Abstract
The accidental spilling of cryogenic liquid leads to formation of a spreading pool, which may result in pool fires, BLEVE(boiled liquid evaporate vapor explosion) or vapor cloud fire, such as liquefied natural gas, is flammable. The key aspect of evaluating the consequence of such a disaster is to predict vaporization rate of the spreading cryogenic liquid pool. In this study, an empirical function was established to predict the temperature gradient of concrete. Afterwards an improved 1-D heat conduction equation was established to predict heat conduction of the spreading cryogenic liquid, and then vaporization rate was measured. In addition, to validate accuracy of the improved 1-D heat conduction equation, small-scale experiments were conducted to calculate vaporization rate for a spreading cryogenic liquid pool. The resulting vaporization rate decreased with discharge time, and increased with spill rate. The established empirical function was used to predict the temperature gradient displayed satisfactory accuracy with absolute average relative errors (AAREs) less than 10%; the improved 1-D heat transfer model AAREs were less than 13% compared with the experimental value. In summary, the improved 1-D heat transfer model can be applied to predict vaporization rate if the spill rate and discharge time are confirmed.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- r :
-
pool radius, m
- u :
-
radial liquid velocity at the edge, m/s
- q s :
-
spill rate, kg/s
- \( {M}_s^{mass} \) :
-
weight of the released liquid , kg
- Δt :
-
discharge time, s
- t st :
-
starting time, s
- t end :
-
end time, s
- ρ :
-
liquid density, kg/m3
- H :
-
depth of the pool, m
- h c,∞ :
-
minimum depth of the pool, m
- α i :
-
molecular weight liquid, kg/mol
- p i :
-
vapor pressure above the pool, N/m2
- u * :
-
atmospheric friction velocity above the pool, m/s;
- n :
-
wind profile index
- m m,V :
-
mole fraction of vapor above liquid pool surface, mol/mol;
- v :
-
kinematic viscosity , m2/s;
- D :
-
diffusion coefficient, m2/s.
- T :
-
temperature
- t :
-
time, s
- q :
-
heat flux, W/m2
- A :
-
pool area, m2
- L C :
-
characteristic length, m
- λ :
-
thermal conductivity, W/(K·m)
- C p :
-
specific heat capacity of air, J/(kg·K)
- η :
-
dynamic viscosity, Pa·s
- L :
-
latent heat of vaporization, J/kg
- a :
-
thermal diffusivity, m2/s
- u w,10 :
-
wind speed at 10 m height, m/s
- g :
-
Acceleration of gravity, 9.8m/s2
- E :
-
vaporization rate, kg/(m2·s)
- L :
-
Liquid phase
- a :
-
Ambient
- v :
-
Vapor phase
- b :
-
Boiling point
- w :
-
Concrete ground
- t :
-
Turbulence flow
- L :
-
Laminar flow
- Nu :
-
Nusselt number
- Re :
-
Reynolds number
- Sc :
-
Schmidt number
- Pr :
-
Prandtl number
References
Thyer AM (2003) A review of data on spreading and vaporisation of cryogenic liquid spills. J Hazard Mater 99(1):31–40
Gopalaswami N, Kakosimos K, Zhang B, Liu Y, Mentzer R, Mannan MS (2017) Experimental and numerical study of liquefied natural gas (LNG) pool spreading and vaporization on water. J Hazard Mater 334:244–255
Drake EM, Reid RC (1975) How LNG boils on soils. Hydrocarb Process 54(5):191–194
Reid RC, Wang R (1978) The boiling rates of LNG on typical dike floor materials. Cryogenics 18(7):401–404
Gopalaswami N, Véchot L, Olewski T, Mannan MS (2015) Small-scale experimental study of vaporization flux of liquid nitrogen released on ice. J Loss Prev Process Ind 37:124–131
Luketa-Hanlin A (2006) A review of large-scale LNG spills: experiments and modeling. J Hazard Mater 132(2–3):119–140
Webber DM, Grant SE, Ivings MJ, Jagger SF (2010) LNG source term models for hazard analysis. Health and Safty Laboratory for the Health and Safety Executive, Buxton: 1st edn, 2010
Takeno K, Ichinose T, Hyodo Y, Nakamura H (1994) Evaporation rates of liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen spilled onto the ground. J Loss Prev Process Ind 7(5):425–431
Olewski T, Mannan MS, Véchot L (2013) Validation of liquid nitrogen vaporisation rate by small scale experiments and analysis of the conductive heat flux from the concrete. J Loss Prev Process Ind 35:277–282
Verfondern K, Dienhart B (2007) Pool spreading and vaporization of liquid hydrogen. Int J Hydrog Energy 32(13):2106–2117
Basha O, Olewski T, Véchot L, Castier M, Mannan MS (2014) Modeling of pool spreading of LNG on land. J Loss Prev Process Ind 30:307–314
Kim M, Nguyen D, Choi B (2016) Experimental study of the evaporation of spreading liquid nitrogen. J Loss Prev Process Ind 39:68–73
Nguyen LD, Kim M, Choi B (2017) An experimental investigation of the evaporation of cryogenic-liquid-pool spreading on concrete ground. Appl Therm Eng 123:196–204
Nguyen LD, Kim M, Choi B, Chung K (2019) Validation of numerical models for cryogenic-liquid pool spreading and vaporization on solid ground. J Heat Mass Transf 128:817–824
Nguyen LD, Kim M, Choi B, Chung K, Do K, Kim T (2020) An evaluation of vaporization models for a cryogenic liquid spreading on a solid ground. J Heat Mass Transf 146:1188–1148
van den Bosch CJH, Wetweings RAPM (2005). Methods for the calculation of physical effects (TNO Yellow Book CPR 14E), 348–361
Gopalaswam N, Mentzer RA, Mannan MS (2015) Investigation of pool spreading and vaporization behavior in medium-scale LNG tests. J Loss Prev Process Ind 35:267–276
Webber DM (2012) On models of spreading pools. J Loss Prev Process Ind 25(6):923–926
ABS Consulting Inc (2004) Consequence assessment methods for incidents involving releases from liquefied natural gas carriers. ABS Consulting Risk Consulting Inc., Houston
Poling EB, Prausnitz MJ, O’Connell PJ (2006) The properties of gases and liquids, fifth edn. McGraw-Hill Education Co.
Jaeger JC, Carslaw HS (1959) Conduction of heat in solids. Oxford University Press
Folland GB (2011) Introduction to partial differential equations, second edn. Princeton University Press
Fleischer MT (1980) Spills: an evaporation/air dispersion model for chemical spills on land. Shell Development Company, Houston
Design Institute for Physical Property Data (U.S.) (2005) DIPPR project 801. Evaluated Standard Thermophysical Property Values, Full Version
Véchot L, Olewski T, Osorio C, Basha O, Liu Y, Mannan MS (2013) Laboratory scale analysis of the influence of different heat transfer mechanisms on liquid nitrogen vaporization rate. J Loss Prev Process Ind 26(3):398–409
Acknowledgements
This paper was supported by a Nanchong Technology Bureau Project Award under grant number 18SXHZ0021 and the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant number 51474184.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dong, J., Jing, C., Wen, H. et al. Predicting the vaporization rate of a spreading cryogenic liquid pool on concrete using an improved 1-D heat conduction equation. Heat Mass Transfer (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00231-021-03018-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00231-021-03018-9