Full-length articleInvestigations of thermophysical properties of submerged arc welding slag using a rutile-acidic flux system
Introduction
To improve the arc stability, fluidity, slag detachability, bead appearance, and to refine the weld metal agglomerated fluxes are frequently used in submerged arc welding process. Mechanical as well as metallurgical properties of weld metal depend upon the ingredients of the welding flux used. The physical as well as chemical properties of fluxes get affected by transfer of these ingredients during submerged arc welding process [1]. To understand the interaction between weld metal and flux it is necessary to correlate the properties with the composition of the weld. Because transfer extent from slag to weld and weld to slag depends upon these slag metal interactions occurring in arc plasma region. It is very difficult to understand the mechanism of element transfer in submerged arc welding due to the complex slag metal as well as gas metal reactions. Weld joint composition after solidification in SAW process depends upon the dilution, parent metal composition and slag metal reactions. Since slag metal reactions plays an important role in deciding the final weld joint composition so the proper understanding of element transfer from flux to slag and vice versa is required [2], [3]. Due to high temperature involved and very fast occurrence of slag metal reactions in arc region, it is not necessary to achieve stable equilibrium. The kinetics as well as other chemical factors is equally responsible which needs to be understood for determining the final weld metal composition during element transfer in SAW process. An instantaneous equilibrium is established at the interface when a slag is placed in contact with an iron alloy. The diffusion coefficients, equilibrium constants and weld metal composition are widely dependent upon the chemical potential of flux ingredients [4], [5]. For improving the strength, various micro constituents such as Mn, Si, and B added in the steel, which provides a solid solution with iron and gives appropriate strength to ferrite. By refining the ferrite grains, the yield strength increased. The electrochemical reactions can be more influential in metallic additions to the weld from the slag. Flux constituents play an important role in deciding the inclusions content in the weld metal or slag. In submerged arc welding, molten droplet passes through high temperature plasma after detaching from the filler wire and combines with various ions present in the arc region. The extent of reactivity of various ions with that of molten droplets depends upon the parent metal & wire composition, and flux composition. There is an intimate contact of slag with that of molten metal takes place due to stirring action in the weld pool during transfer of arc in high temperature region. These interactions in the weld region depend upon the kinetic considerations [6], [7], [8]. Beidokhti and Pouriamanesh investigated the influence of filler metal content on the mechanical behaviour and microstructure of SAW welded API X65 steel. Acicular-ferrite microstructure developed exhibit excellent mechanical properties. For the sample having higher levels of titanium and boron content, tensile strength and impact toughness was higher. As the amount of acicular ferrite expands, the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature reduced. For the microstructure containing 80% of acicular ferrite, the impact energy observed about 70 J at −600C. The optimum size of oxide inclusions/particles (up to 2 μm) acted as nucleation sites for acicular-ferrite microstructure. But the mixing of the diffused fine oxide inclusions favours the nucleation of acicular ferrite, which is beneficial for improving impact properties [9]. Beidokhti et al. reported that the addition of titanium in the range of 0.02−0.08% in the weld metal promotes acicular ferrite. Further increase in titanium or manganese hardenability increased. The impact behaviour of the fused metal enhanced by mixing of Ti, but a more significant increase in the level of Ti percentage results in the development of quasi-cleavage fracture mode. Burck et al. investigated the influence of CaO, calcium fluoride, and iron oxide mixing for the SiO2–MnO–CaF2 flux system on weld metal chemistry. He quantitatively explained the effects of these constituents on the element displacement from the slag to weld metal and vice versa using thermodynamic data. For the manganese-silicate flux system (SiO2–MnO–CaF2), the carbon/oxygen appears to be controlled by a CO reaction in the 1010 steel welds while the manganese level remains constant. It noticed that when welds processed by the SiO2–MnO–FeO flux system on the AISI 4340 and 1020 steel plates despite increasing the oxygen level shows consistent carbon contents. Davis and Coe studied the role of flux content and weld metal inclusions during the SAW welding of C-Mn steels. They observed complex changes from the composition of elevated temperature interactions in arc plasma. The transferring metallic elements are comprised of various chemical blends such as fluorides, oxides, and carbonates and during welding, these elements promote phase transformation. Different elements and oxygen disintegrate in the weld pool, due to the contribution of all oxides from the fluxes. Due to these interactios the weld mechanical as well as microstructural properties improved [10]. Chai and Eagar observed the stability of binary CaF2 oxides during the SAW process. Results indicate that the strength of metal oxides during welding was not exactly similar to their thermodynamic stability. Some fluxes in arc plasma, which is chemically supportive, may dissociate into suboxides. Such oxides produce a high level of oxygen in the weld metal than chemically stable oxide and result in reduced impact toughness of the weld metal. It observed that CaF2 in the weld metal reduced the amount of oxygen by the dilution effect (dilution of metal oxides). In the SAW process, fluxes addition of FeO (less than 10%), MnO, and SiO2 are the primary sources of oxygen contamination [11]. Kanjilal et al. observed the behaviour of various flux ingredients by forming a statistical model for different flux components. At suitable welding current and voltage SAW fluxes processed as per the extreme vertices approach of mixture experiments in rutile basic flux system. It observed that the single flux component is most compelling. It has a synergistic influence on weld metal transfer from silicon, oxygen, manganese, and carbon contents, and displacement of oxygen influenced by various premises of flux constituents such as thermodynamic stability, viscosity and oxygen potential [12]. In the present paper, for TiO2-SiO2-MgO and SiO2-MgO-Al2O3flux system, the thermophysical behaviour of submerged arc slags was studied.
Section snippets
Design method
1) 21 SAW fluxes developed by utilizing four flux elements such as SiO2 (S), Al2O3 (U), TiO2 (R), and MgO (T) as per the extreme vertices design approach [13], [14], [15]. Table 1 gives the elemental analysis of minerals. According to this approach, the minimum & maximum range is provided to flux elements and given by Eqs. (1) and (2).0 ≤ Pi ≤ qi ≤ Qi ≤ 100andwhere, i = 1, 2, 3…., k and Pi and Qi are the lower and upper limits of constants on the qi which is the percentage
Results
Results for twenty-one rutile acidic slags using thermogravimetry, DSC, and hot disc technique shown in Table 3. Results for TGA, DSC, Hot-disc, and density shown in Figs. 5(a–i), 6 (a–g), 7 (a–c), and 8 . Thermogravimetric analysis is used to determine the material's thermal stability (in terms of temperature and time) by monitoring the weight change that occurs as a specimen is heated at a constant heating rate. Fig. 5(a–i) represents the thermal behaviour of different slags which was
Effect of slag components on different properties
Metallurgical properties of weld depend upon the various slag-metal reactions occurring during welding. The slag-metal reaction can be represented by Eq. (5).
Dn Om is the metallic oxide in the slag, and D is the corresponding element dissolved in the molten metal. Slag-metal interactions must proceed thermodynamically to satisfy equilibrium conditions [10], [16], [17]. All individual as well as binary slag components decrease the %WC, and thus giving a negative effect on
FTIR analysis of slags
FTIR spectroscopy used to find the bond length between various slag constituents. Fig. 10 shows the FTIR plots for different slag constituents. SiOSi, AlOAl, BO, and COH different bonds found at multiple wave numbers during FTIR spectroscopy. The structural behaviour of slags is well predicted by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The structure is affected by the thermophysical properties of slag. For slag, 21 SiOSi bonds observed at 1000 (cm−1) wave number. FTIR plots of slag provide
Contour graphs
Predicted values of physicochemical and thermophysical properties represented by contour plots shown in Fig. 11. On the contour surface, different regions show the variation of different properties.
Multi-response optimization
Derringer and Suich have proposed a complicated desirability optimization method, used simultaneously to optimize different properties [28], [29]. The current exercise anticipated to improve thermal parameters to get adequate thermal conductivity and specific heat and minimum value of percentage weight change and thermal diffusivity while in range density and change in enthalpy. Four optimized solutions obtained by giving equal weightage for thermal properties at different levels of
Validity of models
The validity of various developed models was cross-checked by randomly choosing four compositions from 21 sets of compositions. The conclusions are given in Table 7, Table 8.
Conclusions
Binary mixture components R.T, R.U, and S.U are the most significant and have a synergistic effect on TD. R.U. (R–U) and S.U. (S–U) are the ternary mixture component, which indicates the increasing impact on TD and shows synergistic effect. Thermal diffusivity of slag constituents should have optimum value. It observed that the too high and too low amount of diffusivity affects the viscosity, density, and thermal expansion of slag during submerged arc welding.
- •
Binary slag component R.U, S.T, and
References (31)
- et al.
Structural Effects of Zn+2/Mg+2 Ratios on Crystallization Characteristics and Microstructure of Fluorophlogopite Mica-Containing Glass Ceramics
Solid State Sciences
(2015) - et al.
Influence of Y2O3 on Structural and Optical Properties of SiO2–BaO–ZnO–xB2O3–(10−x) Y2O3 Glasses and Glass Ceramics
Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids
(2011) - et al.
Binary, Ternary and Quaternary Silicates of CaO, BaO and ZnO in High Thermal Expansion Seals for Solid Oxide Fuel Cells Studied by High Temperature X-Ray Diffraction (HT-XRD)
Materials Research Bulletin
(2011) - et al.
Experimental Study on Effect of Flux Composition on Element Transfer During Submerged Arc Welding
Sadhana
(2018) Fluxes and Slags in Welding
Welding Research Council Bulletin
(1973)- (1995)
- et al.
The Role of Filler Wire and Flux Composition in Submerged Arc Weld Metal Transformation Kinetics
Welding Journal
(1986) - et al.
Element Transfer Behavior During Submerged Arc Welding
Welding Research Supplement
(1980) Sources of Weld Metal Oxygen Contamination During Submerged Arc Welding
Welding Journal
(1978)- et al.
Microstructural Development in Mild and Low-Alloy Steel Weld Metals
International Metals Reviews
(1986)
Nature of Inclusions in Steel Weld Metals and their Influence on the Formation of Acicular Ferrite
Materials Science and Technology
Effect of Filler Metal on Mechanical Properties of HSLA Welds
Welding Journal
The Chemistry of Submerged Arc Welding Fluxes
Slag Metal Reactions in Binary CaF2—Metal Oxide Welding Fluxes
Welding Journal
Combined Effect of Flux and Welding Parameters on Chemical Composition and Mechanical Properties of Submerged Arc Weld Metal
Journal of Materials Processing Technology
Cited by (9)
Effect of interlayer surface preparation on microstructures and mechanical properties of wire and arc additive manufactured low carbon steel objects
2022, Materials Science and Engineering: ACitation Excerpt :The EDS analysis of the two large inclusions shown in Fig. 12 presents very high atomic fractions of O; and the two spots situate in the matrix marked by B, shown both in Fig. 12a) and b), are confirmed to be Fe-rich non-oxide compound. The detrimental effect of brittle oxide inclusions to the impact toughness has already been discussed by Liao et al. [25] and Sharma et al. [26]. According to the XRD results of the slag (shown in Fig. 4), the slag are main consist of oxides.