Abstract
Non-conforming food products that reach consumers create potential for consumer harm and negative financial consequences for recalling firms. Food quality management systems are therefore of critical importance to consumers, policy-makers, and firms. In addition to implementing a Food Safety Management System (FSMS) for regulatory compliance, a firm may invest in a certified FSMS that enables downstream traceability. Downstream traceability is the ability to follow a product through the supply chain from production to point of sale. We use information processing theory (IPT) and supply chain coordination theory (SCCT) to hypothesize that downstream traceability improves integration and coordination, and hence, outcomes, of a product recall. Evaluating the role of downstream traceability systems in enabling firms to manage quality failures and associated outcomes is relevant because managers and policy-makers need to understand incentives for making such investments. We empirically investigate the effect of downstream traceability on the length of time unsafe product is in distribution, number of products recalled, incidence of product harm, and shareholder value using event study and regression methods in a sample of 211 food recalls announced in the United States (U.S.) from 2007–2013. We find downstream traceability enhances food safety by reducing time in distribution and number of products, but is not significant with respect to product harm. Furthermore, this capability mitigates negative shareholder value impacts. These findings suggest that downstream traceability is both fiscally and socially responsible. These results contribute to the extant academic literature and offer new insights to both practitioners and policy-makers.
Similar content being viewed by others
Availability of data and material
Because our data set includes some proprietary data, we are unable to make our data set publically available.
References
Alimentarius C (2006) Principles for traceability/Product tracing as a tool within a food inspection and certification system. Codex Alimentarius Commission, Rome, Italy
Bevilacqua M, Ciarapica F, Giacchetta G (2009) Business process reengineering of a supply chain and a traceability system: A case study. J Food Eng 93(1):13–22
Bromiley P, Marcus A (1989) The deterrent to dubious corporate behavior: Profitability, probability and safety recalls. Strateg Manag J 10(3):233–250
Brougher C, Greene J (2011) The USDA’s authority to recall meat and poultry products. Congressional Research Service. RL34313
Busse C, Meinlschmidt J, Foerstl K (2017) Managing information processing needs in global supply chains: A prerequisite to sustainable supply chain management. J Supply Chain Manag 53(1):87–113
Campbell’s (2019) Campbell’s supply base requirements and expectations manual. https://www.campbellsoupcompany.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/31/2020/04/Campbell_SBREM_v15.Core_.R1JVH.1.31.2019.pdf. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2015) Vitalsigns. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA
Chang S, Chang H (2015) Corporate motivations of product recall strategy: Exploring the role of corporate social responsibility in stakeholder engagement. Corp Soc Responsib Env Manag 22(6):393–407
Chao G, Iravani S, Savaskan R (2009) Quality improvement incentives and product recall cost sharing contracts. Manag Sci 55(7):1122–1138
Charlebois S, Sterling B, Haratifar S, Naing S (2014) Comparison of global food traceability regulations and requirements. Comp Rev Food Sci Food Saf 13(5):1104–1123
Chen Y, Ganesan S, Liu Y (2009) Does a firm’s product-recall strategy affect its financial value? An examination of strategic alternatives during product-harm crises. J Mktg 73(6):214–226
Cogollo-Flórez J, Correa-Espinal A (2019) Analytical modeling of supply chain quality management coordination and integration: A literature review. Qlty Manag J 26(2):72–83
Conagra (2019) Conagra brands citizenship update 2019. https://www.conagrabrands.com/citizenship-reports/2019. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Daft R, Lengel R (1986) Organizational information requirements, media richness and structural design. Manag Sci 32(5):554–571
Daft R, Macintosh N (1981) A tentative exploration into the amount and equivocality of information processing in organizational work units. Admin Sci Q 26(2):207–224
Dai H, Tseng M, Zipkin P (2015) Design of traceability systems for product recall. Int J Prod Res 53(2):511–531
Dai B, Nu Y, Xie X, Li J (2021) Interactions of traceability and reliability optimization in a competitive supply chain with product recall. Eur J Oper Res 290:116–131
Danone (2014) Danone 13 registration document: annual financial report. https://www.danone.com/content/dam/danone-corp/danone-com/about-us-impact/publications/en/2014/2014%2003%2025%20-%202013%20REGISTRATION%20DOCUMENT.pdf. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Fama E, French K (2015) A five-factor asset pricing model. J Fin Econ 116(1):1–22
Ferguson M, Guide V Jr, Souza G (2006) Supply chain coordination for false failure returns. Mfg Serv Oper Manag 8(4):376–393
Flynn B, Koufteros X, Lu G (2016) On theory in supply chain uncertainty and its implications for supply chain integration. J Supply Chain Manag 52(3):3–27
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2017) Food traceability guidance. http://www.fao.org/3/i7665en/I7665EN.pdf. Accessed 16 Jan 2021
Food and Drug Administration (2020) New era of smarter food safety: FDA’s Blueprint for the future. https://www.fda.gov/food/new-era-smarter-food-safety. Accessed 16 Jan 2021
Fugate B, Sahin F, Mentzer J (2006) Supply chain management coordination mechanisms. J Bus Logist 27(2):129–161
Galbraith J (1974) Organization design: An information processing view. Interface 4(3):28–36
Garren D (2009) Global food safety initiative and traceability. The Consumer Goods Forum Washington, D.C.
Global Food Safety Initiative (2011) Enhancing food safety through third party certification. https://mygfsi.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Third-Party-Certification-GFSI-White-Paper.pdf. Accessed 16 Jan 2021
Global Food Safety Initiative (2020) Walmart: Case Study. Global Food Safety Initiative. https://mygfsi.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/GFSI-Case-Study-Booklet-2020-Walmart.pdf. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Grocery Manufacturers Association (2010) Recall execution effectiveness: Collaborative approaches to improving consumer safety and confidence. Grocery Manufacturers Association Arlington, VA
GS1 (2007) The GS1 traceability standard: What you need to know. GS1 Brussels, Belgium
Hall D, Johnson-Hall T (2017) Learning from conformance quality failures that triggered product recalls: The role of direct and indirect experience. J Supply Chain Manag 53(4):13–36
Hartman R (1987) Product quality and market efficiency: The effect of product recalls on resale prices and firm valuation. Rev Econ Stat 69(2):367–372
Hendricks K, Singhal V (2003) The effect of supply chain glitches on shareholder wealth. J Oper Manag 21(5):501–522
Hoffer G, Pruitt S, Reilly R (1988) The impact of product recalls on the wealth of sellers: A reexamination. J Polit Econ 96(3):663–670
Hosseini-Motlagh S-M, Jazinaninejad M, Nami N (2020a) Recall management in pharmaceutical industry through supply chain coordination. Annals Oper Res (in press): 1–39
Hosseini-Motlagh, S-M, Nematollahi M, Nami N (2020b) Drug recall management and channel coordination under stochastic product defect severity: a Game-Theoretic analytical study. Int J Prod Res (in press): 1–27
International Organization for Standardization (2007) ISO 22005:2007 Traceability in the feed and food chain. International Organization for Standardization Geneva, Switzerland
Jarrell G, Peltzman S (1985) The impact of product recalls on the wealth of sellers. J Polit Econ 93(3):512–536
Johnson-Hall T (2017) Ensuring food safety by preventing food recalls: The impact of locus of failure, regulatory agency discovery, breadth, and firm size on corrective action. J Mktg Channels 24(3–4):115–135
Kanda A, Deshmukh S (2008) Supply chain coordination: perspectives, empirical studies and research directions. Int J Prod Econ 115(2):316–335
Karlsen K, Dreyer B, Olsen P, Elvevoll E (2012) Granularity and its role in implementation of seafood traceability. J Food Eng 112(1–2):78–85
Kellogg (2010) Kellogg Company annual report. https://d1lge852tjjqow.cloudfront.net/CIK0000055067/2ed36bb3a6fe-7ce8d9cd324e.pdf. Accessed 3 Jan 2021
Ketchen D, Wowak K, Craighead C (2014) Resource gaps and resource orchestration shortfalls in supply chain management: The case of product recalls. J Supply Chain Manag 50(3):6–15
Ketokivi M, McIntosh C (2017) Addressing the endogeneity dilemma in operations management research: Theoretical, empirical, and pragmatic considerations. J Oper Manag 52:1–14
Ketzenberg M, Bloemhof J, Gaukler G (2015) Managing perishables with time and temperature history. Prod Oper Manag 24(1):54–70
Kong D, Shi L, Yang Z (2019) Product recalls, corporate social responsibility, and firm value: Evidence from the Chinese food industry. Food Policy 83:60–69
Lange D, Washburn N (2012) Understanding attributions of corporate social irresponsibility. Acad Manag Rev 37(2):300–326
León-Bravo V, Caniato F, Caridi M (2019) Sustainability in multiple stages of the food supply chain in Italy: practices, performance and reputation. Oper Manag Res 12(1–2):40–61
Li X, Wang Q (2007) Coordination mechanisms of supply chain systems. Eur J Oper Res 179(1):1–16
Lin-Hi N, Muller K (2013) The CSR bottom line: Preventing corporate social irresponsibility. J Bus Res 66(10):1928–1936
MacKinlay A (1997) Event studies in economics and finance. J Econ Lit 35(1):13–39
Maitlis S, Christianson M (2014) Sensemaking in organizations: Taking stock and moving forward. Acad Manag Annals 8(1):57–125
Maloni M, Brown M (2006) Corporate social responsibility in the supply chain: an application in the food industry. J Bus Ethics 68(1):35–52
McEntire J, Arens S, Bernstein M et al (2010) Traceability (product tracing) in food systems: Technical aspects and recommendations. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Safety 9:92–158
Mejia C, McEntire J, Keener K et al (2010) Traceability (product tracing) in food systems: Cost considerations and implications. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Safety 9:159–175
Pruitt SW, Peterson DR (1986) Security price reactions around product recall announcements. J Fin Res 9(2):113–122
Regattieri A, Gamberi M, Manzini R (2007) Traceability of food products: General framework and experimental evidence. J Food Eng 81(2):347–536
Roth A, Tsay A, Pullman M, Gray J (2008) Unraveling the food supply chain: Strategic insights from China and the 2007 recalls. J Supply Chain Manag 44(1):22–39
Rupp N (2004) The attributes of a costly recall: Evidence from the automotive industry. Rev Ind Org 25(1):21–44
Salin V, Hooker H (2001) Stock market reaction to food recalls. Agr Appl Econ Assoc 23(1):33–46
Samson D (2020) Operations/supply chain management in a new world context. Oper Manag Res 13(1–2):1–3
Shu J, Barton R (2012) Managing supply chain execution: Monitoring timeliness and correctness via individualized trace data. Prod Oper Manag 21(4):715–729
Sterling B, Gooch M, Dent B, Marenick N, Miller A, Sylvia G (2015) Assessing the value and role of seafood traceability from an entire value-chain perspective. Comp Rev Food Sci Food Saf 14(3):205–268
Thirumalai S, Sinha K (2011) Product recalls in the medical device industry: An empirical exploration of the sources and financial consequences. Manag Sci 57(2):376–392
Thomsen M, McKenzie A (2001) Market incentives for safe foods: An examination of shareholder losses from meat and poultry recalls. Am J Agr Econ 83(3):526–538
Tyson (2020) 2019 Sustainability report. https://www.tysonsustainability.com/downloads/Tyson_2019_Sustainability_Report.pdf. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Verdouw C, Wolfert J, Beulens A, Rialland A (2016) Virtualization of food supply chains with the internet of things. J Food Eng 176:128–136
Wei J, Zhao M, Wang F, Zhao D (2016) The effects of firm actions on customers’ responses to product recall crises: Analyzing an automobile recall in China. J Risk Res 19(4):425–443
Wellik R (2012) Global Food Safety Initiative improves organizational culture, efficiency in food industry. https://www.foodqualityandsafety.com/article/global-food-safety-initiative-improves-organizational-culture-efficiency-in-food-industry/?singlepage=1. Accessed 15 Aug 2020
Wooldridge J (2010) Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT press, Cambridge MA
Wowak K, Craighead C, Ketchen D (2016) Tracing bad products in supply chains: The roles of temporality, supply chain permeation, and product information ambiguity. J Bus Logist 37(3):132–151
Zhang X (2006) Information uncertainty and stock returns. J Fin 61(1):105–137
Zhang M, Hu H, Zhao X (2020) Developing product recall capability through supply chain quality management. Int J Prod Econ 229:107795
Acknowledgements
This research was expedited by professional development leave awarded by Wright State University.
Funding
No funding was received for conducting this study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
David Hall: Conceptualization; Methodology; Validation; Formal analysis; Investigation; Data curation; Writing – original draft; Writing –review & editing; Visualization; Supervision; Project administration. Tracy Johnson-Hall: Conceptualization; Validation; Investigation; Data curation; Writing – review & editing.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest/Competing interests
The authors have no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hall, D.C., Johnson-Hall, T.D. The value of downstream traceability in food safety management systems: an empirical examination of product recalls. Oper Manag Res 14, 61–77 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-021-00184-1
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-021-00184-1