Abstract
This article describes the contribution of Giovanni Mingazzini (1859–1929), the “Father of Italian Neurology,” in the description of the subcortical structures involved in motor aphasia and his opposition to Pierre Marie’s (1853–1940) conception of aphasia. In one of the most famous controversies in the history of neurology, the French neurologists Joseph Jules Dejerine (1849–1917), Augusta Dejerine-Klumpke (1859–1927), and Pierre Marie (1853–1940) faced each other during the three symposiums of the French Society of Neurology in 1908. The debate, which was later called “the aphasia quarrel”, focused on the subject of aphasia. In an article published in January of the same year, the Italian neurologist Giovanni Mingazzini had already explicitly challenged Pierre Marie’s conception of aphasia. Mingazzini’s contribution to the “aphasia debate” deserves to be remembered for the emphasis on the role of Broca’s area, and for his detailed description of a subcortical region representing “the crossroad of the language pathways” which, if lesioned, could cause motor aphasia.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability
Not applicable.
References
Fridriksson J, den Ouden DB, Hillis AE, Hickok G, Rorden C, Basilakos A, Yourganov G, Bonilha L (2018) Anatomy of aphasia revisited. Brain. 141:848–862
Broca P (1861) Remarques sur le siège de la faculté du langage articulé, suivies d'une observation d'aphémie (perte de la parole). Bulletin et Memoires de la Société Anatomique de Paris 6:330–357
Broca P (1861) Sur le principe des localisations cérébrales. Bulletin de la Société d'Anthropologie 2:190–204
Charcot JM (1884) Differenti forme d’afasia. Lezioni fatte nella Salpêtrière nel semestre d’estate dell’anno 1883, redatte col consenso dell’autore dal dottore G. Rummo. Vallardi, Milano
Charcot JM (1885) Lezioni cliniche dell'anno scolastico 1883–84 sulle malattie del sistema nervoso. Redatte dal Dottor Domenico Miliotti. Vallardi, Milano
Häusler M, Bender N, Aldakak L, Galassi FM, Eppenberger P, Henneberg M, Rühli F (2019) Muscoloskeletal system. In: Brüne M, Schiefenhövel W (eds.). Oxford handbook of evolutionary medicine, 2019, Oxford University Press, pp. 269–299
Pearce JM (2004) A note on Pierre Marie (1853–1940). J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 75:1583
Marie P (1883) Revue générale de l’aphasie (cécité verbale, surdité verbale, aphasie motrice, agraphie). La Revue de Médecine 3:693–702
Lecours AR, Chain F, Poncet M, Nespoulous JL, Joanette Y (1992) Paris 1908: the hot summer of aphasiology or a season in the life of a chair. Brain Lang 42:105–152
Marie P (1906) Révision de la question de l'aphasie: la troisième circonvolution frontale gauche ne joue aucun rôle spécial dans la fonction du langage. Sem Méd 26:241–247
Tsapkini K, Vivas AB, Triarhou LC (2008) 'Does Broca's area exist?' Christofredo Jakob's 1906 response to Pierre Marie's holistic stance. Brain Lang 105:211–219
Klippel M (1908) Deuxième discussion sur l’Aphasie. Société de Neurologie de Paris, Séances du 9 juillet 1908. Rev Neurol 16:974–1023
Mingazzini G (1908) Les aphasies de conduction en rapport avec la nouvelle théorie de Pierre Marie. L'Encéphale 3:1–27
Zanchin G, Salomone G (2011) Profilo Storico della Società Italiana di Neurologia in 100 anni della Società di Neurologia. Collana Quaderni di Neurologia, Tipografia Senese Snc, Siena
Mingazzini G (1906) Revisione della questione dell'afasia: la terza circonvoluzione frontale sinistra non ha alcuna parte speciale nella funzione del linguaggio. Il policlinico, sezione pratica. 13: 834–837, 871–874, 897–905
Koehler PJ (2000) The Barré and Mingazzini tests. In: Koehler PJ, Bruyn GW, Pearce JMS (eds.), Neurological eponyms, p. 119–126
Mingazzini G (1914) On aphasia due to atrophy of the cerebral convolutions. By Dr G. Mingazzini, Professor of Neuropathology at the Royal University of Rome. Brain 36:493–524
Pick A (1892) Über die Beziehungen der senilen Hirnatrophie zur Aphasie. Prager Med Wochenschr 17:165–167
Bianchi L (1901) Contributo alla dottrina e alla conoscenza delle afasie sensoriali e della demenza afasica. Atti della R Academia di Napoli An IV Serie nuove:165–172
Moutier F (1908) L’aphasie de Broca, Thèse de médecine de Paris, Steinheil
Henschen SE (1926) Über die funktion der rechten hirnhemisphäre im verhältnis zu der linken, in bezug auf sprache, musik und rechnen. Z f d g Neur u Psych 100:1–16
Acknowledgments
We thank Andrea Orioli for the graphic support.
Funding
This study was not funded.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Francesco Brigo conceived and wrote the article; Raffaele Nardone revised it critically for important intellectual content.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical approval
Not required.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brigo, F., Nardone, R. Giovanni Mingazzini (1859–1929) and his opposition to Pierre Marie’s conception of motor aphasia. Neurol Sci 41, 2973–2976 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10072-020-04568-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10072-020-04568-2