Abstract
1993 Nobel laureates Robert Fogel and Douglass North were pioneers in the “new” economic history, or cliometrics. Their impact on the economic history discipline is great, though not without its critics. In this essay, we use both the “old” narrative form of economic history, and the “new” cliometric form to analyze the impact each had on the evolution of economic history.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
A selection of the papers presented in these early meetings was published by Purdue University in 1967.
The Cliometric Society was formally organized in 1983 by Sam Williamson and Deirdre (nee Donald) McCloskey.
The first use of the term in print: “the logical structure necessary to make historical reconstructions from the surviving debris of past economic life essentially involves ideas of history, economics and statistics… has been labeled “Cliometrics.” (Davis et al. 1960, p. 540).
Temin (2016).
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences Press Release, 12 October 1993, Nobelprize.org, http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/1993/press.html.
Williamson and Whaples (2003, p. 446).
Perhaps more than anyone, D.N. McCloskey has been responsible for holding all economists, not just economic historians, accountable for moving the frontiers of knowledge forward and not simply using the latest techniques to measure something because it can be measured. For example, see McCloskey (1978, 1985, 1987, 2006).
The EHA founded in 1940 by “old” economic historians Anne Bezanson, Arthur Cole, Edwin Gay, Harold Innis and Earl Hamilton.
Engerman et al. (1994, p. 25).
Engerman et al. (1994, p. 29).
Engerman et al. (1994, p. xi).
Lyons et al. (2008, p. 334).
Lyons et al. (2008, p. 335).
Engerman et al. (1994, p. 71).
North (1965, pp. 86–87).
Engerman et al. (1994, p. 73).
Davis (2000).
Throughout this work we use citations as a measure of influence.
Such as the American Economic Review, Journal of Political Economy, and Journal of Economic Literature.
For a visual of the impact of the JEH piece, see Fig 2.
Fogel (1964a, p. 234).
Davis (2000).
Davis (2000).
Davis (2000).
Whaples (1995, p. 143).
Meyer (1966, p. 87).
Riegel (1965, p. 636).
Saul (1966, p. 66).
Madden (1965, p. 612).
Whitney (1966, p. 276).
Davis (2000).
Rothstein (1965, p. 131).
Meyer (1966, p. 88).
Gould (1966, p. 474).
Williamson (1965, p. 110).
Williamson (1965, p. 111).
Hilton (1966, p. 237).
Goodstein (1965, p. 91).
Scheiber (1966, p. 278).
Kirkland (1967, p. 1494).
Erickson (1966, p. 107).
Erickson (1966, p. 109).
Hacker (1966, p. 175).
Kirkland (1967, pp. 1493–1494).
Erickson (1966, p. 107).
Mitchell (1965, p. 603).
Engerman et al. (1994, p. 61).
1963 Board of Trustees members included Hugh Aitken, Rondo Cameron, Shepard Clough, Thomas Cochran, Ralph Hidy, JRT Hughes, EAJ Johnson, Herman Krooss, Frederic Lane, Theodore Marburg, William Parker, Wayne Rasmussen, Fritz Redlich, George Rogers Taylor, Martin Wolfe.
EHA archives, folders 18–27, BoT meeting minutes, Sept 4, 1963, Club Room of the Carolina Inn at Chapel Hill NC.
Lyons et al. (2008).
EHA archives, letter from North to William Parker dated Feb 11, 1966.
EHA archives, letter from Davis to Hal Williamson dated March 7, 1966.
EHA archives, Letter from Hal Williamson to Herman Krooss dated Feb 14, 1966.
EHA archives, letter from Hidy to Hal Williamson dated Mar 3, 1966.
EHA archives, Letter Krooss to Williamson dated Mar 7, 1966.
Lyons et al. (2008, p. 201).
From 1941–1967 the Tasks issue was the December issue of the journal. In 1968 this was changed, and the fall meeting of 1968 was the focus of the March 1969 issue. The March issue continued to be the Tasks issue through 1983. From 1984–1996 it migrated to the June issue, and beginning in 1997 the journal dropped the formal connection between the meetings and the journal. From the 1996 EHA meetings onward, papers presented at the conference were accorded no special treatment regarding submission or publication in the JEH.
See Diebolt (2016).
See the seminal work of Darné and Diebolt (2004).
Fogel (1964a, p. 239).
Taylor (1965, p. 892).
References
Anonymous (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Ethics 75(3):217
Ashton TS (1946) The relation of economic history to economic theory. Economica 50(13):81–96
Basu K, Jones E, Schlicht E (1987) The growth and decay of custom: the role of the new institutional economics in economic history. Explor Econ Hist 24(1):1–21
Boldizzini F (2011) The poverty of Clio: resurrecting economic history. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Braudel F (1949) La méditerranée et le monde méditerranéen à l’époque de Philippe II. A. Colin, Paris
Brown EC (1956) Fiscal policy in the thirties: a reappraisal. Am Econ Rev 46(5):857–879
Cameron R (1965) Has economic history a role in an economist’s education? Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):112–115
Cochran TC (1969) Economic history, old and new. Am Hist Rev 74(5):1561–1572
Conrad A, Meyer J (1958) The economics of slavery in the antebellum South. J Polit Econ 66(April):95–123
Darné Olivier, Diebolt Claude (2004) Unit roots and infrequent large shocks: new international evidence on output. J Monet Econ 51(7):1449–1465
Darné O, Diebolt C (2005) Nonstationarity tests in macroeconomic time series. In: Diebolt C, Kyrtsou C, in collaboration with Darné O (eds) New trends in macroeconomics. Springer, Berlin, pp 173–194
Davis L (2000) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Project 2000, EH.net. http://eh.net/?s=railroads+and+american+economic+growth
Davis LE, Hughes JRT, Reiter S (1960) Aspects of quantitative research in economic history. J Econ Hist 20(4):539–547
Diebolt C (2012) The cliometric voice. Hist Econ Ideas 20(3):51–61
Diebolt C (2016) Cliometrica after 10 years: definition and principles of cliometric research. Cliometrica 10(1):1–4
Diebolt C, Haupert M (eds) (2016a) Handbook of Cliometrics. Springer, Berlin
Diebolt C, Haupert M (2016b) Clio’s contributions to economics and history. Rev Econ Politique 126(5):971–989
Domar ED, Gordon RA (1965) Discussion. Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):116–118
Easterlin RA (1965) Is there need for historical research on underdevelopment? Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):104–108
Economic History Association archives, Hagley Museum and Library, Wilmington, DE, Accession #1479, folders 1–11, 29–31
Engerman SL (1996) Cliometrics. In: Kuper A, Kuper J (eds) The social science encyclopedia, 2nd edn. Routledge, London, pp 96–98
Engerman SL, Hughes JRT, McCloskey DN, Sutch RC, Williamson SH (1994) Two pioneers of cliometrics. The Cliometric Society, Oxford
Erickson C (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Economica 33(129):106–109
Floud R (1991) Cliometrics. In: Eatwell J, Milgate M, Newman P (eds) The new Palgrave. A dictionary of economics. Bd. 1, 2. Aufl., London, pp 452–454
Fogel R (1962) A quantitative approach to the study of Railroads in American economic growth: a report of some preliminary findings. J Econ Hist 22(2):163–197
Fogel R (1964a) Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history. Johns Hopkins, Baltimore
Fogel R (1964b) A provisional view of the ‘New Economic History’. Am Econ Rev 54(May):377–389
Fogel R (1965) The reunification of economic history with economic theory. Am Econ Rev 55(May):86–91
Fogel RW (2000) The fourth great awakening and the future of egalitarianism. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Galiani S, Sened I (eds) (2014) Institutions, property rights, and economic growth: the legacy of Douglass North. Cambridge University Press, New York
Gallman RE (1965) The role of economic history in the education of the economist. Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):109–111
Goldin C (1995) Cliometrics and the Nobel. J Econ Perspect 9(2):191–208
Goodstein ME (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. South Econ J 32(1):90–91
Gould JD (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Econ Rec 2(99):475
Hacker L (1966) The new revolution in economic history: a review article based on railroads and economic growth: essays in economic history, by Robert William Fogel. Explor Entrep His Second Ser 3(2):159–175
Haupert M (2016) The history of cliometrics and its impact on economic history. In: Diebolt C, Haupert M (eds) The handbook of cliometrics. Springer, Berlin, pp 3–32
Hilton GW (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Explor Entrep His Second Ser 3(2):234–238
Kirkland E (1967) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Am Hist Rev 72(4):1493–1495
Lyons JS, Cain LP, Williamson SH (eds) (2008) Reflections on the cliometrics revolution: conversations with economic historians. Routledge, New York
Machlup F (1952) The political economy of monopoly: business, labor and government policies. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Madden JJ (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Can J Econ Polit Sci 31(4):611–612
McAfee RP (1983) American economic growth and the voyage of Columbus. Am Econ Rev 73(4):735–740
McClelland P (1968) Railroads, American Economic growth, and new economic history—critique. J Econ His 28(1):102–123
McCloskey D (1978) The achievements of the cliometric school. J Econ Hist 38(1):13–28
McCloskey DN (1985) The problem of audience in historical economics: rhetorical thoughts on a text by Robert Fogel. Hist Theory 24(1):1–22
McCloskey D (1987) Econometric history. Macmillan, London
McCloskey DN (1992) Robert William Fogel: an appreciation by an adopted student. In: Goldin C, Rockoff H (eds) Strategic factors in nineteenth century American economic history. A volume to honor Robert W. Fogel. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 14–25
McCloskey DN (2006) The bourgeois virtues: ethics for an age of commerce. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Menard C, Shirley MM (2014) The contribution of Douglass North to new institutional economics. In: Galiani S, Sened I (eds) Economic Institutions, Rights, Growth, and Sustainability: the legacy of Douglass North. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Menger C (1884) Die Irrthümer des Historismus in der deutschen Nationalökonomie. Alfred Hölder, Vienna
Meyer J (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. J Polit Econ 74(1):87–88
Meyer J, Conrad A (1957) Economic theory, statistical inference, and economic history. J Econ Hist 17(4):524–544
Mitchell BR (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. J R Stat Soc Ser A Gen 128(4):602–603
Nerlove M (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. J Econ Hist 26(1):107–115
North DC (1961) the economic growth of the United States 1790–1860. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
North DC (1963) Quantitative research in American economic history. Am Econ Rev (part 1) 53(1):128–130
North DC (1965) The state of economic history. Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):86–91
North DC (1966) Growth and welfare in the American past: a new economic history. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
North DC (1968) Sources of productivity change in ocean shipping, 1600–1850. J Polit Econ 76:953–970
North DC (1981) Structure and change in economic history. W. W. Norton & Co., New York
North DC (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge University Press, New York
Parker WN (ed) (1960) Trends in the American economy in the nineteenth century, studies in income and wealth. In: Conference on research in income and wealth, vol 24. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Parker WN (1980) The historiography of American economic history. In: Porter G (ed) Encyclopedia of American economic history: studies of the principal movements and ideas, vol 1. Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York, pp 3–16
Polanyi K (1944) The great transformation. Farrar & Rinehart, New York
Purdue Faculty Papers in Economic History. (1967) Herman CK Graduate School of Industrial Administration, Purdue University, Monograph Series, Richard D. Irwin, Inc., Homewood
Redlich F (1965) ‘New’ and traditional approaches to economic history and their independence. J Econ Hist 25(4):480–495
Riegel RE (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. J Am Hist 52(3):735–736
Rothstein M (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Bus His Rev 39(1):130–132
Saul SB (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Bus Hist 8(1):65–67
Scheiber HN (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Can Hist Rev 47(3):277–279
Supple B (1965) Has the early history of developed countries any current relevance? Am Econ Rev Papers Proc 55(2):99–103
Taylor GR (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Am Econ Rev 55(4):890–892
Temin P (2016) Economic history and economic development: new economic history in retrospect and prospect. In: Diebolt C, Haupert M (eds) Handbook of cliometrics. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 33–52
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences Press Release (1993) Nobelprize.org. http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/1993/press.html
Whaples R (1991) A quantitative history of the journal of economic history and the cliometric revolution. J Econ Hist 51(2):289–301
Whaples R (1995) Where is there consensus among American economic historians? The results of a survey on forty propositions. J Econ Hist 55(1):139–154
Whitney WG (1966) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. J Am Stat Assoc 61(313):275
Williamson JG (1965) Review of Railroads and American economic growth: essays in econometric history, by Robert William Fogel. Econ Dev Cult Change 14(1):109–113
Williamson JG (1974) Late nineteenth-century American development: a general equilibrium history. Cambridge University Press, London
Williamson SH (1991) The history of cliometrics. In: Mokyr J (ed) The vital one: essays in honor of Jonathan R. T. Hughes. JAI Press, Greenwich, pp 15–31 (REH, supplement 6)
Williamson SH (1994) The history of cliometrics. In: Engerman SL et al (eds) Two pioneers of cliometrics: Robert W. Fogel and Douglass C. North, Nobel Laureates of 1993. The Cliometric Society, Miami
Williamson SH, Whaples R (2003) Cliometrics. In: Mokyr J (ed) The Oxford encyclopedia of economic history, vol 1. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 446–447
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Diebolt, C., Haupert, M. A cliometric counterfactual: what if there had been neither Fogel nor North?. Cliometrica 12, 407–434 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-017-0167-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11698-017-0167-8