Direct oxidation of methane to methanol on Co embedded N-doped graphene: Comparing the role of N2O and O2 as oxidants
Graphical abstract
Introduction
Traditional conversion of methane (CH4) to methanol (CH3OH) is performed by a two-step process in the industry under the harsh reaction conditions such as high temperature and pressure [1,2]. Despite the fact that it is not a cost-effective procedure, there exists no industrial process capable of directly converting methane to methanol. In addition, N2O is known as an agricultural toxic gas which may also originate from other activities like wastewater treatments, or the combustion of fossil fuels and biomass. During the last century, it is found that the global warming of CH4 and N2O are 28 and 265 times higher than CO2. Therefore, investigating the conversion of these gas molecules is of great interest. Direct synthesis of CH3OH from CH4 at room temperature and pressure is a promising way for the industry. To date, many studies have been explored on the direct synthesis of methanol but none of them has proven cost-effective. Thus, it remains one of the considerable challenges in the sector of methane utilization due to the strong CH bond energy and its chemical inertness of methane.
It is known that although noble metals like Ir, Pt, Rh and Ru [[3], [4], [5], [6], [7]] are highly active toward DRM and resistant to carbon formation, they are economically less attractive materials for large-scale industrial use due to their scarcity, high cost and toxicity [8]. Amongst different types of catalysts, single individual metal atoms anchored to graphene-based materials [[9], [10], [11]] are discovered as novel material not only because they minimize material usage to meet the goal of cost-effective catalysis, but also because they surpass conventional catalysts in terms of having a high specific activity with a significantly reduced amount of noble metals. Recently, single metal atoms doped into monolayer surfaces have been tested as catalysts for various reactions owing to their well-defined sites, unsaturated coordination environment, and high atom efficiency. Doping single-atoms into the graphene structure may be effective to improve its catalytic properties [12,13]. Amongst an increasing number of single-atoms, most have been focusing on supporting noble metal atoms like Pt or Pd on metal oxide or metal surfaces [14,15]. Dopants such as P [16], Si [17,18], Fe [19,20], Pt [21,22], Pd [23,24], Ni [25,26] substitute with carbon atoms in the graphene sheet and can significantly enhance the properties of graphene sheet. On the other hands, tailoring the graphene sheet by introducing defects [27,28] or heteroatoms (e.g., N, B, P) [29] into the structure of graphene sheet will speed up the catalytic reactions occurred on the surface [30,31] and modulate the electronic properties of the catalyst [[32], [33], [34], [35]].
It has been reported that N-doped graphene (N-G) [36] and transition metal-coordinated nitrogen-doped graphene (TMN-G) can enhance the chemical reactivity of graphene due to their low cost, high durability, and high catalytic activity. They are widely used in molecular sensors [37,38], bio-sensing applications [39], metal-free oxygen reduction catalysis (ORR) [40,41], CO oxidation reactions [42], and in lithium batteries [[43], [44], [45]]. The introduced N atoms modify the energy distribution of electronic states and thereby the local reactivity [46]. Three common N-doped configurations are observed in N-G, i. e., pyridinic, pyrrolic, and graphitic nitrogen [47,48]. However, there are no investigations toward the differences of catalytic ability between different N defects. Recently, it was found that pyridinic-N can better anchor transition metal atoms in comparison to other types of N-G, due to their higher stability and catalytic activity toward various reactions [49,50]. For instance, Yeager et al. [51] found that metal cations coordinated by pyridinic nitrogen-doped at the defective sites of graphitic carbon are the active sites for ORR in alkaline and acid electrolytes. Experimentally, graphene or carbonic structures containing nitrogen-coordinated transition metals can be easily synthesized [33,52,53]. Recently, Fei et al. [54] worked on the synthesis of nitrogen-enriched core-shell structured cobalt-carbon nanoparticles dispersed on graphene sheets, which can be used for hydrogen evolution reaction in both acidic and basic media. Wang et al. [55] found that Co embedded N-doped carbon nanotubes have high activity toward ORR and the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in both alkaline and neutral media due to their low cost and appropriate features to act as bifunctional catalysts for both the ORR and OER.
In the last few decades, researchers have been dedicated to the synthesis of cost-effective electrocatalysts using cheaper transition metals [56] in which, cobalt-based electrocatalysts show the most promising results [57]. As of any first-row transition metal (Ni, Fe, and Cu), cobalt is a cheap, environmentally friendly, and accessible metal in comparison with noble metals [58] and it can be introduced into the graphene lattice with no difficulties [10]. Recently, Fei et al. [54] worked on the synthesis of nitrogen-enriched core-shell structured cobalt-carbon nanoparticles dispersed on graphene sheets, which can be used for hydrogen evolution reaction in both acidic and basic media. In an experimental investigation, Jurković et al. [59] reported the plasma‐activated methane partial oxidation reaction in a designed dielectric barrier discharge ionization reactor unit. They could produce valuable platform chemicals like methanol, formaldehyde, intermediate formic acid, acetic acid, and paraformaldehyde at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. Moreover, it is found that Co nanoparticles doped into carbon nanotube structures can decrease the local work function of the carbon surface because electrons transfer from cobalt to the surrounding carbon atoms, very easily [60]. Kattel et al. [61] investigated the ORR reaction pathway on M–N (M = Fe, Co, or Ni) catalytic clusters formed between pores in graphene supports. They found that O2 molecule chemisorbs on CoN4-graphene (CoN4-G) and FeN4-graphene (FeN4-G) clusters but not on NiN4-graphene (NiN4-G) clusters. Therefore, the first two clusters were regarded as more active substrates toward ORR. The high stability is mainly attributed to the high conductivity of N-doped graphene and the embedded Co nanoparticles. N-doping increases the electron donor-acceptor properties of graphene and leads to the improvement of the conductance and interfacial electron transfer by doped Co nanoparticles [62]. Zhang et al. [49] calculated the activation barriers and thermodynamic properties of ORR on CoN4-G. They demonstrated that CoN4-G can enhance the ORR and resulted in the formation of two H2O molecules. Kiefer et al. [63] reported that graphitic CoN4 defects are stable at all potentials (U = 0–1.23 V) while CoN2 defects are predicted to be unstable at high potentials. In addition, they predicted that the CoN4 defect is the dominant in-plane graphitic defect in CoNx/C electrocatalysts.
Graphene nano-flakes and graphene nano-ribbons are promising graphene-based materials with a size controllable energy bandgap, which might be useful for various technological applications [64,65]. They are important because of their potential for bottom-up fabrication of molecular devices, spintronic, and quantum dot technology [66]. They are cheap catalysts and being produced by a cheap method, they typically contain many defects. Because of the small size of graphene flakes they can be considered as a zero-dimensional form of graphene sheet showing different properties from graphene nanoribbons and bulk graphene. Such graphene-flakes are promising for a variety of applications such as electronic and magnetic devices with different molecular sizes and shapes, and in light absorption in photovoltaics due to their edge structure and wide spectrum. They have unique electronic, magnetic, and optical properties since their bandgap can be modified. Moreover, the saturation of the zigzag edges of graphene flakes with different atoms (like H in our investigations) or molecular groups leads to a spin-polarized ground state with a non-zero total magnetic moment, an electronic energy gap, and spin density that strongly depends on the used atomic group to passivate the dangling bonds of the C atoms [67]. In this study, we have chosen to model such a graphene flake as a polyaromatic hydrocarbon molecule (PAH).
This article describes our efforts to develop a mechanism for methane conversion to methanol on a modified graphene flake. The modification of the graphene flake has been done in three steps, i. e., introducing a single vacancy (SV) and di-vacancy (dV) defect, doping the defective flake with nitrogen heteroatoms making pyridinic N-doping graphene flake (N3- and N4-G), and finally introducing a single Co atom into the defective graphene flake lattice. Then, we investigated and compared the effect of nitrogen doping on the catalytic activity of the designed catalysts toward direct oxidation of CH4 to CH3OH using O2 and N2O as an oxidant. N2O acts as an O-donor compound and gives us the ability to convert two pollutant gas simultaneously. The effects of using different oxidants have been studied in several investigations. For instance, Dasireddy et al. [68] studied the effects of oxidants (H2O, N2O, and O2) on methane oxidation to methanol over the FePO4 catalyst. They found that FePO4 can actively convert methane to methanol using O2 and N2O oxidants.
It should be noted that although Ni or Cu metal surfaces would be most effective for CH bond cleavage, the activity of an individual single Ni or Cu atoms doped graphene-like surfaces will vary toward the same reaction. For instance, in our previous investigation [69], single Ni and Si atoms were chosen to compare the catalytic activity of the tuned graphene flake toward the direct conversion of methane to methanol. Interestingly, we found that single Ni atom doped graphene flake (Ni-G) cannot actively catalyze methane oxidation while Si-doped graphene flakes (Si-G) showed a better catalytic activity thanks to the lower activation energies and more favourable thermodynamic properties. Therefore, we reasonably assume that depending on the investigated graphene nano-flake (with applying different tuning methods), the activity of an arbitrary doped single metal atom and consequently the whole tailored graphene nano-flake will change. Motivated by previous investigations, in this article, a single Co atom is chosen as a single metal atom due to its considerable activity for ORR and OER. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations are utilized in order to find the most energetically favourable substrate for the direct oxidation of methane to methanol. All the reactions take place at room temperature and then the catalytic performances of these carbon material catalysts were investigated. Moreover, the detailed surface interactions and reaction pathways that occurred on the interface of the substrate were also discussed.
Section snippets
Computational details
All structure optimizations and reaction pathway calculations are based on DFT using the Gaussian 16 package [70]. We employed the meta-GGA hybrid functional M06-2X [71] for geometry optimizations and frequency calculations. For carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen, and oxygen atoms the all-electron 6-31G* basis set is used. The Los Alamos National Laboratory [72] basis set of double- quality (LANL2DZ) used for Co atom. No significant spin contamination was found. To model the pristine graphene as a
Results and discussion
This work aims to investigate the catalytic activity of Co-SV-G, Co-dV-G, CoN3-G, and CoN4-G toward methane activation and conversion to methanol using N2O and O2 as an oxidant. In most cases, the methane oxidation reaction starts with CH bond cleavage that is a challenge in heterogeneous catalysis, because of its great thermodynamic stability (435 kJ mol−1) and strong tetrahedral bonds. Therefore, upon CH bond cleavage, two different pathways with different intermediates can be identified for
Conclusions
In summary, the geometric stability and catalytic activity of Co-SV-G, Co-dV-G, CoN3-G, and CoN4-G toward adsorption of gas reactants are studied in detail employing DFT calculations. Studying the geometric, electronic, and thermodynamic properties of all optimized structures showed that amongst other modified graphene flakes, CoN3-G and CoN4-G are energetically more stable than other substrates. Investigating the adsorption behavior of CoN3-G and CoN4-G toward the gas reactants indicated that
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Parisa Nematollahi: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Validation, Visualization, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing. Erik C. Neyts: Supervision, Writing - review & editing.
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgments
This work was performed with the financial support from the Doctoral Fund of the Antwerp University (NO. BOFLP33099). All the simulations are performed on resources provided by the high-performance computing center of Antwerp University.
References (110)
- et al.
Catal. Today
(2017) - et al.
J. Catal.
(1998) - et al.
J. Mol. Struct.-THEOCHEM
(2002) - et al.
Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
(2011) - et al.
Chem. Phys. Lett.
(2016) - et al.
J. Mol. Graph. Model.
(2013) - et al.
Appl. Surf. Sci.
(2017) - et al.
Appl. Surf. Sci.
(2015) - et al.
Surf. Sci.
(2011) - et al.
Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
(2016)
Carbon
Electrochim. Acta
Appl. Surf. Sci.
Catal. Commun.
Solid State Commun.
Carbon
Appl. Surf. Sci.
J. Mol. Catal. A Chem.
Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
J. Power Sources
J. Power Sources
Science
Chem. Soc. Rev.
Top. Catal.
ChemPhysChem
Environ. Chem. Lett.
Nano Lett.
Nat. Commun.
Energy Environ. Sci.
Sci. J.
Science
J. Am. Chem. Soc.
RSC Adv.
J. Phys. Chem. C
Struct. Chem.
Sci. Rep.
J. Nanopart. Res.
Phys. Rev. B
J. Phys. Chem. C
J. Chem. Phys.
J. Phys. Chem. C
Nano Lett.
J. Mater. Chem. A
Nano Lett.
Appl. Phys. Lett.
Nano Lett.
J. Phys. Chem. C
Phys. Rev. B
Sci. Rep.
ACS Nano
Cited by (12)
Synthesis of NaKCO<inf>3</inf>@(Mn-Na<inf>2</inf> WO<inf>4</inf>/SiO<inf>2</inf>) core-shell catalyst for oxidative coupling of methane
2023, Arabian Journal of ChemistryOxidation of methane and ethylene over Al incorporated N-doped graphene: A comparative mechanistic DFT study
2022, Journal of Molecular Graphics and ModellingCitation Excerpt :The Eads value for the N-site configuration is −0.40 eV, which is nearly equal to that of the O-site (−0.33 eV). These Eads values are comparable with the previously reported values for N2O adsorption on SiN4-Gr [91] and CoN3-Gr [31]. The Hirshfeld analysis also shows that 0.12 and 0.14 electrons are transferred from N2O into the surface for N- and O-site configurations, respectively.
Graphene-Supported Single-Atom Ni as High-Performance Catalyst for Direct Methane-to-Methanol Conversion
2023, Journal of Physical Chemistry C