Abstract
Energy security as a concept is void of meaning if not related to specific sociotechnical settings, this article argues. By bringing in insights from science and technology studies and national identity-making, we focus on how sociotechnical imaginaries of energy security in Norway and Ukraine are formative and productive for both technological development and societal discourses. This leads to diverse national narratives and strategies for providing energy security. In Norway, the imaginary transcends technical reasoning and day-to-day administration and has created a highly stable discourse seldom politicised. In Ukraine, the sociotechnical imaginary is in flux and highly politicised – if not securitised – as a new Ukrainian identity is under construction with and against energy technology and the Russian other. The article shows the benefits of understanding energy security as an interplay between societal discourses, technologies and natural resources rather than a stable end goal to be pursued.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ang, Beng W. et al. (2015) ‘Energy Security: Definitions, Dimensions and Indexes’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 42: 1077‒93.
Antonenko, Anton et al. (2018) ‘Reforming Ukraine’s Energy Sector: Critical Unfinished Business’, Carnegie Europe, 6 February, available at https://carnegieeurope.eu/2018/02/06/reforming-ukraine-s-energy-sector-critical-unfinished-business-pub-75449 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Aradau, Claudia (2010) ‘Security That Matters: Critical Infrastructure and Objects of Protection’, Security Dialogue 41(5): 491‒514.
Arel, Dominique (2018) ‘How Ukraine has become more Ukrainian’, Post-Soviet Affairs 34(2‒3): 186‒89.
BBC (2018a) ‘Russian Orthodox Church severs links with Constantinople’, BBC, 16 October, available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-45870939 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
BBC (2018b) ‘Ukraine Orthodox priests establish independent Church’, BBC, 15 December, available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-46575548 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Bekus, Nelly (2010) Struggle Over Identity: The Official and the Alternative ‘Belarusianness?’, Budapest: Central European University Press.
Bilousova, Nataliia (2012) ‘Den Energetychnoi Nezalezhnosti Ukrainy’ [Energy Independence Day of Ukraine ], Den, 27 November, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/den-ukrayini/den-energetichnoyi-nezalezhnosti-ukrayini (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Burgess, Peter (2001) Culture and Rationality: European Frameworks of Norwegian Identity, Kristiansand: Høyskoleforlaget/ Norwegian Academic Press.
Burgess, J. Peter and Jens Jonas Hyvik (2004) ‘Ambivalent Patriotism: Jacob Aall and Dano-Norwegian Identity Before 1814’, Nations and Nationalism 10(4): 619‒37.
Buzan, Barry, Ole Wæver and Jaap de Wilde (1998) Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (2018) ‘On Approval of the Concept for the Development of Ukraine’s Gas Production’, No. 1079-p, Kiev, 24 October, available at https://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1079-2016-%D1%80 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Campbell, David (1992) Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Cherp, Aleh (2012) ‘Defining Energy Security Takes More Than Asking Around’, Energy Policy 48: 841‒42.
Cherp, Aleh and Jessica Jewell (2011) ‘The Three Perspectives on Energy Security: Intellectual History, Disciplinary Roots and the Potential for Integration’, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 3(4): 202–12.
Cherp, Aleh and Jessica Jewell (2014) ‘The Concept of Energy Security. Beyond the Four As’, Energy Policy 75: 415‒21.
Ciută, Felix (2010) ‘Conceptual Notes on Energy Security. Total or Banal Security?’, Security Dialogue 41(2): 123‒44.
Cloke, Jonathan, Alison Mohr and Ed Brown (2017) ‘Imagining renewable energy: Towards a Social Energy Systems approach to community renewable energy projects in the Global South’, Energy Research & Social Science 31: 263‒72.
Cox, Emily (2016) ‘Opening the black box of Energy Security: A study of conceptions of electricity security in the United Kingdom’, Energy Research & Social Science 21(1): 1‒11.
Daiss, Tim (2016) ‘Ukraine Celebration: One Year Without Russian Gas’, Forbes, 27 November, available at https://www.forbes.com/sites/timdaiss/2016/11/27/ukraine-celebration-one-year-without-russian-gas/#259a40b962f4 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Datskevych, Natalia (2018) ‘Renewables to bring energy independence to Ukraine’, Kyiv Post, 28 June, available at https://www.kyivpost.com/business/renewables-to-bring-energy-independence-to-ukraine.html (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Dawisha, Karen and Bruce Parrott (1994) Russia and the new states of Eurasia: the politics of upheaval, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Delina, Laurence L. (2018) ‘Whose and what futures? Navigating the contested coproduction of Thailand’s energy sociotechnical imaginaries’, Energy Research & Social Science 35: 48‒56.
Den (2007) ‘Vitalii Gaiduk: Naigolovnishe -Tse Vlasna Energobezpeka’ [Vitaliy Hayduk: The most important thing is our own energy security ], Den, 2 February, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/panorama-dnya/vitaliy-gayduk-naygolovnishe-ce-vlasna-energobezpeka (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Diyak, Ivan V. (2009) Gazova Promysovist I Energetychna Bezpeka Ukrainy [Gas Industry And Energy Security of Ukraine ], Kiev: Svit Uspikhu.
Dobransky, Steve (2010) ‘Politics, energy and security’, Cooperation and Conflict 45(3): 353‒59.
Dyczok, Marta (2000) Ukraine: movement without change, change without movement, Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers.
Dyer, Hugh and Maria Julia Trombetta (2013) International Handbook of Energy Security, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Eaton, Weston M., Stephen P. Gasteyer and Lawrence Busch (2013) ‘Bioenergy futures: framing sociotechnical imaginaries in local places’, Rural Sociology 79(2): 227‒56.
Energifakta Norge (2017) ’Energiforsyningens utvikling i Norge’ [The development of energy supply in Norway], Energifakta Norge, 8 December, available at https://energifaktanorge.no/om-energisektoren/energiforsyningens-utvikling-i-norge/ (last accessed on 27 June, 2019).
Eriksen, Knut E. and Geir Lundestad (1972) Norsk utenrikspolitikk [Norwegian Foreign Policy], Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
Eriksen, Thomas Hylland and Iver Brynild Neumann (2011) ‘Fra slektsgård til oljeplattform: Norsk identitet og Europa’ [From family farm to oil platform. Norwegian identity and Europe], Internasjonal Politikk 69(3): 413‒36.
Gaidai, Andrii (2009) ‘Zorianyi Chas Mistsevoi Energopolityky’ [The heyday of local energy policy], Den, 18 March, available at http://day.Kiev.ua/uk/article/ekonomika/zoryaniy-chas-miscevoyi-energopolitiki (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Glenthøj, Rasmus (2012): Skilsmissen. Dansk og norsk identitet før og efter 1814, [The divorce. Danish and Norwegian identity before and after 1814] Viborg: Syddansk Universitetsforlag.
Gonchar, Mychail (2008) ‘“Formula” gazovoi Nezalezhnosti’ [The formula of gas independence], Den, 17 July, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/ekonomika/formula-gazovoyi-nezalezhnosti (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Hansen, Lene (2002) in Lene Hansen and Ole Wæver, eds, European Integration and National Identity: The challenge of the Nordic States, 1‒19, London: Routledge.
Hansen, Lene and Ole Wæver (2002) European Integration and National Identity: The challenge of the Nordic states, London: Routledge.
Hansen, Lene (2006) Security as Practice: Discourse Analysis and the Bosnian War, London: Routledge.
Hecht, Gabrielle (1998) The Radiance of France. Nuclear Power and National Identity after World War II, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Herder, John G. (1803) Outlines of a Philosophy of the History of Man, translated from German by T. Churchill, London: Luke Hanford.
Janmaat, Jan G. (2000) Nation-building in post-Soviet Ukraine: Educational policy and the response of the Russian-speaking population, Utrecht: Royal Dutch Geographical Society.
Jasanoff, Sheila and Sang-Hyun Kim (2009) ‘Containing the Atom: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and Nuclear Power in the United States and South Korea’, Minerva 47(2): 119–46.
Jasanoff, Sheila and Sang-Hyun Kim (2013) ‘Sociotechnical Imaginaries and National Energy Policies’, Science as Culture 22(2): 189–96.
Jasanoff, Shella and Sang-Hyun Kim (2015) Dreamscapes of modernity: Sociotechnical imaginaries and the fabrication of power, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kester, Johannes (2018) The Politics of Energy Security: Critical Security Studies, New Materialism and Governmentality, London: Routledge.
Kniazhanskyi, Vitalii (2006) ‘Truba <vg> Istoriya Ta Isteriya’ [Trumpet <br> History and hysteria], Den, 13 January, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/panorama-dnya/truba-istoriya-ta-isteriya (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Kniazhanskyi, Vitalii (2011) ‘Shans Na Energetychnyi Suverenitet’ [Chance for Energy Sovereignty], Den, 31 August, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/panorama-dnya/shans-na-energetichniy-suverenite (last accessed on 1 April, 2015).
Kohn, Hans (1967) The Idea of Nationalism, London: Macmillan.
Korostelina, Karina (2011) ‘Shaping unpredictable past: National identity and history education in Ukraine’, National Identities 13(1): 1‒16.
Kruyt, Bert, Detlef van Vuren, H. J. M. de Vries and Heleen Groenenberg, (2009) ‘Indicators for Energy Security’, Energy Policy 37(6): 2166–81.
Kuchler, Magdalena (2014) ‘Sweet dreams (are made of cellulose): Sociotechnical imaginaries of second-generation bioenergy in the global debate’, Ecological Economics 107: 431‒37.
Kuchler, Magdalena (2017) ‘Post-conventional energy futures: Rendering Europe’s shale gas resources governable’, Energy Research & Social Science 31: 32‒40.
Kuchler, Magdalena and Gavin Bridge (2018) ‘Down the black hole: Sustaining national socio-technical imaginaries of coal in Poland’, Energy Research & Social Science 41: 136‒47.
Kulyk, Volodymyr (2016) ‘National identity in Ukraine: Impact of Euromaidan and the war’, Europe-Asia Studies 68(4): 588‒608.
Kulyk, Volodymyr (2018) ‘Shedding Russianness, recasting Ukrainianness: the post-Euromaidan dynamics of ethnonational identifications in Ukraine’, Post-Soviet Affairs 34(2-3): 119‒38.
Kuzio, Taras (2002a) Ukraine: State and nation building, London: Routledge.
Kuzio, Taras (2002b) ‘The Nation-Building Project in Ukraine and Identity: Toward a Consensus’, in Taras Kuzio and Paul Anieri, eds, Dilemmas of State-Led Nation Building in Ukraine, 9‒27, Westport, CT: Praeger.
Kuzio, Taras (2001) ‘Identity and nation-building in Ukraine: Defining the “other”’, Ethnicities 1(3): 343‒65.
Kuzio, Taras (1998) ‘National Identity and Foreign Policy: The East Slavic Conundrum’, in Taras Kuzio, ed., Contemporary Ukraine: Dynamics of Post-Soviet Transformation, New York City: ME Sharpe.
Kylnytskyi, Oleg (2006) ‘Yuryi Nedashkovskyi: “V Ukraine Net Realnoy Alternatyvy Atomnoy Energetike”’ [Yuriy Nedashkovskiy: "There is no real alternative to nuclear energy in Ukraine"], Zerkalo Nedeli, 24 February, available at http://gazeta.zn.ua/ECONOMICS/yuriy_nedashkovskiy_v_ukraine_net_realnoy_alternativy_atomnoy_energetike.html (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Laclau, Ernesto and Chanta Mouffe (1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics, London: Verso.
Law, John (1992) ‘Notes on the Theory of the Actor-Network: Ordering, Strategy, and Heterogeneity’, Systems Practice 5(4): 379–93.
Levenda, Anthony M., Jennifer Richter, Thaddeus Miller and Erik Fisher (2019) ‘Regional sociotechnical imaginaries and the governance of energy innovations’, Futures 109: 181‒91.
Levidow, Les and Theo Papaioannou (2013) ‘State imaginaries of the public good: shaping UK innovation priorities for bioenergy’, Environmental Science & Policy 30: 36‒49.
McCollum, David L., Volker Krey and Keywan Riahi (2011) ‘An Integrated Approach to Energy Sustainability’, Nature Climate Change 1(9): 428‒29.
Malksoo, María (2009) The Politics of Becoming European: A study of Polish and Baltic Post-Cold War security imaginaries (New International Relations), London: Routledge.
Nadeyn, Ivan (2010) ‘Alternativnaya Energetika: v Ukrainu Okolnymi Putyami Cherez Evropu’, [Alternative energy: to Ukraine in roundabout routes across Europe] Zerkalo Nedeli, 9 July, available at http://gazeta.zn.ua/ECONOMICS/alternativnaya_energetika_v_ukrainu_okolnymi_putyami_cherez_evropu.html (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
NBIM (2017) ‘Holdings per 2017’, Norges Bank Investment Management, 31 December, available at https://www.nbim.no/en/the-fund/holdings/holdings-as-at-31.12.2017/?fullsize=true (last accessed on 1 July, 2017).
NBIM (2020): “History”, Norges Bank Investment Mangament, available at https://www.nbim.no/en/the-fund/the-history/ (last accessed on 17 April, 2020).
Neumann, Iver B. (2002) ‘This little piggy stayed at home: why Norway is not a member of the EU’, in Lene Hansen and Ole Wæver, eds, European Integration and National Identity: The challenge of the Nordic states, 88‒129, London: Routledge.
NVE (2018) ’Vannkraft utbygd og ikke utbygd’, [Hydropower developed and non-developed] NVE, 22 May, available at https://temakart.nve.no/link/?link=vannkraft (last accessed on 27 June, 2019).
Nymann, Jonna (2018) The Energy Security Paradox. Rethinking Energy (In)security in the United States and China, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pascual, Carlos and Evie Zambetakis (2010) ‘The Geopolitics of Energy. From Security to Survival’, in Pascual and Zambetakis, eds, Energy Security: Economics, Politics, Strategies, and Implications, 9‒36, Washington: Brookings Institution.
Peter, Laurence (2018) ‘Orthodox Church split: Five reasons why it matters’, BBC, 17 October, available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-45877584 (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
.
Pop-Elches, Grigore and Graeme Robertson (2018) ‘Revolutions in Ukraine: Shaping Civic Rather Than Ethnic Identities’, PONARS Eurasia, available at http://www.ponarseurasia.org/memo/revolutions-ukraine-shaping-civic-rather-ethnic-identities (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Roth, Andrew (2019) ‘Ukraine adopts language law opposed by Kremlin’, Guardian, 25 April, available at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/apr/25/ukraine-adopts-law-enforcing-use-of-ukrainian-in-public-life (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Ryzhkov, Vadym (2009) ‘Alternatyva Gazu Lezhyt Pid Nogamy’ [An alternative to gas lies beneath your feet], Den, 18 March, available at http://day.kyiv.ua/uk/article/ekonomika/alternativa-gazu-lezhit-pid-nogami (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Salter, Mark B. et al. (2013) ‘Part VI: The material turn’, in Mark B. Salter and Can E. Mutlu, eds, Research Methods in Critical Security Studies: An Introduction, 402‒58, London and New York City: Routledge.
Sasse, Gwendolyn and Alice Lackner (2018) ‘War and identity: the case of the Donbas in Ukraine’, Post-Soviet Affairs 34(2‒3): 139‒57.
Sherwood, Harriet (2019) ‘Ukraine: new Orthodox church gains independence from Moscow’, Guardian, 5 January, available at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/05/ukraine-new-orthodox-church-gains-independence-from-moscow (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Smith, Jessica M. and Abraham S. D. Tidwell (2016) ‘The everyday lives of energy transitions: Contested sociotechnical imaginaries in the American West’, Social Studies of Science 46(3): 327‒50.
Sovacool, Benjamin K. (2010) The Routledge Handbook of Energy Security, London: Routledge.
Sovacool, Benjamin K. and Marilyn A. Brown (2010) ‘Competing Dimensions of Energy Security: An International Perspective’, Annual Review of Environment and Resources 35: 77–108.
Sovacool, Benjamin and Ishani Mukherjee (2011) ‘Conceptualizing and Measuring Energy Security: A Synthesised Approach’, Energy 36(8): 5343‒55.
Sovacool, Benjamin K. and Tai Wei Lim (2011) ‘Conclusion: Exploring the Contested and Convergent Nature of Energy Security’, in Benjamin K. Sovacool, ed., The Routledge Handbook of Energy Security, 414‒27, London: Routledge.
Sovacool, Benjamin K. (2014) ‘Diversity: Energy studies need social science’, Nature, 30 July, available at https://www.nature.com/news/diversity-energy-studies-need-social-science-1.15620 (last accessed on 14 April, 2020).
SSB (2020) ‘Statistisk Sentralbyrå – Statistics Norway: Elektrisitet’ [Statistics Norway: Electricity], 14 October, available at https://www.ssb.no/energi-og-industri/statistikker/elektrisitet (last accessed on 11 November, 2020).
Surwillo, Izabela (2019) Energy Security Logics in Europe: Threat, Risk Or Emancipation?, London: Routledge.
Szporluk, Roman (1992) ‘The national question’, in Timothy J. Colton and Robert Legvold, eds, After the Soviet Union: From Empire to Nations, 85 -112, New York: Norton & Company.
Szulecki, Kacper (2018) ‘The Multiple Faces of Energy Security: An Introduction’, in Kacper Szulecki, ed., Energy Security in Europe: Divergent Perceptions and Policy Challenges, 1‒29, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Tamil, Gamze (2012) Why Is Norway Outside the European Union? Norwegian National Identity and the Question of European Integration, Frankfurt: Peter Lang GmbH - Internationaler Verlag der Wissenschaften.
Tidwell, Abraham S. D. and Jessica M. Smith (2015) ‘Morals, materials, and technoscience: the energy security imaginary in the United States’, Science, Technology & Human Values 40(5): 687‒711.
Thomson, Elspeth and Augustin Boey (2013) ‘Securing energy supply: strategic reserves’, in Hugh Dyer and Maria Julia Trombetta, eds, International Handbook of Energy Security, 117‒32, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
Triandafyllidou, Anna (1998) ‘National identity and the “other”’, Ethnic and Racial Studies 21(4): 593‒612.
Trombetta, Maria J. (2018) ‘Fuelling Threats: Securitization and the Challenges of Chinese Energy Policy’, Asian Perspective 42(2): 183–206.
Ukraine Open for Business (2018) ‘Number of Households with Solar Panels on Roofs in Ukraine Increases 2.5-Fold’, Ukraine Open for Business, 29 October, available at https://open4business.com.ua/number-of-households-with-solar-panels-on-roofs-in-ukraine-increases-2-5-fold/ (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Ukrenergo (2016) ‘Plan rozvytku Ob’yednanoyi enerhetychnoyi systemy Ukrayiny na 2017‒2026 roky’ [The development plan of the united energy system of Ukraine for 2017‒2026], 10 February, available at https://ua.energy/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Proekt-Planu-rozvytku-OES-Ukrayiny-na-2017-2026-roky.pdf (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Verkhovna Rada (1990) ‘Declaration of State Sovereignty of Ukraine’, 16 July, available at http://static.rada.gov.ua/site/postanova_eng/Declaration_of_State_Sovereignty_of_Ukraine_rev1.htm (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Vogler, John and Hannes Stephan (2013) ‘Governance dimensions of climate and energy security’, in Hugh Dyer and Maria Julia Trombetta, eds, International Handbook of Energy Security, 297‒318, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Voswinkel, Johannes (2006) ‘Moskaus Rohrkrepierer’, [Moscow’s deadlock], Zeit Online, 5 January, available at http://www.zeit.de/2006/02/Ergas (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Wanner, Catherine (2010) Burden of Dreams: History and identity in post-Soviet Ukraine, Pennsylvania: Penn State University Press.
Wilson, Andrew (1997) ‘Myths of national history in Belarus and Ukraine’, in Geoffrey Hosking and George Schopflin, eds, Myths and Nationhood, 182‒97, London: C. Hurst & Co.
Winderl, Thomas (1999) Nationalism, Nation and State, Vienna: facultas wuv Universitätsverlag.
Wolczuk, Kataryna (2000) ‘History, Europe and the “national idea”: The “official” narrative of national identity in Ukraine’, Nationalities Papers 28(4): 671‒94.
World Nuclear Association (2019) ‘Nuclear Power in Ukraine’, World Nuclear Association, August, available at http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-t-z/ukraine.aspx (last accessed on 25 June, 2019).
Wæver, Ole (2002) ‘Identity, communities and foreign policy: discourse analysis as foreign policy theory’, in Lene Hansen and Ole Wæver, eds, European Integration and National Identity: The challenge of the Nordic States, 20‒49, London: Routledge.
Yergin, Daniel (1988) ‘Energy Security in the 1990s’, Foreign Affairs 67(1): 69‒82.
List of interviews
Interview (Policy Advisor to Norwegian Government), 20 June, 2018, carried out by Trine Villumsen Berling.
Interview (Ekoklub Rivne), Rivne, 27 April, 2018, carried out by Izabela Surwillo.
Interview (Movement 350), Kiev, 12 May, 2018, carried out by Izabela Surwillo.
Acknowledgements
Trine Villumsen Berling would like to thank the Nordic Centre of Excellence for Security Technologies and Societal Values (NordSTEVA) for financing the research behind this article. Izabela Surwillo would like to thank the Centre for Security Studies, Metropolitan University Prague, Prague, Dubečská 900/10, 100 31 Strašnice Czech Republic for their support.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Berling, T.V., Surwillo, I. & Sørensen, S. Norwegian and Ukrainian energy futures: exploring the role of national identity in sociotechnical imaginaries of energy security. J Int Relat Dev 25, 1–30 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41268-021-00212-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41268-021-00212-4