Short communicationPrediction of extreme asphaltene onset pressures with PC- SAFT for petroleum reservoir fluids
Introduction
Perturbed chain- statistical association fluid theory equation of state (PC- SAFT EoS) [1] is based on the first-order thermodynamic perturbation theory (TPT) for chain molecules developed by Wertheim [2], [3] and Chapman et al. [4]. This model includes attractive (dispersion) interactions by using the second-order perturbation theory of Barker and Henderson [5]. Not long ago, Abutaqiya et al. [6] reported that the original PC- SAFT [1] predicts a minimum upper critical solution temperature (MUCST) and a hyper- asphaltene onset pressure (HAOP) curve for petroleum mixtures prone to precipitate asphaltenes. The HAOPs result because the UAOP curves return from the respective MUCST up to more elevated temperatures (see Fig. 2 in [6]). This last finding appears to be independent of the characterization method chosen to describe the petroleum fluid [6]. In this work, UAOP and HAOP curves are predicted for six real petroleum reservoir fluids by employing four distinct PC- SAFT versions [7]. In short, these four PC- SAFT models result by combining two distinct sets of universal constants for the second-order dispersion with two different expressions of effective diameter [7]. The first model considered is the original PC- SAFT EoS [1], hereafter called as GS- PC- SAFT. This one employs the Gross and Sadowski universal constants (GSUCs) and the original PC- SAFT temperature-dependent effective diameter, displayed by Eq. (3) in [1]. The second one is the result of combining Liang- Kontogeorgis universal constants (LKUCs) [8] with the original PC- SAFT effective diameter, named hereafter as LK- PC- SAFT [7]. The third PC- SAFT version combines the GSUCs with a recently published temperature-and density-dependent effective diameter given by Eq. (4) in [9], resulting in the GS- PC- SAFT- model. Wherein means an effective diameter dependent upon temperature and density. This diameter is theoretically supported, and its contribution occurs principally at low temperatures, high pressures, and for dense (condensed) phases like asphaltenes [9]. Ultimately, the latter PC- SAFT model is given by combining the LKUCs with resulting in the LK- PC- SAFT- version. In fact, these four PC- SAFT EoS models are amply discussed in [7]. Thus, the results published in this manuscript complement those presented in [7] and [9].
Liang and Kontogeorgis [8] showed that under actual application conditions, the original PC-SAFT [1] predicts more than three volume (density) roots or two stable liquid volume roots. In addition, discontinuous volume roots were obtained as the pressure increases, which produces unrealistic predictions of phase behavior [7], [8]. Those authors reformulated the universal constants used in the dispersion part of PC- SAFT to eliminate that drawback. The resulting universal constants are here called LKUCs. In addition, those constants usually produce lower densities at reduced temperatures or higher pressures than GSUCs [1]. This last fact increases the pressure and temperature range wherein the fluid is isotropic, relegating the metastable conditions to very low temperatures or very high pressures. In fact, in conditions practically out of the most relevant engineering applications. It is important to highlight that the TPT of Barker and Henderson, the basis for PC- SAFT, was really formulated for fluid phases under isotropic conditions [5].
Section snippets
Materials and methods
As reported by Liang and Kontogeorgis [8], the original PC- SAFT parameters ( and) provided by Gross and Sadowski [1] can be reused with the LKUCs. In fact, Cañas-Marín et al. reported a similar result for the temperature- and density-dependent effective diameter given by Eq. (4) in [9]. Moreover, for each PC- SAFT version utilized in this work, the PC- SAFT parameters were recently refitted in [7] for the main pure components present in the light gases from petroleum reservoir fluids
Results and discussions
For Fluids 1-6, Fig. 1 compares the UAOPs, MUCSTs, and HAOPs predicted by the four PC- SAFT versions. For completeness, the meaning of these curves is explicitly depicted for fluid 1 also, including the presence of very steep ascending AOP branches. Fig. 2 in [6] presents also the meaning of UAOPs, MUCSTs, and HAOPs. Those authors were the first in publishing MUCSTs and HAOPs predicted by the original PC- SAFT [1]. However, ascending AOP branches were unreported.
As shown in Fig. 1, the LK- PC-
Conclusions
- •
LK- PC- SAFT- generally predicts inferior UAOPs and MUCST than the other three PC- SAFT versions investigated. This model produces the lowest densities for the global and incipient liquid phases. Hence, this EoS increases the range of the isotropic fluid conditions in which the TPTs are expected to perform better. Hence, phase behavior predictions with SAFT- type versions at packing fractions superior to should be considered with caution.
- •
LKUCs try to suppress or eliminate the
Authors' contribution
Wilson A. Cañas-Marín (WACM): PhD student in the Universidad Nacional de Colombia (Medellín), and his doctaral Project is focused to develop a new theoretically-based model to predict the phase behavior of hydrocarbon mixtures prone to precipitate asphaltenes.
Bibian A. Hoyos (BAH): Dr. Hoyos is a professor in chemical engineering of the Universidad Nacional de Colombia (Medellín), with amply expertise in molecular simulation and equations of state (EoS). Dr. Hoyos is the advisor of the doctoral
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors, Wilson A. Cañas-Marín (WACM), Bibian A. Hoyos (BAH), Doris L. Gonzalez (DLG) declare that does not exist any confict of interest related with the present paper. This work is not linked to any company. The authors BAH and DLG are the advisor and co-advisor, respectively, of the WACM's doctoral Project. The manuscript “Prediction of extreme asphaltene onset pressures with PC- SAFT for petroleum reservoir fluids” is theoretical in nature and it does not violate any restrictions
Acknowledgments
To the reviewers by their comments to improve this manuscript.
References (30)
- et al.
A linear extrapolation of normalized cohesive energy (LENCE) for fast and accurate prediction of the asphaltene onset pressure
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(2019) - et al.
Comparison of four different PC- SAFT versions to predict liquid- liquid equilibria of polymer and asphaltene systems at low temperatures
Fluid Phase Equilib
(2020) - et al.
A temperature- and density-dependent effective diameter for PC- SAFT
J. Mol. Liq.
(2020) - et al.
A theoretically modified PC- SAFT equation of state for predicting asphaltene onset pressures at low temperatures
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(2019) - et al.
Rethinking the modeling approach for asphaltene precipitation using the PC- SAFT Equation of State
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(2016) Equilibrium constants from a modified Redlich-Kwong equation of state
Chem. Eng. Sci.
(1972)- et al.
A solution of Rachford-Rice equations for multiphase systems
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(1995) Calculation of multiphase equilibrium
Comput. Chem. Eng.
(1994)The isothermal flash problem. Part I. Stability
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(1982)A preliminary evaluation of two and three phase flash initialization procedures
Fluid Phase Equilib.
(1989)
Perturbed-chain SAFT: an equation of state based on a perturbation theory for chain molecules
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.
Fluids with highly directional attractive forces. I. Statistical thermodynamics
J. Stat. Phys.
Fluids with highly directional attractive forces. III. Multiple attraction sites
J. Stat. Phys.
Phase equilibria of associating fluids: chain molecules with multiple bonding sites
Mol. Phys.
Perturbation theory and equation of state for fluids: the square-well potential
J. Chem. Phys.
Cited by (3)
The hard-core effect on PC-SAFT to model asphaltene precipitation in petroleum reservoir fluids
2022, Fluid Phase EquilibriaCitation Excerpt :In addition, the numerical stability is improved. This simple effective diameter could explain, in part, the tendency of PC-SAFT to over-predict the AOPs for petroleum reservoir fluids at low temperatures [26–29]. The effective diameter impacts both the repulsive and attractive (e.g., dispersion) term in PC-SAFT.
Forecasting Asphaltene Deposition Zones at High Temperature and High Pressure via Bubble Point Pressure Analysis
2023, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research