Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T05:30:59.275Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Retirement plan wealth inequality: measurement and trends

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  31 March 2020

Teresa Ghilarducci ,
Siavash Radpour  and
Anthony Webb Open the ORCID record for Anthony Webb [Opens in a new window]
Teresa Ghilarducci
Affiliation:
Economics, New school, New York, USA
Siavash Radpour
Affiliation:
Economics, The New School, New York, USA
Anthony Webb*
Affiliation:
Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis, New School University, New York, USA
*
*Corresponding author. Email: tonywebb10014@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Using Health and Retirement Study data linked to summary plan descriptions and W-2s, this study reports trends in retirement wealth inequality of older employees 1992–2010. The study identifies and corrects methodological flaws in past research. Retirement wealth is highly unequally distributed; the top lifetime earnings quintile holds half of all retirement wealth, the bottom quintile, only 1%. The top earnings quintile fared better in 2010 than in 1992, whereas bottom-quintile earners fared worse. But retirement wealth inequality mainly reflects inequality within earnings quintiles, resulting from inadequate savings, not outsize accumulations. Systemic flaws reduce median retirement wealth by 84%

Keywords

Inequalityretirement wealth

JEL classification

D14: Household Saving • Personal Finance J32: Nonwage Labor Costs and Benefits • Retirement Plans • Private Pensions D15: Intertemporal Household Choice • Life Cycle Models and Saving H55: Social Security and Public Pensions
Type
Article
Information
Journal of Pension Economics & Finance , Volume 21 , Issue 1 , January 2022 , pp. 119 - 139
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Agnew, J, Balduzzi, P and Sunden, A (2003) Portfolio choice and trading in a large 401(K) plan. American Economic Review 93, 193–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brady, PJ (2010) Measuring retirement resource adequacy. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance 9, 235–262, April.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brady, PJ (2017) Who participates in retirement plans. ICI Research Perspective 23. Available at http://www.ici.org/pdf/per23-05.pdf.Google Scholar
Cannon, E and Tonks, I (2004) U.K. annuity rates, money's worth and pension replacement ratios 1957–2002. Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance: Issues and Practice 29, 371–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chan, S and Stevens, A-H (2004) What you don't know can't help you: pension knowledge and retirement decision making. The Review of Economics and Statistics 90, 253–266.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, RL, Maki, JA and Morrill, MS (2014) Can simple informational nudges increase employee participation in a 401(k) plan? Southern Economic Journal 80, 677–701.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cunningham, CR and Engelhardt, GV (2002) Federal tax policy, employer matching, and 401(k) saving: evidence from HRS W-2 records. National Tax Journal 45, 617–645.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cunningham, CR, Engelhardt, GV and Kumar, A (2007) Measuring pension wealth. In Madrian, B, Mitchell, OS and Soldo, BJ (eds), Redefining Retirement: How Will Boomers Fare? Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, pp. 211–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Devlin-Foltz, S, Henriques, AM and Sabelhaus, J (2015 a) Is the U.S. retirement system contributing to rising wealth inequality? Unpublished Working Paper.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Devlin-Foltz, S, Henriques, AM and Sabelhaus, J (2015 b) The evolution of retirement wealth. Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2015–9. U.S. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dushi, I and Honig, M (2010) Participation and contributions in tax-deferred retirement accounts: evidence from social security records. Michigan Retirement Research Center WP 2009–219.Google Scholar
Dushi, I and Honig, M (2015) How much do respondents in the health and retirement study know about their contributions to tax-deferred contribution plans? A cross-cohort comparison. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance 14, 203–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dushi, I and Iams, HM (2015) The impact of employment and earnings shocks on contribution behavior in defined contribution plans: 2005–2009. The Journal of Retirement 2, 86–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dushi, I, Iams, HM and Lichtenstein, J (2011) Assessment of retirement plan coverage by firm size, using W-2 tax records. Social Security Bulletin 71, 53–65.Google Scholar
Engen, EM and Gale, WG (1997) Debt, taxes, and the effects of 401(k) plans on household wealth accumulation. Mimeo. Brookings.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fang, C, Brown, C and Weir, D (2016) Cohort changes in social security benefits and pension wealth. Michigan Retirement Research Center WP2016–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fidelity (2018) How much do i need to retire? Available at https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/retirement/how-much-do-i-need-to-retire.Google Scholar
Friedberg, L and Webb, A (2005) Retirement and the evolution of pension structure. Journal of Human Resources 40, 281–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghilarducci, T and James, H (2018) Rescuing Retirement: A Plan to Guarantee Retirement Security for All Americans. New York: Columbia University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghilarducci, T, Papadopoulos, M and Webb, A (2017) Inadequate retirement savings for workers nearing retirement. Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis Policy Note.Google Scholar
Ghilarducci, T, Papadopoulos, M, Sun, W and Webb, A (2018 a) Catch-up contributions: an equitable and affordable solution to the retirement savings crisis. Public Policy and Aging Report 28, S4–S14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghilarducci, T, Saad-Lessler, J and Reznik, GL (2018 b) Earnings volatility and 401(k) contributions. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance 17, 554–575.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghilarducci, T, Radpour, S and Webb, A (2019) Household economic shocks increase retirement wealth inequality. Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis and Department of Economics, The New School for Social Research, Policy Note Series.Google Scholar
Gustman, AL and Steinmeier, TL (2004) What people don't know about their pension and social security: an analysis using linked data from the health and retirement study. In Gale, WG, Shoven, JB and Warshawsky, MJ (eds), Private Pensions and Public Policies. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, pp. 57–119.Google Scholar
Gustman, AL, Steinmeier, TL and Tabatabai, N (2007) Imperfect knowledge of pension plan type. NBER WP 13379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gustman, AL, Steinmeier, TL and Tabatabai, N (2010) Pensions in the Health and Retirement Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Gustman, AL, Steinmeier, TL and Tabatabai, N (2014) Researcher contribution: part III: pension wealth variables 1992–2010. Health and Retirement Study.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ibbotson Associates (2018) Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation: 2018 Yearbook. Chicago, IL: Morningstar.Google Scholar
Karamcheva, NS and Sanzenbacher, GT (2010) Is pension inequality growing? Issue in brief 10-1. Chestnut Hill, MA: Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.Google Scholar
Kolodrubetz, WW and Landry, DM (1973) Coverage and vesting of full-time employees under private retirement plans. Social Security Bulletin 36, 20–36.Google Scholar
Laibson, D (1997) Golden eggs and hyperbolic discounting. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112, 443–477.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lusardi, A and Mitchell, OS (2013) The economic importance of financial literacy: theory and evidenc.e. NBER WP 18952.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lusardi, A, Michaud, P-C and Mitchell, OS (2017) Optimal financial knowledge and wealth inequality. Journal of Political Economy 125, 431–477.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mitchell, OS and Moore, JF (1997) Projected retirement wealth and savings adequacy in the Health and Retirement Study. NBER WP 6240.Google Scholar
Munnell, AH and Bleckman, D (2014) Is pension coverage a problem in the private sector? Center for Retirement Research at Boston College Issue Brief 14-7.Google Scholar
Munnell, AH and Webb, A (2015) The impact of leakages from 401(k)s and IRAs. Center for Retirement Research at Boston College WP, 2015–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Munnell, AH, Orlova, N and Webb, A (2013) How important is asset allocation to financial security in retirement? In Mitchell, OS and Kent, S (eds), The Market for Retirement Financial Advice. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press, pp. 89–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Munnell, AH, Sanzenbacher, GT and Rutledge, MS (2015) What causes workers to retire before they plan? Center for Retirement Research at Boston College WP 2015-22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Munnell, AH, Hou, W and Sanzenbacher, G (2016 a) National retirement risk shows modest improvement in 2016. Center for Retirement Research at Boston College Issue Brief 18-1.Google Scholar
Munnell, AH, Hou, W, Webb, A and Li, Y (2016 b) Pension participation, wealth, and income: 1992–2010. Center for Retirement Research at Boston College WP 2016-3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Olivera, J (2019) The distribution of pension wealth in Europe. The Journal of the Economics of Ageing 13, 30–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Poterba, J, Rauh, J, Venti, S and Wise, D (2006) Defined Contribution Plans, Defined Benefit Plans, and the Accumulation of Retirement Wealth. NBER WP 12597.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Poterba, J, Venti, S and Wise, DA (2007) The rise of 401(k) plans, lifetime earnings, and wealth at retirement. NBER WP 13091.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rohwedder, S (2003) Measuring pension wealth in the HRS: employer and self-reports. Unpublished Manuscript. Santa Monica, CA. RAND Corporation.Google Scholar
Saad-Lessler, J, Ghilarducci, T and Resnik, GL (2018) Retirement savings inequality: different effects of earnings shocks, portfolio selections, and employer contributions by worker earnings level. Social Security Bulletin 78, 1–18.Google Scholar
Scholz, JK, Seshadri, A and Khitatrakun, S (2006) Are Americans saving ‘optimally’ for retirement? Journal of Political Economy 114, 607–643.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skinner, J (2007) Are you sure you're saving enough for retirement? Journal of Economic Perspectives 21, 59–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tang, N, Mitchell, OS, Mottola, GR and Utkus, SP (2010) The efficiency of sponsor and participant portfolio choices in 401(k) plans. Journal of Public Economics 94, 1073–1085.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
United States Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2012) 401(k) Plans: Increased Educational Outreach Broader Oversight May Reduce Plan Fees. GAO-12-325. Washington, DC: GPO.Google Scholar
United States Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2014) Individual Retirement Accounts: IRS Could Bolster Enforcement of Multimillion Dollar Accounts, but More Direction From Congress is Needed. GAO-15-16. Washington, DC: GPO.Google Scholar
United States Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2016) 401(k) Plans: Effects of Eligibility and Vesting Policies on Workers’ Retirement Savings. GAO-17-69. Washington, DC: GPO.Google Scholar
VanDerhei, J, Holden, S, Copeland, C and Alonso, L (2012) 401(k) plan asset allocation, account balances, and loan activity in 2011. EBRI Issue Brief 380, Washington, DC: Employee Benefit Research Institute.Google Scholar
VanDerhei, J, Holden, S, Alonso, L and Bass, S (2018) 401(k) plan asset allocation, account balances, and loan activity in 2016. EBRI Issue Brief 458, Washington, DC: Employee Benefit Research Institute.Google Scholar
Vanguard (2014) How America saves 2014: a report on Vanguard 2013 defined contribution plan data. Valley Forge, PA.Google Scholar
Venti, SF (2011) Economic measurement in the health and retirement study. Forum for Health Economics & Policy 14, 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Venti, SF and Wise, DA (1998) The cause of wealth dispersion at retirement: choice or chance? The American Economic Review 88, 185–191.Google Scholar
Venti, SF and Wise, DA (2004) Aging and housing equity – another look. In Wise, DA (ed.), Perspectives on the Economics of Aging. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 121–180.Google Scholar
Wolff, E (2015) U.S. Pensions in the 2000s: the Lost Decade? Review of Income and Wealth 61, 599–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wu, A and Rutledge, MS (2014) Lower income individuals without pensions: who misses out and why? Center for Retirement Research WP 2014-2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar