Abstract
My discussions with John Bell about reality in quantum mechanics are recollected. I would like to introduce the reader to Bell’s vision of reality which was for him a natural position for a scientist. Bell had a strong aversion against “quantum jumps” and insisted to be clear in phrasing quantum mechanics, his “words to be forbidden” proclaimed with seriousness and wit – both typical Bell characteristics – became legendary. I will summarize the Bell-type experiments and what Nature responded, and discuss the implications for the physical quantities considered, the real entities and the nonlocality concept due to Bell’s work. Subsequently, I also explain a quite different view of the meaning of a quantum state, this is the information theoretic approach, focusing on the work of Brukner and Zeilinger. Finally, I would like to broaden and contrast the reality discussion with the concept of “virtuality,” with the meaning of virtual particle occurring in quantum field theory. With some of my own thoughts I will conclude the paper which is composed more as a historical article than as a philosophical one.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
F. Close,Half life, Oneworld Publication, London, 2015
R.A. Bertlmann,Decay modes of ϒ(9.4), ϒ′(10) and their pseudoscalar partners ηq, η′q, Preprint of JINR, E2 - 11029, Dubna (1977)
J.J. Sakurai, Phys. Lett. B 46, 207 (1973)
J.S. Bell and R.A. Bertlmann, Z. Phys. C 4, 11 (1980)
J.S. Bell and R.A. Bertlmann, Nucl. Phys. B 177, 218 (1981)
J.S. Bell and R.A. Bertlmann, Nucl. Phys. B 187, 285 (1981)
R.A. Bertlmann and J.S. Bell, Nucl. Phys. B 227, 435 (1983)
J.S. Bell and R.A. Bertlmann, Phys. Lett. B 137, 107 (1984)
A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen, Phys. Rev. 47, 777 (1935)
J.S. Bell,Bertlmann’s socks and the nature of reality, CERN preprint Ref.TH.2926-CERN (1980)
J.S. Bell, J. Phys., Colloque C2, 42, C2 (1981)
E. Schrödinger, Brit. J. Phil. Sci. 3, 109, 233 (1952)
J.S. Bell, Are there quantum jumps? inSchrödinger. Cenetary of a polymath, Cambridge University Press, 1987
J.S. Bell,Speakable and unspeakable in quantum mechanics, Cambridge University Press, Second Ed., 2004
S. Harouche and J.-M. Raimond,Exploring the quantum, Oxford University Press, 2013
N. Gisin, Sundays in a quantum engineer’s life, inQuantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 199, Springer, 2002
R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.),Quantum [Un]speakables, Springer, 2002
J.S. Bell and R. Jackiw, Nuovo Cim. 60, 47 (1969)
S.L. Adler, Phys. Rev. 177, 2426 (1969)
A. Shimony, John S. Bell: some reminiscences and reflections, inQuantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 51, Springer, 2002
J.S. Bell, Physics 1, 195 (1964)
A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen, Phys. Rev. 47, 777 (1935)
D. Bohm,Quantum theory, Prentice-Hall Inc., 1951
D. Bohm and Y. Aharonov, Phys. Rev. 108, 1070 (1957)
J.F. Clauser, M.A. Horne, A. Shimony, and R.A. Holt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 880 (1969)
E.P. Wigner, Am. J. Phys. 38, 1005 (1970)
J.F. Clauser and M.A. Horne, Phys. Rev. D 10, 526 (1974)
P.H. Eberhard, Phys. Rev. A 47, 747 (1993)
R.A. Bertlmann and B.C. Hiesmayr, Phys. Rev. A 63, 062112 (2001)
R.A. Bertlmann, A. Bramon, G. Garbarino, and B.C. Hiesmayr, Phys. Lett. A 332, 355 (2004)
R.A. Bertlmann, W. Grimus, and B.C. Hiesmayr, Phys. Lett. A 289, 21 (2001)
B.C. Hiesmayr, A. Di Domenico, C. Curceanu, A. Gabriel, M. Huber, J-A. Larsson, and P. Moskal, Eur. Phys. J. C 72, 1856 (2012)
A. Bramon and G. Garbarino, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 040403 (2002)
A. Bramon and G. Garbarino, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 160401 (2002)
H. Tataroglu,Nichtlokale Korrelation in Kaonischen Systemen, Diploma Thesis (in German), University of Vienna, 2009
Y.-B. Ding, J.-L. Li, and C.-F. Qiao, High Energy Phys. Nucl. Phys. 11, 1086 (2007)
J.-L. Li and C.-F. Qiao, Phys. Lett. A 373, 4311 (2009)
J.-L. Li and C.-F. Qiao, Sci. China G 53, 870 (2010)
R.A. Bertlmann, Entanglement, Bell inequalities and decoherence in particle physics, inQuantum coherence: from quarks to solids, W. Pötz, J. Fabian, and U. Hohensteiner (Eds.), Lect. Notes Phys. 689, 1–45, Springer, 2006
J.F. Clauser,Early history of Bell’s theorem, in Quantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 61, Springer, 2002
S.J. Freedman and J.F. Clauser, Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 938 (1972)
S.J. Freedman, LBL Rep. No. 191, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 1972
E.S. Fry and R.C. Thompson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 37, 465 (1976)
A. Pais,‘Subtle is the Lord’ ... The Science and Life of Albert Einstein, Oxford University Press, 1982
A. Aspect, Phys. Rev. D 14, 1944 (1976)
A. Aspect, P. Grangier, and G. Roger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 47, 460 (1981)
A. Aspect, P. Grangier, and G. Roger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 91 (1982)
A. Aspect, J. Dalibard, and G. Roger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1804 (1982)
A. Aspect and P. Grangier, Lett. Nuovo Cim. 43, 345 (1985)
R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.),Quantum [Un]speakables, Springer, 2016
M.A. Nielsen and I.L. Chuang,Quantum computation and quantum information, Cambridge University Press, 2000
G. Weihs, T. Jennewein, C. Simon, H. Weinfurter, and A. Zeilinger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5039 (1998)
G. Weihs,Ein Experiment zum Test der Bellschen Ungleichung unter Einstein Lokalität, PhD Thesis, University of Innsbruck, 1998
J. Brendel, E. Mohler, and W. Martienssen, Europhys. Lett. 20, 575 (1992)
P.R. Tapster, J.G. Rarity, and P.C.M. Owens, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1923 (1994)
W. Tittel, J. Brendel, H. Zbinden, and N. Gisin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3563 (1998)
K.J. Resch, M. Lindenthal, B. Blauensteiner, H.J. Böhm, A. Fedrizzi, C. Kurtsiefer, A. Poppe, T. Schmitt-Manderbach, M. Taraba, R. Ursin, P. Walther, H. Weier, H. Weinfurter, and A. Zeilinger, Optics Express 13, 202 (2005)
R. Ursin, F. Tiefenbacher, T. Schmitt-Manderbach, H. Weier, T. Scheidl, M. Lindenthal, B. Blauensteiner, T. Jennewein, J. Perdigues, P. Trojek, B. Ömer, M. Fürst, M. Meyenburg, J. Rarity, Z. Sodnik, C. Barbieri, H. Weinfurter, and A. Zeilinger, Nat. Phys. 3, 481 (2007)
J. Yin, Y. Li, S. Liao, et al., Nature 582, 501 (2020)
D. Rauch, J. Handsteiner, A. Hochrainer, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 080403 (2018)
T. Scheidl, R. Ursin, J. Kofler, S. Ramelow, X.-S. Ma, T. Herbst, L. Ratschbacher, A. Fedrizzi, N.K. Langford, T. Jennewein, and A. Zeilinger, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 19708 (2010)
M. Giustina, A. Mech, S. Ramelow, B. Wittmann, J. Kofler, J. Beyer, A. Lita, B. Calkins, T. Gerrits, S.W. Nam, R. Ursin, A. Zeilinger, Nature 497, 227 (2013)
M.A. Rowe, D. Kielpinsky, V. Meyer, C.A. Sackett, W.M. Itano, and D.J. Wineland, Nature 409, 791 (2001)
D.N. Matsukevich, P. Maunz, D.L. Moehring, S. Olmschenk, and C. Monroe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 150404 (2008)
G. Kirchmair, F. Zähringer, R. Gerritsma, M. Kleinmann, O. Gühne, A. Cabello, R. Blatt, and C.F. Roos, Nature 460, 494 (2009)
Y. Hasegawa, R. Loidl, G. Badurek, M. Baron, and H. Rauch, Nature 425, 45 (2003)
H. Bartosik, J. Klepp, C. Schmitzer, S. Sponar, A. Cabello, H. Rauch, and Y. Hasegawa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 040403 (2009)
Y. Hasegawa, K. Durstberger-Rennhofer, S. Sponar, and H. Rauch, Kochen-Specker theorem studied with neutron interferometer, arXiv:1004.2836 (2010)
M. Giustina, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 250401 (2015)
L.K. Shalm, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 250402 (2015)
B. Hensen, et al., Nature (London) 526, 682 (2015)
Homepage of the Symposium “Shut up and contemplate!”: https://shutupandcontemplatesymposium.wordpress.com
J.S. Bell, The theory of local beables, Epistemological Letters, March 1976, and paper 7, p. 52 inSpeakable and unspeakable in quantum mechanics, J.S. Bell, Cambridge University Press, Second Ed., 2004
D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 85, 166 (1952); ibid p. 180 (1952)
A. Einstein, Letter to M. Born, May 12th, 1952, inAlbert Einstein Max Born, Briefwechsel 1916–1955, Rowohlt, 1969
J. von Neumann,Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik, Springer, Berlin 1932 [English translation: Princeton University Press, 1955]
J.S. Bell, Rev. Mod. Phys. 38, 447 (1966)
S.B. Kochen and E. Specker, J. Math. Mech. 17, 59 (1967)
J. Conway and S.B. Kochen, The geometry of quantum paradoxes, inQuantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann, and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 257, Springer, 2002
J.S. Bell and W. Walkinshaw,A variational approach to disc loaded waveguides, AERE G/R 680, 1950
J.S. Bell and W. Walkinshaw,Review of theory of dielectric loaded linear accelerators, AERE G/R 544, 1950
J.S. Bell,Scattering by focussing foils in a proton linear accelerators, AERE T/M 62, 1952
J.S. Bell,Phase debunching by focussing foils in a proton linear accelerators, AERE T/M 68, 1952
J.S. Bell,Basic algebra of the strong focussing system, AERE T/R 1114, 1953
J.S. Bell, La nouvelle cuisine, inBetween Science and Technology, eds. A. Sarlemijn and P. Kroes, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1990
R.A. Bertlmann,Bell’s theorem and the nature of reality, preprint University of Vienna 1988, Found. Phys. 20, 1191 (1990)
A. Zeilinger, Found. Phys. 29, 631 (1999)
Č. Brukner and A. Zeilinger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3354 (1999)
Č. Brukner and A. Zeilinger, Phys. Rev. A 63, 022113 (2001)
Č. Brukner and A. Zeilinger, Information and fundamental elements of the structure of quantum theory, inTime, quantum, information, L. Castell and O. Ischebeck (eds.), pp. 323–354, Springer, 2003
C.F. von Weizsäcker,Aufbau der Physik, Carl Hanser Verlag, München/Wien, 1985
J.A. Wheeler, Information, physics, quantum: the search for links, Proceedings of the IIIrd International Symposium on Foundation of Quantum Mechanics, pp. 354–368, Tokyo, 1989
E. Schrödinger, Die gegenwärtige Situation in der Quantenmechanik, Naturwissenschaften 23, 807 (1935)
E. Schrödinger, Discussion of probability relations between separated systems, Proc. Cambr. Phil. Soc. 31, 555 (1935); 32, 446 (1936)
S. Malin, Quantum Information Process. 5, 233 (2006)
Č. Brukner, On the quantum measurement problem, inQuantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 95, Springer, 2016
B. Dakić and Č. Brukner, Quantum theory and beyond: is entanglement special?, inDeep beauty: understanding the quantum world through mathematical innovation, H. Halvorson (ed.), pp. 365–392, Cambridge University Press, 2011, arXiv:0911.0695
B. Dakić and Č. Brukner, The classical limit of a physical theory and the dimensionality of space, inQuantum theory: informational foundations and foils, G. Chiribella and R. Spekkens (eds.), pp. 249–282, Springer, 2016, arXiv:1307.3984
Č. Brukner, M. Zukowski, and A. Zeilinger,The essence of entanglement, arXiv:0106119
E.P. Wigner, Remarks on the mind-body question, inThe scientist speculates, I.J. Good (ed.), pp. 284–302, London, Heinemann, 1961
D. Deutsch, Quantum theory as a universal physical theory, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 24, I (1985)
V. Baumann, A. Hansen, and S. Wolf,The measurement problem is the measurement problem is the measurement problem, arXiv:1611.01111
V. Baumann and S. Wolf, On formalisms and interpretations, Quantum 2, 99 (2018), arXiv:1710.07212
V. Baumann and Č. Brukner, Wigner’s friend as a rational agent, arXiv:1901.1127
L. Hardy, Quantum theory from five reasonable axioms, arXiv:quant-ph/0101012
R. Clifton, J. Bub, and H. Halvorson, Found. Phys. 33, 1561 (2003)
L. Masanes and M.P. Müller, New J. Phys. 13, 063001 (2011)
G. Chiribella, G.M. D’Ariano, and P. Perinotti, Phys. Rev. A 84, 012311 (2011)
C.A. Fuchs and R. Schack, Rev. Mod. Phys. 85, 1693 (2007)
C.A. Fuchs and R. Schack, QBism and the Greeks: why a quantum state does not represent an element of physical reality, arXiv:1412.4211 (2014)
C. Rovelli, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637 (1996)
F. Horvath,Information theoretical reconstructions of quantum theory, Bachelor Thesis, University of Vienna 2013, https://homepage.univie.ac.at/reinhold.bertlmann, and go to Research/Former Students
C. Regner,Information as foundation principle for quantum mechanics, Bachelor Thesis, University of Vienna 2015, https://homepage.univie.ac.at/reinhold.bertlmann, and go to Research/Former Students
T. Traxler, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Vienna, 2020
T. Aoyama, M. Hayakawa, T. Kinoshita, and M. Nio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 111807 (2012)
D. Hanneke, S. Fogwell Hoogerheide, and G. Gabrielse, Phys. Rev. A 83, 052122 (2011)
H.B.G. Casimir, On the attraction between two perfectly conducting plates, Royal Netherlands Acad. Arts Sci. Proc. 51, 793 (1948); reprinted in Gems from a century of science 1898–1997. Centenary issue of the Proc. of the Royal Netherlands Acad. of Arts and Sciences, L.M. Schoonhoven (eds.), Amsterdam, pp. 61–63 (1997)
M. Sparnaay, Nature 180, 334 (1957)
M.J. Sparnaay, Physica 24, 751 (1958)
S.K. Lamoreaux, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 5 (1997)
U. Mohideen and Anushree Roy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4549 (1998)
S. Hawking, Nature 248, 30 (1974)
W.G. Unruh, Phys. Rev. D 14, 870 (1976)
R.A. Bertlmann,Anomalies in quantum field theory, Oxford University Press, 2000
R.A. Bertlmann, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 47, 424007 (2014)
R.A. Bertlmann, Bell’s Universe: A Personal Recollection, inQuantum [Un]speakables, R.A. Bertlmann and A. Zeilinger (eds.), p. 17, Springer, 2016
Acknowledgments
Open access funding provided by University of Vienna.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
The EPJ Publishers remain neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Bertlmann, R.A. Real or not real that is the question.... EPJ H 45, 205–236 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2020-10022-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjh/e2020-10022-x