Hostname: page-component-6b989bf9dc-jks4b Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-15T01:15:45.090Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Interpreters of International Economic Law: Corporations and Bureaucrats in Contest over Chile's Nutrition Label

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Tim Dorlach Open the ORCID record for Tim Dorlach [Opens in a new window]  and
Paul Mertenskötter
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article analyzes the everyday interpretive practices of corporations and bureaucrats that shape the meaning and force of international economic law. To understand how common practices such as public consultation submissions, corporate threat letters, and external legal assistance influence regulators' understanding of their “legally available” policy space, we study the contested introduction of a pioneering nutrition labeling regulation in Chile. The transnational food industry powerfully challenged the regulation's legality under World Trade Organization law. But Chilean health bureaucrats, in coordination with segments of the country's legally highly competent economic bureaucracy, effectively defended the legality of their proposed regulatory measure. Drawing on data from freedom-of-information requests and in-depth interviews, the article argues that the outcomes of such interpretive contests are substantially shaped by participants' knowledge of the entitlements created by international economic law and thus by the international legal expertise they have access to. This often but not always puts transnational corporations at an advantage over national regulators in the strategic interpretation of international economic law.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 54 , Issue 3 , September 2020 , pp. 571 - 606
Copyright
© 2020 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

For comments that helped improve this article we thank Umut Aydin, Hannes Hemker, Alexandra Jones, Nicolas Lamp, Lauro Locks, Aldo Madariaga, Antoine Maillet, Inu Manak, Isık Özel, Lorena Rodríguez, Richard B. Stewart, Thomas Streinz, Christel Tham, Umut Türem, Robert Wade, Erik Wijkström, Oya Yeğen, as well as the reviewers and editors of the Law & Society Review.

References

Abbott, Kenneth W. and Snidal, Duncan. 2000. “Hard and Soft Law in International Governance.” International Organization 54: 421–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abdelal, Rawi, Blyth, Mark, and Parsons, Craig, eds. 2010. Constructing the International Economy. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Alter, Karen and Meunier, Sophie. 2009. “The Politics of International Regime Complexity.” Perspectives on Politics 7: 13–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amsden, Alice H. and Hikino, Takashi. 2000. “The Bark Is Worse than the Bite: New WTO Law and Late Industrialization.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 570: 104–14.Google Scholar
Ares, Gastón, Isabel, Bove, Rodrigo, Díaz, Ximena, Moratorio, Wilson, Benia Fabio, Gomes. 2020. “Argumentos de la industria alimentaria en contra del etiquetado frontal de advertencias nutricionales en Uruguay.” Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 44: e20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ares, Gastón, Varela, Fiorella, Machin, Leandro, Antúnez, Lucía, Giménez, Ana, Curutchet, María Rosa, and Aschemann-Witzel, Jessica. 2018. “Comparative Performance of Three Interpretative Front-of-Pack Nutrition Labelling Schemes: Insights for Policy Making.” Food Quality and Preference 68: 215–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bartley, Tim. 2018. “Transnational Corporations and Global Governance.” Annual Rev. of Sociology 44: 145–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biblioteca del Congreso Nacional. 2011 “Historia de la Ley N° 20.606 Sobre Composición Nutricional de los Alimentos y su Publicidad.” https://perma.cc/VB4H-HAGJ (accessed 14 February, 2020).Google Scholar
Black, Julia. 1997. Rules and Regulators. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black, Julia. 2002. “Regulatory Conversations.” J. of Law & Society 29: 163–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Block-Lieb, Susan. 2019. “Soft and Hard Strategies: The Role of Business in the Crafting of International Commercial Law.” Michigan J. of International Law 40: 433–77.Google Scholar
Boza, Sofía, Polanco, Rodrigo, and Espinoza, Macarena. 2019. “Nutritional Regulation and International Trade in APEC Economies: The New Chilean Food Labeling Law.” Asian J. of WTO & International Health Law and Policy 14: 73–113.Google Scholar
Bril-Mascarenhas, Tomás and Madariaga, Aldo. 2019. “Business Power and the Minimal State: The Defeat of Industrial Policy in Chile.” J. of Development Studies 55: 1047–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Busch, Marc, Reinhardt, Eric, and Shaffer, Gregory. 2009. “Does Legal Capacity Matter? A Survey of WTO Members.” World Trade Review 8: 559–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buzard, Kristy, and Voon, Tania. 2019. “How Trade-Restrictive is Standardised Packaging? Economic and Legal Implications of the WTO Panel Reports in Australia—Tobacco Plain Packaging.” EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2019/72, https://perma.cc/HD59-5RKH (accessed 13 February, 2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Büthe, Tim and Harris, Nathaniel. 2011. “Codex Alimentarius Commission.” In The Handbook of Transnational Governance: Institutions and Innovations, edited by Hale, T. and Held, D. Cambridge, MA: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Carpenter, Daniel. 2001. The Forging of Bureaucratic Autonomy: Reputations, Networks, and Policy Innovation in Executive Agencies, 1862–928. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Carpenter, Daniel. 2013. “Detecting and Measuring Capture.” In Preventing Regulatory Capture: Special Interest Influence and How to Limit It, edited by Carpenter, D. and Moss, D. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carr, E. Summerson. 2010. “Enactments of Expertise.” Annual Rev. of Anthropology 39: 17–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Conti, Joseph. 2010. “Learning to Dispute: Repeat Participation, Expertise, and Reputation at the World Trade Organization.” Law & Social Inquiry 35: 625–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Corvalán, Camila, Reyes, Marcela, Garmendia, María Luisa, and Uauy, Ricardo. 2013. “Structural Responses to the Obesity and Non-Communicable Diseases Epidemic: The Chilean Law of Food Labeling and Advertising.” Obesity Rev. 14: 79–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Creamer, Cosette D. 2019. “From the WTO's Crown Jewel to its Crown of Thorns.” American J. of International Law Unbound 113: 51–5.Google Scholar
Crosbie, Eric, Sosa, Particia, and Glantz, Stanton A. 2018. “Defending Strong Tobacco Packaging and Labelling Regulations in Uruguay: Transnational Tobacco Control Network Versus Philip Morris International.” Tobacco Control 27: 185–94.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Crosbie, Eric and Glantz, Stanton A. 2014. “Tobacco Industry Argues Domestic Trademark Laws and International Treaties Preclude Cigarette Health Warning Labels, Despite Consistent Legal Advice that the Argument Is Invalid.” Tobacco Control 23: 1–21.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Crosbie, Eric and Thomson, George. 2018. “Regulatory Chills: Tobacco Industry Legal Threats and the Politics of Tobacco Standardised Packaging in New Zealand.” New Zealand Medical J. (Online) 131: 25–41.Google ScholarPubMed
Curran, Louise and Eckhardt, Jappe. 2017. “Smoke Screen? The Globalization of Production, Transnational Lobbying and the International Political Economy of Plain Tobacco Packaging.” Rev. of International Political Economy 24: 87–118.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Davison, Mark and Emerton, Patrick. 2014. “Rights, Privileges, Legitimate Interests, and Justifiability: Article 20 of TRIPS and Plain Packaging of Tobacco.” American University International Law Rev. 29: 505–80.Google Scholar
Dezalay, Yves and Garth, Bryant G. 1996. Dealing in Virtue: International Commercial Arbitration and the Construction of a Transnational Legal Order. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Dezalay, Yves and Madsen, Mikael Rask. 2012. “The Force of Law and Lawyers: Pierre Bourdieu and the Reflexive Sociology of Law.” Annual Rev. of Law and Social Science 8: 433–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dorlach, Tim. 2019. “El etiquetado frontal de los alimentos bajo las normas de la OMC: un corsé falso,” Nexos, 6 December, https://perma.cc/ED6E-TGQH (accessed 05 February, 2020).Google Scholar
Drahos, Peter. 2010. The Global Governance of Knowledge: Patent Offices and their Clients. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Durkee, Melissa J. 2017. “Astroturf Activism.” Stanford Law Rev. 69: 201–68.Google Scholar
Egnell, Manon, Talati, Zenobia, Hercberg, Serge, Pettigrew, Simone, and Julia, Chantal. 2018. “Objective Understanding of Front-of-Package Nutrition Labels: An International Comparative Experimental Study across 12 Countries.” Nutrients 10: 1542–57.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Erlanger, Howard S., Chambliss, Elizabeth, and Melli, Marygold S. 1987. “Participation and Flexibility in Informal Processes: Cautions from the Divorce Context.” Law & Society Rev. 21: 585–604.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, Peter. 1995. Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ewick, Patricia and Silbey, Susan S. 1998. The Common Place of the Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fairfield, Tasha. 2015. Private Wealth and Public Revenue. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Farrell, Henry and Newman, Abraham L. 2014. “Domestic Institutions beyond the Nation-State: Charting the New Interdependence Approach.” World Politics 66: 331–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, Jodi and Rossi, Jim. 2012. “Agency Coordination in Shared Regulatory Space.” Harvard Law Rev. 125: 1131–211.Google Scholar
Fuchs, Doris A. 2007. Business Power in Global Governance. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galanter, Marc. 1974. “Why the Haves Come out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change.” Law & Society Rev. 9: 95–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallagher, Kevin P., ed.. 2005. Putting Development First: The Importance of Policy Space in the WTO and IFIs. London, UK: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Global Health Advocacy Incubator. 2019. “GHAI Equips Partners with Tools at Legal Workshop.” 15 July 2019, https://perma.cc/R3SS-3992 (accessed 19 August, 2019).Google Scholar
Gottwald, Eric. 2007. “Leveling the Playing Field: Is it Time for a Legal Assistance Center for Developing Nations in Investment Treaty Arbitration.” American University International Law Rev. 22: 237–75.Google Scholar
Greenhalgh, Susan. 2019. “Soda Industry Influence on Obesity Science and Policy in China.” J. of Public Health Policy 40: 5–16.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hart, H. L. A. 1961. The Concept of Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Howse, Robert. 2000. “Democracy, Science, and Free Trade: Risk Regulation on Trial at the World Trade Organization.” Michigan Law Rev. 98: 2329–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howse, Robert. 2012. “Regulatory Measures.” In The Oxford Handbook on the World Trade Organization, edited by Narlikar, A., Daunton, M., and Stern, R. M. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Howse, Robert. 2016. “The World Trade Organization 20 Years On: Global Governance by Judiciary.” European J. of International Law 27: 9–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacobs, Alan M. 2014. “Process Tracing the Effects of Ideas.” In Process Tracing: From Metaphor to Analytic Tool, edited by Bennett, A. and Checkel, J. T. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Jacobs, Andrew. 2018. “In Sweeping War on Obesity, Chile Slays Tony the Tiger.” New York Times, 7 February, https://perma.cc/T4NC-7L6E (accessed 05 March, 2019).Google Scholar
Jones, Alexandra, Neal, Bruce, Reeve, Belinda, Ni Mhurchu, Cliona, and Thow, Anne Marie. 2019. “Front-of-Pack Nutrition Labelling to Promote Healthier Diets: Current Practice and Opportunities to Strengthen Regulation Worldwide.” BMJ Global Health 4: e001882.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kapczynski, Amy. 2009. “Harmonization and its Discontents: A Case Study of TRIPS Implementation in India's Pharmaceutical Sector.” California Law Rev. 97: 1571–650.Google Scholar
Lamp, Nicolas. 2018. “The ‘Practice Turn’ in International Law: Insights from the Theory of Structuration.” In Research Handbook on the Sociology of International Law, edited by Hirsch, M. and Lang, A. London, UK: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
Lang, Andrew and Scott, Joanne. 2009. “The Hidden World of WTO Governance.” European J. of International Law 20: 575–614.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Donna and Hocking, Brian. 2011. “Economic Diplomacy.” In The International Studies Encyclopedia, Vol. II, edited by Denemark, R. London, UK: Wiley Blackwell.Google Scholar
Marcus, George E. 1995. “Ethnography in/of the World System: The Emergence of Multi-Sited Ethnography.” Annual Rev. of Anthropology 24: 95–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mediano Stoltze, Fernanda, Reyes, Marcela, Smith, Taillie Lindsey, Correa, Teresa, Corvalán, Camila, and Carpentier, Francesca R. Dillman. 2019. “Prevalence of Child-Directed Marketing on Breakfast Cereal Packages before and after Chile's Food Marketing Law: A Pre- and Post-Quantitative Content Analysis.” International J. of Environmental Research and Public Health 16: 4501.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merry, Sally. 2006a. “Transnational Human Rights and Local Activism: Mapping the Middle.” American Anthropologist 108: 38–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merry, Sally. 2006b. “New Legal Realism and the Ethnography of Transnational Law.” Law & Social Inquiry 31: 975–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mertenskötter, Paul and Stewart, Richard B. 2018. “Remote Control: Treaty Requirements for Regulatory Procedures.” Cornell Law Rev. 104: 165–232.Google Scholar
Moehlecke, Carolina. 2020. “The Chilling Effect of International Investment Disputes: Limited Challenges to State Sovereignty.” International Studies Quarterly 64: 1–12.Google Scholar
Moravcsik, Andrew. 2014. “Transparency: The Revolution in Qualitative Research.” PS: Political Science & Politics 47: 48–53.Google Scholar
Mnookin, Robert H. and Kornhauser, Lewis. 1979. “Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case of Divorce.” The Yale Law J. 88: 950–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nader, Laura. 1984. “A User Theory of Law.” Southwestern Law J. 38: 951–63.Google Scholar
Nishida, Chizuru, Uauy, Ricardo, Kumanyika, Shiriki, and Shetty, Prakash. 2004. “The Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation on Diet, Nutrition, and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases: Process, Product, and Policy Implications.” Public Health Nutrition 7: 245–50.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Provost, René. 2015. “Interpretation in International Law as a Transcultural Project.” In Interpretation in International Law, edited by Bianchi, A., Peat, D., and Windsor, M. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Quack, Sigrid. 2013. “Regime Complexity and Expertise in Transnational Governance: Strategizing in the Face of Regulatory Uncertainty.” Oñati Socio-Legal Series 3: 647–78.Google Scholar
Quark, Amy. 2016. “Ratcheting up Protective Regulations in the Shadow of the WTO: NGO Strategy and Food Safety Standard-Setting in India.” Rev. of International Political Economy 23: 872–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ralston, Johanna. 2018. “Chile's ‘Radical’ Approach to Addressing Obesity” [Letter to the editor]. New York Times, February 21, https://perma.cc/W73Z-XFHM (accessed 24 September, 2019).Google Scholar
Reyes, Marcela, Garmendia, María Luisa, Olivares, Sonia, Aqueveque, Claudio, Zacarías, Isabel, and Corvalán, Camila. 2019. “Development of the Chilean Front-of-Package Food Warning Label.” BMC Public Health 19: 906.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rodríguez, Pilar. 2014. “La Guerra Entre Salud y el Área Económica del Gabinete por el Etiquetado de los Alimentos.” CIPER, https://perma.cc/Y8C5-WBUV (accessed 24 September, 2019).Google Scholar
Santos, Alvaro. 2012. “Carving Out Policy Autonomy for Developing Countries in the World Trade Organization: The Experience of Brazil & Mexico.” Vanderbilt J. of International Law 52: 551–632.Google Scholar
Scrinis, Gyorgy and Parker, Christine. 2016. “Front-of-Pack Food Labeling and the Politics of Nutritional Nudges.” Law & Policy 38: 234–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sell, Susan. 2003. Private Power, Public Law: The Globalization of Intellectual Property Rights. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaffer, Gregory. 2003. Defending Interests: Public-Private Partnerships in WTO Litigation. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.Google Scholar
Shaffer, Gregory, Sanchez, Michelle R., and Rosenberg, Barbara. 2008. “The Trials of Winning at the WTO: What Lies behind Brazil's Success.” Cornell International Law J. 41: 383–501.Google Scholar
Shaffer, Gregory. 2015a. “How the WTO Shapes Regulatory Governance.” Regulation & Governance 9: 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaffer, Gregory. 2015b. “The New Legal Realist Approach to International Law.” Leiden J. of International Law 28: 189–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaffer, Gregory, Elsig, Manfred, and Puig, Sergio. 2017. “The Law and Politics of WTO Dispute Settlement.” In Research Handbook on the Politics of International Law, edited by Sandholtz, W. and Whytock, C. London: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
Sherman, Richard and Eliasson, Johan. 2006. “Trade Disputes and Non-State Actors: New Institutional Arrangements and the Privatisation of Commercial Diplomacy.” The World Economy 29: 473–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Slaughter, Anne-Marie. 2002. “Breaking out: The Proliferation of Actors in the International System.” In Global Prescriptions: The Production and Exportation of a New State Orthodoxy, edited by Dezalay, Y. and Garth, B. G. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Steele, Sarah, Ruskin, Gary, Sarcevic, Lejla, McKee, Martin, and Stuckler, David. 2019. “Are Industry-Funded Charities Promoting “Advocacy-Led Studies” or “Evidence-Based Science” ? A Case Study of the International Life Sciences Institute.” Globalization and Health 15: 36–44.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Taillie, Lindsey Smith, Reyes, Marcela, Colchero, M. Arantxa, Popkin, Barry, and Corvalán, Camila. 2020. “An Evaluation of Chile's Law of Food Labeling and Advertising on Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Purchases from 2015 to 2017: A before-and-after Study.” PLoS Medicine 17: e1003015. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1003015.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Tapia, María José. 2014. “Grandes empresas salen de Chilealimentos y crean gremio para defender la industria.” El Mercurio, 29 April, https://perma.cc/U68A-VNWH (accessed 10 February, 2020).Google Scholar
Tavernise, Sabrina. 2013. “Tobacco Firms' Strategy Limits Poorer Nations' Smoking Laws.” The New York Times, December 13, https://perma.cc/4X7X-WEQS (accessed 24 September, 2019).Google Scholar
Thow, Anne Marie, Jones, Alexandra, Schneider, Carmen Huckel, and Labonté, Ronald. 2019. “Global Governance of Front-of-Pack Nutrition Labelling: A Qualitative Analysis.” Nutrients 11: 268–81.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Thow, Anne-Marie and McGrady, Benn. 2013. “Protecting Policy Space for Public Health Nutrition in an Era of International Investment Agreements.” Bulletin of the World Health Organization 92: 139–45.Google Scholar
Tienhaara, Kyla. 2018. “Regulatory Chill in a Warming World: The Threat to Climate Policy Posed by Investor-State Dispute Settlement.” Transnational Environmental Law 7: 229–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trachtman, Joel P. 2006. “The Constitutions of the WTO.” European J. of International Law 17: 623–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tulli, Eugenia. 2018. “La Tensión Entre Propiedad Intelectual y el Derecho a la Salud y a la Información en el Etiquetado Frontal de Alimentos.” Tesis de Maestría. FLACSO. Sede Académica Argentina, Buenos Aires, https://perma.cc/EBB9-URTV (accessed 30 August, 2019).Google Scholar
United Nations. 2012. “Political Declaration of the High-level Meeting of the General Assembly on the Prevention and Control of Non-communicable Diseases.” https://perma.cc/SUW3-WP4Q (accessed 03 March, 2019).Google Scholar
USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). 2013. “Chile's Food Processing Sector.” GAIN Report No. CI1318, https://perma.cc/7B3U-XBEC (accessed 10 February, 2020).Google Scholar
Veggeland, Frode and Borgen, Svein Ole. 2005. “Negotiating International Food Standards: The World Trade Organization's Impact on the Codex Alimentarius Commission.” Governance 18: 675–708.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wagner, Wendy E. 2010. “Administrative Law, Filter Failure, and Information Capture.” Duke Law J. 59: 1321–432.Google Scholar
Waibel, Michael. 2015. “Interpretive Communities in International Law.” In Interpretation in International Law, edited by Bianchi, A., Peat, D., and Windsor, M. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
WHO and FAO. 2003. “Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases: Report of the Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation.” WHO Technical Report Series, No. 916 (TRS 916), https://perma.cc/6C4Y-DFNU (accessed 24 September, 2019).Google Scholar
WHO. 2018. “NCD Mortality and Morbidity.” https://perma.cc/4YUW-H5XK (accesssed 24 September, 2019).Google Scholar
WTO. 2006. “Fourth Triennial Review of the Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade—Good Regulatory Practice and Transparency—Communication from Chile.” G/TBT/W/268, https://perma.cc/42ZC-YSP5 (accessed 16 February, 2020).Google Scholar
Yackee, Jason W. and Yackee, Susan W. 2006. “A Bias Towards Business? Assessing Interest Group Influence on the US Bureaucracy.” J. of Politics 68: 128–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Dorlach and Mertenskötter supplementary material
Download undefined(File)
File 331.4 KB