Assessing Dimensions of the Security-Liberty Trade-off in the United States
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
The trade-off between security and liberty has been a leading frame for understanding public opinion about domestic surveillance policies. Most of the empirical work explicitly examining whether individuals meet the trade-off framework’s core attitudinal assumptions comes from European studies. This study uses a survey of US residents to assess the veracity of the assumptions embedded in the trade-off framework, namely whether domestic counterterrorism policies are simultaneously viewed as improving security and decreasing liberty. We find that the vast majority of US respondents do not meet the basic attitudinal assumptions of the trade-off frame. Next, we evaluate the source of these attitudes with a focus on whether attitudes toward surveillance policies merely relate to core political values or whether they also depend on the messages from political leaders. We find that both political values and opinion leadership shape these attitudes. Finally, because general attitudes towards surveillance and privacy often fail to have practical implications, we assess whether these attitudes matter for understanding the structure of policy support. Our results show that heightened terrorism threat positively associates with increased support for counterterrorism policies only when people believe these policies are effective security tools.
Article Details
Surveillance & Society uses a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
- The author. The author licenses the article to the Surveillance Studies Network (SSN) for inclusion in Surveillance & Society (S&S), right of first publication. The copyright to the article remains with the author and any subsequent commercial reuse must be agreed by both parties.
- Non-commercial Users. SSN authorises all persons to use material published in S&S in any manner that is not primarily intended for or directed to commerical advantage or private monetary compensation, also provided that it is not modified and retains all attribution notices.
- Commercial Users. SSN retains the right to benefit from commerical reuse, in each specific case subject to the agreement of the author, and payment to SSN of a standard per-page fee (set by a vote of the Network and Editorial Board) by the Commercial User.
- Surveillance & Society supports open access archives and the free distribution of the results of academic work. Authors are encouraged to place copies of the final published version of their article in their university and / or other open access archives. We only ask that you make sure to include a link to the original published version on the Surveillance & Society website.
References
Ajzen, Icek. 1991. The Theory of Planned Behavior. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 50 (2): 179–211.
Barth, Suzanne, and Menno D.T. de Jong. 2017. The Privacy Paradox – Investigating Discrepancies Between Expressed Privacy Concerns and Actual Online Behavior – A Systematic Literature Review. Telomatics and Information 34 (7): 1038–58.
Bellanova, Rocco, and Gloria González-Fuster. 2013. Politics of Disappearance: Scanners and (unobserved) Bodies as Mediators of Security Practices. International Political Sociology 7: 188–209.
Best, Samuel. 2007. Center for Survey Research Analysis. University of Connecticut.
Best, Samuel J., Brian S. Krueger, and Shanna Pearson-Merkowitz. 2012. Al Qaeda versus Big Brother: Anxiety about Government Monitoring and Support for Domestic Counterterrorism Policies. Political Behavior 34 (4): 607–25.
Budak, Jelena, Edo Rajh, and Vedran Recher. 2017. Citizens’ Privacy Concerns: Does National Culture Matter. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 36–51. London: Routledge.
Buzan, Barry, Ole Waever, and Jaap de Wilde. 1998. Security: A Framework for Analysis. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Press.
Cas, Johann, Rocco Bellanova, J. Peter Burgess, Michael Friedewald, and Walter Peissl. 2017. Introduction. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 1–12. London: Routledge.
Citrin, Jack. 1979. Do People Want Something for Nothing: Public Opinion on Taxes and Government Spending. National Tax Journal 32 (2): 113–29.
Cohrs, Christopher J., Sven Kielmann, Jurgen Maes, and Barbara Moschner. 2005. Effects of Right-Wing Authoritarianism and Threat from Terrorism on Restriction of Civil Liberties. Analyses of Social Issues & Public Policy 5: 263–76.
Conti, Gregory, Lisa Shay, and Woodrow Hartzog. 2014. Deconstructing the Relationship Between Privacy and Security. IEEE Technology and Society Magazine 33 (2): 28–30.
Davis, Darren W., and Brian D. Silver. 2004. Civil liberties vs. Security: Public Opinion in the Context of the Terrorist Attacks on America. American Journal of Political Science 48 (1): 28–46.
Degli Esposti, Sara, Vincenzo Pavone, and Elvira Santiago-Gomez. 2017. Aligning Security and Privacy: The Case of Deep Packet Inspection. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 71–90. London: Routledge.
Dolan, Thomas M., Nathan Ilderton. 2017. Scared into Demanding Action: The Effects of the Perceived Threat from Terrorism on Policy Salience. Polity 49 (2): 245–69.
Dragu, Tiberiu. 2011. Is There a Trade-Off between Security and Liberty? Executive Bias, Privacy Protections, and Terrorism Prevention. The American Political Science Review 105 (1): 64–78.
———. 2017. The Moral Hazard of Terrorism Prevention. The Journal of Politics 79 (1): 223–36.
Friedewald, Michael, and Marc van Lieshout. 2015. Factors Influencing Citizens' Attitudes Toward Surveillance Oriented Security Technologies. In The Next Horizon of Technology Assessment: Proceedings from the PACITA 2015 Conference in Berlin, edited by Constanze Shertz, Tomas Michaelel, Leonhard Hennen, Lenka Hebankova, Julia Hahn, and Stephanie Seitz, 259–64. Prague: Technology Centre ASCR.
Friedewald, Michael, Marc van Lieshout, Sven Rung, and Merel Ooms. 2016. The Context-Dependence of Citizens’ Attitudes and Preferences Regarding Privacy and Security. In Data Protection on the Move: Current Developments in ICT and Privacy/Data Protection, edited by Serge Gutwirth, Ronald Leenes, and Paul De Hert, 51–74. Dordrecht, NL: Springer.
Friedewald, Michael, Marc van Lieshout, Sven Rung, Merel Ooms, and Jelmer Ypma. 2015. Report on Statistical Analysis of the PRISMS Survey. PRISMS. http://publica.fraunhofer.de/documents/N-367427.html [accessed December 1, 2018].
Fuchs, Christian. 2013. Political Economy and Surveillance Theory. Critical Sociology 39 (5): 671–87.
Garcia, Blake E., and Nehemia Geva. 2016. Security versus Liberty in the Context of Counterterrorism: An Experimental Approach. Terrorism and Political Violence 28 (1): 30–48.
Gaskell, George, Nick Allum, Wolfgang Wagner, Nicole Kronberger, Helge Torgensen, Juergun Hampel, and Julie Bardes. 2004. GM Foods and the Misperception of Risk Perception. Risk Analysis 24 (1): 185–94.
Haider-Markel, Donald P., Mark R. Joslyn, and Mohammed Tarek Al-Baghal. 2006. Can We Frame the Terrorist Threat? Issue Frames, the Perception of Threat, and Opinions on Counterterrorism Policies. Terrorism and Political Violence 18 (4): 545–59.
Henderson, Harry. 2015. Online Privacy and Government: Privacy in the Online World. San Diego: Reference Point Press.
Hetherington, Marc J., and Jonathan D. Weiler. 2009. Authoritarianism and Polarization in American Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hibbs, Douglas A. 1979. The Mass Public and Macroeconomic Performance: The Dynamics of Public Opinion toward Unemployment and Inflation. American Journal of Political Science 23 (4): 705–31.
Huddy, Leonie, Stanley Feldman, Charles Taber, and Gallya Lahav. 2005. Threat, Anxiety, and Support of Antiterrorism Policies. American Journal of Political Science 49 (3): 593–608.
Huddy, Leonie, Stanley Feldman, and Christopher Weber. 2007. The Political Consequences of Perceived Threat and Felt Insecurity. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 614 (1): 131–53.
Huijboom, Noor, and Gabriella Bodea. 2015. Understanding the Political PNR-debate in Europe: A Discourse Analytical Perspective. Perspectives on European Politics and Society 16 (2): 241–255.
Hundt, Reed. 2014. Saving Privacy: Forum. Boston Review: A Political & Literary Forum. http://bostonreview.net/forum/reed-hundt-saving-privacy [accessed August 23, 2017].
Joinson, Adam. 1999. Social Desirability, Anonymity, and Internet-Based questionnaires. Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers 31: 433–38.
Joslyn, Mark R., and Donald P. Haider-Markel. 2007. Sociotropic Concerns and Support for Counterterrorism Policies. Social Science Quarterly 88 (2): 306–19.
Kam, Cindy D., and Donald R. Kinder. 2007. Terror and Ethnocentrism: Foundations of American Support for the War on Terrorism. Journal of Politics 69 (2): 318–36.
Keeter, Scott, Carolyn Miller, Andrew Kohut, Robert M. Groves, and Stanley Presser. 2000. Consequences of Reducing Nonresponse in a National Telephone Survey. Public Opinion Quarterly 64 (2): 125–148.
King, Gary, Michael Tomz, and Jason Wittenberg. 2000. Making the Most of Statistical Analyses: Improving Interpretation and Presentation. American Journal of Political Science 44 (2): 347–61.
Kuklinski, James H., Paul J. Quirk, Jennifer Jerit, and Robert F. Rich. 2001. The Political Environment and Citizen Competence. American Journal of Political Science 45 (2): 410–24.
Lewis, Carol W. 2005. The Clash between Security and Liberty in the US Response to Terror. Public Administration Review 65 (1): 18–30.
Margolis, David N. 1996. Cohort Effects and Returns to Seniority in France. Annales d’Economie et de Statistique 41/42: 443–64.
Menichelli, Francesca. 2017. Beyond the Trade-Off between Privacy and Security? Organizational Routines and Individual Strategies at the Security Check. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 91–104. London: Routledge.
Merolla, Jennifer. L., and Elizabeth J. Zechmeister. 2009. Democracy at Risk: How Terrorist Threats Affect the Public. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Mueller, John. 2009. Overblown: How Politicians and the Terrorism Industry Inflate National Security Threats, and Why We Believe Them. New York: Free Press.
Nacos, Brigette L., Yaeli Bloch-Elkon, and Robert Y. Shapiro. 2011. Selling Fear: Counterterrorism, the Media, and Public Opinion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Norris, Gareth. 2017. Authoritarianism and Privacy: The Moderating Role of Terrorist Threat. Surveillance and Society 15 (3/4): 573–81.
Pavone, Vincenzo, and Sara Degli Esposti, 2012. Public Assessment of New Surveillance-Oriented Security Technologies: Beyond the Trade-Off Between Privacy and Security. Public Understanding of Science 21 (5): 556–72.
Peffley, Mark, Marc L. Hutchison, and Michal Shamir. 2015). The Impact of Persistent Terrorism on Political Tolerance: Israel, 1980 to 2011. American Political Science Review 109 (4): 817–32.
Potoglou, Dimitris, Neil Robinson, Chong W. Kim, Peter Burge, and Richard Warnes. 2010. Quantifying Individual Trade-off Between Privacy, Liberty & Security: The Case of Individual Rail Travel in the US. Transportation Research Part A: Policy & Practice 44 (3): 169–81.
Richey, Warren. 2009. Bush Pushed the Limits of Presidential Power. Christian Science Monitor, January 14. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2009/0114/p11s01-usgn.html [accessed December 1, 2018].
Ridout, Travis N., Ashley C. Grosse, and Andrew M. Appleton. 2008. New Media Use and Americans’ Perception of Global Threat. British Journal of Political Science 38 (4): 575–93.
Schneier, Bruce. 2003. Beyond Fear: Thinking Sensibly about Security in an Uncertain World. New York: Copernicus Books.
———. 2008. The Psychology of Security. In Progress in Cryptology – AFRICACRYPT Conference Proceedings, edited by Serge Vaudenay, 11–14. New York: Springer.
Simon, Herbert A. 1955. A Behavioral Model of Rational Choice. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 69 (1): 99–118.
———. 1982. Models of Bounded Rationality, Volume 1: Economic Analysis and Public Policy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Smith, H. Jeff, Tamara Dinev, and Heng Xu. 2011. Information Privacy Research: An Interdiscipinary Review. MIS Quarterly 35 (4): 989–1015.
Solove, Daniel J. 2008. Data Mining and the Security-Liberty Debate. The University of Chicago Law Review 75: 343–62.
Stevens, Daniel, and Nick Vaughn-Williams. 2014. Citizens and Security Threats: Issues, Perceptions, and Consequences Beyond the National Frame. British Journal of Political Science. 46 (1): 149–75.
Strauβ, Stephan. 2017. A Game of Hide and Seek? Unscrambling the Tradeoff. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 255¬–72. London: Routledge.
Strickland, Lee S., and Laura E. Hunt. 2005. Technology, Security, and Individual Privacy: New Tools, New Threats, and New Public Perceptions. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 53 (3): 221–34.
Sunstein, Cass R. 2003. Terrorism and Probability Neglect. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 26 (2/3): 121–36.
van den Broek, Tijs, Merel Ooms, Michael Friedewals, Marc van Lieshouot, and Sven Rung. 2017. Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Desires for an Equal Footing. In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 15–35. London: Routledge.
Vermeersch, Hans, and Evelien De Pauw. 2017. The Acceptance of New Security Oriented Technologies: A “Framing Experiment.” In Surveillance Privacy and Security: Citizens’ Perspectives, edited by Michael Friedewald, Michael, J. Peter Burgess, Johann Cas, Rocco Bellanova, and Walter Peissl, 52–70. London: Routledge.
Witte, Kim. 1992. Putting the Fear Back into Fear Appeals: The Extended Parallel Process Model. Communication Monographs 59 (4): 329–49.
Witte, Kim, and Mike Allen. 2000. A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns. Health Education and Behavior 27 (5): 591–615.
Zaller, John R. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.