A system dynamics model to analyze future electricity supply and demand in Iran under alternative pricing policies
Introduction
As an infrastructure industry, electricity has a fundamental impact on sustainable development and the comprehensive growth of any region (Qudrat-ullah, 2014). Policy-makers generally justify granting subsidies to ensure the poor's access to electricity, and see it as a way to achieve social and distributional objectives (Komives et al., 2007).
In, 2017, the value of fuel subsidies was estimated at more than $ 300 billion, with Iran, China and Saudi Arabia having the most energy subsidies, respectively. Additionally, Table 1 indicates the top ten countries in the allocation of subsidies to the electricity sector (International Energy Agency (IEA), 2017). However, by distorting price signals, energy subsidies can increase energy consumption and reduce the incentive to save energy. For instance, the former Soviet Union, where electricity prices were much lower than their costs, faced high per capita consumption and low energy efficiency (Sterner, 2007). Energy subsidies also hurt the environment, decrease motive to invest in the energy sector, and they are not an effective way to support low-income groups (Coady et al., 2016). These issues make the economic and environmental sustainability of electricity generation worse (Akber et al., 2017). Therefore, countries with this structure may be involved with problems such as the gap between supply and demand and high emissions of greenhouse gases in the coming years.
Many countries prepare to diminish or eliminate subsidies to address these problems. However, energy subsidies are among the most pervasive and controversial financial policy tools due to their impacts on many sectors (Elkatiri and Fattouh, 2017). Considering the importance of the electricity industry and the effect of subsidized prices on electricity supply and demand, environment and system sustainability in general, models helping to better understand the interactions among the subsystems seem necessary for energy planners. Accordingly, a system dynamics approach is used in this paper to analyze the future behavior of a regulated electricity system and examine different pricing policies. The electricity system is challenging to model due to the complexity of feedback processes among the modules and its interactions with the economy and the environment (Qudrat-ullah and Seong, 2010). According to energy researchers, system dynamics is a suitable tool to model the dynamics and feedback structure of energy policy system (Ansari and Seifi, 2012). Many have used the system dynamics method for energy system planning and the development of models in various types of energy, including oil and natural gas (NG) (Hosseini and Shakouri, 2016; Pan et al., 2017; Kiani and Pourfakhraei, 2010), renewable energy (Tang and Rehme, 2017), environmental emissions (Liu et al., 2015; Saysel and Hekimoğlu, 2013), a specific industry (Chen et al., 2014) and electricity (Xiao et al., 2016; Wang et al., 2019).
Among the system dynamics models for energy systems, some of them are designed to analyze supply and demand and related policy interventions in deregulated power systems. Ochoa and Van Ackere (2009) considered the important dynamics of capacity expansion in the Swiss electricity market and the impact of different policies such as nuclear withdrawal and management of electricity exchanges. Simulation results indicated that international electricity exchanges are needed to meet demand, maintain low electricity costs and generate revenue for electricity companies. Olsina et al. (2006), Assili et al. (2008), De Vries and Heijnen (2008), and Kadoya et al. (2005) have also applied the system dynamics to model the dynamics of investment in the power industry, emphasizing the cyclic behavior. Using system dynamics, Verhoog et al. (2018) investigated the impact of low European electricity prices on electricity supply and demand sectors in Switzerland. They concluded that the current low electricity prices, which are mainly due to overinvestment in generation capacity, are likely to persist for another decade. Zapata et al. (2019) adopted a system dynamics method to simulate the effect of investment incentives in renewable and conventional energies on the supply and demand of Colombian electricity market. Their study showed that renewable complementarities help the security of supply at a lower cost than thermoelectricity plants, and that in the mid-term the system becomes much cleaner and more balanced.
The combination of system dynamics with other methods has also used to enrich the electricity supply and demand model. Pereira and Saraiva (2013) used a hybrid system dynamics and optimization model to simulate long-term behavior of electricity markets and the evolution of electricity price and demand. A feedback mechanism was defined between the individual expansion plans and the long-term dynamic model of the system. They applied a mixed-integer optimization as the input of the system dynamics model for updating the price and demand. A model based on system dynamics and dynamic systems was constructed by Morcillo et al. (2018) to simulate demand growth scenarios in the Colombian electricity market. Their study showed that Colombia is in dire need of new investment. Zhu et al. (2020) developed a system dynamics model of a tripartite evolutionary game to investigate the policy effects of the renewable portfolio standard. By simulating the strategic evolution of participants in the electricity market, they concluded that a stronger incentive is more effective than a heavier punishment.
A number of researchers have modeled generation expansion capacity under dynamic supply and demand conditions. These models assume a deregulated and fully competitive market. Qudrat-Ullah (2013) considered the issue of electricity generation capacity in Canada. According to the simulation results, he concluded that the current level of investment would not adequately meet the demand in the coming years. So, there is a need to increase investment which was simulated in another scenario. Qudrat-Ullah (2015) also investigated the impact of privatization and the investments made by independent producers in Pakistan's electricity sector. He proposed an alternative energy policy focused on indigenous resources to provide cheaper and cleaner electricity considering the problem of the severe gap between demand and supply and high greenhouse gas emissions from its current electricity generation. A comprehensive study of the system dynamics models about simulating the capacity expansion of the deregulated electricity markets was carried out by Teufel et al. (2013).
Additionally, among the generation capacity expansion models, some have also dealt with the issue of the capacity payment mechanism, which is used as an incentive to expand generation capacity. Hasani and Hosseini (2011) investigated the capacity investment in a decentralized market-based model, considering the complementary capacity mechanism. The long-term capacity investment decisions in the liberalized electricity market were evaluated, and investment decisions were fundamentally based on total revenues gained by investors. The system dynamics concepts were applied to model the structural characteristics of the electricity market, as the long-term behavior of firms and relationships among variables. Hasani-Marzooni and Hosseini (2013) suggested a complementary capacity mechanism with different payments for each region based on the reliability index to avoid shortages by comparing different payment schemes. The problem of the adequacy of electricity generation after liberalization reforms in a power system was investigated by Hary et al. (2016). They assessed the dynamic effects of capacity remuneration mechanisms for fewer shortages and lower generation costs. Ahmad et al. (2016) conducted a comprehensive overview of the application of the system dynamics in the electricity industry, which divided the models into six categories of policy assessment, generation capacity expansion, financial instruments, mixing-methods, demand-side management and micro-world.
In this study, a system dynamics model of the electricity industry is presented to analyze the supply and demand, the total subsidy allocated for electricity and gas consumption, as well as the amount of gas consumption in four subsystems. The model simulation is carried out using data from Iran's electricity industry under the policies of changing electricity and gas prices and various demand scenarios. The model examines the current policies as to whether or not they are suitable for the country's sustainable development. The distinctions between this study and the similar research are in the characteristics of the electricity industry's structure and the purpose of the study, both of which affect the problem modeling. The model is applicable to countries where the price of energy is not a function of supply and demand, unlike the way it is in a deregulated power industry. In such countries, pricing policies are determined by government strategies (Daneshzand et al., 2018).
Furthermore, governments allot subsidies to energy carriers to make them more affordable for consumers in this system. The modeled electricity industry also has a centralized and regulated structure in which competitive market rules do not necessarily work, and state-owned companies carry out the operational activities to supply electricity demand. To the best of our knowledge, none of the previous studies has modeled how the subsidized prices of electricity and power plants’ fuel affect electricity supply and demand in a centralized power industry. Moreover, another distinction of this study is the aim to model the effect of increasing electricity and gas prices on the amount of consumed gas and allocated subsidies. A suitable country case of the mentioned structure is Iran, where the government spends vast amounts every year to maintain low electricity prices, resulting in over-consumption, a dearth of investment, low power plant efficiency and severe air pollution.
Section snippets
Methodology
The proposed system dynamics model consists of four main subsystems, including demand, generation, capacity expansion, and subsidy, as well as the interactions among the subsystems in an integrated framework. Mathematical notations and nomenclatures are presented in Table 2.
Demand module
The internal electricity demand in Iran is formed of four broad sections of household, industrial, agricultural and commercial usage. A small portion is also allocated to street lighting. The internal demand, along with net demand associated with exports, constitutes the total electricity demand. Fig. (1) shows the variables and relationships used to estimate electricity demand in different sectors. Electricity demand in the various sectors increases with growth in the gross domestic product
Generation module
In the generation module, each technology comprises two stock variables to represent the aging process of installed capacity. These technologies include thermal and renewable power plants. The primary technologies used in Iran are thermal, consisting of three types of combined cycle, gas turbine, and steam turbines, which contains more than 85% of total electricity generation. Furthermore, the main renewable technology for electricity generation in Iran is hydropower with more than 98% of the
Capacity expansion module
The available funds for capacity generation are accumulated by the yearly revenues that stem from domestic and foreign electricity sales (Eq. (16)). However, the capital and operating expenditures on generation also reduce the available financial resources. Investment in capacity expansion occurs when it is predicted there will be a shortage to supply demand. The required capacity is determined by subtracting the current supply capacity from the forecasted electricity demand for the future
Subsidy module
Thermal power plants obtain subsidized natural gas from the government and sell electricity at a very low price. Thus, the generation of electricity is a disadvantage for the government that controls the entire network.
The natural gas consumption in power plants in a given year depends on the amount of electricity consumed in that year which is shown in Eq. (21). The price difference between the produced natural gas and the gas supplied to the power plants multiplied by the amount of natural
Model validation
In this section, the proposed model is validated using extracted data from Iran electricity industry to specify whether the model behavior is realistic and representative of the case study. Therefore, the real data is simulated by the proposed model using Vensim software, and then its results are compared with historical data from 2004 to 2016 in order to validate the model. The observed data of the primary variables, including household demand, forecast of electricity demand, total electricity
Demand scenarios and pricing policies
The 16th largest electricity generator in the world is Iran, and it ranks the second after Saudi Arabia in the Middle East. From the consumption point of view, it ranks eighteenth globally. Furthermore, in terms of energy and electricity subsidy allocations, Iran is the first and second in the world, respectively (Iran Ministry of Power, 2016).
The electricity price in Iran has been determined by the Ministry of Energy since 1967. The retail price is specified using an obligatory and imperative
Computational results and discussion
Under the first policy, demand will reach to 595,377, 484,826 and 790,547 million kilowatt-hours (kWh) under the base, low, and high demand scenarios, respectively, which is shown in Fig. (9). Due to low prices, demand is too high, and there is not enough income to provide sufficient financial resources for required capacity expansion. So, the problems lead to a gap between supply and demand in 2025. Consequently, more outages and crises will be inevitable after the year. The generated
Conclusion
An electricity supply and demand model has been presented for analyzing electricity demand and generation, allocated subsidies and gas consumption in various pricing policies under different demand scenarios using system dynamics. The model contains four subsystems of demand, generation, capacity expansion and subsidy.
The proposed model was simulated using data related to Iran. Due to the poor efficiency of power plants and low electricity prices, Iran's power sector is a losing industry.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
References (45)
- et al.
Application of system dynamics approach in electricity sector modelling: a review
Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev.
(2016) - et al.
Life cycle sustainability assessment of electricity generation in Pakistan: policy regime for a sustainable energy mix
Energy Pol.
(2017) - et al.
A system dynamics analysis of energy consumption and corrective policies in Iranian iron and steel industry
Energy
(2012) - et al.
A system dynamics model for analyzing energy consumption and CO2 emission in Iranian cement industry under various production and export scenarios
Energy Pol.
(2013) - et al.
An improved mechanism for capacity payment based on system dynamics modeling for investment planning in competitive electricity environment
Energy Pol.
(2008) - et al.
A bottom-up analysis of China's iron and steel industrial energy consumption and CO2 emissions
Appl. Energy
(2014) - et al.
How large are global fossil fuel subsidies?
World Dev.
(2017) - et al.
The impact of electricity market design upon investment under uncertainty: the effectiveness of capacity mechanisms
Util. Pol.
(2008) Electricity demand analysis and forecasting: a panel cointegration approach
Energy Econ.
(2013)- et al.
The electricity generation adequacy problem: assessing dynamic effects of capacity remuneration mechanisms
Energy Pol.
(2016)
Dynamic assessment of capacity investment in electricity market considering complementary capacity mechanisms
Energy
Dynamic analysis of various investment incentives and regional capacity assignment in Iranian electricity market
Energy Pol.
A study on the future of unconventional oil development under different oil price scenarios: a system dynamics approach
Energy Pol.
A system dynamic model for production and consumption policy in Iran oil and gas sector
Energy Pol.
How might China achieve its 2020 emissions target? A scenario analysis of energy consumption and CO2 emissions using the system dynamics model
J. Clean. Prod.
Simulation of demand growth scenarios in the Colombian electricity market: an integration of system dynamics and dynamic systems
Appl. Energy
Policy changes and the dynamics of capacity expansion in the Swiss electricity market
Energy Pol.
Modeling long-term dynamics of electricity markets
Energy Pol.
A system dynamic analysis of China's oil supply chain: over-capacity and energy security issues
Appl. Energy
A long term generation expansion planning model using system dynamics–Case study using data from the Portuguese/Spanish generation system
Elec. Power Syst. Res.
How to do structural validity of a system dynamics type simulation model: the case of an energy policy model
Energy Pol.
Understanding the dynamics of electricity generation capacity in Canada: a system dynamics approach
Energy
Cited by (17)
A game-theoretic approach for investigating the competition between energy producers under the energy resilience index: A case study of Iran
2023, Sustainable Cities and SocietyA system dynamics approach to study the long-term interaction of the natural gas market and electricity market comprising high penetration of renewable energy resources
2022, International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy SystemsCitation Excerpt :The authors of [3] measured the investment risk of wind units in a dynamic model and introduced a new incentive policy to reduce this risk. The behavior of electricity markets in several countries such as Colombia, Tanzania, China, and Iran was studied by dynamic models in [29–32], respectively. In [33], the effect of various factors on the long-term production and demand of the UK natural gas system was analyzed through a dynamic model and the effectiveness of policies that help the UK to shift from a self-sufficient country in gas production into the gas importer country in the long term was investigated.
A dynamic and integrated approach of safety investment decision-making for power grid enterprises
2022, Process Safety and Environmental ProtectionCitation Excerpt :Some scholars have applied the SD to study the productivity and long-term investment costs of electric power under different policy measures (Esmaieli and Ahmadian, 2018; Hasani-Marzooni and Hosseini, 2011; Ibanez-Lopezand and Moratilla-Soria, 2017; Nabavi et al., 2017). In addition, some studies are devoted to the sustainable development of energy and the impact of different policies on the balance of supply and demand in the electricity market (Dehghan et al., 2021; Qudrat-Ullah, 2013; Riva and Colombo, 2020; Sheikhi et al., 2014; Wang et al., 2021). Despite the existence of economic models that can support the general decision-making process, most of the researches paid attention to the impact of government policies.
Long-term electricity consumption forecasting method based on system dynamics under the carbon-neutral target
2022, EnergyCitation Excerpt :The cross-correlation models mainly contain two types of models, i.e., deterministic models and uncertainty prediction models. In more detail, the former one includes econometric models [14], system dynamics models [15], and multiple regression models [16]. And both gray models [17] and fuzzy models [18] belong to the latter one.
Bidding strategy of energy storage in imperfectly competitive flexible ramping market via system dynamics method
2022, International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy SystemsCitation Excerpt :The SD method has also been employed in the field of power industry. The policies for future electricity system development are evaluated in [22], [23] and [24] for California, Tanzania and Iran, respectively. Issues such as electricity generation transitioning to renewable energy sources, rural electrification and ensuring sustainable electricity supply are formulated by corresponding SD models.