chinese Christian Faces Blasphemy Rap in Muslim Indonesia,” South China Morning Post, 1 December, https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/politics/article/2175671/another-ahok-chinese-christian-faces-blasphemy-rap-muslim (accessed 10 December 2018).Google Scholar
Suryadinata, Leo (2019) “Identity Politics in Indonesia: The Meliana Case,” 4 ISEAS Perspective, 23 January, https://www.iseas.edu.sg/images/pdf/ISEAS_Perspective_2019_4.pdf (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Teguh, Irfan (2019) “Sejarah Diskriminasi Penganut Agama Lokal di Indonesia [History of Discrimination against Adherents of Local Religions in Indonesia],” Tirto, 28 February, https://tirto.id/sejarah-diskriminasi-penganut-agama-lokal-di-indonesia-dhTX (accessed 10 March 2020).Google Scholar
Tempo (2017) “Ahok’s Trial, This Is the Testimony of MUI Chairman Ma’ruf Amin [Sidang Ahok, Ini Kesaksian Ketua MUI Ma’ruf Amin],” Tempo, 31 January, https://metro.tempo.co/read/841454/sidang-ahok-ini-kesaksian-ketua-mui-maruf-amin (accessed 5 December 2018).Google Scholar
UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (2017) “Blasphemy Law Has No Place in a Tolerant Nation like Indonesia—UN Rights Experts,” 22 May, https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=21646&LangID=E (accessed 6 December 2018).Google Scholar
van Bruinessen, Martin (2013) “Introduction: Contemporary Developments in Indonesian Islam and the Conservative Turn of the Early Twenty-First Century,” in van Bruinessen, M., ed., Contemporary Developments in Indonesian Islam: Explaining the Conservative Turn, Singapore: ISEAS, 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Viva (2011) “Ahmadiyah, Blood and Worship [Ahmadiyah, Darah Dan Ibadah],” Viva, 11 February, https://www.viva.co.id/indepth/sorot/204268-ahmadiyah-darah-dan-ibadah (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
VOA (2010) “FPI Mob Attacks Ahmadiyah Mosque in West Java [Massa FPI Serang Masjid Ahmadiyah Di Jawa Barat],” VOA Indonesia, 30 July, https://www.voaindonesia.com/a/massa-fpi-serang-masjid-ahmadiyah-di-jawa-barat-99666344/82045.html (accessed 7 July 2019).Google Scholar
Weatherbee, Donald E. (1985) “Indonesia in 1984: Pancasila, Politics, and Power.” 25 Asian Survey 187–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson, Ian (2014a) “Morality Racketeering: Vigilantism and Populist Islamic Militancy in Indonesia,” in Khoo, B. T., Hadiz, V. R., & Nakanishi, Y., eds., Between Dissent and Power: The Transformation of Islamic Politics in the Middle East and Asia, London: Palgrave Macmillan, 248–74.Google Scholar
Wilson, Ian (2014b) “Resisting Democracy: Front Pembela Islam and Indonesia’s 2014 Elections,” 10 ISEAS Perspective, 24.Google Scholar
Woodward, Mark, Mariani, Yahya, Inayah, Rohmaniyah et al. (2014) “The Islamic Defenders Front: Demonization, Violence and the State in Indonesia.” 8 Contemporary Islam 153–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar