In situ friction and wear behavior of rubber materials incorporating various fillers and/or a plasticizer in high-pressure hydrogen
Graphical abstract
Introduction
The conversion of stationary power sources and mobile applications from fossil fuels to cleaner, more renewable hydrogen continues [[1], [2], [3], [4], [5]]. However, the broader application of hydrogen on a global scale is impeded by the potential for materials exposed to high-pressure hydrogen for long periods of time to degrade [6]. The United States Department of Energy's Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office has launched the H2@Scale program that is supporting work in hydrogen compatibility of materials to improve the durability and reliability of materials for the hydrogen infrastructure. To improve reliability of hydrogen energy, including infrastructure delivery and distribution systems, fueling stations, and automotive fueling systems, the effects of high-pressure hydrogen on their materials of construction must be better understood. For example, some steels and titanium degrade in high-pressure hydrogen environments by forming hydrides, leading to embrittlement and subsequently structural damage [[6], [7], [8], [9]]. Unlike metals, polymers are thought not to react chemically with hydrogen, leading many to conclude that mechanical failure is the primary damage mechanism when polymers are not challenged by other factors such as temperature [6,[10], [11], [12]]. It is widely accepted in the hydrogen energy community that most damage to polymers in hydrogen applications occurs during sudden decompression of high-pressure hydrogen. This type of damage is commonly referred to as rapid or explosive decompression failure (RDF or XDF) [[13], [14], [15]] and has been investigated in several studies driven by growing interest in high-pressure hydrogen applications. XDF is induced by sudden expansion of the hydrogen absorbed within the polymer due to rapid removal of external pressure, which causes bubbles, internal cracking, surface blistering, or even catastrophic failure by exfoliation. Since commercial polymer products are typically not pure materials, the failure mechanism can be influenced by additives (e.g., filler, plasticizer), conditions (e.g., pressure, gas species), microscale morphology (e.g., additive-polymer interaction) and others. Therefore, further understanding of polymer degradation modes is still in need. The hydrogen compatibility program (H-Mat), led by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) and Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) under the H2@Scale program, seeks to address the challenges of hydrogen degradation by elucidating the mechanisms of hydrogen-materials interactions with the goal of providing science-based strategies to design materials (micro)structures and morphology with improved resistance to hydrogen degradation.
Given the gaps in knowledge and data for polymers suitable for hydrogen service, a growing quantity of work has been devoted to such areas as tribology, failure modes, mechanical property variation, and polymer permeability/solubility. Among these, the interest in hydrogen's effects on tribological friction and wear have surged in recent years, as polymers are typically used in dry, sliding components, where frictional wear plays a central role in determining reliability and durability for intended hydrogen applications [[16], [17], [18]]. Tribological factors that affect characteristics of the friction and wear behavior of polymers are of particular interest. Such factors include but are not limited to surface roughness, mechanisms of adhesion, real contact area, normal load, sliding velocity, temperature, humidity, and physical and chemical interactions between the two surfaces in contact [[19], [20], [21], [22]]. Considering the effects of viscoelasticity, a larger variation in friction and wear behavior is expected for most polymers than for metals. Theiler et al. [16,23] described tribological experiments carried out at room temperature in a low-pressure hydrogen environment on a variety of polymer composites. The authors concluded that the apparent coefficient of friction (CoF) decreased to varying extents in hydrogen, and the fillers of choice had a greater influence on the tribological performance of the composites than the polymer matrix had. Sawae et al. [24] investigated high-pressure (40 MPa) hydrogen effects on the wear behavior of unfilled polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, a common sealing compound) and 15% graphite-filled PTFE using 316 L austenitic steel as the sliding counterface in a pin-on-disk type tribometer. The results revealed that the hydrogen gas environment enhanced formation of the polymer transfer film, thereby reducing the specific wear rate despite the fillers, but the 15% graphite-filled PTFE had a lower specific wear rate than the unfilled PTFE when exposed to high-pressure hydrogen. Later, Sawae et al. [25] compared graphite-filled PTFE and bronze-filled PTFE friction and wear performance in a 40 MPa hydrogen environment and concluded that the effects of high-pressure hydrogen were relatively small for graphite-filled PTFE. Unlike the pin-on-disk tribometer, a custom-built linear reciprocating tribometer was developed by Duranty et al. [18], wherein a steel pin is rubbed against the surface of a polymer disk in high-pressure hydrogen (26.2 MPa). A commercial elastomer used for sealing purposes, nitrile butadiene rubber (NBR), filled with magnesium oxide (MgO) was studied using the custom-made tribometer, and results indicated that friction between the pin and the NBR was higher during testing in the high-pressure hydrogen environment than in high-pressure argon or ambient air. They attributed this result to three main effects: (1) pseudo-plasticization, in which hydrogen gas can decrease the mechanical strength of the material, making damage more likely to occur, (2) voids created between the filler and the polymer matrix, and (3) hydriding of the magnesium-based fillers within the polymer, which can trigger a change in surface roughness and morphology. However, there have been only few studies in this field and there exists a need for a comprehensive work where more than one polymer will be looked at and the effects of additives on tribological performance of polymers are explored fundamentally in high-pressure hydrogen.
Particulate fillers are often added to polymers for reinforcement, cost effectiveness, or processability [[26], [27], [28]]. Especially in the rubber industry, either carbon black, silica, or a combination thereof has been commercially used to modify the physical properties of rubber compounds to help meet certain requirements for intended uses [28,29]. There are many functional groups such as hydroxyl, carboxyl, lactone, pyrone, ketone, quinone, and phenol on the carbon black surface, but the amount is limited [30]. Silica has abundant hydroxyl groups on the surface, which contribute to strong filler-filler interactions and adsorption of polar materials by hydrogen bonds [31]. Research has shown that bubbles and voids form at the interface between fillers and rubber polymer during exposure to high-pressure hydrogen gas, deteriorating the filler-polymer interaction at the interface, leading to blister fracture of the bulk [6,[32], [33], [34]]. However, the filler effects on tribological performance of polymers in high-pressure hydrogen environments have not been well established. Furthermore, commercial rubber materials often include a variety of plasticizers, such as dioctylphthalate, dioctyl sebecate, and other oil type plasticizers, to maintain or improve rubbery characteristics of the compounds [35,36]. A few studies revealed that large additions of plasticizer bring about a change in CH4 and CO2 diffusivity within a polymer matrix as a result of an increase in the mobility of polymer chains [37,38]. Unfortunately, these studies only provide us limited insights, though useful guidelines for subsequent studies, into polymer compatibility with hydrogen gas. Worthwhile noting, outside the rubber industry, carbon nanotubes (CNTs) were reportedly utilized in carbon fibric-reinforced phenolic composites for improving wear resistance due to the improved interfacial bonding of the composites by the incorporation of CNTs [39]. Also, MoS2 particles were used as additives and friction modifier to improve the wear and friction behavior of carbon fabric reinforced phenolic composites [40]. Kurdi et al. [41] studied the tribological properties of three different high-performance polymers reinforced with different TiO2 content and compared at different temperatures, suggesting that TiO2 particles reduce the adhesion between polymer and transfer film layers. Yin et al. [42] found that introducing fluorine rubber micro powder into boron phenolic resin-based composites can reduce wear rate by 80.9% owing to the reduction of fatigue wear and the formation of large-area friction film.
To address these gaps, we sought to understand the friction and wear behavior of representative rubber compounds under 27.6 MPa of hydrogen, using a custom-built in situ tribometer previously described by Duranty et al. [18]. In situ measurements were carried out on model material compounds of ethylene propylene diene (EPDM) and NBR—elastomers often used in dynamic sliding components or seals, mostly for hydrogen transportation, delivery and infrastructure—that were loaded with various fillers and/or plasticizers in the present work. In situ measurements are useful because the finite diffusion rates of hydrogen through the polymers introduce time dependence into the polymer degradation upon changing pressure. The first goal of the work described below is to characterize the friction and wear of target elastomers quantitatively. The CoF and specific wear rate are calculated from the frictional force and penetration depth recorded in situ. The second goal is to understand the role of fillers and plasticizers in influencing the tribological performance of EPDM and NBR.
Section snippets
The in situ tribometer
The custom tribometer developed previously (Fig. 1) used to perform the in-situ testing in this work. This testing system is equipped with a hemispherical steel pin sliding or rubbing across the polymer sample in a linear, reciprocating fashion and a stepper motor for precise control over the reciprocating motion, particularly for swift braking or acceleration at the turnaround points. The frictional force is measured by an in-line capacitor design load cell that is left open to the hydrogen
Frictional force
Frictional force measurements at cycle #120 (i.e., the end of a test) were used for comparison and discussion because previous work [18] suggested that the rubber materials’ behavior would be quite stabilized by cycle #120. Fig. 2 shows representative (not mean) frictional force data as a function of time for all of the EPDM and NBR samples tested in ambient air and in high-pressure hydrogen. The plateau regions indicate the dynamic friction of sliding motion (negative values indicate motion in
Conclusions
The friction and wear behavior of rubber materials frequently used in hydrogen infrastructure was studied in both ambient air and high-pressure hydrogen environments using an in situ linear reciprocating pin-on-flat tribology tester. Frictional force and wear/penetration depth were measured to calculate the CoF and wear factor for materials tested in the two different environments. Generally speaking, introduction of high-pressure hydrogen led to an increase in CoF for all of the model
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Wenbin Kuang: Writing - original draft, Visualization, Writing - review & editing, Methodology, Formal analysis, Investigation, Data curation, Software. Wendy D. Bennett: Investigation, Formal analysis. Timothy J. Roosendaal: Investigation, Writing - review & editing. Bruce W. Arey: Investigation. Alice Dohnalkova: Investigation. Kevin L. Simmons: Conceptualization, Methodology, Resources, Funding acquisition, Writing - review & editing, Supervision.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgement
This work was fully supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (USDOE), Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE), Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Technologies Office (HFTO) under Contract Number DE-AC05-76RL01830. We also acknowledge support from the Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory (EMSL). EMSL is a national scientific user facility sponsored by the DOE's Office of Science, Biological and Environmental Research program that is located at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.
References (64)
Hydrogen the fuel for 21st century
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2009)- et al.
Damage due to hydrogen embrittlement and stress corrosion cracking
Eng Fail Anal
(2000) - et al.
Hydrogen damage of steels: a case study and hydrogen embrittlement model
Eng Fail Anal
(2015) - et al.
Hydrogen influence on the tensile properties of mono and multi-layer polymers for gas distribution
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2010) - et al.
On key parameters influencing cavitation damage upon fast decompression in a hydrogen saturated elastomer
Polym Test
(2011) - et al.
Degradation behavior of acrylonitrile butadiene rubber after cyclic high-pressure hydrogen exposure
Int J Hydrogen Energy
(2015) - et al.
“Rapid gas decompression performance of elastomers – a study of influencing testing parameters
Procedia Structural Integrity
(2016) - et al.
Tribological characteristics of polyamide composites in hydrogen environment
Tribol Int
(2015) - et al.
Tribology of polymers: adhesion, friction, wear, and mass-transfer
Tribol Int
(2005) A review of the influence of environmental humidity and water on friction, lubrication and wear
Tribol Int
(1990)
Effects of a multifunctional additive on bound rubber in carbon black and silica filled natural rubbers
Eur Polym J
Reinforcement of natural rubber with silica/carbon black hybrid filler
Polym Test
Influence of fillers on hydrogen penetration properties and blister fracture of rubber composites for O-ring exposed to high-pressure hydrogen gas
Int J Hydrogen Energy
Degradation behavior of acrylonitrile butadiene rubber after cyclic high-pressure hydrogen exposure
Int J Hydrogen Energy
The roles of hardness in the sliding behavior of materials
Wear
Grafting CNTs on carbon fabrics with enhanced mechanical and thermal properties for tribological applications of carbon fabrics/phenolic composites
Carbon
Tribological behavior of high performance polymers and polymer composites at elevated temperature
Tribol Int
Superior wear resistance of boron phenolic resin-based composites using fluorine rubber micro powder as high-performance additive
Tribol Int
Morphology of ice wear from rubber-ice friction tests and its dependence on temperature and sliding velocity
Wear
Hydrogen safety: the road toward green technology
Int J Hydrogen Energy
A theory of dynamic rubber friction
Wear
On the theory of rubber friction
Surf Sci
Influence of surface oxidation of carbon black on its interaction with nitrile rubbers
Polymer
Physical modification of elastomers to improve their tribological properties
Wear
formation of an adsorption film of MoS2 nanoparticles and dioctyl sebacate on a steel surface for alleviating friction and wear
Tribol Int
Effect of penetration depth on indentation response of soft coatings on hard substrates: a finite element analysis
Surf Coating Technol
Tribological testing of peroxide-cured EPDM rubbers with different carbon black contents under dry sliding conditions against steel
Tribological International
Chapter 22 – solubility of plasticizers, polymers and environmental pollution,”
Influence of fillers on free volume and gas barrier properties in styrene-butadiene rubber studied by positrons
Polymer
“Wear in relation to friction – a review
Wear
Hydrogen-storage materials for mobile applications
Nature
Fuel cell electric vehicles and hydrogen infrastructure: Status 2012
Energy Environ Sci
Cited by (16)
A comprehensive review of hydrogen-induced swelling in rubber composites
2024, Composites Part B: EngineeringPhase field modeling of hydrogen release in nitrile-butadiene rubber composites after high-pressure hydrogen exposure
2024, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergyImpacts of deep eutectic solvent on silica/nitrile rubber nanocomposites for high-pressure hydrogen storage applications
2024, Composites CommunicationsIn-situ observation of particles invasion behavior into the sealing interface under vibration
2023, Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement ConfederationMulti-scale imaging of high-pressure hydrogen induced damage in EPDM rubber using X-ray microcomputed tomography, helium-ion microscopy and transmission electron microscopy
2023, International Journal of Hydrogen EnergyCitation Excerpt :Simmons et al. [21], using helium ion microscopy (HeIM) and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectroscopy (ToF-SIMS), discovered that an oil-based plasticizer, dioctyl sebacate (DOS), underwent phase separation in nitrile butadiene rubber (NBR) upon exposure to 28 MPa hydrogen, which eventually can cause a change in material performance. As dynamic sliding seals are used widely in compressors for hydrogen services, another work [22] investigated the tribological performance of a group of ethylene propylene diene (EPDM) rubber and NBR model compounds under high-pressure hydrogen environments. The results suggested that the presence of plasticizer results in relatively low wear in both environments due to its lubricating nature.
Adopting bio-inspired interfacial modification and reinforcements simultaneously for optimizing the tribological performance of fabric composites
2022, Tribology InternationalCitation Excerpt :The incorporation of tiny amount of fillers allows to endow polymer composites with improved mechanical and tribological properties [21]. Previous studies indicated that the abrasion resistance of polymer matrix was greatly improved by filling micro-nano ceramic particles due to their high strength, thermal conductivity, and high hardness [22,23]. In addition, the ceramic particles were transferred to the friction interface during the friction process and then participated in the formation of high-quality tribofilm [24,25].