Abstract
Trans medicine has historically naturalized a heterosexual binary model of gender by treating variation as aberrant. Gender dysphoria, the current psychiatric diagnosis that often facilitates trans medicine, is represented by mental health experts and LGBTQ groups as a superficial semantic shift in this tradition. Based on in-depth interviews with experts who crafted gender dysphoria for the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-5) in 2013 and archival study of the experts’ research process, I find far more than semantics at stake. Because experts had an imperative for evidence-based revisions to the DSM-5 and an underdetermined research based on gender identity development, their revision affirms gender variation as natural and non-pathological. Gender dysphoria is maintained as a mental disorder because experts insist on its importance for the institutional legitimation of trans people, not because gender variation is understood to be pathological. This move toward treating gender variation as a flexible spectrum of illness and wellness required a new scientific interpretation of evidence. This interpretation (1) finds underdetermined research to be credible evidence of natural variation and (2) applies this variation simultaneously to traits (like gender) and also to health status. Consequently, natural variation becomes a scientific finding.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
“Trans” is how I refer to a broad group or community of people with non-normative gender identities and experiences. I use the term “gender-variant” to more accurately reflect the clinical language of experts when discussing the subjects of their work.
“Gender dysphoria” is introduced here in quotes to indicate that I am referring to the psychiatric diagnosis which may or may not be the actual experience of dysphoria that many trans people have. In this article, gender dysphoria will refer to the diagnosis rather than the experience unless specified otherwise and will not appear in quotes.
References
American Psychiatric Association. 1980. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, 3rd ed. Washington: American Psychiatric Association.
American Psychiatric Association. 2000. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, 4th ed. Washington: American Psychiatric Association.
American Psychiatric Association. 2013. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, 5th ed. Washington: American Psychiatric Association.
Bayer, R. 1981. Homosexuality and American Psychiatry: The politics of diagnosis. New York: Basic Books.
Berg, M., and S. Timmermans. 2003. The gold standard: The challenge of evidence-based medicine. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Bryant, K. 2006. Making gender identity disorder of childhood: Historical lessons for contemporary debates. Sexuality Research & Social Policy 3 (3): 23–39.
Cambrosio, A., P. Keating, T. Schlich, and G. Weisz. 2006. Regulatory objectivity and the generation and management of evidence in medicine. Social Science and Medicine 63 (1): 189–199.
Clarke, A., J. Shim, L. Mamo, J. Fosket, and J. Fishman. 2003. Biomedicalization: Technoscientific transformations of health, illness, and U.S. biomedicine. American Sociological Review 68 (2): 161–194.
Cohen-Kettenis, P., and F. Pfäfflin. 2010. The DSM diagnostic criteria for gender identity disorder in adolescents and adults. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39 (2): 499–513.
Conrad, P. 1992. Medicalization and social control. Annual Review of Sociology 18: 209–232.
Daley, A., and N. Mulé. 2009. LGBTQs and the DSM-5: A critical queer response. Journal of Homosexuality 61 (9): 1288–1312.
Davis, G. 2015. Contesting Intersex: The Dubious Diagnosis. New York: New York University Press.
Dean, M. 2010. Power at the heart of the present: Exception, risk, and sovereignty. European Journal of Cultural Studies 13 (4): 459–475.
Decoteau, C.L. 2013. Exclusionary inclusion and the normalization of biomedical culture. JAmerican Journal of Cultural Sociology 1 (3): 403–430.
Deogracias, J., L. Johnson, H. Meyer-Bahlburg, S. Kessler, J. Schober, and K. Zucker. 2007. The gender identity/gender dysphoria questionnaire for adolescents and adults. Journal of Sex Research 44 (4): 370–379.
Diamond, L., and M. Butterworth. 2008. Questioning gender and sexual identity: Dynamic links over time. Sex Roles 59: 365–376.
Drescher, J. 2010. Queer diagnoses: Parallels and contrasts in the history of homosexuality, gender variance, and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39 (2): 427–460.
Drescher, J., and W. Byne. 2012. Gender dysphoric/gender variant (GD/GV) children and adolescents: Summarizing what we know and what we have yet to learn. Journal of Homosexuality 59 (3): 501–510.
Eder, S. 1950s. The volatility of sex: Intersexuality, gender, and clinical practice in the 1950s. Gender & History 22 (3): 692–707.
Epstein, S. 1995. The construction of lay expertise: AIDS activism and the forging of credibility in the reform of clinical trials. Science, Technology, & Human Values 20 (4): 408–437.
Eyal, G. 2013. For a sociology of expertise: The social origins of the autism epidemic. American Journal of Sociology 118 (4): 863–907.
Fausto-Sterling, A. 2000. Sexing the body: Gender politics and the construction of sexuality. New York: Basic Books.
Frances, A. 2014. Saving normal: an insider’s revolt against out-of-control psychiatric diagnosis, DSM-5, big pharma, and the medicalization of ordinary life. New York: HarperCollins.
Foucault, M. 1978. History of sexuality: An introduction, vol. 1. New York: Vintage Books.
Gill-Peterson, J. 2014. The technical capacities of the body: Assembling race, technology, and transgender. Transgender Studies Quarterly 1 (3): 402–418.
Greenberg, G. 2013. The book of Woe: The DSM and the unmaking of psychiatry. New York: Plume.
Grossman, J., and F.J. MacKenzie. 2005. The randomized clinical trial: Gold standard, or merely standard? Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 48 (4): 516–534.
Haraway, D. 2016 [1991]. A cyborg manifesto: science, technology, and socialist feminism in the late twentieth century. In: Manifestly haraway, ed. Wolfe, C, 5–90. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Hennessy, E. 2018. The politics of a natural laboratory: Claiming territory and governing life in the Galápagos Islands. Social Studies of Science 48 (4): 483–506.
Heyes, C., and J.R. Latham. 2018. Trans surgeries and cosmetic surgeries: The politics of analogy. Transgender Studies Quarterly 5 (2): 174–189.
Horwitz, A. 2002. Creating mental illness. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Howard Brown Health. 2019. Revised THInC protocol. https://howardbrown.org/programs-services/transgender-health/revised-thinc-protocol/. Accessed 23 March 2019.
Igoe, J., K. Neves, and D. Brockington. 2010. A spectacular eco-tour around the historic bloc: Theorising the convergence of biodiversity conservation and capitalist expansion. Antipode 42 (3): 486–512.
Johnson, A.H. 2019. Rejecting, reframing, and reintroducing: Trans people’s strategic engagement with the medicalisation of gender dysphoria. Sociology of Health & Illness 41 (3): 517–532.
Knaapen, L. 2013. Being ‘evidence-based’ in the absence of evidence: The management of non evidence in guideline development. Social Studies of Science 43 (5): 681–706.
Lane, C. 2007. Shyness: How normal behavior became a sickness. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Lane, R. 2009. Trans as bodily becoming: Rethinking biology as diversity, not dichotomy. Hypatia 24 (3): 136–157.
Lev, A.I. 2013. Gender dysphoria: Two steps forward, one step back. Clinical Social Work 41: 288–296.
Meyer-Bahlburg, H. 2010. From mental disorder to iatrogenic hypoganodism: Dilemmas in conceptualizing gender identity variants as psychiatric conditions. Archives of Sexual Behavior 39 (2): 461–476.
Meyerowitz, J. 2002. How sex changed: A history of transsexuality in the united States. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Money, J., and J.G. Brennan. 1970. Homosexual vs. homosexual attitudes: Male partners’ perception of the feminine image of male transsexuals. Journal of Sex Research 6: 193–209.
Money, J., and P. Tucker. 1975. Sexual signatures: On being a man or a woman. Boston: Little, Brown.
Moreira, T. 2007. Entangled evidence: Knowledge making in systematic reviews in healthcare. Sociology of Heath & Illness 29 (2): 180–197.
Nguyen, V. 2009. The republic of therapy: Triage and sovereignty in West Africa’s time of AIDS. Durham: Duke University Press.
Norton, A.T. 2013. Surveying risk subjects: Public health surveys as instruments of biomedicalization. BioSocieties 8 (3): 265–288.
Petryna, A. 2004. Biological citizenship: The science and governance of Chernobyl-exposed populations. Osiris 2 (19): 250–265.
Pickersgill, M. 2011. ‘Promising’ therapies: Neuroscience, clinical practice, and the treatment of psychopathy. Sociology of Health & Illness 33 (3): 448–464.
Pitts-Taylor, V. 2016. Brain’s body: Neuroscience and corporeal politics. Durham: Duke University Press.
Pitts-Taylor, V. 2019. Neurobiologically poor? Brain phenotypes, inequality, and biosocial determinism. Science, Technology, & Human Values 44 (4): 660–685.
Plemons, E. 2014. Descriptions of sex difference as prescription for sex change: On the origins of facial feminization surgery. Social Studies of Science 44 (5): 657–679.
Plemons, E. 2017. The look of a woman: Facial feminization surgery and the aims of trans-medicine. Durham: Duke University Press.
Preciado, P.B. 2013. Testo junkie: Sex, drugs, and biopolitics in the pharmacopornographic era. New York: The Feminist Press.
Rose, N. 2007. The politics of life itself: Biomedicine, power, and subjectivity in the twenty first century. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Singh, D., J. Deogracias, L. Johnson, S. Brandley, S. Kibblewhite, A. Owen-Anderson, M. Peterson-Badali, H. Meyer-Bahlburg, and K. Zucker. 2010. The Gender identity/gender dysphoria questionnaire for adolescents and adults: Further validity evidence. Journal of Sex Research 47 (1): 49–58.
Spade, D. 2011. Normal life: Administrative violence, critical trans politics, and the limits of law. Brooklyn: South End Press.
Steensma, T., R. Biemond, F. de Boer, and P. Cohen-Kettenis. 2010. Desisting and persisting gender dysphoria after childhood: A qualitative follow-up study. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry 16 (4): 499–516.
Stone, S. 2007. The empire strikes back: a posttranssexual manifesto. In Transgender studies reader, ed. S. Stryker and S. Whittle, 221–235. New York: Routledge.
Sullivan, N. 2015. Reorienting transsexualism: from brain organization theory to phenomenology. In Fuckology: Critical essays on John money’s diagnostic concepts, ed. L. Downing, I. Morland, and N. Sullivan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sweet, P.L., and C.L. Decoteau. 2018. Contesting normal: The DSM-5 and psychiatric subjectivation. BioSocieties 13 (1): 103–122.
Thornton, J., J. Zher, and M. Loose. 2009. Effects of prenatal androgens on rhesus monkeys: A model system to explore the organizational hypothesis in primates. Hormones and Behavior 55 (5): 633–644.
Timmermans, S. 2011. The joy of science: Finding success in a “failed” randomized clinical trial. Science, Technology, & Human Values 36 (4): 549–572.
Vance, S., P. Cohen-Kettenis, J. Drescher, H. Meyer-Bahlburg, F. Pfäfflin, and K. Zucker. 2010. Opinions about the DSM gender identity disorder diagnosis: Results from an international survey administered to organizations concerned with the welfare of transgender people. International Journal of Transgenderism 12 (1): 1–14.
Whooley, O. 2016. Measuring mental disorders: The failed commensuration project of the DSM-5. Social Science & Medicine 166: 33–40.
Zucker, K., and R. Duchinsky. 2015. Dilemmas encountered by the sexual and gender identity disorders workgroup for DSM-5: An interview with Kenneth J. Zucker. Psychology & Sexuality 7 (1): 23–33.
Zucker, K., and R. Spitzer. 2005. Was the gender identity disorder of childhood diagnosis introduced in DSM-III as a backdoor maneuver to replace homosexuality? A historical note. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy 31 (1): 31–42.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author is not aware of any conflict of interest—intellectual or financial.
Ethical approval
This manuscript is the product of original research by the author, from a protocol approved by the Institutional Review Board at University of Illinois at Chicago (#2017-0537). This manuscript is not currently under review at any other publication.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Garrett, C.L. Finding natural variation: assembling underdetermined evidence of gender dysphoria, doing trans therapeutics. BioSocieties 17, 28–52 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41292-020-00201-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41292-020-00201-9