The Thai Red Cross protocol experience in Côte d'Ivoire
Introduction
Every year, rabies accounts for more than 59,000 deaths worldwide. It poses a serious public health concern, namely in remote areas in Asia and Africa(WHO, 2018). However, rabies is preventable (Shim et al., 2009) with several Immunization protocols used by intramuscular or intradermal route (Hervé, 2013). Difficulty related to availability and cost of rabies vaccines sometimes complicate the PEP process (Hampson et al., 2011;Changalucha et al., 2018). In addition to these challenges, there is a lack of collaboration between veterinarian and medical services (Mindekem et al., 2017). In Côte d'Ivoire, there are 30 Anti-rabies centers for exposure‘s Immunization in 30 departments. These centers are under the administrative responsibilities of the National Institute of Public Hygiene (NIPH). In addition, there are 21 small anti-rabies units located in 21 other departments. The epidemiological rabies surveillance in Côte d'Ivoire revealed 10,197 exposures including 17 human deaths in 2015 and 11,481 exposures including 18 human deaths in 2016. In the same period, twenty one (21) human rabies cases have been confirmed by the national reference laboratory for rabies diagnosis (Tiembré, 2018). The exposed people were manage by using two World Health Organization (WHO) approved PEP (Essen and Zagreb). But the application of these anti-rabies protocols showed low compliance with 45–50% people lost to follow-up (non-completion), mainly related to the cost of rabies PEP vaccine (Table 1).
In 2016, Gavi Rabies Project "Impact of Rabies and Immunization in Central and West Africa" was initiated in two departments of Côte d'Ivoire (Bouaké and San pedro). Considering the difficulties linked to the Intra muscular protocols compliance in this country, it was agreed to experiment in 2017 a free rabies PEP vaccine based on the TRC that was administered by intradermal route. This study has a limitation linked to the use of two rabies vaccines stocks in anti-rabies centers: free vaccine for TRC and another stock of paid rabies vaccine which belonged to the national party (NIPH). Despite this limitation, the study remains relevant for several reasons: TRC protocol which was effectively implemented by ID route is a new PEP schedule which has never been used in Côte d'Ivoire, the selection of the people was based on voluntary consent, the results of this study will be determinant for a better orientation of the new ID vaccination as recommended by the WHO in the future. The reduction of cost to the free and the painlessness of the vaccination act related to the ID route could lead the exposed persons to follow the PEP until the end. The main objective of this study was to test the feasibility of a PEP using TRC protocol with free vaccines.
Section snippets
Study site and population
The study took place in two departments of Côte d'Ivoire: Bouaké and San pedro (Fig. 1) in 2017. The choice of theses departments was justified by the fact that Bouake records yearly the highest number of exposed people while San Pédro regularly reports rabies death (Tiembré et al., 2018).
These two study sites have respectively 680,700 and 631,200 inhabitants (RGPH, 2014). In the department of Bouaké, especially, the main part of the people resides in urban area and account for 80% of the
Summary of PEP following-up from 2016 to 2017
In 2016, the Bouaké and San Pedro anti-rabies centers have received 1,263 rabies exposures. Overall completion rate of the PEP was 37%, which means that 63% of exposed people did not complete their PEP protocol. This assessment was estimated at 42% of the PEP completion for patients who received the Zagreb protocol against 26% for the people vaccinated by the Essen protocol.
In 2017, the amount of exposed people raised up to 1,625 for the two study areas; 1,121 persons in Bouaké and 504 in San
Discussion
During the first year of the study, bite victims PEP, which were mainly based on the Essen and Zagreb protocols, revealed a high rate of exposed people who had not completed the PEP course, namely for the Essen protocol. That gap might certainly be linked to the long duration of the said protocol (28 days), its high number (5) of administered doses which lead excess cost. Coulibaly et al. (2017) had already recorded 54.4% patients who did not completed the PEP in Bouaké and 76% of them had
Conclusion
Essen and Zagreb protocols that have been used for PEP in Côte d'Ivoire for several years causing many non-completion cases. The introduction of free of charge PEP through the TRC protocol revealed wastage of doses in anti-rabies center that receiving very few bite victims. Nevertheless, this free protocol found the population adherence, successful with better PEP completion and reflecting safe protection against rabies. The few cases of PEP non completion were mainly related to negligence.
Author statement
ACTROP_2019_781_R2: Risk factors for rabies in Côte d'Ivoire
The co-authors of this article contributed as stated below
M= Minimal
I= Intermediate
E= ExtensiveActivity Author Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell Empty Cell mathilde
tetchim'begnan coulibaly vessaly
kallognamien
sylvain traorétiembre issaka benie joseph felix gerber jasmina saric monique lechenne jakob zinsstag bassirou bonfoh Organisation and planning e i i i m i M m i i m Data collection E E E I M M M M M MI M Data analysis E M M I M M M M M M M Article writing E E I M I I M I M E M Article revision E M M M M M M M M E E Quality control E E I M M M M M M M M
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Acknowledgement
This article is based on GAVI project experience in Côte d'Ivoire. It was prepared with the support of the DELTAS Africa Initiative [Afrique One-ASPIRE /DEL-15–008]. Afrique One-ASPIRE is funded by a consortium of donor including the African Academy of Sciences (AAS) Alliance for Accelerating Excellence in Science in Africa (AESA), the New Partnership for Africa's Development Planning and Coordinating (NEPAD) Agency, the Wellcome Trust [107753/A/15/Z] and the UK government.We thank the agents
References (17)
Vaccinations contre la rage et prophylaxie post-exposition Recommandations
Avis et Rapports
(2013)- et al.
Déterminants de l'abandon de la prophylaxie post exposition à la rage au Centre Antirabique de Bouaké
Côte d'Ivoire. Revue Malienne d'Infectiologie et de Microbiologie
(2017) - Diop, S.A., Manga, N.M., Dia, N.M., Ndour, C.T., Seydi, M., Soumare, M., Diop, B.M., SowP.S.,2007. Le point sur la rage...
- et al.
Evaluation of cost-effective strategies for rabies post-exposure vaccination in low-income countries
PLoS Negl. Trop. Dis.
(2011) - et al.
. Estimating the global burden of endemic canine rabies
PLoS Negl. Trop. Dis.
(2015) - et al.
Modelling to inform prophylaxis regimens to prevent human rabies
Vaccine
(2018) - et al.
Pre-exposure rabies prophylaxis: a systematic review
Bull. World Health Organ.
(2017) - et al.
Cost description and comparative cost Efficiency of Post-Exposure Prophylaxis and canine mass vaccination against rabies in N’Djamena
Chad. Front. Vet. Sci.
(2017)
Cited by (4)
Increasing rabies data availability: The example of a One Health research project in Chad, Côte d'Ivoire and Mali
2021, Acta TropicaCitation Excerpt :The health impact of PEP in terms of survival considering injection method, use of RIG, and timing and number of doses received at health facility level are extremely valuable data to inform future treatment recommendations. Data from Côte d'Ivoire were used to evaluate the efficacy of PEP with and without RIG (Gerber et al., 2020) and evaluate the uptake of the Updated Thai Red Cross ID regiment (Tetchi et al., 2020b). Since it was the first time a research One Health collaboration was attempted in the study regions, mechanisms for data sharing with and between participating facilities were not yet well established.
RABIES IMMUNOGLOBULIN: Brief history and recent experiences in Côte d'Ivoire
2020, Acta TropicaCitation Excerpt :The better adherence to vaccination protocol in the eRIG group might be linked to the fact that the vaccine for ID application was offered free of charge while patients had to pay the regular price for IM vaccinations. Tetchi et al. showed that free provision of vaccine improves compliance significantly in this setting (Tetchi et al., 2020). The improved awareness and the free provision of vaccine for ID protocols should both have favored survival in the eRIG group and, therefore, do not limit the significance our finding of no additional benefit of eRIG with PEP compared to PEP with vaccination alone.
Identification of risk factors for rabies exposure and access to post-exposure prophylaxis in Chad
2020, Acta TropicaCitation Excerpt :Nonetheless, a significant proportion of victims abandoned treatment, as reported in many other countries (Tiembre et al., 2013; Shankaraiah et al., 2015; Changalucha et al., 2018). Change of schedule from intramuscular schemes to the most recently recommended intradermal schemes, reducing the number of required visits to three, for a full course of PEP would increase compliance (WHO, 2018, Tetchi et al., 2020). In our study, uptake of the four-dose Updated Thai Red Cross scheme by health personnel was generally good, although slightly reduced in rural facilities.
Determinants of Rabies Post-exposure Prophylaxis Drop-Out in the Region of San-Pedro, Côte d'Ivoire
2022, Frontiers in Veterinary Science