Effectiveness of a web-based acceptance and commitment therapy program for adolescent career preparation: A randomized controlled trial
Introduction
Career preparation including clarifying vocational preferences and specifying and implementing educational choices is considered among the most important developmental tasks for adolescents (Super, 1980, Super, 1990). The successful performance of this developmental task has been shown to promote personal growth, psychological and economic well-being, and vocational careers (Germeijs & Verschueren, 2007; Lent & Brown, 2013). Career preparation and career control might be particularly important nowadays when future career prospects are more insecure and unstable due to major changes occurring in working life (e.g., Briscoe, 2015; Guest & Rodrigues, 2015). Not only adolescents' goals, values and interests, but also self-efficacy and coping skills play a central role in their educational and vocational choices as well as in their future careers (e.g., Betz, 2007; Briscoe, 2015; Gainor, 2006; Lent, 2013).
Among adults, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) interventions in an occupational context have been found to promote employees' job performance, productivity and innovation potential (Bond et al., 2010; Bond & Bunce, 2003), and reduce absenteeism as well as job burnout (Bond & Flaxman, 2006; Flaxman & Bond, 2010; Puolakanaho et al., 2018). In general, ACT interventions aim to support individuals' personal growth and resilience, with an emphasis on clarification of interests and values and acting in accordance with one's values (Hayes et al., 2006; Hoare et al., 2012). ACT also emphasizes building acceptance skills or a flexible behavioral repertoire in relation to one's own inner experiences (e.g. self-critical thoughts, anxiety; Hayes et al., 2006), which can increase adaptability and the ability to pursue long-term goals that, in turn, are related to career preparation (see Lent, 2013). According to Hoare et al. (2012), ACT has potential to offer a holistic approach to career development interventions and enhance individuals' cognitive and emotional functioning in regard to career planning. Thus, ACT-based interventions may also promote the goals of adolescent career preparation. However, no previous studies have examined the effectiveness of ACT interventions to promote adolescents' career preparation, which we focus on.
Specifically, our study focuses on the career preparation of 15- to 16-year-old Finnish adolescents in the ninth grade fall before they make critical educational choices regarding upper secondary education (i.e., vocational vs. academic track) after compulsory basic education. In Finland, this is the first milestone in transition from school to working life in adolescents' educational track.
The aim of the current randomized controlled trial was to examine the effects of acceptance and values-based skill training during the five-week online ACT intervention program on ninth grade adolescents' career preparation, measured as career choice self-efficacy, career-related insecurity, and preparation against career setbacks. Additionally, the current study examined whether intervention efficacy was moderated by gender and academic achievement.
Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) is a so-called third wave, process-based cognitive behavioral therapy (Hayes, Pistorello, et al., 2012; Hayes, Strosahl, et al., 2012). ACT does not attempt to manipulate or change the form or the frequency of individual thoughts. Instead, it aims to alter the function that the thought, emotional reaction or behavior has. The aim of ACT is to create a “mind” that is more flexible and open to the new opportunities and more aware of consequences of actions (Hayes, Pistorello, et al., 2012; Hayes, Strosahl, et al., 2012). The ACT-model proposes that adolescents' ineffective actions or problems can be caused by entangled mind processes leading to poorly developed self-awareness, failure to see the perspective of others, and weak skills to pursue for one's own goals and solve challenging life events.
Psychological flexibility is a key concept in the ACT theory, referring to individuals' capability to focus on their current situation and, depending on the opportunities provided by the situation, to act towards achieving their personal goals and values, even in the presence of unwanted thoughts, emotions, physiological sensations and memories (Bond et al., 2008; Flaxman et al., 2013; Hayes, Pistorello, et al., 2012; Hayes, Strosahl, et al., 2012). Essentially, ACT intervention models focus on promoting six inter-related psychological processes: (a) remaining flexibly and purposefully in the present moment and being mindful of thoughts, feelings, bodily sensations, and action potentials; (b) maintaining a perspective-taking attitude on thoughts and emotional reactions; (c) clarifying one's hopes, values, and goals in life; (d) acting in line with identified personal hopes, values, and goals; (e) willingly experiencing unwanted inner experiences to engage in valued action; and (f) observing and recognizing the thoughts that interfere with one's experienced life events and valued actions and seeing them as thoughts rather than literal truths (Flaxman et al., 2013; Hayes, Strosahl, et al., 2012; Puolakanaho et al., 2019). Each of these processes is a psychological skill that can be useful in planning one's own actions and committing to pursuing long-term goals (characterized in the current paper as career-related goals) as well as addressing possible barriers or setbacks (characterized in the current paper as career—related setbacks) including inner experiences that may function as barriers to action (e.g. self-doubt).
Essentially, ACT-based interventions are thought to be a process-based psychological treatments that potentially influence psychologically derived obstacles and challenges in multiple different life domains, including that of career (Dindo et al., 2017; Hayes & Hofmann, 2017; Hayes, Pistorello, et al., 2012; Muto et al., 2011; Pistorello, 2013). A growing number of studies have successfully used the ACT approach with adolescents, for example, to alleviate depression and stress (e.g., Petts et al., 2017), to alter unwanted behavior (e.g., Armstrong et al., 2013), and to relieve physical conditions, such as pain (e.g., Wicksell et al., 2009). Furthermore, ACT-based interventions have shown positive effects in alleviating psychological symptoms, increasing quality of life, and enhancing psychological flexibility in adolescents (Puolakanaho et al., 2019; Lappalainen et al., 2021; Swain et al., 2015) and in university students (e.g., Levin et al., 2017; Muto et al., 2011; Pistorello, 2013; Räsänen et al., 2016). Among adults ACT has also been found to enhance self-efficacy, performance, productivity and innovation potential in occupational settings (Flaxman et al., 2013). Current literature suggests that ACT may have the potential to promote school engagement and decrease the risk of adolescents dropping out of school (Moore et al., 2003). However, as far as we know, no previous studies have examined the efficacy of ACT in promoting adolescent's career preparation which we focus on in the current paper. In the present study career preparation was examined through career choice preparedness, including the readiness to take advantage of opportunities and the readiness to deal with barriers and setbacks in the domain of career choice (Koivisto et al., 2011; Sweeny et al., 2006; Vuori et al., 2008).
Career development is a dynamic process that continues over the span of one's career (which encompasses much of the life span) and where the formation of career-related choices is particularly relevant and active during adolescence (Lent & Brown, 2013). Adolescents' high abilities to cope with career decisional tasks have been shown to predict their subsequent academic commitment and adjustment in higher education, which, in turn, has been associated with successful vocational careers (Germeijs & Verschueren, 2007; Keller & Whiston, 2008).
Lent (2013, see also Lent et al., 1994) launched an integrative social cognitive career theory (SCCT) to understand educational and occupational behavior. SCCT proposes that experiences of one's own skill development at young age shape career choice-related self-efficacy, expectations and interest and ultimately career development. Indeed, high career choice–related self-efficacy has shown to positively associate with career exploration (Brown & Lent, 2016; Creed et al., 2007), career persistence (Choi et al., 2012; Lent et al., 1994) and promote actual career-related choices and performance (Betz & Hackett, 1981; Brown & Lent, 2016; Lent et al., 1993). Outcome expectations, e.g., experiences of career and labour market insecurity, in turn, have been shown to complement self-efficacy in the prediction of educational and vocational intentions (Fouad & Smith, 1996; Lent et al., 1993), educational choice goals (Lent et al., 2005), and impaired self-management (Alisic & Wiese, 2020). In SCCT, self-efficacy and outcome beliefs are seen as jointly influencing career-related interests, which tend to foster career choice goals (i.e., intentions to pursue a particular career path) that are congruent with one's interests (Lent, 2013; Lent et al., 1994).
Following this boosting self-efficacy beliefs and outcome expectations related to career preparation has become one of the most important proximal goals in career-related interventions (for reviews, see Betz, 2007; Gainor, 2006). Therefore, the present study focuses on adolescents' experienced career-choice self-efficacy and career-related insecurity (closely related to career outcome expectations) as key indicators of career preparation. As context factors (e.g. societal structures, feedback from others, media coverage etc.) can also influence career development (Lent, 2013; Lent et al., 1994), it is important to develop competence to prepare for overcoming problems when facilitating career choices (Creed et al., 2007; Koivisto et al., 2011). Therefore, the present study focuses also on preparation against career setbacks as an indicator of career preparation.
Previous studies have provided evidence that various preventive interventions can be successful in increasing an adolescent's efficacy in making career decisions (Betz, 2007; Brown & Ryan Krane, 2000; Gainor, 2006; Koivisto et al., 2011). For example, Koivisto et al. (2011) showed for a community sample of youth that a one-week workshop program intervention successfully promoted ninth graders' career choice preparedness and positive attitude towards career planning. Web-based interventions to promote exploring career options and searching for career-related information have also been found to be useful tools in career counseling for adolescents and university students (Betz & Borgen, 2009; Fowkes & McWhirter, 2007; Tirpak & Schlosser, 2013; Turner & Lapan, 2005).
However, most previous preventive interventions (for a review, see Lent, 2013) have been educational with the emphasis on promoting capabilities in information seeking, crystallizing vocational interests, and promoting effective career decision-making. Less attention has been paid to the role of psychological processes and emotional functioning in career preparation (Hoare et al., 2012; Kidd, 2004, Kidd, 2008). An important part of ACT's potential contribution to career counseling and preventing career interventions is that it may enable counselors and clients to better address adolescents' interests (i.e., Brown, 2007), relationships (i.e., Schultheiss, 2003), and emotions (i.e., Kidd, 2004, Kidd, 2008) as they pertain to the career-related issues (see also Hoare et al., 2012). The ACT model integrates psychological theories and practices as well as career counseling, offering a new model to understand career preparation and to identify the life domains in which adolescents are struggling to carry out valued activities, to recognize and tackle the obstacles related to emotional and cognitive barriers (Hoare et al., 2012).
As far as we know, no career interventions, based on ACT to promote adolescents' career preparation, have thus far been implemented. Since finding a purpose in life and obtaining flexibility and adaptation skills are particularly relevant aims for ensuring adolescents' successful careers (Bronk et al., 2009; Burrow et al., 2010; Eccles, 2004; Hill et al., 2013; Savickas, 2005), it is arguably feasible to test the efficacy of ACT also in the promotion of adolescents' career preparation.
Individuals may also differ in the extent to which they benefit from ACT interventions, implying that individual difference factors may moderate (weaken/strengthen) intervention outcomes. Even though little is thus far known about the factors that moderate the efficacy of ACT interventions, increasing understanding about such factors is important because it helps to improve the efficacy of interventions by tailoring intervention content to the needs of different individuals (Pots et al., 2016; Välimäki et al., 2017). In this intervention study, two potential moderating factors are considered: adolescent gender and academic achievement.
Poor academic achievement is related to more limited career options available and to a heightened need for making alternative plans if the primary educational choices are not realized. Hence, poor academic achievement may also hinder adolescents' career preparation, shown as lower self-efficacy in making career choices and increased experiences of career insecurity (see also Negru-Subtirica & Pop, 2016). Furthermore it has already been shown that youth career interventions are more effective among those who have learning difficulties (Vuori et al., 2008), which again might be linked with (poorer) academic achievement. These findings suggest that academic achievement may moderate the relationships between ACT intervention and career outcomes.
In previous studies, it has also been shown, somewhat paradoxically, that adolescent girls tend to outperform boys academically (Kiuru et al., 2007; Marcenaro-Gutierrez et al., 2017; Pomerantz et al., 2002) but at the same time are more vulnerable to school-related stress than boys (Currie et al., 2012; Hirvonen et al., 2019). In one previous study, the results showed that the efficacy of a web-based ACT intervention in alleviating adolescent stress and increasing their academic buoyancy did not depend on the level of adolescents' academic skills (Puolakanaho et al., 2019). However, no previous studies have examined whether adolescents' gender and academic achievement might moderate efficacy of ACT interventions to promote adolescent career preparation.
The goal of this study was to investigate the effects of the Youth Compass program (a web-based five-week ACT intervention) on career preparation i.e., career-choice self-efficacy, career-related insecurity, and preparation against career setbacks, among adolescents. A total of 249 ninth-grade adolescents were randomly assigned to three conditions of which two groups received an iACT including online support (iACTface: iACT + two face-to-face sessions; only iACT: iACT with no face-to-face sessions). These two iACT interventions were compared to a control group receiving only the usual support from the school. The following three research questions and hypotheses were addressed.
- 1)
Can adolescents' career preparation be promoted with the web-based Youth Compass program, and does intervention efficacy vary between the two intervention groups (i.e., iACTface vs. only iACT)? It is expected (H1) that the Youth Compass program promotes adolescents' career preparation in terms of higher career-choice self-efficacy, lower career-related insecurity, and higher preparation against career setbacks (closely related to career outcome expectations). Due to inconsistent previous research, no hypotheses are set regarding differences between intervention groups (i.e., iACTface vs. only iACT).
- 2)
Are the intervention results maintained at the six-month follow-up, and does maintenance of intervention effects vary between the two intervention groups (i.e., iACTface vs. only iACT)? It is expected (H2) that the positive intervention results persist at the six-month follow-up, indicating maintenance of intervention effects. Due to the lack of previous research, no hypotheses are nevertheless set regarding differences between intervention groups in the maintenance of intervention effects (i.e., i.e., iACTface vs. only iACT).
- 3)
Is the efficacy of Youth Compass in promoting adolescent career preparation moderated by adolescent gender and academic achievement? Adolescents with lower achievement, who likely need especially much further career guidance and counseling (see also Pope, 2015), were tentatively expected (H3) to particularly benefit from Youth Compass with regard to their career preparation. Due to the lack of previous research, no hypotheses are set regarding adolescent gender as a moderator of intervention effects. However, regarding practical implications it is important to find out whether girls and boys differentially benefit from the intervention.
Section snippets
Participants and group protocols
The participant flow diagram is shown in Fig. 1 and demographic characteristics are shown in Table 1 (for details of the study procedures, see Puolakanaho et al., 2019; Lappalainen et al., 2021). The five-week interventions were carried out in the fall of the ninth grade (2017) before a transition to upper secondary school. A group-administered pre-measurement during regular school hours was carried out in the early fall of 2017 (September–October), post-measurement in the late fall of 2017
Intention-to-treat analyses
In the intention-to-treat analyses group differences in the changes in the career preparation indicators (i.e., career-choice self-efficacy, career-related insecurity, preparation against career setbacks) were examined using the whole randomized sample (intention-to-treat analyses). In the first analyses (Model 1), the intervention groups (i.e., iACTface and iACT) were contrasted with the control group. Changes in career preparation investigated both from pre- to post-measurement and from post-
Discussion
Programs based on acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) have rarely been used as preventive tools for promoting adolescents' career preparation. This randomized controlled trial examined the possibility to promote adolescents' career preparation (i.e., career-choice self-efficacy, career-related insecurity, and preparation against career setbacks) with a web-delivered, five-week ACT-based intervention program among a general sample of ninth-grade adolescents. Preventive career intervention
Limitations and future directions
This study is not without limitations. First, although the results were interesting and promising, the overall intervention effects of the online ACT intervention for adolescents' career preparation were small albeit moderate for subgroups. One possible explanation for this is that the length of the online ACT intervention was only five weeks and career domain was only one of the multiple life domains in focus. On the other hand, career choices are made in a broader life context, and these
Conclusions and practical implications
The results suggest that brief ACT-based online intervention programs have the potential to promote adolescent career preparation. Given the rapid changes in contemporary life contexts, psychological flexibility and adaptability are important for maintaining well-being and successful educational and vocational careers (Hoare et al., 2012). ACT has the potential to contribute to and promote adolescent career preparation. ACT aims to increase committed action while also improving skills to
CRediT authorship contribution statement
NK conceived of the study, participated in the design and coordination, led the main study including implementation of the data collection and interventions, analyzed the data and drafted the manuscript; AP, PL and RL planned the intervention program, participated in the design and helped to draft the manuscript, KK and SM participated in interpretation of the data and helped to draft the manuscript, and JM participated in the data analyses and interpretation of the data. All authors read and
Ethical approval
This study was conducted in compliance with APA ethical standards. It was approved by the Ethical Committee of the University of Jyväskylä, and has been registered at ClinicalTrials.gov.
Informed consent
Informed consent was obtained from all the participants of the study.
Funding
This study was funded by the Finnish Cultural Foundation and the Academy of Finland (No. 324638).
Data sharing and declaration
The datasets generated and/or analyzed during the current study are not publicly available but are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References (95)
- et al.
Keeping an insecure career under control: The longitudinal interplay of career insecurity, self-management, and self-efficacy
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2020) - et al.
Predicting change over time in career planning and career exploration for high school students
Journal of Adolescence
(2007) - et al.
Acceptance and commitment therapy: A transdiagnostic behavioral intervention for mental health and medical conditions
Neurotherapeutics
(2017) - et al.
A randomised worksite comparison of acceptance and commitment therapy and stress inoculation training
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2010) - et al.
High school students’ career decision-making process: Consequences for choice implementation in higher education
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2007) Acceptance and commitment therapy, relational frame theory, and the third wave of behavioral and cognitive therapies
Behavior Therapy
(2004)- et al.
Acceptance and commitment therapy: Model, processes and outcomes
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2006) - et al.
School-related stress among sixth-grade students - Associations with academic buoyancy and temperament
Learning and Individual Differences
(2019) Emotion in career contexts: Challenges for theory and research
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2004)- et al.
The Youth Compass - The effectiveness of an online Acceptance- and Commitment Therapy program to promote adolescent mental health – a Randomized Controlled Trial
Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science
(2021)
Toward a unifying social cognitive theory of career and academic interest, choice, and performance
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Predicting mathematics-related choice and success behaviors: Test of an expanded social cognitive model
Journal of Vocational Behavior
The effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy bibliotherapy for enhancing the psychological health of Japanese college students living abroad
Behavior Therapy
Longitudinal links between career adaptability and academic achievement in adolescence
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Acceptance and commitment therapy for adolescent depression: Application with a diverse and predominantly socioeconomically disadvantaged sample
Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science
Burnout-related ill-being at work: Associations between mindfulness and acceptance skills, worksite factors, and experienced well-being in life
Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science
An online guided ACT intervention for enhancing the psychological wellbeing of university students: A randomized controlled clinical trial
Behaviour Research and Therapy
A life-span, life-space approach to career development
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Acceptance and commitment therapy for children: A systematic review of intervention studies
Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science
Applications of self-efficacy theory to the understanding and treatment of career indecision
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Evaluation of an intervention to increase non-traditional career interests and career-related self-efficacy among middle-school adolescents
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Towards working life: Effects of an intervention on mental health and transition to post-basic education
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Effectiveness of career choice interventions: A meta-analytic replication and extension
Journal of Vocational Behavior
Evaluating the effectiveness of exposure and acceptance strategies to improve functioning and quality of life in longstanding pediatric pain
Pain
Efficacy of treatment acceptance and commitment and emotion regulation strategies on anxiety sensitivity, excitement irregularities and self-efficacy
International Journal of Medical Research and Health Sciences
Alliance structure assessed by the Agnew Relationship Measure (ARM)
British Journal of Clinical Psychology
Therapeutic alliance and outcome of psychotherapy: Historical excursus, measurements, and prospects for research
Frontiers in Psychology
A preliminary investigation of acceptance and commitment therapy for adolescent obsessive-compulsive disorder
Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy
Career self-efficacy: Exemplary recent research and emerging directions
Journal of Career Assessment
Comparative effectiveness of CAPA and FOCUS online
Journal of Career Assessment
The relationship of career-related self-efficacy expectations to perceived career options in college women and men
Journal of Counseling Psychology
The role of acceptance and job control in mental health, job satisfaction, and work performance
Journal of Applied Psychology
The ability of psychological flexibility and job control to predict learning, job performance, and mental health
Journal of Organizational Behavior Management
The influence of psychological flexibility on work redesign: Mediated moderation of a work reorganization intervention
Journal of Applied Psychology
The impact of psychological flexibility and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) on health and productivity at work
Do we know who will drop out? A review of the predictors of dropping out of high school: Precision, sensitivity, and specificity
High School Journal
Educating students for sustainable careers: In the classroom and beyond
Purpose, hope, and life satisfaction in three age groups
Journal of Positive Psychology
Career information, career counseling, and career development
Vocational psychology: Agency, equity, and well-being
Annual Review of Psychology
Four (or five) sessions and a cloud of dust: Old assumptions and new observations about career counseling
Profiles of a developmental asset: Youth purpose as a context for hope and well-being
Journal of Youth and Adolescence
Understanding career decision self-efficacy
Journal of Career Development
Get out of your mind & into your life for teens: A guide to living an extraordinary life
Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
The state of learning disabilities
Social determinants of health and well-being among young people. Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) study: International report from the 2009/2010 survey
Cited by (10)
The role of psychological flexibility and socioeconomic status in adolescent identity development
2023, Journal of Contextual Behavioral ScienceThe role of career adaptability resources in dual career pathways: A person-oriented longitudinal study across elite sports upper secondary school
2023, Psychology of Sport and ExerciseA guided online ACT intervention may increase psychological well-being and support school engagement in adolescents
2023, Journal of Contextual Behavioral ScienceThe role of psychological inflexibility in adolescent satisfaction with the educational track and school dropout intentions
2022, Journal of Contextual Behavioral ScienceCitation Excerpt :In addition, Grégoire et al. (2018) showed that the ACT-based intervention increased Canadian university students' engagement with their studies. A web-based ACT intervention, in turn, has been shown to promote adolescents' career preparation (Kiuru et al., 2021). Therefore, previous research suggests that psychological inflexibility may be associated with school engagement.