Abstract
To date, few large-scale bronze foundry sites of the Bronze Age have been found in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River in Southern China, but highly developed bronze cultures have occurred here. For instance, in Qiaojiayuan, Yunxian County, northwestern Hubei Province, on the border of Southern and Northern China, a high-level tomb cluster of Spring and Autumn period (8th–5th c. BC) has been unearthed. The location of the site is identical with the Ancient Jun 麇 State recorded in the historical documents. Thus, figuring out where these bronzes were made can shed light on the status of the Jun State and its potential links to other great powers. X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry (ICP-AES) were conducted to characterize the major elements, trace elements, and rare earth elements in the casting core residues of the Qiaojiayuan bronze ritual vessels. They are largely different from the loess in the Yellow River Basin, but very similar to the laterite in southern China. Moreover, from the chemical characteristics, the samples from Qiaojiayuan are well resembled with those from Panlongcheng and Zuozhong, but differ from the casting core residues or clay molds manufactured in Northern China, and they are not consistent with the local soil geochemical characteristics. It can be further speculated that the Qiaojiayuan bronzes were first cast and finished in the Chu State before being transported to the area of Jun.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bian HY (2014) Stratigraphic characteristics of loess-paleosol and its response to climate change in grade I terrace of Hanjiang River in Yunxi-Yunxian section, Doctoral thesis Shaanxi Normal University, Xi’an (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Chen TM (2005) Quantitative archaeology. Peking University Press, Beijing, p 166 (in Chinese)
Chen GL (2008) Research on erlitou cultural bronze vessels, in Early Chinese bronze culture: a monographic study of Erlitou culture (ed. Archaeological science center in Chinese academy of social science). 124–274, Sciences Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Chen QD, Chen G (1990) Utility of rare earth elements geochemistry. 196, Metallurgy Industry Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Chen J, An ZS, Liu LW, Ji JF, Yang JD, Chen Y (2001) Variations in chemical compositions of the eolian dust in Chinese Loess Plateau over the past 2.5Ma and chemical weathering in the Asian inland. Science in China (Series D) 44(5):403–413
Cogswell J, Neff H, Glascock M (1996) The effect of firing temperature on the elemental characterization of pottery. J Archaeol Sci 23:283–287
Fang Q (2017) A research of Zeng State’s history and culture: based on new archaeological materials. Doctoral thesis Wuhan University, Wuhan (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Han RB, Ke J (2007) Technological history of China: mining and metallurgy technology. Science Press, Beijing, pp 631–632 (in Chinese)
Hanson GH (1980) Rare earth elements in petrogenetic studies of igneous systems. Annu Rev Earth Planet Sci 8:371–406
He GY (1982) The textual research of Jun state. in A monographic study on the history of Chu state. Hubei Renmin Publishing House, Wuhan (in Chinese)
Hong HL, Gu YS, Li RB, Zhang KX, Li ZH (2010) Clay mineralogy and geochemistry and their palaeoclimatic interpretation of the Pleistocene deposits in the Xuancheng section, southern China. J Quat Sci 25(5):662–674
HPICRA (Henan Provincial Institute of Cultural Heritage and Archaeology) (2007) The tombs of Xinghonghuayuan and Redianchang in Zhenghangucheng site. 86+104, Cultural Relics Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Hua JM (1986) Analects of history of China metallurgy. Cultural Relics Press, Beijing, pp 71–75 (in Chinese)
Huang FC, Huang XC (2008) The Qiaojiayuan tombs with human victims from Spring and Autumn period excavated in Yun country Hubei province. Archaeology 4:316–338 (in Chinese with English abstract)
Huang H, Qin Y, Sun S, Wang XF, Chen QW, Han CW, Chen MH (2010) Primary exploration on tracing the sites of bronze casting through clay and pottery from the same tomb: illustrated by some Eastern Zhou Dynasty tombs in Xiangfan, Hubei. Sciences of Conservation and Archaeology 3:30–35 (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
LCWTCR (Luoyang City Work Team of Cultural Relics) (2007) Report on the excavation of the tombs of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty to the west of the Luoyang stadium road. Cultural Relics Press, Beijing, p 38 (in Chinese)
Li BQ (1990) The developmental stages and multi-regional systems of bronze culture in China. Huaxia Archaeology 2:82–91 (in Chinese)
Li SC (2005) Regional characteristics and interaction of early metallurgical copper industry in northwest and central China. Acta Archaeologlca Sinica 3:239–278 (in Chinese)
Liang ZX (1991) Tentative research on history of culture at upper reaches of Han River. Journal of Hanzhong Teachers College 1:25–30 (in Chinese)
Liu DS (1964) Loess in middle course of Yellow River. Science Press, Beijing, pp 189–190 (in Chinese)
Liu DS (1965) China loess deposits. 202+204, Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Liu SR, Wang K, Cai QF, Chen JL (2013) Microscopic study of Chinese bronze casting moulds from the Eastern Zhou period. J Archaeol Sci 40:2402–2414
Luo WG, Song GD, Cui BX, Wang W, Chen D (2019) Based on chemical and mineralogical examination of casting cores to determine the foundry area of bronze vessels from the Xiaxiangpu site in Nanyang city, Henan Province, China. Microchemical Journal 150
Ma CY (1988) Chinese bronze ware. Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House, Shanghai, pp 516–525 (in Chinese)
Menzies MS, Seyfried WJ, Blanchard D (1979) Experimental evidence of rare earth element immobility in greenstones. Nature 282:398–399
Nan PH, Qin Y, Xie YT, Fan WQ, Han CW, Luo WG, Jin S (2008a) Analysis of mineral and chemical compositions of clay core collected in bronze vessels excavated from cemetery of Western Zhou Dynasty in Hengshui. Rock and Mineral Analysis 4:259–262 (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Nan PH, Qin Y,Luo WG, Han CW (2008b) Analysis of clay core residues of bronze vessel unearthed from Chenpo Chu tomb in Xiangfan by XRF and ICP-AES, J. Instrum. Anal. 5:467-471+475(in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Niu P (2011) A preliminary study on the bronze artifacts of Shen County, Graduated University of Academy of Sciences, Beijing, Chu State. Master’s thesis (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Olin J S, Harbottle G, Sayre EV (1978) Elemental compositions of Spanish and Spanish-colonial majolica ceramics in the identification of provenance, in Archaeological Chemistry II, Advances in Chemistry Series 171. 200-229, American Chemical Society, Washington D. C
SPIA (Shanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology) (1994) The tombs of Shangma. 65+81, Cultural Relics Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Sun S, Qin Y, Zhang SY, Xie RT, Jin PJ (2008) Surface treatment technique of pottery moulds in Houma site Foundry.10:1037-1040 (in Chinese with English abstract)
Tan DR (1986a) Study on material of Houma clay mould and its processing technique in the Eastern Zhou Dynasty. Archaeology 4:355–362 (in Chinese)
Tan DR (1986b) Study on processing technique of clay mould of bronze vessels in Shang and Zhou Dynasties. Studies in the History of Natural Sciences 6:346–360 (in Chinese)
Tan DR (1999) A study of the techniques of bronze casting with clay moulds in Bronze Age China. Acta Archaeologlca Sinica 2:211–249 (in Chinese)
Wang ZM, Gao SC (1990) Excavation of Xiangnan tombs of the Spring and Autumn period in Yuncheng. World of Antiquity 1:42 (in Chinese)
Wang ZG, Yu XY, Zhao ZH (1989) Geochemistry of rare earth elements. 321, Science Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Wei GF, Qin Y, Hu YL, Huang FC, Xu TJ, Wang CS (2006) Determining foundry area of bronze vessel using REE in clay mould residues. J Rare Earths 24:497–502
Wei GF, Qin Y, Yao ZQ, Wang CS, Hu YL, Huang FC (2011) Determining the foundry area of the bronze vessel from Jiuliandun tombs using the casting core residue of the bronzes. Acta Petrol Mineral 4:701–715 (in Chinese with English abstract)
Xia N (1985) The origin of Chinese civilization. Cultural Relics 8:1–8 (in Chinese)
Zang CP (2008) Study on the bronze vessels of Zeng State. Archaeology 2008(1):81–89 (in Chinese)
ZCCRI (Zhengzhou City Cultural Relic Institute), HPACR (Henan Provincial Administration of Cultural Relics) (2010) Excavation of Tieling tombs M429 in Xinzheng. Cultural Relics of Central China 1:4–8 (in Chinese)
Zhang HY (2013) Pleistocene loess deposits reveal paleoenvironment of the hominins lived in the South Luo River region. Doctoral thesis Nanjing University, Nanjing (in Chinese with English title and abstract)
Zhang JM, Cai FQ, He TK (1995) Pedogeography of China. The Commercial Press, Beijing (in Chinese)
Zhang BT, Ling HF, Chen PR (2003) Trace element geochemical comparison among multiple geological objects-problems and solutions. Geology-Geochemistry 31:102–106 (in Chinese)
Zhao CC (2006) An introduction to archaeometry. Higher Education Press, Beijing, p 312 (in Chinese)
Zheng YM, Zhou SZ, Kang JC (2005) On the southern vermicular laterite and its forming environment. Journal of Jiaying University 23:79–83 (in Chinese)
Zhu ZY, Wang JD, Huang BL (1995) Laterite, loess: global change. Quat Res 3:268–276 (in Chinese)
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to anonymous reviewers whose comments greatly improved the quality of the manuscript.
Funding
The research is supported by the second sub-project of National Social Science Foundation of China (No. 15ZDB056), the University of Chinese Academy of Sciences (No. 2019-Y954026XX2), the Youth Innovation Promotion Association of CAS, National Scholarship Fund of China (CSC NO. 201404910198), and National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 41471167).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Ding Ma and Wugan Luo contributed equally to the manuscript and should be regarded as co-first authors.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ma, D., Luo, W., Qin, Y. et al. Study on the casting cores to identify the manufacturing place of Chinese bronze vessels excavated in the Qiaojiayuan tombs from Spring and Autumn period. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 12, 203 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-020-01169-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-020-01169-0