Abstract
Although catastrophic debris flow-slides from anthropogenic fill slopes are common, their failure mechanisms during both earthquakes and extreme rainfall events remains under-studied. We have used a suite of tests using a dynamic back-pressured shear box on fill materials with varying grain size characteristics and stress histories to explore their potential failure mechanisms in response to seismic loading and elevated pore water pressures. Our experiments demonstrate that whilst looser coarse-grained fills display a ductile style of deformation in response to elevated pore water pressures, denser fine-grained fills display a brittle style of deformation and require higher levels of pore water pressure to initiate failure. Dynamic loading of these fills did not generate significant excess pore water pressures or liquefaction but instead resulted in densification and seismic compression. This process of densification made these fills more prone to brittle failure in response to subsequent elevation of pore water pressures. Our results show that grain size characteristics and stress history (density) significantly impact fill slope failure mechanisms and indicate that, although in some instances, fill slopes may be strengthened by earthquake shaking, seismic compression often results in significant deformation, resulting in tension crack formation, severing of services and the development of new pore fluid pathways. This may allow high pore water pressure to develop in the slope in future rainstorms, which would increase their vulnerability to rapid debris flow-slides. The results provide new insights into the styles of failure that may be anticipated from different fill slopes and the hazards they may pose. These findings may help to inform future long-term management practices for engineered fill slopes in dynamic environments.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bishop AW (1973) The stability of tips and soil heaps. Q J Eng Geol Hydrol 6:335–376
Bolton MD, Take WA, Wong PCP, Yeung FJ (2003) Mechanicsms of failure in fill slopes after inesne rainfall. In. International Conference on Slope Engineering, 2003-12-8 to 2003-12-10, Hong Kong, pp 1-25
Boyer S, Daly M (2013) Wellington homes evacuated by landslide. Dominion Post. Retrieved from http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/8745337/Wellington-homes-evacuated-by-landslide
Brain MJ, Rosser NJ, Sutton J, Snelling K, Tunstall N, Petley DN (2015) The effects of normal and shear stress wave phasing on coseismic landslide displacement. J Geophys Res Earth Surf 120(6):1009–1022
Brain MJ, Rosser NJ, Tunstall N (2017) The control of earthquake sequences on hillslope stability. Geophys Res Lett 44:865–872
Brideau M-A, Massey C, Carey J, Kellet R, Abbott E, Monteith F, Lyndsell B (2021) Geomechanical characterisation and dynamic numerical modelling of two anthropogenic fill slopes. Eng Geol 281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2020.105980
Brown I R, Larkin T J (2005) The performance of hillside earth fills under earthquake loading. New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering Conference 2005
Carey JM, Petley DN (2014) Progressive shear-surface development in cohesive materials; implications for landslide behaviour. Eng Geol 177:54–65
Carey JM, McSaveney MJ, Lyndsell B, Petley DN (2016) Laboratory simulation of a slow landslide mechanism. In: Aversa et al. (eds). Landslides amd Engineered Slopes. Experience, Theory and practice. Associazione Geotechnica Italia, Rome, pp 557-564
Carey JM, McSaveney MJ, Petley DN (2017) Dynamic liquefaction of shear zones in intact loess during simulated earthquake loading. Landslides 14(3):789–804
Carey JM, Massey CI, Lyndsell B, Petley DN (2019) Displacement mechanisms of slow-moving landslides in response to changes in porewater pressure and dynamic stress. Earth Surf Dyn 7:707–722
Castro G, Enos JL, France JW, Poulos SJ (1982) Liquefaction induced by cyclic loading. National Science Foundation NSF/CEE-82018
Chen H, Lee CF, Law KT (2004) Causative mechanisms of rainfall-induced fill slope failures. J Geotech Geoenviron 130(6):593–602
Crozier MJ, Vaughan EE, Tippett JM (1990) Relative instability of colluvium-filled bedrock depressions. Earth Surf Process Landf 15:329–339
Duff M (2013) A Wellington problem that won't go away. Dominion Post. Retrieved from http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/news/wellington/8771245/A-Wellington-problem-that-won-t-go-away
Hancox GT, Dellow GD, Massey C, Perrin ND (2007) Reconnaissance studies of landslides caused by the July-October 2006 rainstorms in southern North Island, New Zealand. GNS Science Report
Hungr O (2007) Dynamics of Rapid Landslides. In: Sassa K., Fukuoka H., Wang F., Wang G. (eds) Progress in Landslide Science. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-70965-7_4
Hungr O, Leroueil S, Picarelli L (2014) The Varnes classification of landslide types, an update. Landslides 11(2):167–194
Hunt T, George D (2017) Slip-prone Wellington hillside to get full examination after two massive mudslides. Dominion Post. Retrieved from https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/91318527/Three-homes-evacuated-in-Wellington-after-land-slip-in-suburb-of-Kingston
Hyodo M, Orense RP, Nodal S, Furukawa S, Furui T (2011) Slope failures in residential land on valley fills in Yamamoto town. Soils Found 52(5):975–986
Hyodo M, Orense RP, Noda S, Furukawa S, Furui T (2012) Mechanism of slope failures in residential land on fill during Great East Japan Earthquake. In: Proceedings of the International Symposium on Engineering Lessons Learned from the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake, March 1-4, Tokyo, Japan, pp 937–948
Iverson RM (2005) Regulation of landslide motion by dilatancy and pore pressure feedback. J Geophys Res 110:F02015
Iverson RM, George DL, Allstadt K, Reid ME, Collins BD, Vallance JW, Magirl CS (2015) Landslide mobility and hazards: implications of the 2014 Oso disaster. Earth Planet Sci Lett 412:197–208
Legros F (2002) The mobility of long run-out landslides. Eng Geol 63(3):301–331
Lyndsell B, Carey JM, Bruce Z (in press). SLIDE (Wellington): geotechnical laboratory testing of greywacke and anthropogenic fill from the Wellington region. GNS Science Report 2019/40.
Massey C, Townsend D, Rathje E, Kaneko Y, Lukovic B, Horspool N, Bradley B, Hamling I, Wartman J, Allstadt K, Carey J, Cox S, Davidson J, Dellow S, Godt J, Holden C, Jibson R, Jones K, Kaiser A, Lyndsell B, McColl S, Morgenstern R, Petley DN, Rengers F, Rhoades D, Rosser N, Strong D, Singeisen C, Villeneuve M (2018) Landslides triggered by the 14 November 2016, MW 7.8 Kaikoura Earthquake, New Zealand. Bull Seismol Soc Am 108(3B):1630–1648
NIWA. (n.d.). CliFlo: NIWA's National Climate Database on the Web. Retrieved from: http://cliflo.niwa.co.nz/
Okada Y, Sassa K, Fukuoka H (2000) Liquefaction and the steady state of weathered granitic sands obtained by undrained ring shear tests: a fundamental study of the mechanism of liquidized landslides. J Nat Dis Sci 22(2):75–85
Petley DN, Higuchi T, Petley DJ, Bulmer MH, Carey J (2005) The development of progressive landslide failure in cohesive materials. Geology 33:201–204
Sassa K (2000) Mechanism of flows in granular soils. Paper presented at the ISRM International Symposium.
Sassa K, Fukuoka H, Scarascia-Mugnozza G, Evans S (1996) Earthquake-induced-landslides: distribution, motion and mechanisms. Soils Found 36(Special):53–64
Sassa K, Fukuoka H, Wang G, Ishikawa N (2004) Undrained dynamic-loading ring-shear apparatus and its application to landslide dynamics. Landslides 1(1):7–19
Stewart JP, Bray JD, McMahon DJ, Smith PM, Kropp AL (2001) Seismic performance of hillside fills. J Geotech Geoenviron 127(11):909–919
Stewart JP, Smith PM, Whang DH, Bray JD (2004) Seismic compression of two compacted earth fills shaken by the 1914 Northridge Earthquake. J Geotech Geoenviron 130(5):461–476
Take WA, Bolton MD, Wong PCP, Yeung FJ (2004) Evaluation of landslide triggering mechanisms in model fill slopes. Landslides 1:173–184
Wang G, Sassa K (2002) Post-failure mobility of saturated sands in undrained load-controlled ring shear tests. Can Geotech J 39(4):821–837
Wang G, Sassa K (2003) Pore-pressure generation and movement of rainfall-induced landslides: effects of grain size and fine-particle content. Eng Geol 69(1):109–125
Wang G, Sassa K, Fukuoka H, Tada T (2007) Experimental study on the shearing behaviour of saturated silty soils based on ring shear tests. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng ASCE 133(3):319–333
Wang G, Zhang D, Furuya G, Yang J (2014) Pore- pressure generation and fluidization in a loess landslide triggered by the 1920 Haiyuan earthquake, China: a case study. Eng Geol 174:36–45
Whang DH, Stewart JP, Bray JD (2004) Effect of compaction conditions on the seismic compression of compacted fill soils. Geotech Test J ASTM 27(4):371–379
Acknowledgements
We thank GNS Science staff Brenda Rosser and Dr Marc-Andre Brideau for their technical input during the study. Urban landslide data for the Wellington region was provided by Wellington City Council (WCC).
Funding
Financial support has been provided through the GNS Science Strategic Development Fund, MBIE Targeted contract C05X159: Emerging Anthropogenic Slope Hazards and by the NERC/ESRC Increasing Resilience to Natural Hazards programme, grant NE/J01995X/1, and NERC/Newton Fund grant NE/N000315.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carey, J.M., Cosgrove, B., Norton, K. et al. Debris flow-slide initiation mechanisms in fill slopes, Wellington, New Zealand. Landslides 18, 2061–2072 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10346-021-01624-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10346-021-01624-6