Abstract
Introduction
Mathematical and computational modeling have a long history of uncovering mechanisms and making predictions for biological systems. However, to create a model that can provide relevant quantitative predictions, models must first be calibrated by recapitulating existing biological datasets from that system. Current calibration approaches may not be appropriate for complex biological models because: 1) many attempt to recapitulate only a single aspect of the experimental data (such as a median trend) or 2) Bayesian techniques require specification of parameter priors and likelihoods to experimental data that cannot always be confidently assigned. A new calibration protocol is needed to calibrate complex models when current approaches fall short.
Methods
Herein, we develop CaliPro, an iterative, model-agnostic calibration protocol that utilizes parameter density estimation to refine parameter space and calibrate to temporal biological datasets. An important aspect of CaliPro is the user-defined pass set definition, which specifies how the model might successfully recapitulate experimental data. We define the appropriate settings to use CaliPro.
Results
We illustrate the usefulness of CaliPro through four examples including predator-prey, infectious disease transmission, and immune response models. We show that CaliPro works well for both deterministic, continuous model structures as well as stochastic, discrete models and illustrate that CaliPro can work across diverse calibration goals.
Conclusions
We present CaliPro, a new method for calibrating complex biological models to a range of experimental outcomes. In addition to expediting calibration, CaliPro may be useful in already calibrated parameter spaces to target and isolate specific model behavior for further analysis.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- ODE:
-
Ordinary differential equation
- LHS:
-
Latin hypercube sampling
- HDR:
-
Highest density region
- ADS:
-
Alternative density subtraction
- SIR:
-
Sample importance resampling
- TB:
-
Tuberculosis
References
Ades, A. E., et al. Bayesian methods for evidence synthesis in cost-effectiveness analysis. Pharmacoeconomics 24:1–19, 2006.
An, G. The crisis of reproducibility, the denominator problem and the scientific role of multi-scale modeling. Bull. Math. Biol. 80:3071–3080, 2018.
Azhar, N., and Y. Vodovotz. Innate immunity in disease: insights from mathematical modeling and analysis. Adv. Exp. Med. Biol. 844:227–243, 2014.
Beaumont, M. A., W. Zhang, and D. J. Balding. Approximate Bayesian computation in population genetics. Genetics 162:2025–2035, 2002.
Blum, C., and A. Roli. Metaheuristics in combinatorial optimization: overview and conceptual comparison. ACM Comput. Surv. 35:268–308, 2003.
Bohachevsky, I. O., M. E. Johnson, and M. L. Stein. Generalized simulated annealing for function optimization. Technometrics 28:209–217, 1986.
Bottou, L. Large-scale machine learning with stochastic gradient descent. Proceedings of COMPSTAT’2010, 2010, pp. 177–186.
Brännmark, C., et al. Insulin signaling in type 2 diabetes: experimental and modeling analyses reveal mechanisms of insulin resistance in human adipocytes. J. Biol. Chem. 288:9867–9880, 2013.
Brewka, G. Artificial Intelligence—A Modern Approach by Stuart Russell and Peter Norvig: Series in Artificial Intelligence. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1996.
Cadena, A. M., S. M. Fortune, and J. L. Flynn. Heterogeneity in tuberculosis. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 17:691–702, 2017.
Castiglione, F., F. Pappalardo, C. Bianca, G. Russo, and S. Motta. Modeling biology spanning different scales: an open challenge. Biomed. Res. Int. 2014. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/902545.
Cedersund, G., and P. Strålfors. Putting the pieces together in diabetes research: towards a hierarchical model of whole-body glucose homeostasis. Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 36:91–104, 2009.
Cilfone, N. A., C. R. Perry, D. E. Kirschner, and J. J. Linderman. Multi-scale modeling predicts a balance of tumor necrosis factor-α and interleukin-10 controls the granuloma environment during mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. PLoS ONE 2013. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0068680.
Cilfone, N. A., et al. Computational modeling predicts IL-10 control of lesion sterilization by balancing early host immunity-mediated antimicrobial responses with caseation during mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. J. Immunol. 194:664–677, 2015.
Cockrell, C., and G. An. Sepsis reconsidered: Identifying novel metrics for behavioral landscape characterization with a high-performance computing implementation of an agent-based model. J. Theor. Biol. 430:157–168, 2017.
Cornuet, J. M., J. M. Marin, A. Mira, and C. P. Robert. Adaptive multiple importance sampling. Scand. J. Stat. 39:798–812, 2012.
Cowles, M. K., and B. P. Carlin. Markov Chain Monte Carlo convergence diagnostics: a comparative review. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 91:883, 1996.
Deng, X., and Y. Nakamura. Cancer precision medicine: from cancer screening to drug selection and personalized immunotherapy. Trends Pharmacol. Sci. 38:15–24, 2017.
Eisenberg, M. C., and H. V. Jain. A confidence building exercise in data and identifiability: modeling cancer chemotherapy as a case study. J. Theor. Biol. 431:63–78, 2017.
Fallahi-Sichani, M., M. El-Kebir, S. Marino, D.E. Kirschner, and J.J. Linderman. Multiscale computational modeling reveals a critical role for TNF-receptor 1 dynamics in tuberculosis granuloma formation. J. Immunol. 186:3472–3483, 2011. Available from: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=3127549&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract.
Farah, M., P. Birrell, S. Conti, and D. De Angelis. Bayesian emulation and calibration of a dynamic epidemic model for A/H1N1 influenza. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 109:1398–1411, 2014.
Friedman, A. A., A. Letai, D. E. Fisher, and K. T. Flaherty. Precision medicine for cancer with next-generation functional diagnostics. Nat. Rev. Cancer. 15:747–756, 2015.
Gábor, A., and J. R. Banga. Robust and efficient parameter estimation in dynamic models of biological systems. BMC Syst. Biol. 9:74, 2015.
Guzzetta, G., and D. Kirschner. The roles of immune memory and aging in protective immunity and endogenous reactivation of tuberculosis. PLoS ONE 2013. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0060425.
Hogue, T. S., S. Sorooshian, H. Gupta, A. Holz, and D. Braatz. A multistep automatic calibration scheme for river forecasting models. J. Hydrometeorol. 1:524–542, 2000.
Holland, J.H. Adaptation in Natural and Artificial Systems: An Introductory Analysis with Applications to Biology, Control, and Artificial Intelligence. Ann Arbor: Univ. Michigan Press, 1975. Available from: http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/item/default.asp?ttype=2&tid=8929.
Hyndman, R. J. Computing and graphing highest density regions. Am. Stat. 50:120–126, 1996.
Kitano, H. Systems biology: a brief overview. Science 295:1662–1664, 2002.
Kuepfer, L., R. Kerb, and A. M. Henney. Clinical translation in the virtual liver network. CPT Pharmacometrics Syst. Pharmacol. 3:e127, 2014.
Lin, P. L., and J. L. Flynn. Understanding latent tuberculosis: a moving target. J. Immunol. 185:15–22, 2010.
Lin, P. L., et al. Quantitative comparison of active and latent tuberculosis in the cynomolgus macaque model. Infect. Immun. 77:4631–4642, 2009.
Lin, P. L., et al. Sterilization of granulomas is common in active and latent tuberculosis despite within-host variability in bacterial killing. Nat. Med. 20:75–79, 2014.
Lunn, D. J., A. Thomas, N. Best, and D. Spiegelhalter. WinBUGS—a Bayesian modelling framework: concepts, structure, and extensibility. Stat. Comput. 10:325–337, 2000.
Marino, S., I. B. Hogue, C. J. Ray, and D. E. Kirschner. A methodology for performing global uncertainty and sensitivity analysis in systems biology. J. Theor. Biol. 254:178–196, 2008.
Marino, S., J. J. Linderman, and D. E. Kirschner. A multifaceted approach to modeling the immune response in tuberculosis. Wiley Interdiscip. Rev. Syst. Biol. Med. 3:479–489, 2011.
Marino, S., and D. Kirschner. A multi-compartment hybrid computational model predicts key roles for dendritic cells in tuberculosis infection. Computation 4:39, 2016. Available from: http://www.mdpi.com/2079-3197/4/4/39.
Marino, S., et al. Computational and empirical studies predict mycobacterium tuberculosis-specific T cells as a biomarker for infection outcome. PLoS Comput. Biol. 2016. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004804.
Menzies, N. A., D. I. Soeteman, A. Pandya, and J. J. Kim. Bayesian methods for calibrating health policy models: a tutorial. Pharmacoeconomics 35:613–624, 2017.
Nyman, E., et al. A hierarchical whole-body modeling approach elucidates the link between in vitro insulin signaling and in vivo glucose homeostasis. J. Biol. Chem. 286:26028–26041, 2011.
Palsson, S., et al. The development of a fully-integrated immune response model (FIRM) simulator of the immune response through integration of multiple subset models. BMC Syst. Biol. 2013. https://doi.org/10.1186/1752-0509-7-95.
Pienaar, E., et al. Comparing efficacies of moxifloxacin, levofloxacin and gatifloxacin in tuberculosis granulomas using a multi-scale systems pharmacology approach. PLoS Comput. Biol. 13:e1005650, 2017.
Qu, Z., A. Garfinkel, J. N. Weiss, and M. Nivala. Multi-scale modeling in biology: how to bridge the gaps between scales? Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 107:21–31, 2011.
Raftery, A. E., and L. Bao. Estimating and projecting trends in HIV/AIDS generalized epidemics using incremental mixture importance sampling. Biometrics 66:1162–1173, 2010.
Rajaona, H., et al. An adaptive Bayesian inference algorithm to estimate the parameters of a hazardous atmospheric release. Atmos. Environ. 122:748–762, 2015.
Read, M. N., K. Alden, J. Timmis, and P. S. Andrews. Strategies for calibrating models of biology. Brief. Bioinform. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1093/bib/bby092.
Regev, A., et al. The human cell atlas. Elife 2017. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.27041.
Rikard, S. M., et al. Multiscale coupling of an agent-based model of tissue fibrosis and a logic-based model of intracellular signaling. Front. Physiol. 2019. https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2019.01481.
Rubin, D. B. Using the SIR algorithm to simulate posterior distributions. In: Bayesian Statistics, edited by J. M. Bernardo, D. V. Lindley, M. H. DeGroot, and A. F. M. Smith. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988, pp. 395–402.
Rutter, C. M., D. L. Miglioretti, and J. E. Savarino. Bayesian calibration of microsimulation models. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 104:1338–1350, 2009.
Santoni, D., M. Pedicini, and F. Castiglione. Implementation of a regulatory gene network to simulate the TH1/2 differentiation in an agent-based model of hypersensitivity reactions. Bioinformatics 24:1374–1380, 2008.
Schliess, F., et al. Integrated metabolic spatial-temporal model for the prediction of ammonia detoxification during liver damage and regeneration. Hepatology 60:2040–2051, 2014.
Schwen, L. O., et al. Representative sinusoids for hepatic four-scale pharmacokinetics simulations. PLoS ONE 2015. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0133653.
Segovia-Juarez, J. L., S. Ganguli, and D. Kirschner. Identifying control mechanisms of granuloma formation during M. tuberculosis infection using an agent-based model. J. Theor. Biol. 231:357–376, 2004.
Spinosa, P. C., et al. Short-term cellular memory tunes the signaling responses of the chemokine receptor CXCR4. Sci. Signal. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1126/scisignal.aaw4204.
Steele, R. J., A. E. Raftery, and M. J. Emond. Computing normalizing constants for finite mixture models via incremental mixture importance sampling (IMIS). J. Comput. Graph. Stat. 15:712–734, 2006.
Sud, D., C. Bigbee, J. L. Flynn, and D. E. Kirschner. Contribution of CD8+ T cells to control of mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. J. Immunol. 176:4296–4314, 2014.
Sunnåker, M., A. G. Busetto, E. Numminen, J. Corander, M. Foll, and C. Dessimoz. Approximate Bayesian computation. PLoS Comput. Biol. 2013. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002803.
Toro, M., and J. Aracil. Chaotic behavior in predator–prey–food system dynamics models. Proc. 1986 Int. Conf. Syst. Dyn. Soc. Syst. Dyn. Move., 1986, p. 353.
Wang, Q. J. The genetic algorithm and its application to calibrating conceptual rainfall-runoff models. Water Resour. Res. 27:2467–2471, 1991.
Warsinske, H. C., E. Pienaar, J. J. Linderman, J. T. Mattila, and D. E. Kirschner. Deletion of TGF-β1 increases bacterial clearance by cytotoxic t cells in a tuberculosis granuloma model. Front. Immunol. 2017. https://doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2017.01843.
Wessler, T., et al. A computational model tracks whole-lung Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection and predicts factors that inhibit dissemination. PLOS Comput. Biol. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1007280.
Whyte, S., C. Walsh, and J. Chilcott. Bayesian calibration of a natural history model with application to a population model for colorectal cancer. Med. Decis. Mak. 2011. https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989X10384738.
Wigginton, J. E., and D. Kirschner. A model to predict cell-mediated immune regulatory mechanisms during human infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis. J. Immunol. 166:1951–1967, 2001.
Wong, E. A., et al. Low levels of T cell exhaustion in tuberculous lung granulomas. Infect. Immun. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1128/IAI.00426-18.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by NIH Grants R01AI123093 (DEK) and U01 HL131072 awarded to DEK and JJL. Simulations also use resources of the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center, which is supported by the Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. ACI-1053575 and the Extreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment (XSEDE), which is supported by National Science Foundation Grant MCB140228
Conflict of interest
LRJ, DEK, and JJL declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Human Studies
No human studies were carried out by the authors for this article.
Animal Studies
No animal studies were carried out by the authors for this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Additional information
Associate Editor Michael R. King oversaw the review of this article.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Joslyn, L.R., Kirschner, D.E. & Linderman, J.J. CaliPro: A Calibration Protocol That Utilizes Parameter Density Estimation to Explore Parameter Space and Calibrate Complex Biological Models. Cel. Mol. Bioeng. 14, 31–47 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12195-020-00650-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12195-020-00650-z