Abstract
In a comment on two recent articles on the archaeological impacts of metal detecting, this paper advocates clearer and more valid measures of those impacts and more nuanced classification of the legal and cultural environments in which metal detecting takes place. The need to rely on open-source, online data for transnational analysis makes the former challenging but not impossible. Using the example of Canada, the paper shows that jurisdictional and other complexities make simple “permissive” and “restrictive/prohibitive” dichotomies unhelpful, and suggests using multivariate analysis that accounts for such factors as presumption of ownership, locations of metal detecting, availability of finds reporting, and whether heritage legislation concerns artifacts or only sites. This is essential for development of sound, evidence-based policy on the metal-detecting hobby.
References
Alberta (2000). Historical Resources Act, RSA 2000, c H-9. Edmonton: Alberta Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
British Columbia (1996). Heritage Conservation Act, RSBC 1996, Chapter 187. Victoria: Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Campbell, S. (2013). Metal detecting, collecting and portable antiquities: Scottish and British perspectives. Internet Archaeology, 33, intarch.ac.uk/journal/issue33/index.html10.11141/ia.33.1Search in Google Scholar
Canada Shipping Act (1985). Canada Shipping Act, R.S. 1985, c. S9, part VI. Ottawa: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Canadian Press (2014, December 5). Man with metal detector finds mortar shell in Vancouver’s Stanley Park. CTV News, https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/man-with-metal-detector-finds-mortar-shell-in-vancouver-s-stanley-park-1.2134903Search in Google Scholar
Caton, M. (2018, July 24). Metal detecting club fears end to digging in Windsor parks. Windsor Star, https://windsorstar.com/news/local-news/metal-detecting-club-fears-end-to-digging-in-windsor-parksSearch in Google Scholar
CBC (2016, March 22). Unexploded mortar shells discovered in St. George blueberry field. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/mortar-shells-hollis-justason-1.3502018Search in Google Scholar
Deckers, P., Bleumers, L., Ruelens, S., Lemmens, B., Vanderperren, N., Marchal, C., Pierson, J., & Tys, D. (2016). MEDEA: Crowd-sourcing the recording of metal-detected artefacts in Flanders (Belgium). Open Archaeology, 2(1), 264–277. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2016-001910.1515/opar-2016-0019Search in Google Scholar
Deckers, P., Dobat, A., Ferguson, N., Heeren, S., Lewis, M., & Thomas, S. (2018). The complexities of metal detecting policy and practice: A response to Samuel Hardy, ‘Quantitative analysis of open-source data on metal detecting for cultural property’ (Cogent Social Sciences 3, 2017). Open Archaeology, 4(1), 322–333. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2018-001910.1515/opar-2018-0019Search in Google Scholar
Denhez, P. (2010). Unearthing the law: Archaeological legislation on lands in Canada. Gatineau, Québec: Archaeological Services Branch, Parks Canada. https://www.pc.gc.ca/en/docs/r/pfa-fap/indexSearch in Google Scholar
Dobat, A. & Jensen A. (2016). “Professional amateurs”. Metal detecting and metal detectorists in Denmark. Open Archaeology, 2(1), 70–84. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2016-000510.1515/opar-2016-0005Search in Google Scholar
Explore (2012, May 14). Celebrate National Metal Detecting Day. Explore, https://www.explore-mag.com/celebrate-nationalmetal-detecting-daySearch in Google Scholar
Gamble, S. (2008, August 30). Detecting graveyards? Don’t even think about it. Brantford Expositor.Search in Google Scholar
Hardy, S.A. (2017). Quantitative analysis of open-source data on metal detecting for cultural property: Estimation of the scale and intensity of metal detecting and the quantity of metal-detected cultural goods. Cogent Social Sciences, 3. Doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2017.129839710.1080/23311886.2017.1298397Search in Google Scholar
Hardy, S.A. (2018a). Metal-detecting for cultural objects until ‘there is nothing left’: The potential and limits of digital data, netnographic data and market data for open-source analysis. Arts, 7(40), 1–36.10.3390/arts7030040Search in Google Scholar
Hardy, S.A. (2018b). A response to a response on metal-detecting and open-source analysis. Conflict Antiquities, https://conflictantiquities.wordpress.com/2018/07/26/a-response-to-a-response-on-metal-detecting-and-open-sourceanalysis/Search in Google Scholar
Kehler, J. (2017, November 28). Okanagan city digs in heels over metal detector in parks. CBC News, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/ammo-bullets-metal-detector-vernon-1.4423930Search in Google Scholar
Lorinc, J. & Williamson, R. (2016, June 10). Ontario’s hidden archaeological scandal. The Toronto Star. https://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2016/06/10/ontarios-hidden-archaeological-scandal.html10.1002/wilm.10518Search in Google Scholar
Manitoba (2003). The Heritage Resources Act, CCSM c H39.1. Winnipeg: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Manitoba (n.d.). Make history. Preserve Manitoba’s past. Municipal heritage resource guide. Winnipeg: Province of Manitoba.Search in Google Scholar
New Brunswick (2010). Heritage Conservation Act, Chapter H-4.05. Fredericton: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Newfoundland (2001). Historic Resources Act, RSNL 1990 Chapter H-4, as Amended 2001 cN03.1 s2. St. John’s: The Province of Newfoundland.Search in Google Scholar
OAS (2003). Ontario Archaeological Society policy statement on archaeological collections ownership and curation. Arch Notes ns 8(1), 9–13.Search in Google Scholar
OMTC (2011). Standards and guidelines for consultant archaeologists. Toronto: Ontario Ministry of Tourism and Culture.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (1974). Bill 176: An Act to provide for the Conservation, Protection and Preservation of the Heritage of Ontario. Toronto: J.C. Thatcher, Queen’s Printer for Ontario.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (1990a). Ontario Heritage Act: Revised Statutes of Ontario, 1980, Chapter 337 as Amended by 1989, Chapter 72, s. 28. Toronto: Ministry of the Attorney General of Ontario.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (1990b). Ontario Regulation 881. Toronto: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (2004). Ontario Regulation 170/04, Definitions. Toronto: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (2006a). Ontario Regulation 8/06, Licences under Part VI of the Act—Excluding Marine Archaeological Resources. Toronto: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Ontario (2006b). Ontario Regulation 10/06, Criteria for Determining Cultural Heritage Value or Interest of Provincial Significance. Toronto: The Queen’s Printer.Search in Google Scholar
Parks Canada (2005). Parks Canada guidelines for the management of archaeological resources. Ottawa: Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada.Search in Google Scholar
Paynton, C. (2008). The Portable Antiquities Scheme and education. In S. Thomas & P.G. Stone (Eds.), Metal detecting and archaeology, (pp. 203–213). Woodbridge: The Boydel Press.Search in Google Scholar
Quebec (2012). Loi sur le patrimoine culturel, P-9.002. Québec: Publications Québec.Search in Google Scholar
Spectator (2008 August 21). Man arrested in Brantford Cemetery, with metal detector. Hamilton Spectator, https://www.thespec.com/news-story/2104832-man-arrested-in-brantford-cemetery-with-metal-detector/Search in Google Scholar
Stanton, K. & Talmazan, Y. (2014, January 9). Watch: Treasure hunter finds 400-year-old English coin in Victoria. Global News, https://globalnews.ca/news/1073582/watch-treasure-hunter-finds-400-year-old-english-coin-in-victoria/Search in Google Scholar
Thomas, S. (2013). Editorial: Portable antiquities: Archaeology, collecting, metal detecting. Internet Archaeology, 33. Doi: https://doi.org/10.11141/ia.33.1210.11141/ia.33.12Search in Google Scholar
Thomas, S. (2016). The future of studying hobbyist metal detecting in Europe: A call for a transnational approach. Open Archaeology, 2(1), 140–149. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2016-001010.1515/opar-2016-0010Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Edward B. Banning, published by De Gruyter
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Public License.
